Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Observation about sharpenability - nomi

Posts

Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#1

Observation about sharpenability - nomi

David Weaver

I've bought probably a couple of hundred japanese chisels from japan now - more than 100. The draw to do it is that I can often find nice chisels for about $15 each and decent for a little less, then add proxy and shipping (Which isn't too bad if you can wait a few months).

Quite often, a chisel that is older and has had almost no use is overhard. Once in a while, I'll get overhard chisels that have been used heavily, but usually not. The ones that are heavily used have all had curious sharpening geometry (usually curvature of the bevel and a much shallower primary -I think the people using them are trying to minimize the area that they're sharpening).

A couple of weeks ago, I'd forgotten about an order that I made and I got about 60 chisels. 15 of them were in good sets, and most of the rest were junk (but they were priced like junk so that I could take the few good chisels out of them and maybe dump on ebay or throw away the rest of the garbage).

One of these two sets was very well used and almost perfectly cared for - this isn't common. I sold them on ebay yesterday, and some of them had been hand sharpened significantly out of square over time. I generally offer to correct this hoping someone will defer and say they want to, but the back polish on all of these chisels was perfect and flat and the top side sharpening was well done (slightly radiused) and the edges crisp. I have never bought a set with significant use that was in as good of shape as these.

Unfortunately, the buyer said they'd wait for me to correct them (i'm usually hoping not to get into finding out that they're overhard). It only took me about 30 minutes to completely correct 6 of the 10 chisels. They sharpen beautifully - easily on an india stone and will finish reasonably nicely on a washita stone with some focused work near the edge. A small burr forms (the washita won't create a burr on overhard chisels), and then I buffed the tip (of course) :|

What made these so well loved? They likely have zero tendency to chip and would be amenable to natural or synthetic stones. if I hadn't sold them already, I probably would've sold one of my high hardness sets to keep them.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#2

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

Jack Dover

I would totally buy the 5 chisels set, if only ebay alerts would get delivered before an item is sold.

Pretty much every source states HSS chisels don't get as sharp as carbon steel. It makes sense. Definitely a paring chisel is preferable in carbon steel, but what about bench chisels, could this difference be quantified in some way? Most people on internet assume HSS is for chopping bricks, concrete, cast iron pipes, rebar and ironwood occasionally. Many seems to imply it should be your secondary set.Unfortunately I can't test my assumptions whether it will be useful for regular cabinetmaking other than buying a set.

I have a single HSS cutter in a tiny Hong Kong-style plane, didn't realize it was HSS because diamonds didn't have any problems cutting it. Carbon steel cutters would drop to the same level of sharpness after just a couple of minutes of use. So shouldn't carbon steel chisels drop to about the same sharpness as HSS chisels after a a little bit of chopping and a little bit of paring? And surely HSS chisels should retain sharpness better and longer than soft chisels that bend over almost immediately, right?

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#3

edge stability

David Weaver

I learned these terms from knife people. Generally, whatever is going to be driven to high hardness with a fine edge is going to be something about like file steel. A knife like that won't be tough to twisting or hitting nails, but it holds its fine edge well.

No matter how good the carbon steel is, though, it won't have the abrasion resistance in wood or especially in worse than a decent high speed steel or a similar type with tons of carbides.

There's a combination of things, I think, that keep people from really liking HSS chisels and going back to something that's easier to sharpen (and for me, the same with the muji planes - they're great irons, but I like a plainer iron better because of edge stability - resistance to losing the very bit of the edge and uniform wear).

* HSS takes longer to sharpen, usually about twice as long on an able abrasive. Most people don't count strokes so sharpening 25% more as a thought after finishing a normal cycle seems like doing a lot. When I counted strokes with the 3V, it took double. If someone is using a honing guide with two steps and the second is very fine, it may take 100 strokes total to completely finish an edge. People think they do that, but nobody does. It's a 4-5 minute process

* aversion to doing that makes people do sharpening less ("but the steel is better, so it shouldn't be an issue, it should last longer" and they deal with more damaged edges). I guess the fact that those kinds of tools usually hold on to a wire edge doesn't help, either- if you don't remove it, it makes them seem marginally sharp and they only shave hair on one side of the bevel - you can flip the side back and forth with a fine stone - one side shaves easily, the other one doesn't at all. When something is sharp with no wire, it shaves easily on both sides. I used to have this with shaptons - I thought I was orienting the edge, but i think the reality is the pros are aggressive enough that they create a tiny wire edge. If you orient it in your favor, it's not noticeable - I think that just causes it to be ripped off when you start working with it.

