WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Newbie experiment gone right

Posts

Newbie experiment gone right

#1

Newbie experiment gone right

Mike Schwing from Maryland

>These are finally dry now, or are at least not losing any weight and aren't cold to the touch. Both were my first end grain turnings and I left the pith right in the center, hoping that they would survive. Both did very well! Beginner's luck probably. I know they're not perfect or wonderful but I'm new. 14" tall and 10" tall.

They were both turned wet to about 3/8" all way around, sanded and put in a few paper bags to slow dry for a few weeks. Then they were both liberally coated with walnut oil in the hopes of helping keep them from cracking.

The cherry vase did not crack or warp in the least. The apple one had little pith cracks in it when I turned it, I just didn't notice them until I was done. Still, they didn't expand while drying. The apple one warped just a bit.

I know they might still move a bit more as the time and years roll by, but would consider them air dry.

Fun new turning method for me. I guess the oil limits the finishing options, but if it helps keep them from cracking, might be worth it? Do you gents think that it helps or was it just another case of wishful thinking?


Re: Newbie experiment gone right

#2

Re: Newbie experiment gone right

RPE

>Thanks Mike for this!

I've been telling my wife and friends for the last two or three years that you can't turn a bowl or vase with the pith in it. It will just come apart.

"Well, just try it" is what I get all the time!

I tell them I don't need to reinvent the wheel. There are plenty of folks out there who say you turn with the pith perpendiclar to the ways and you remove it.

Now it looks like you've blown that theory. I guess I'll have to try it.

I like the way the color comes up from the base to the rim and changes. Looks like a coke float!!

Thanks for showing these.

RP

Re: Newbie experiment gone right

#3

Re: Newbie experiment gone right

David Hammond, in Powder Springs GA

>Maybe it's just coincidence here too Mike, but the tung oil I use seems to help with cracking, and even warping - nothing scientific here, but this is just what I think I've been noticing. :o) Great peices by the way, I really like them both.

David

Re: Newbie experiment gone right

#4

Re: Newbie experiment gone right

Brian Roberts

>Good show Mike! Sometimes just do it is the way to go - what's the worst that can happen? I turned things with the pith left in before I had read any turning books or seen any online forums that told me not to try it. I just didn't "know any better" and some of them were just fine.

Actually - at that time the only "computer" I had seen was actually a dumb terminal connected (by laying the phone handset in a "modem" cradle) to a mainframe at the University of Minnesota (IIRC). The only thing the teacher was able to do with it was send a command to the main frame, which would then send back the data to print out (on an OLD teletype printer) a picture of Snoopy kicking a football! Very crude picture, since the "pixels" were actually various full letters, but BOY were we amazed!!

There obviously was no WWW in them days! Any guess as to what year that was?

Nice work!

Brian

Re: Newbie experiment gone right

#5

Re: Newbie experiment gone right

Gary Bills in NC

>Mike,

I really like these. Could you turn them over and take a side veiw of them? That apple has nice grain!

Gary

Re: Newbie experiment gone right

#6

Re: Newbie experiment gone right

David Eaves

>Hi Mike,

That's great news. Glad to hear they are still in one piece. Ignorance in some ways is bliss. I left the pith in a few early pieces. Only one cracked fortunatly and it is still together.

Cheers

David

Re: Newbie experiment gone right

#7

Re: Newbie experiment gone right

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I have to guess, the 60's. I remember the same things, but I was a kid then.

keithz

Re: Newbie experiment gone right

#8

Re: Newbie experiment gone right

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>MIke, I regularly turn endgrain. Sometimes the pith will crack, sometimes not. My very first turning as a footed bowl that is endgrain. It has one crack in it that existed before I turned it. No other cracks have appeared since. I used Minwax Tung Oil Finish on that bowl.

YOur vases look very good. Congrats on the successful endgrain turning.

keithz

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.