WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Surprise planing

Posts

Surprise planing

#1

Surprise planing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I sold someone some cedar a while back and offered some woodworking lessons to be collected in the future. Bruce showed up this AM to make a quilt ladder. I thought we were going to make it from cherry. Nope, he showed up with cedar rails and rungs, to be mortised and tenoned. To my amazement the mortises for the rungs could be located where knots were not. Rungs had teeth marks from ripping, ditto rails. Power jointed short rungs. No hope of jointing rails on my long bed jointer because each had a bow.

There were knot-free places on the sawed edges. I offered to try to hand plane some between the knots. In a moment of experimentation, I planed into one of the cedar knots (#4, close set cap iron). The plane breezed through the knot, tear-out free on both sides. That was a surprise. I handed off the plane and he was able to smooth the edges of the rails with as little tear-out around the knots as I would be able to accomplish on the jointer with a very slow fee.

I have not yet examined the blade but I suspect after mowing through something as hard as cedar knots I will need to do some sharpening.

Re: Surprise planing

#2

PM V11 faired fine

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Examined edge and it was dulled some, less than the point where I normally sharpen (which is later than you all). That blade went through many knots many times. I was sure there would be chipping.

Re: Surprise planing

#3

Re: Surprise planing

Jack Dover

I have not yet examined the blade but I suspect after mowing through something as hard as cedar knots I will need to do some sharpening.

It's going to be less damaging to the edge if you go really slow over a knot. Most probably you'll get a continuous end grain shaving from a knot with a sharp blade. It's bumping into knots at full speed is what dings the edge.

Also, wetting knots (or any non-cooperating spot) with something like mineral spirits, turpentine, denaturated alcohol or even water softens them considerably.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.