WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

couple of nat edge cherry - comments please

Posts

couple of nat edge cherry - comments please

#1

couple of nat edge cherry - comments please

Mike Schwing from Maryland

>Turned these two today. They're remarkably similar, but I found the shape to be pleasing in the first one, the smaller, so I kind of redid it with the 2nd. No foot at all on these, I used an internal dovetail recess for mounting. That is something I'm returning to after too many turnings blew off of the lathe using the internal method when I was just starting out. I don't really have catches anymore, so it now works well.

With natural edge bowls, I seem to try to approximate, with the profile, the same profile that the edge curve shows. It looks like the two major design elements match to me when the top curve and the profile are sort of the same. I would like to hear, please, what you think of these. I have a lot more natural edge cherry blanks and its too cold to do anything much other than go to work outdoors. These two are unfinished and just off of the lathe. I might leave them that way after they dry, except for a sanding if needed. They are both about 3/8" thick, I didn't feel the need to go thinner.

Sorry about the 2nd pic, all but the first one suffered from "just brought the camera in from the cold auto" syndrome. Thanks in advance for your critiques, I can handle it. I would guess the large one is about 8"x8".



Re: couple of nat edge cherry - comments please

#2

Re: couple of nat edge cherry - comments please

Mike Rubes

>Hi Mike,

I think they look good. I don't think I would have consciously picked up on the rim matching the bottom curve if you hadn't mentioned it, but I think it ties it in together nicely. It looks like you were able to keep most or all of the bark which I think helps.

On most of my bowls, I try to bring the bottom in more than you've done here, but again I think it works with the matching of the rim.

Good pics,

Thanks,

Mike

Re: couple of nat edge cherry - comments please

#3

Re: couple of nat edge cherry - comments please

Alan Tolchinsky

>Mike, I like those a lot. You did a great job of keeping all the bark on. I don't pretend to be a "shape" expert, but I think the form great. Alan in Md.

Re: couple of nat edge cherry - comments please

#4

Re: couple of nat edge cherry - comments please

David Eaves

>Hi Mike,

They both look really good, your poingt about the curves is an interesting one and I think you are right. I've never turned anything with the bark still on like this so have never really considered it. Have seen some really nice pieces here this way now, I will be looking for a suitable log or two :o)

My only comment on the form, is I think the smaller one has a slightly more pleasing profile. It seems to round in slightly at the top. Wheras the larger one seems to go straight and is not just quite as nice. Very small nitpick, as I really like them the rounded bases suit them well.

David

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.