* and lastly, the desire to set a chisel up like another chisel and call it no good because they don't perform the same is a problem. I'd bet edge stability is had with HSS at a couple of degrees more than carbon steel. You cater to the tool the way it wants to be used and it will deliver what it's supposed to.

I didn't unicorn and test any of the HSS chisels that I bought, but I'd be willing to bet that in a double blind test, nobody would be able to tell the difference between their sharpness and a carbon steel chisel in use once the edge was unicorned. The strange thing about the whole unicorn process is that while It will allow the edges to remain fine edges on high speed steel, it makes mediocre chisels last half a project and you still get drawn back by how well the mediocre chisels sharpen because they don't resist abrasion.

The set of 5 that I sold had a lot of surface corrosion (the listing said that, too, but you never know with people - I rarely ever get anything back or even a complaint but once in a while someone tells me their wife looked at something they bought and didn't like it - which is code for "i don't have the spine to tell you I changed my mind, and I know there's nothing on these that wasn't in the listing, so I'm coming up with a wild card"). I've gotten that one a few times. At any rate, they were sharpened with a grinder, and the entire bevel wasn't uniformly sharpened and they were convex but shallow. Someone found them hard to sharpen. They weren't that bad and anyone with a diamond plate, india stone and a buffer would do fine with them as long as they reminded themselves to follow the rules and complete each step (those chisels are hard enough and abrasion resistant enough that a settled in fine india stone only cuts like a washita does on the back of a carbon steel chisel).

I cannot remember the name of those chisels, but they were sold in droves over here cheaply in the 1980s. Part of the reason for that was the exchange rate (250-300 yen per dollar, currently probably 110 or something - same with electric guitars - they could be sold here at a price around or lower than a gibson offering and music stores could really mark them up. when the exchange rate lost that, the favorability of importing guitars that had much labor went away. I'd guess some of that also has to do with why the first wave of japanese tool fanaticism crapped out - it was no longer possible for someone to bring in chisels at $10 each and sell them for $40 each, etc. It became more like $25-$30 and sell for $40 and nobody wanted to do that. )

Too much TLDR there, but I just shoveled all of the snow here and am working my way through my coffee.

(those chisels are made nicely despite being budget chisels, and last I saw them in the states, or on dictum, they were closer to $60-$70 each. That's highway robbery for what they are. They're just cut and ground to shape, mono steel).

https://www.ebay.com/p/1966452371

(I guess they're still made. They're sold cheaply in japan still if someone will go to the trouble to ship them free on ebay and sell to gaijin. Probably $25-$30 in japan. The used set that I bought was $70 on buyee, probably $100 once proxy and shipping and consolidation fees are added, and I sold them for $125. I felt a little guilty selling them at that with surface corrosion, too!! but buyee can be a little risky and sometimes things don't show up in the same condition you expected and you lose out. Identical set, including the box. They've been making those for probably 40 years. I wouldn't buy them new at that price).

(another btw - I don't know if you were reading here when I did a plane durability test - the HSS irons from china in clean wood do run about 60% further than a good O1 iron, which is probably about the practical limit for any low alloy steel. Really hard carbon steel with a little bit more alloying like super blue has the potential to last about as long as A2, but that's about it, but even that loses a bit of edge stability.

chinese HSS

https://i.imgur.com/E4KQVMc.jpg

O1

https://i.imgur.com/NEa8MHe.jpg

You can see how much more uniform O1 stays. It's not really possible to retain that kind of edge stability once carbide count goes up - even with V11. V11 is very abrasion resistant, but not very tough.

(I suspected that, but saw toughness testing by a metallurgist here charting knife steels and XHP is about 1/3rd as tough as the fine carbide stainless steels like AEB-L at similar hardness. It also probably wears twice as long. Avoiding edge damage in a controlled test is easy, but in normal use, I've seen more edge trouble anecdotally - in terms of avoiding little notches that split shavings or leave lines on work. Same is true for the chinese stuff, which seems tough further up the bevel but will let the edge go.

Found the unicorn method to be protective of all edges in really abrasive woods, though - even the $2.99 butter-steel buck blade held up well in cocobolo vs. falling apart almost immediately on anything with silica otherwise - even white limba, which is like marshmallow with sand in it.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#4

HSS chisels

Winston

It's commonly believed that HSS doesn't get as sharp as carbon steel, but I don't think that's really true. Or at least, it's not true for the reasons that people think it is.

