Re: JKI and Maksim
David Weaver
you could be right, though I tend to think they're on the way high side (I haven't looked specifically at their knives and crossed to listings in japan, but would guess a knife in the mid range from either would be about 50-100% higher than the cost in japan).
The one shining example of inexpensive in the US was chef's knives to go, at least relatively. They were the first seller that I can recall selling imanishi products at a price only a little bit above what they cost in japan. I haven't followed them for at least 8 years, so some of this could've changed. What CKTG seemed to be interested in was volume and making a private label brand of knives at the time (and they were often a bit adventurous, and some of them failures).
There's a tie in to imanishi here (who distributes a huge number of the natural stones and so many that they will often have uniform stones from certain mines - like atagaoyama and ohira tomae. These are useful here because there are grades of them but enough of each that you can price parallel grades).
Here's an example of ohira tomae prices (I never checked maksim for these):
* hida - $400 (may be more if they still have some). These are always marked "Ippon sen", or specially selected or something like that
* CKTG - $235
* Heavy Tool (a retail store in japan that lists on japan yahoo) $150-$165
I had one of these from hida and eventually sold it for half of new cost or thereabouts. Out of curiosity, I bought two from heavy tool - same stone.
Atagoyama is where I was flabbergasted by maksim. I bought an atagoyama (imanishi marked) stone from heavy tool, new at retail, for $235. It cost a fair bit to ship the stone because it was over 7 pounds. Maksim has the same stone listed for about $800 -$900 (several listings). These are ubiquitous and a lot easier to compare than something like nakayama suita, etc, where there aren't tons and there definitely aren't big ones. Atagoyama was a surface mine and they were actually very good stones (finer than the ohira tomae), but i think their common availability actually hurt their reputuation. So's page relayed information about the mine and the uniformity of the stones, and thus the ability to easily cut them into stones at 3kg or bigger. Their fineness makes them a bit slow, but all truly fine japanese finishers are slow. If they get a reputation for being slow, it's unfair.
One final example - ogata planes. There are two dealers at least selling these right now. Ogata supposedly retired (and if he did, he had an enormous stock of unsold planes). One dealer in japan who specializes in foreign sales had the same planes (ogata has a couple of designs that he repeated, so you can compare them). Before these dealers carried ogata's planes, I got one from alex gilmore with subblade for $265. This is where a mark up artist comes in. A plane isn't selling in japan, the maker keeps making irons, builds a big stock and retires. Create a narrative and the dealer in japan begins to sell them for $450-$500. Then, Japan woodworker lists them in their catalog for $780 and claims to be the only place that you can buy ogata's planes because "he retired and they bought all of them" or something similar. I wonder how much of that ogata received. I'm guessing less than $200 per blade and subblade, but that's just a guess. (this is to be expected from JWW - their listed prices were double Stu's for the same plane from tsunesaburo)
The dealer who specializes in selling to people who speak english then removed the listings from his site and ogata's planes reappeared at $780. That is the price for the exact blade and subblade that I had including a dai. I thought $450-$500 was a little high given that alex could apparently go over and get some and come back and sell them for $265 so, but that's life - dealers in japan who speak english generally charge more (some who sell both in and out of country sell for 50% more to foreign customers, but their foreign customer price is still below what most foreign-only dealers charge).
(I tracked down the ohira type 30 tomae mentioned above on maksim's site - it converts to $512 right now without vat)
All of that said, it is fair to say that's just business. CKTG is the only retailer I'm aware of who gets a bunch of stuff from imanishi and only marks it up a little bit. They are often out of stock because of that. I think it's also fair to say that the strategy on stones is likely a lot worse than knives, as stamping is a free for all over there except for a few stamps, and stones that I would've bought on yahoo japan for about $75 are now stamped with maruka stamps (bright purple) and sold for $400-$600. I usually resold those for about $100, and I think a dealer trying to make a profit would've needed to sell them for $150-$175 to cover costs and deal with returns. The whole stamping thing is an entirely different issue, but
https://www.chefknivestogo.com/atmequ.html
(actually, the stone that maksim is selling for $512 is a couple of grades lower than the one in the CKTG listing. Here is an example of koppa that should sell for about $80 being marked to over $400 with public domain stamps - 15mm thick is generally thinner than most koppa)
some of this could be happening at the distribution level, too, but not all of it. I'm being polite by saying that (the distributor may be doing the stamping and some of the marking up).
I included JKI in the lists because (if I recall correctly), they had a bunch of alumina private label stones created and sold them for double the price of an imanishi synthetics. The narrative that goes with that is to say that there's something special about the private label stone, but a more realistic assumption is that private label stone sellers aren't satisfied with the margins on common stones distributed widely. The private stones aren't any better.
A few (like fujibato and takeshi kuroda would have private label stones made, but in the case of theirs, they were cheaper than the branded stones. I bought a few of those from both, and in each case, they were very good. At the same time choseras came out and said the magnesia binder was very expensive, fujibato had a magnesia binder 6k grit stone made, no label, and it was $38 with free shipping from japan. I think he was trolling them. I still have that. I wish he'd have chosen a 10k grit range stone, but 6k finish is probably more typical for knife people, and that's likely most of his market. If fujibato carried or ordered anything that the above mentioned ogata seller also sold, fujibato's price was generally about half - I see fujibato isn't carrying iyoroi's specialty chisels right now, so I can't make an easy comparison, but there are people who buy from the high priced dealer i'm mentioning and I'll let it rest, same as I haven't taken much of a look through maksim's knives, I don't think he deals many of the high volume knives that sell for not much - a quick browse at the bottom of a listing states that he doesn't carry anything in knives that's mass produced - perhaps the stones are his profit center, don't know).
(I just browsed a couple of CKTG items to see if they're still operating on the same philosophy and see prices close to what are charged at retail in japan for rikizai knives. Cheers to them for choosing to sell more at a lower margin to get to the same place).