Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

pins or tails

Posts

pins or tails

#1

pins or tails

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Now that I am immune travel will resume. A stop this weekend will be at the shop in Shelbyville, KY to poke into English antiques and see how things were made over the ages. Is there something that would reveal whether pins or tails were done first?

Re: pins or tails

#2

marking maybe?

John in NM

If they used pencil for marking, you might see evidence of an overmark on the tails if they did pins first. I'm assuming that they wouldn't bother removing such marks, particularly on the rear of drawer boxes.

Re: pins or tails

#3

Re: marking maybe?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When you make pins first, the marking is on the inside of the drawer or box, and so the sawing is done from the inside also. The result is that the show side of the tail board is a little sloppier than the inside, because the saw leaves a little fuzzier edge and is liable to overcuts. To prevent overcuts some people today check the back side between saw strokes, or they deliberately saw a little short and then have to clean up the corners with a chisel. These would have been big time wasters historically.

In the 18th century the emphasis was on the outside of the case, and things like interior joinery and backs could be somewhat sloppy. Today you can make a beautiful piece with stylish mouldings, beautiful finish and wonderful carvings or inlay and many people think they have to look at drawer dovetails to gauge quality. So this influences our decisions about making drawer dovetails.

Here is an 18th century drawer side, inside back corner. You can see the scribe lines from transferring from the pins. If these lines had been made with bevel gauge, they would have continued at the same slant, but they change as soon as they pass the pins. The maker faced the inside of the pin board when marking.


Here is the outside front of the same side. Note that there are overcuts at every single cut. This makes it easy to chop out but is not designed for show. When dovetails show on the outside of a case, like the top of a slant front desk, they are done differently and appear neat.


Re: pins or tails

#4

Re: pins or tails

TomD

If they were doing it for speed and ganged parts, then left and right sides would be the same. Which is noticeable if they were eyeballed.

------------------

. I remember this highboy in the waiting room where my cousin was staged before getting her OBE. This was in the palace waiting room! and it looked like a lot of gold was in use. I wish she had pulled out the drawer so that we could see the dovetails in that piece. Whether they were fussed over. I assume so, as a lot of better furniture is very neat also. As close as I got was the video...

Re: pins or tails

#6

Re: pins or tails

Charlie

https://jeffreygreenenewport.com/Dovetail%20Joinery.pdf

Re: pins or tails

#7

Re: pins or tails

Charlie

His website: https://www.jeffreygreenenewport.com/

You may recall Greene being the author of American Furniture of the 18th Century.

Greene is also heavily involved in the Newport Restoration Foundation and has some videos on their YouTube channel that are worth a watch.

He seems to be a tails first guy, so that might give a little comfort.

Re: pins or tails

#8

Good pics...

John in NM

That is exactly what I was thinking of, but with a knife mark. Having never done it that way I didn't want to speculate what result you would see, but there it is, right in a pic!

I wouldn't have guessed they would be inside either, making as I was a set of assumptions based in part on the modern outlook you describe - but that is the trouble with assumptions, they are often proved wrong and are generally of less value than even opinions :D

Re: pins or tails

#9

Thanks, interesting on the tapering

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I turn to Greene often for advice on building.

I always wanted to peek into a Townsend drawer. Thank you for providing the opportunity.

The tapering discussion matches what Alan Batty reported for making English drawers in the factory where he worked.

Re: pins or tails

#10

Re: Thanks, interesting on the tapering

Charlie

He's forgotten far more than I'll ever know.

He has some pieces apparently built on spec available for sale on his website. Pretty stunning:

https://www.jeffreygreenenewport.com/in%20showroom.html

Re: pins or tails

#11

Re: pins or tails

Philip F Duffy

Are you the beneficiary of 2 vaccines and wait period of 1 month between and 1 month after? If so you still only have 75% immunity coverage from the disease. 'course the experts could be wrong. Good luck

Re: pins or tails

#12

vaccine efficacy vs time

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Pfizer data


These data can be found in the application for FDA emergency approval for each vaccine candidate. By now Pfizer has vastly more data so the confidence levels will have tightened up a lot. If they have published follow up data I have not seen it.

My reaction to the 2nd injection suggests my enthusiastic immune system was primed to mount a full scale attack if spike proteins showed up. Nothing was held back for about 36 hours. Satisfied the invader was subdued my immune system returned to standby.

Re: pins or tails

#13

Re: pins or tails

Joe shelton

I think that no individual, Bill included, can have 75% effectiveness. He will have effective response or not, in the defined period you state.

And the gradual improvement over time depicted in the chart Bill showed is a group response, not a person's response.

Re: pins or tails

#14

Re:Drawers or carcasses?

Steve Voigt

For half blinds, I don't know how you would start with the pins first, so surely it was always tails. If through dovetailing the rear of the drawer, it would be natural to follow the same procedure. But for carcasses, it was the opposite, and that's what I was referring to in a previous thread. When Greene says it's easier to mark the pins from the tails, he must only be talking about drawers, because with a case it's so much easier to mark the tails from the pins; all I can say is try it.

I know the "joiner and cabinetmaker" book describes the pins first method, and I'm pretty sure there are other 19th c texts that do the same, but I just emerged from a week in the hospital and don't have the energy to look. Maybe someone else can do the legwork.

Again, I'm not arguing for one approach or the other.