It's probably true that when most people sharpen HSS, they don't get it as sharp as carbon steel, simply because it's takes significantly more effort to do so. (I believe the same is true for sharpening A2 vs carbon steel, but HSS may be even more difficult than A2.)

It may also be true that, when people are getting blades really sharp, HSS won't get as sharp as carbon steel. But we're talking straight-razor levels of sharpness, not the level of sharpness you'd get even with a 12000 grit stone.

I'll try to dig up some microscope pictures tonight of a carbon steel chisel and an HSS chisel, each sharpened to 12000 grit, and then buffed.

I have a set of relatively inexpensive HSS chisels. I think they're the same ones that David linked to on eBay. I got mine from https://www.fine-tools.com/high-speed-steel-chisels.html, before COVID restrictions made shipping prohibitively expensive. They were around $30-40 each (the listed prices include VAT, but if you live outside the EU, you don't need to pay it, so the actual cost is less).

Here are my observations about them:

- You really need to use a grinder and make a microbevel. Otherwise it takes forever to sharpen them.

- The backs of some of them were not flat initially, and it took a lot of work to flatten them.

- They are very tough. I roughed out the mortise for a plane out of a dry and hard piece white oak. I tried a number of different chisels, including a Buck Bros chisel sharpened to 25 degrees and then buffed, a Veritas PM-V11 at 25 degrees and buffed. They all sustained some edge damage. Finally I went to one of these HSS chisels sharpened to 30 degrees and then buffed, and with it I did about 60% of this mortise with no visible edge damage. Still just a thin line reflecting light at the edge. At the end of, it was still able to pare oak end grain (though it wasn't as sharp as it was at the beginning).

Here's a picture of the plane with the roughed-out mortise, and the chisel in the background:


Now, given that the bevel angle before buffing was 30 degrees for these HSS chisels, that of course means that the edge will be more durable than one that started at 25 degrees. But I've used the other chisels also at 30 degrees and buffed, and the HSS chisels are definitely more durable.

I don't think the abrasion resistance of the HSS chisels really makes a difference for the stuff that I've used the chisels for -- I think it's just that they're really hard.

I would like to find carbon steel chisels that have a similar hardness to these HSS chisels, but in a western pattern, and not super expensive. With the unicorn edge, there's much less risk of chipping, which is something one would normally have to worry about with very hard carbon steel. And a carbon steel would be easier to sharpen than HSS. Unfortunately, I'm not sure anyone sells chisels like this.

As an aside, here's a glamor shot of the plane with some of the shavings it made:


Thanks, by the way, to David for his videos about making planes and to Steve Voigt for his article in Popular Woodworking on the topic!

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#5

at woodworking angles...

David Weaver

..same initial sharpness, same cut resistance, etc. The only thing I noticed in plane iron testing is that lots of chromium seems to lead to less cut resistance and lots of vanadium seems to lead to more.

I'm sure it's more complex than that, but it could be felt.

That could also lead someone to believe one tool was sharper than another (just the feel) when the edge and the wood surface don't show it.

Let me know what size and pattern you'd like for a pair of chisels, and what you want to do with them. I can get files really close to that hardness and they'll last with the unicorn. The only condition is that they'll be tang chisels, but I can make the tang chisels really heavy.

The one thing you'll notice, though, is that high carbon chisels at 65c will still be very slow sharpening. I've had softer HSS chisels that are much easier to sharpen than my file chisels at the highest hardness - one of the reasons I'm so enamored with the files as a base to make chisels is because they have super edge stability and must have enough alloying elements to take a bonkers hard initial hardness. They can be made to feel like japanese steel without lamination.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#6

no charge for a pair of file chisels...

David Weaver

....by the way.

It gives me an opportunity to try different things and nobody can complain about workmanship when you charge nothing!

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#7

this ground was plowed by Steve Elliot

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Conclusion, when sharpened with an abrasive that will cut hard carbides HSS can sharpen equivalently. There is always the caveat that the steel can be poorly manufactured and not sharpen well. But particle steel M2 will sharpen just fine with diamond, if you want to go there. Virtually all of Kato and Kawai's work was with HSS knives. That is all that will hold up in a planing machine.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#8

diamond is the caveat...

David Weaver

..most people don't want to use loose diamonds on cast.

As odd as it may sound to most, it's better to choose the stone that you like and then the steel that matches it than it is to choose the steel you like and then find out you don't like the sharpening media.

Whatever feels good and is quick and assured, we will do. I guess it's fine to throw diamonds on an oilstone, though, too, if one has to really cross boundaries.

