edge stability
David Weaver
I learned these terms from knife people. Generally, whatever is going to be driven to high hardness with a fine edge is going to be something about like file steel. A knife like that won't be tough to twisting or hitting nails, but it holds its fine edge well.
No matter how good the carbon steel is, though, it won't have the abrasion resistance in wood or especially in worse than a decent high speed steel or a similar type with tons of carbides.
There's a combination of things, I think, that keep people from really liking HSS chisels and going back to something that's easier to sharpen (and for me, the same with the muji planes - they're great irons, but I like a plainer iron better because of edge stability - resistance to losing the very bit of the edge and uniform wear).
* HSS takes longer to sharpen, usually about twice as long on an able abrasive. Most people don't count strokes so sharpening 25% more as a thought after finishing a normal cycle seems like doing a lot. When I counted strokes with the 3V, it took double. If someone is using a honing guide with two steps and the second is very fine, it may take 100 strokes total to completely finish an edge. People think they do that, but nobody does. It's a 4-5 minute process
* aversion to doing that makes people do sharpening less ("but the steel is better, so it shouldn't be an issue, it should last longer" and they deal with more damaged edges). I guess the fact that those kinds of tools usually hold on to a wire edge doesn't help, either- if you don't remove it, it makes them seem marginally sharp and they only shave hair on one side of the bevel - you can flip the side back and forth with a fine stone - one side shaves easily, the other one doesn't at all. When something is sharp with no wire, it shaves easily on both sides. I used to have this with shaptons - I thought I was orienting the edge, but i think the reality is the pros are aggressive enough that they create a tiny wire edge. If you orient it in your favor, it's not noticeable - I think that just causes it to be ripped off when you start working with it.
* and lastly, the desire to set a chisel up like another chisel and call it no good because they don't perform the same is a problem. I'd bet edge stability is had with HSS at a couple of degrees more than carbon steel. You cater to the tool the way it wants to be used and it will deliver what it's supposed to.
I didn't unicorn and test any of the HSS chisels that I bought, but I'd be willing to bet that in a double blind test, nobody would be able to tell the difference between their sharpness and a carbon steel chisel in use once the edge was unicorned. The strange thing about the whole unicorn process is that while It will allow the edges to remain fine edges on high speed steel, it makes mediocre chisels last half a project and you still get drawn back by how well the mediocre chisels sharpen because they don't resist abrasion.
The set of 5 that I sold had a lot of surface corrosion (the listing said that, too, but you never know with people - I rarely ever get anything back or even a complaint but once in a while someone tells me their wife looked at something they bought and didn't like it - which is code for "i don't have the spine to tell you I changed my mind, and I know there's nothing on these that wasn't in the listing, so I'm coming up with a wild card"). I've gotten that one a few times. At any rate, they were sharpened with a grinder, and the entire bevel wasn't uniformly sharpened and they were convex but shallow. Someone found them hard to sharpen. They weren't that bad and anyone with a diamond plate, india stone and a buffer would do fine with them as long as they reminded themselves to follow the rules and complete each step (those chisels are hard enough and abrasion resistant enough that a settled in fine india stone only cuts like a washita does on the back of a carbon steel chisel).
I cannot remember the name of those chisels, but they were sold in droves over here cheaply in the 1980s. Part of the reason for that was the exchange rate (250-300 yen per dollar, currently probably 110 or something - same with electric guitars - they could be sold here at a price around or lower than a gibson offering and music stores could really mark them up. when the exchange rate lost that, the favorability of importing guitars that had much labor went away. I'd guess some of that also has to do with why the first wave of japanese tool fanaticism crapped out - it was no longer possible for someone to bring in chisels at $10 each and sell them for $40 each, etc. It became more like $25-$30 and sell for $40 and nobody wanted to do that. )
Too much TLDR there, but I just shoveled all of the snow here and am working my way through my coffee.
(those chisels are made nicely despite being budget chisels, and last I saw them in the states, or on dictum, they were closer to $60-$70 each. That's highway robbery for what they are. They're just cut and ground to shape, mono steel).
https://www.ebay.com/p/1966452371
(I guess they're still made. They're sold cheaply in japan still if someone will go to the trouble to ship them free on ebay and sell to gaijin. Probably $25-$30 in japan. The used set that I bought was $70 on buyee, probably $100 once proxy and shipping and consolidation fees are added, and I sold them for $125. I felt a little guilty selling them at that with surface corrosion, too!! but buyee can be a little risky and sometimes things don't show up in the same condition you expected and you lose out. Identical set, including the box. They've been making those for probably 40 years. I wouldn't buy them new at that price).
(another btw - I don't know if you were reading here when I did a plane durability test - the HSS irons from china in clean wood do run about 60% further than a good O1 iron, which is probably about the practical limit for any low alloy steel. Really hard carbon steel with a little bit more alloying like super blue has the potential to last about as long as A2, but that's about it, but even that loses a bit of edge stability.
chinese HSS
https://i.imgur.com/E4KQVMc.jpg
O1
https://i.imgur.com/NEa8MHe.jpg
You can see how much more uniform O1 stays. It's not really possible to retain that kind of edge stability once carbide count goes up - even with V11. V11 is very abrasion resistant, but not very tough.
(I suspected that, but saw toughness testing by a metallurgist here charting knife steels and XHP is about 1/3rd as tough as the fine carbide stainless steels like AEB-L at similar hardness. It also probably wears twice as long. Avoiding edge damage in a controlled test is easy, but in normal use, I've seen more edge trouble anecdotally - in terms of avoiding little notches that split shavings or leave lines on work. Same is true for the chinese stuff, which seems tough further up the bevel but will let the edge go.
Found the unicorn method to be protective of all edges in really abrasive woods, though - even the $2.99 butter-steel buck blade held up well in cocobolo vs. falling apart almost immediately on anything with silica otherwise - even white limba, which is like marshmallow with sand in it.