Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Follow up on Japanese Knife

Posts

Follow up on Japanese Knife

#1

Follow up on Japanese Knife

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A friend sent the information to someone in Japan who wrote back.....

it says Kai Group, Kai means Shell in Japanese.

This is top brand of (shell mark brands) knife in Japan, especially for Sushi chef, some of those are quite expensive over $500 - 1,000.

He suggested that I take good care of it.

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#2

Kai group...

David Weaver

..looks like a manufacturer in seki-city who makes knives for distribution (some brands like shun, etc). I think you'd probably find that knife as mentioned below to be in the $100 class or so in japan, maybe a little bit above depending on where it's positioned.

Brands like shun are probably mostly export (they're sold for multiple of what the same tojiro knife would be sold for, flashier, similar quality).

The high three and four figure knives are generally made by someone with a story in a small shop and hand finished (for example, shigefusa knives have caught fire price-wise, but the shop master/maker apprenticed under iwasaki and they do actually do a lot of their knife finishing by hand - as in scraping and hand stone finishing. They probably actually forge the core and laminations together vs. factory rolled-together material that can be cut, shaped and finished by machine without any forging).

In between factory made knives of about $125-$150 at the top end and the $500-$1000 hand finished knives is a no-man's land of prestige pricing (for example, if you see a $500 japanese knife that's 62 hardness blue or white steel sold in the united states, and maybe kind of showy, it's distributed by pt. barnum's distribution). Danger exists below about the $75 price level also, which will be knives that look like yours but that have soft steel in them or similar to german steel knives. Some of the production of the lower end knives has gone to china only to be checked over and distributed from japan. These types of knives are more in line with $40 for a chef's knife, look like the $75-$125 knives, and will often be sold in the US (or tried) at the same cost of a good knife in japan.

Referring back to the shigefusa knives (only because they're popular in the west and really high priced, so they get attention), the maker's claim (or at least the seller's) is that shigefusa has figured out some kind of process that makes the knives very hard but very easy to sharpen .Any time this has ever been said for chisels (often with swedish carbon steel), the chisels are just tempered softer. Same with plane irons. People glow about how easy sharpening some swedish plane irons are, but the washita rats them out as being a softer temper when it can generate a wire edge on them.

Not relevant for your knife, but this kind of thing is one of the dippy things about japanese tools, knives and razors. People like to work with something that is plain steel and a little on the soft side (but hard by western standards - like 62/63 hardness), but they don't want to admit it's soft. They want to believe the maker is magical instead.

A $100 (street price) factory knife in japan is *awfully* good. Good enough to be marked up to $200 or $300 depending on distribution and branding in the US.

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#3

an example of no-man's land.. *LINK*

David Weaver

https://www.arizonacustomknives.com/products/389657/

$599 for a knife with some guy's name on it, made of a slightly varied VG-10 steel at 61 hardness. ("VG-Max").

The handle and bolster are slapped on prelaminated material (and look strange compared to the typical knife with the blade welded to the bolster and then finished - like yours and mine). The whole combination is "really something".

Compared to what looks like a nicer knife made by Kai and sold on ebay with shipping from japan for less than a third (this knife would be $100 in japan at retail)..

(correction, it wasn't hard to track down in japan - $90 equivalent in japan. "cannot be shipped to the united states". Of course. It would be hard to sell them for double or triple if you could just be linked to japan and pay $20 shipping). https://www.amazon.co.jp/AE-5205-Damascus-Kitchen-Knife-Series/dp/B003YUBLW4?ref_=ast_sto_dp

The forum link shortener puts these out of order - the ebay link is at the end, and the follow up finding of the same knife on amazon japan is before it)


ebay link - kai damascus

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#4

Re: an example of no-man's land..

Philip F Duffy

I find it hard to believe you can belittle a knife made by a MASTER craftsman in Japan when you can not hold it in your hands and compare it to some mass produced piece of cheap blade on ebay. P

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#5

Re: Kai group...

Winston

There are many knives in the $150 and up range that are not made in a factory; they're made by individual blacksmiths. These are usually found at dealers who specialize in Japanese knives; kitchenware stores and retailers like Amazon will generally only carry factory-made knives.

Kai is large manufacturer of knives. As David mentioned, they make the Shun line of knives, but they also make more and less expensive knives.

Most of the craftsman-made knives are layered, with a hard steel in the middle and softer steel cladding. I believe that most of these are made from prelaminated material, except for at the higher end.

The exceptions to this are honyaki knives, which, instead of having layers of different steel, are differentially hardened so the spine is not as hard as the cutting area. They are also very expensive (like $1000 and up).