I could stir up some trouble by putting 1 micron diamond on my oilstones and then comparing edge longevity and surface brightness (longevity and initial sharpness would be better with micron diamonds spread on the oilstone as long as there was enough of them to do a significant amount of the work).

Larrin has published more or less the same - that in a controlled test, none of the blades are difficult to refresh.

(in the cycle of more plane use, and probably with abuse of knives, things change, though unless the user of the super steel is a rare individual who loves to sharpen before it really needs to be done).

I would be surprised by two things:

1) if anyone ever made a plain steel iron that matches 3v in edge longevity in clean planing or almost any planing (even rough wood)

2) if in any practical setup, a 3v chisel would outlast a high carbon steel chisel driven to a higher hardness (where 3V can't reach).

V11 is less tough than 3V according to toughness charts (unclear how this applies directly to chiseling, though, as some of the high carbon steels great at fine edge holding will do terribly in an industry standard notching test), but I found it much harder to accommodate a V11 chisel (that ground and sharpened half as fast) than I did to find a way to cease damage in chisels of white steel or O1).

Ultimately, the sorby was too soft to eliminate all damage at any reasonable flat apex, too - even at 34, there was still notching in the edge. It was just too soft.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#9

Thanks!

Winston

I'll have to think about what exactly I'd use them for, but I'll get in touch about it directly.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#10

Re: HSS chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you think that A2 steel can get as good an edge as carbon steel, I would question your sharpening skill.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#11

they can...

David Weaver

it's a matter of media.

Once the media is fine enough to avoid creating any material foil at the edge, things are equivalently sharp.

The next step after that is fine edge holding, and that's where things come apart. Literally.

You can make a razor out of S30V that will be extremely sharp, but it probably will degrade significantly within a shave. If someone is a fan of the method that cliff stamp suggests (which is to more or less chase sharpening just to the edge without creating a large wire edge, then the super steels are not going to satisfy).

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#12

Observation of LN irons...

David Weaver

.at LN events isn't going to be a good indicator, as A2, even theirs (Which is as good as A2 gets from what I've used) will take damage over the day and they won't do what it takes to remove it. typical damage from rough use planing can be 2-4 thousandths deep from what I've seen, and nobody takes that much steel off of a tool in a sharpening session - not even close (and it remains invisible once it gets below a fraction of that, but still leaves its mark on wood).

From a practical standpoint, if the chart I'm reading is correct, A2 has about 0.4% vanadium, which would yield very little that wasn't in solution. So the carbides would be chromium and molybdenum - neither is uncuttable by a waterstone, they just hone more slowly than iron carbides (which is another reason that people don't usually complete the job).

Most of the carbides in 440c at high hardness and XHP are chromium. Even though they are easily cut by alumina, it still takes much longer to grind away the same material. A2 is tougher than anything we use that's cast steel, O1, 1095 at a given hardness, but the toughness test that's used somehow doesn't (in my experience) match what knife people refer to as edge stability.

Edge stability in A2 is fine for sharpening at angles where carbon steel doesn't take damage - arguable about use (really large carbide steels at narrow angles will lose carbides while sharpening if the edge gets small enough - like 10 degrees total bevel or maybe at razor levels - 16-18 degrees - I think high carbide steels won't stand up to a razor strop).

The S-series of steels (especially the ones with larger carbides) can prescribe as much as 50 degrees to have a stable edge, but they're mostly used in plastic manufacturing as far as I know, so I doubt they care about that. Plenty of knives made with them, but I've never had one. 154CM was bad enough for me.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#13

Re: Observation of LN irons...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Over the day? I have been to LN events and watched them sharpen the stuff and seen the result.

I have been to Woodworking in America events where guys had $3,000 planes, freshly sharpened. They tell you the resulting surface is smooth as glass, but it is not up to the carbon steel standard.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#14

They're not completing the sharpening job..

David Weaver

...each time.

XHP/V11 create a brighter surface than carbon steel does at same hardness with the same abrasive, and A2 is at least as bright.

If the wood is typical, A2 doesn't chip in continuous wood until it gets about to the point (feet planed) where similar hardness O1 fails.

It's not the fault of the material in either case, it's the fault of the person sharpening. Most people sharpen what they can see looking at an iron, they don't sharpen to a result.

