WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Cherry Salad Bowl

Posts

Cherry Salad Bowl

#1

Cherry Salad Bowl

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Hi Everyone,


The pictures below show a cherry salad bowl I just completed last night. The wood came from a large wild cherry ("Choke Cherry" I believe) tree Bill Grumbine and I harvested back in the Fall of 2002. Since this bowl was rather large, the roughed out blank was allowed to dry for more than a year. It's been sitting in my shop for all that time waiting for me to get the chance to work on it.

The bowl measures 13" diameter x 4 1/2" high with a 3 1/4" diameter base. The wall thickness is approximately 1/2".

Plan view of Cherry Salad Bowl

Side view of Cherry Salad Bowl

Bottom view of Cherry Salad Bowl

I decided to dress up the rather utilitarian profile with some beads along the rim. At first I was going to add Inlace. But, reasoning that sometimes "less is more", decided against it in favor of the beads. The base also features a cove and bead in keeping with the motif of the rim. The sap lines running along the inside give the piece a nice bit of "distraction" and in my opinion seem to add to the overall feel of the bowl. But like the dark spot on the outside, these too will fade over time. That's is the reason I went with the more tactile, and lasting bead decoration.

After final turning, the bowl was sanded to 220 grit, then wet sanded to 2000 grit. The finish is Watco's Danish Oil (natural color), which was recommended to me again, by Bill Grumbine. I had never had the opportunity to use this finish before and was very impressed with the results on this piece of Cherry. It brought out the grain better than the Urethane Oil I was previously using. I gave this bowl several coats over a period of days and allowed each to dry before buffing in between coats with 0000 steel wool. The final step was buffing with a Beall Buffing System.

If you look back a couple of days ago, you will recognize this bowl as the same one in which I was asking about methods for coloring the cherry so to remove the dark spot. The majority of you felt that attempting to color the wood to obscure the spot was not necessary. The wood itself would darken over time as it aged. Far be it from to to disagree with a logical course of action that requires me to do nothing! So here it is, the way Nature intended. Until the same Nature causes the wood to mellow and darken.

Thanks for viewing

See ya around,

My ugly mug

Dominic

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#2

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

Ron Sardo in PA

>Looking Good Dom!

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#3

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

Ruth

>Dominic, you did good! Very nice and since that stain in only on the bottom, it just adds personality. I also like the beading on the rim rather than inlay. This is my kind of bowl, elegant rather than fancy.

Very nice work.

Ruth

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#4

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

Mike Schwing from Md

>I like it, too, Dominic! Glad you chose to display it the way mother nature intended.

You say is choke cherry, if thats the same "choke cherry" I have on hand, it won't change color dramatically the way black cherry does, at least from my experience. I was expecting it to, but only the sapwood really changed color - it went to a pretty bright orange color. The heartwood, I was surprised to see, was mostly the same color 6 months later.

The inlace would have looked nice, I'm sure, but I like the detail you chose instead as well.

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#5

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

Greg W. in NC

>Dom, nice job! I too like the simplicity, with the touch of the beads on top. Very well done!

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#6

Nice!

Joel Hunnicutt

>You make the salad and I'll bring the steaks!

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#7

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

Bill Grumbine, Kutztown PA

>Very nice Dominic! I still have a chunk or two of that stuff left, but we may need to get back to that well again. ;-)

I think you managed a very nice form on the bowl, and I like the beading details. Keep up the good work!

Bill

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#8

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Nice, Dom.

Do think the foot's a bit small for an actual serving dish of that size; it may tend to be a little tippy under load.

Try an inlay next time. I think a color contrast would really set off the rim, although the beads are a nice detail.

Mark

drop the 2 for mail

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#9

Foot size deceptive

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Mark,

Thanks for the comments.

The base diameter I report isn't exactly the size of the base. Rather it is the size of the detail on the base. The bowl rests on the rim of the base which is more like 4 1/2" in diameter wide and more than wide enough to prevent that "tippy" feeling you're describing.

Dominic

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#10

..and the crowd goes wild!!

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#11

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

Bob M

>Dom,

I really like the rim detail. Detail such as that adds to the beauty of the wood and quality of the turning. I wouldn't change a thing.

Bob M.

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#12

Re: Foot size deceptive

John U - Charlotte, NC

>Wow -- I am impressed with this bowl!! The bead detail on the rim really adds to it. I just finished a smaller bowl, sanded to 2000 grit, and it feels good to hold, so I know how this one feels to hold. Great job Dominic!!

You bring up a good point on foot size --- I know about the 1/3 rule, but for utilitarian bowls, the foot is often bigger. On your bowl, the actual footprint is a little more than 1/3, and the proportions and shape look great.

We have a fruit bowl at home that was given to us as a wedding gift 10 years ago -- it's about 10" diameter, with about a 4" footprint, or about 2/5 the diameter. It's stable, not tippy, and the proportions also look OK.

I'm interested in hearing what others have to say when it comes to these design "rules" -- for those who really USE these size salad serving bowls (say in the size range of this one 13"-15"), and have family and friends passing it around the table and abusing it as much as they can, what's the max/min footprint size that keeps the bowl stable, yet still look right in design?

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#13

Re: Foot size deceptive *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>It is OK for something artistic to appear as if it is ready to fall over or take flight. A useable salab bowl must LOOK and BE stable, and not require a 3rd hand to hold it in place while it is being used. That means that the foot is large enough to anchor the bowl to the table in both perception and reality. Other than that, there are no rules.

You can read my "Rules of the S's" for a salad bowl. Most of these "rules" are opinion, a lot of it is in disagreement with what the "experts" are telling us about bowl design, but all of them better describe a Salad Bowl than a comparison with an artistic guide.


Salad Bowls

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#14

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

jim bennett

>Dominic,

Very nice work, I can't wait to start turning bowls. Because of your lathe review on the Jet, I bought the 2hp 1642EVS and just wired up the shop (garage) for 220v. The lathe is very smooth and quiet, I am very happy with the purchase. Now I just need to finish off some flat work and then build your ballast box and feet. Hopefully this weekend I will be making chips.

jim

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#15

Re: Deceiver!!!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You SAID it was 3-1/2 in diameter!

Liar, Liar, Pants-on-fire!

4-1/2's ok with the 4+ height. 5+ would be way more sold in its feel on the table.

|;-}}

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#16

Thanks for all the compliments!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Thanks for all the kind words!

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#17

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

Larry Hancock; Ardmore, OK

>I really like the rim detail and the curve looks to flow very well through the piece. Thanks for sharing it.

Larry

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#18

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

Mike Rubes

>Hi Dominic,

Great looking bowl! I really like the form and rim treatment. Really good stuff.

That must have been one heck of a lot of shavings from a bowl that size!

Thanks for the pics,

Mike

Flatwork has the lathe gathering dust in Apex, NC...

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

#19

Re: Cherry Salad Bowl

David Eaves

>Hi Dominic,

That's a really nice bowl. I think your form is excellent and the rim is interesting. I'm thinking more about rims these days after the feedback on my last bowl. I like what you did.

The finish looks very good too. If you still have this bowl in a few months time it would be interesting to see how it mellows.

Thanks for posting

David

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.