For those that are curious, here's a place that sells Japanese knives:

https://www.japaneseknifeimports.com/

And here's a documentary about knife makers in Japan. It sounds like the craftsman knife makers are experiencing a bit of a revival these days, in contrast to woodworking tool smiths.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iFedUlHx558

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#6

Re: an example of no-man's land..

David Weaver

Which one is made by a different group than another - all three of those knives are made by the same manufacturer with the same cladding and either identical or nearly identical core.

They're all factory knives. I'm sure they are all good knives for slicing (Which is what most of us do with knives). One is $90, one is the same knife for $176 and one is practically the same knife in a different shape (but with clad bolsters instead of integral forged) for $600.

They're all the same hardness. Presumably ken onion pockets a fair amount of royalty for his name use in the odd shaped one, and since it's sold in the US, it's distributed here.

hand made and hand forged knives look like this:

https://www.aframestokyo.com/shigefusa-wa-petty-kitaejj-6inch-150mm-blade-k6150.html

of course, I don't know for sure that shigefusa does all of the work in house (but they do at least on some knives)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zNPc6xBBiLk&ab_channel=MaksimEnevoldsen

My point is simple, though - there are knives made with factory process, and there are hand made and hand forged knives. Most of the stuff in between is the former dressed up and prestige priced. The $100 knives are shockingly good, which is why nobody complains about the blingy $400 knives once they get them.

An example of blingy in japan also comes along with the naniwa chosera stones. Naniwa makes a magnesia binder stone for $80, it's between the 5000 and 10,000 chosera. The chosera stones are sold in knife shops without the snow white in the rotation. I asked stu about this once, and his response was that the chosera stones are positioned in high end knife shops, and the snow white isn't. I'm sure you can find higher end knife shops that sell the no-man's land knives, but they often have western brands on them ("bob kramer zwilling damascus").

We can't read japanese here, that makes is easy targets for stuff like that. Zwilling's "kramer" knife is about $400. Kai's un-endorsed knife is $90.

https://www.cutleryandmore.com/zwilling-ja-henckels-bob-kramer/stainless-damascus-chefs-knife-p132879

(for the extra cost, you get an SG2 core, which tips you off further that there's no "skilled craftsman forging" or anything of the sort going on. there are probably factory finishers operating jigged fixtures or slack belts on the handles. Sg2 vs. a simple stainless is a pretty bad idea in a kitchen knife, but it's a good way to spend an extra $10 on the laminated stock and charge an extra couple of hundred. The factory made "damascus" is a little bit more fancy, too).

The reviews for that knife on amazon are funny, because some of them warped in hardening and tempering, but shipped, anyway. Maybe they were bent in handling or shipping, who knows? Zwilling offers a 3 month turn around time for an exchange :| If kai makes those knives, I'd be surprised if they get more than $100 from the factory to make them. Zwilling says they're made in "seki city", so if it's not kai, it's another factory.

I may seem a bit cranky and obnoxious about this but I spent some time looking at what's out there before I bought my knives a few years ago and then pinged stu tierney about the difference between the $75 and $400 knives, and his commentary fits the formula. Hand forged knives made in a shop with a master (vs. a factory process) aren't to be found below nosebleed price.

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#7

JKI and Maksim

David Weaver

and others who sell to europe and the US are kind of mark-up artists. Maskim would sell stones I could find in japan for $235 at retail for $800-$900 (there's less ability to do that with knives, but some).

Mahogany Masterpieces or whatever that video was set the template and most of the industry revival is for export.

The videos of traditional making go out, and then everything is sold kind of with that notion that it's all made that way. Layers are discussed (but even a $75 Tojiro VG10 knife is rikizai - non-layered knifes are kind of uncommon unless they're something odd), and we get a glitzed up version of what's in japan.

Which is OK if someone wants to pay for the glitz. I don't think it goes back to the manufacturers, but they do get an expanded market.

I recall on the razor forum once that someone said "I want to try iwasaki kamisori, maybe tamahagane when I'm in japan. can you give me some places to go?" and one of the japanese members flatly said "they're mostly export market, you'll have trouble finding them on the ground here".

:\

the good end to this is you can sneak your way in one way or another to buying from japan without going through the mark up artists and get something like that Kai knife for $90 (perhaps through proxy) and it will last a lifetime. I have a tojiro (slightly less well finished, same specs) chef's knife that's VG10 and it tolerates my wife scraping things from time to time without chipping, never needs steeling and can be sharpened lightly every couple of months.

There is a positive side to this (to me, especially, I bought a few knives in blue 2 and VG10, they're excellent - none cost more than a typical solingen-made knife). That is, that bill can use his knife without feeling that it's too precious or needs to be babied. Just no dishwasher where the knife is banging around against other things - most are hard enough to chip).