This is the edge of an LN A2 iron sharpened with 1 micron diamonds. I can almost guarantee that when you strop on bare leather, you remove bigger particles than anything shown in this picture. If you were local to me, I'd be glad to sit in when you took an iron in use, sharpened in 90 seconds, and then take a picture of the edge with this scope. If you are using any oilstones, it would be less fine. No wear was as uniform as this starting edge when I put the wood into a test in an idealized situation.

it's not a big deal, but the statement that it can't attain similar sharpness, surface brightness or feel is incorrect, and incomplete sharpening by some demonstrators doesn't change that.

I'm not sure why we expect planemakers to be master sharpeners if we don't manufacturers of butcher knives to be master butchers.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#15

A2 and carbon steel

Winston

I think it makes more sense to question the sharpening skill of someone who can't get A2 as sharp as carbon steel.

I know you've said in the past that the A2 blades you've used at Lie-Nielsen events aren't as sharp as your carbon steel blades, but I don't think those are necessarily a good point of comparison. If you say that someone making a $3000 plane isn't getting their A2 blades as sharp as your carbon steel blades, then it stands to reason that they don't have the sensitivity to tell the difference -- why would they knowingly sell a plane with a blade that leaves an inferior surface? And if that's the case, it makes sense to question their sharpening skill, since, if they can't detect the difference in surface quality, they'd have no reason to learn how to get a blade sharper.

Here's a carbon steel chisel (Buck Bros) finished on a Shapton Pro 12000:


Here's an A2 blade (Veritas) finished on the same stone:


They look pretty darn similar to me, and in use, I've never noticed a difference in initial sharpness.

Now, there are large carbides present in A2 that aren't present in the carbon steel, but they're not visible in the pictures above. They are revealed by buffing, though -- probably because the buffing wheel is a much more compliant surface than the hard sharpening stone.

Here's the carbon steel blade after being buffed:


And the A2 blade:


The carbides are clearly visible in A2, but not the carbon steel. Even so, I don't think they're large enough to make a noticeable difference in practice. There are only a few places in the picture where carbides are right at the cutting edge. And the size of the carbides look like they're on par with the size of the scratches from the 12000 grit stone.

With all of these blades, after they've been buffed, I'm able to catch and cut hairs without the blade contacting skin. That goes for A2, O1 and other carbon steels, PM-V11, and HSS.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#16

and a follow up picture...

David Weaver

..A2 after 200 feet. I didn't observe any degradation in the surface when using A2 (in clean wood) until about 800 feet. My O1 iron stopped at 780.

The O1 surface didn't have significant degredation at all, but the surface brightness may have been slightly lower:

https://i.imgur.com/jFlhzip.jpg

This A2 picture shows an edge at 200 feet that is more uniform than most sharpening options are capable of creating at the outset in carbon steel.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#17

Re: HSS chisels

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A2 is not a HSS. But to the point, the most common high speed steel is M2. It will be the steel that is in you thickness planer or jointer. It is abrasion resistant which is why it is used in these application. Steve Elliot demonstrated that it could be made as sharp as anything else.

That said it makes a lousy chisel. Abrasion resistance is not of primary importance to a chisel. Toughness is and M2 is not tough. I made a chisel from an M2 jointer blade and it microchipped severely. This deficiency coupled with the impossibility of sharpening it with anything but diamond makes it, and likely most other HSS, poor candidates for a chisel.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#18

Re: A2 and carbon steel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Several of the plane makers whom I was talking about have switched from A2 to O1 in recent years. Maybe there are some things you don't know.

If you were using a 12,000 Shapton stone for polishing, it is no wonder the buffing improved it.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#19

Warren, you're the one missing..

David Weaver

..accuracy in this discussion. You've formed an opinion about something you haven't worked with and you're hinging your argument on people who may not be very good at sharpening, or may not care.

You can criticize the shapton 12k, and it's definitely an aggressive stone with less than close grading, but the reality is that without buffing the bevel side, most oilstones don't look a whole lot better.

If you're using an oilstone, you don't have anything that will prepare an edge on a plane iron that will match the diamond prepared edge that I showed (Which didn't have the benefit of having the bevel side buffed).

The defects caused by stropping in general with more than the weight of the plane iron are greater than anything shown in the A2 picture.

You're wrong on this, and you don't have enough experience with it to know that you are. There's a parallel here to your assertion that you could find a carbon steel iron that would outlast the alloyed irons. It's incorrect and only based on lack of experienced combined with confidence that lack of experience can generate.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#20

Re: A2 and carbon steel

Winston

> Several of the plane makers whom I was talking about have switched from A2 to O1 in recent years. Maybe there are some things you don't know.

