Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Four types of dovetail markers

Posts

Four types of dovetail markers

#1

Four types of dovetail markers

The humble dovetail marker. Some make a fetish about using them, and some make a fetish about not using them. I have a couple of different types to show for those interested in purchasing or making one.

The important feature of a dovetail marker for me is the ability to scribe an angle and run this directly across the top of the board, that is, it converts into a saddle square.

 

The first marker on show is one that used to be made by Lie Nielsen many years ago. I believe that this is a design by Rob Cosman, who sells them in a complete wooden construction. This one was a gift from Thomas Lie Nielsen about 10 years ago. 

This one comes in 1:6 and 1:7 ratios.

 

What I like about this design is that it has good registration and good balance. I can also function as a saddle square ..

Its weakness lies with the two ratios being easy to confuse as you flit the gauge to each side.

 

Another discontinued gauge by the original maker, and again one that is being manufactured by another party (now by Crucible Tools), is this marker by Woodjoy ...

It looks so cute and is small enough to tuck away in a pocket, but I do not recommend it. It is difficult to balance, and this is even more so when switching to the non-dominant hand to mark ...

It is better as a saddle square ..

The original (copied by Crucible) has 1:6 and 1:8 ratios. I find 1:8 to be too flat and lacking character, and converted it to 1:7. This marker would be better balanced if made twice as wide.

 

The marker I use mainly is this one (of a set of 4 ratios) I made from angle brass. This one is 1:6 ...

It is small but large enough for case work (markers only have to work to 1" maximum), well balanced, and will work comfortably to left and right. 

It also works well as a saddle square ...

Aluminium angle may be easier and cheaper to construct than the brass here. This is a good design - I have them in all popular ratios.

 

I also find a sliding bevel to be useful to mark dovetails. Set whatever ratio you want. The sliding bevel is especially handy when marking reverse angles as it has the best registration of all the markers ...

The downside of a sliding bevel is that it requires a second tool, here a small double square, for the vertical lines ..

 

Regards from Perth

Derek


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#2

Re: Four types of dovetail markers

I'm a LV guy......








Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#3

Re: Four types of dovetail markers

Roger, I have the LV Saddle Square. It is great for case work, but it is too large in my view for dinky drawer dovetails. This goes for the dovetail markers as well. Well made and nicely balanced, but large. Now if Veritas would make a set half as large …


Regards from Perth


Derek


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#4

Two more, even better





The even better could be a personal prejudice.  :) The brass plate is easily sawed to shape with a thin kerf blade on a table saw.  I captured the plate in a slot in a scrap of wood to hold the plate while sawing.  I don't use it anymore. 






Rather I do away with marking altogether by using a gage block to start the saw. This approach is a large time saver.  


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#5

Re: Two more, even better

Thanks for the pictures and ideas, Bill. I think that the saw guide you use is clever, and will certainly assist in setting the saw on track. No doubt there are those who will follow your lead here. There are many saw guides to be purchased.


I prefer not to do this as the choice if angle is something I like to be flexible about, and select one that suits each project. This reflects that I view dovetails as a design feature, as well as a structural joint. 


Do you have more than one dovetail angle you use? Here is a set of 4 markers, from 8:1 through 5:1. The other marker was a fun piece I made about 20 years ago, a dovetailed dovetail marker :)





Regards from Perth


Derek



Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#6

curious?????

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3107/md/read/id/112948/sbj/dovetail-marking-guage/


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#7

dovetail angles

Do you have more than one dovetail angle you use?    No,  I chose about 12 degrees for drawers because that is what the Headley shop used. I say "about" because I don't fret exactly orienting the saw to the guide.  In fact I usually wind up 11 degrees, +/-.  It matters not, to me. Of course it would take 5 minutes to make a block with some different angle.  The brass thingy shown has the advantage of easily adjustable size.  But again, it involves marking and marking is wasted time in my case.  





I regard dovetails as an engineering choice, and not part of any design element of a piece.  In fact, I cover up dovetails where I can.  Not once have I ever had a customer for a piece of furniture scrutinize or comment on a dovetail beyond rarely noticing there was one.  I never subject my furniture to judges at shows so I don't have that worry either.  I don't get any personal reward for making a drawer with dovetails this or that angle so I don't put any energy to this decision.  My design energy goes into wood and wood grain selection, and the overall look of the piece.  Joints are there to hold it together and not be noticed when possible.  





Well, not exactly no.  For drawer blades I use 14 degrees to match a dovetail router bit.  But they are always covered up. 




Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#8

Curious about what?


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#9

Re: Curious about what?

Looks like the gauge i wrote about in 2007


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#10

Derek's large image file posts...

... hang, and open very slowly for me. I had same trouble with another thread he started recently. The posts open fine but only after several attempts ... and a good deal of patience.


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#11

A possible offspring.......

John.....it has been so long, I don't remember if your gauge was my inspiration or not......but, there photos were made in 2012 so it's origin could be due to you......








Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#12

Re: Derek's large image file posts...

Oh, the next thread. Roger's shop survival was the one giving me fits.


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#13

Re: A possible offspring.......

Roger,  I like your gauge.  A simple practical design.  Nicely done.  


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#14

Re: Derek's large image file posts...

Bruce, these images are not large files. On average, about 115-120 Kb. 


If they are opening slowly for you, it may be your server which is responsible.


Regards from Perth


Derek


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#15

Re: A possible offspring.......

Roger, that is beautifully made. Have you used it much?


The issue I have with this style of gauge is that they require a second tool to scribe across the top of the tails. In other words, they cannot be used as a saddle square.


Regards from Perth


Derek


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#16

Re: A possible offspring.......

Derek, 


You say, "The issue I have with this style of gauge is that they require a second tool to scribe across the top of the tails"


Not true.  Look at my gauge and Roger's....mine also functions like a double square.  No second tool is required.  I've done many with this tool.  Granted, it is a two step operation, but the tool does both....whether you do tails first or pins first.










Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#17

Re: A possible offspring.......

This right angle allows for the kind of marking you're referring to......





no, I haven't been using this gauge very much.....got in the habit of using the LV gauges instead......


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#18

Re: Curious about what?

Bill 


Is this the marking gauge that you made that you no longer use?


http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives.pl/bid/1001/md/read/id/431468/sbj/ingenious-dovetail-layout-device/


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#19

don't use that one either

That was the not such a good idea for marking that I used before I made the brass one that is the reverse of the Plexiglas one.  For laying out and sawing I now use just a divider and the two aids shown in the picture.







Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#20

Continuing improvement

I seem to be settled in how I make a drawer.  But for several years I tried different ways with the goal of taking time out of making a drawer. I have had a steady diet of case pieces with drawers for the past 15 years.  ( had a lot of opportunity to try different techniques, keeping what worked better for me and rejecting those that didn't.  I don't make drawer now anything like I did even 5 years ago.  I used to dread the tedium of an 8 drawer chest of drawers.  Now it moves along efficiently.  


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#21

How the V was cut.......



in the unlikely event that someone wanted to make such a gauge........


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#22

Ellis Walentine

Can't replicate here

I'm on a slow 4G connection and Derek's photos load almost instantly. I wonder if you've checked your download speed? Our server capability is really quite good since our recent transition. On another note, please post your website feedback on our Feedback forum, so as not to divert attention from hand tools discussions. Peter, our messageboard guru, is more likely to be able to address your questions there.


Thanks!


Ellis Walentine, host


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#23

Done. Comment transferred.


Re: Four types of dovetail markers

#24

Ellis Walentine

Thanks!