Who sells $3,000 planes and has switched from A2 to O1? You're right that I don't know. I would be interested to know, and I'm sure that others here would also be interested. Instead of hinting at some hidden knowledge, you could enlighten the community.

From a previous post:

> I have been to Woodworking in America events where guys had $3,000 planes, freshly sharpened. They tell you the resulting surface is smooth as glass, but it is not up to the carbon steel standard.

You were telling us that these mystery makers either didn't know what a really sharp blade was, or that they were deceiving their audience about how smooth the surface was. Now you want us to trust their judgment.

All that said, I think there are valid reasons for a maker to go from A2 to O1. The latter is easier to grind and sharpen, which increases the likelihood that the customer would actually get a very sharp edge.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#21

The switch from A2 to O1 is...

David Weaver

....likely due to forum sentiment. When A2 came along, the scuttlebutt was that there was no reason to buy O1 irons. LN added O1 as an option later (and then the firm that did their heat treatment for O1 stopped doing it, retired or went out of business or something).

As time has gone on, A2 has gotten a bunch of negative press (I could be responsible for some of that, and I do think that the part of it that outlasts O1 is not that much, only about 25% at same hardness, and with an edge quality in that interval where it's not desirable, but before then, it's OK - the real issue is that it's more than 25% more effort to sharpen, so the bargain is lost). If you're selling a $3000 plane, you can't have something in it that other people criticize. Karl holtey sold a lot of planes with it (For more than $3000).

It's like anything else - if you're going to use it, you have to learn what it likes and accommodate it. Most of the people who refuse to accommodate it want to sharpen it or use it like another steel, which doesn't make a lot of sense. Just as much as talking about the sharpness of really high alloy steels doesn't make sense if the person sharpening them insists that everything has to be judged off of oilstones.

A2 doesn't like washitas, though - I can't deny that.

The forum and wood show choice now of O1 (which was tossed aside when A2 first came around because it didn't "wear long enough") goes in cycles. It'll be something else soon.

FWIW, in reading the blade steel testing thread from Larrin Smith, I noticed that japanese tool fanatics declared his data to be suspect because they didn't get what they wanted out of super blue steel. Super blue has about the potential to wear as long as A2. There's nothing in it that would put it beyond that, but that's difficult for people to accept. The only thing that never appears is actual data to prove the real data sets wrong.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#22

Re: A2 and carbon steel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Konrad Sauer switched from A2 to O1 some years ago. He explained that it was so he could get sharper irons. There are two other high price plane makers who now use O1 but I am not certain what their motivations are.

I avoid naming makers like this because people who have bought their wares get pretty excited when someone criticizes the product. A guy who has spent five or ten thousand for a collection of these planes finds it upsetting to read that they do not perform any better than a cheap plane.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#23

Re: HSS chisels

Jack Dover

You really need to use a grinder and make a microbevel. Otherwise it takes forever to sharpen them.

That would be my next question. From what I learned about HSS tools they assume high speed grinding, so hollow grinding came to mind immediately. There's some Iyoroi reseller's website suggesting a grinder is a must for HSS chisels.

That's a really nice plane by the way. A Chinese style body - curved shape and proportions, all that - is very appealing. And heavy mortising like that is why I was considering a HSS set.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#24

Re: edge stability

Jack Dover

Found the unicorn method to be protective of all edges in really abrasive woods, though - even the $2.99 butter-steel buck blade held up well in cocobolo

Well, I managed to find "chisels" made of recycled soda cans it seems. Some time ago I had a great deal on 3 Footprint chisels, and the story of Footprint is similar to Bluechip. Mine are hard and properly tempered, but a 3/4" chisel was missing. I've bought another set that had it and they're very soft. Even unicorning at some ridiculous primary angle of >33˚ can't prevent an edge from folding after just a few chops in red oak. I should probably stop buying tools like this. Don't want to re-sell them either, because most probably a beginner would buy them and will be very disappointed.

But getting back to abrasion resistance: how important is it in moderate hardwoods? Many people claim Japanese chisels are more abrasion resistant because most of their work is in softwoods rich in silica, like cedar and certain firs. I understand that all woods are abrasive, but was thinking that an edge will break way before it will wear from abrading in most domestic hardwoods.

Re: Observation about sharpenability - nomi

#25

Re: edge stability

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Hardness to prevent deforming the edge, and toughness to prevent chipping are the important variables for a chisel. Plane blades can pass through hundreds of feet of wood before dulling. That would be a lot of chiseling!