If maksim or some other english-speaking (I think maksim is danish) manage to get a blacksmith's name well known, then the prices go up. It looks like shigefusa's knives have gone up a lot, and they are still always out of stock (the latter being the mark of a knife maker who is a few guys working in a shop - when they're out of stock, they're out. There's no magic ramp-up of supply, which is why we get main line retailers selling only factory knives. Nobody in the united states can tolerate waiting for stock unless they're really looking for something specialized. Seen not that long ago in the LN/WC dispute over LN's planes. As I recall WC wanted stock/quantity guarantees and LN wasn't able to guarantee them as many as they wanted. LN operates like an old school company "ghee, I don't know".

I have a tanaka santoku that was $65 10 years ago. It's "damascus" and blue steel. For some reason, they're double now (or more). I guess the maker has gained popularity, but they are just rikizai knives with a decent finish, and there's pressure from the chinese made knives now making clad VG10 and damacus knives well sharpened for $40 (I have one of those, too, and other than being slightly inaccurate in spots aesthetically, it's a *really* good knife that the stones say meets its hardness spec). I have trouble finding any fault in any of them. For the price, they're otherworldly. I have a little bit of scorn for fantasy narratives and $300-priced $100 knives, though, but that kind of thing isn't exclusive to knives.

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#8

Re: JKI and Maksim

Philip F Duffy

Too much gibberish for such a small argument!

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#9

Re: JKI and Maksim

David Weaver

It's data dense. However, it appears that for the dense, it looks like it's got little data.

(I thought your first post about the other knives being hand made was sarcastic, but I see it's more likely that you just don't know anything about the subject).

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#10

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My knife appears to have been around a while. Lots of patina on blade and handle. Also very well made as one can see in the handle.

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#11

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

Wiley Horne

Bill,

You have a fine knife. Sharpen it and use it every day in good health, with the wind at your back.

If you want to sell that knife for any reason, or no reason, email me. If I were you, I would keep the knife and see how sharp it will get under buffing!

Wiley

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#12

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

David Weaver

Typical factory knives in japan far outclass the knives made in solingen, even when they're made in what's probably an older solingen or french pattern like that. They make them thinner and harder and they're just better unless someone is absolutely married to steeling it.

If it doesn't outlast you 4 times over in heavy use, then that would be very unusual!!

I'll be interested in hearing whether or not you can raise much of a burr on it with a washita (which is a good choice finishing pre-buffer, anyway). A washita is one of the more reliable methods that I can think of in terms of gauging hardness.

The same is pretty much true of the chisels. Even the mid market chisels are sweeter and better in chopping than equivalent cost boutique western chisels. The first set of japanese chisels I ever bought were much like your knife - they had nice handles, no maker's mark and in the case with them, they had a chrysanthemum instead of a shell. They were made for export (I don't believe your knife was, but that's just a guess, or it would likely say "made in japan" somewhere on it in english). The only person who gave me a response to find out what the chisels were was the owner of hida. He flatly said "I don't know what they are, and don't recognize the mark, but if you use them, you will like them".

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#13

Re: an example of no-man's land..

Jack Dover

You seem to imply that mass manufactured items are a priori inferior in quality to items made by hand. It's very debatable if so, even if you have a particular item type in mind (e.g. knives, tools, etc.), beginning with a definition of "handmade"\"made by hand". You also seem to have an implicit definition of "cheap" which makes your point somewhat vague.

At any rate the "which chef knife is the best" misses the point: it's irrelevant how much money a cook paid for a knife, nobody ever asked about it at a restaurant. There is a certain kind of knife collectors that buy knives for a bunch of reasons other than its metallurgical properties, which is okay I guess, just don't expect same level of reverence on a woodworking hand tools forums. The perspective on such forums is usually whether something enables you to get projects done and at what cost if it does. Maybe this is why most of us use mass manufactured tools.

Also I'm bad at detecting sarcasm.

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#14

Re: JKI and Maksim

Philip F Duffy

Well, I have hammered out a few knives from start to finish but I suppose that does not count for much in your mind. Perhaps I can go ask George what he thinks. P.

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#15

Re: JKI and Maksim

David Weaver

I guess you'd have to tell me where hammering knives out in your own shop fits in with determining how the japanese knives are made and spotting which are factory made and which are made by hand.

That's the relevant part of this discussion. If you have a $500 knife, you may be inclined to baby it. If you know it's a really good $100 knife, you may be more inclined to use it and enjoy it without babying it. If you have a $100 knife and are concerned that it's a $500 knife, that doesn't make a lot of sense.

Bill's not that soft that he'd be put off by attempts at narrowing down exactly what he has.

Tell me what part of your hand made knives look like the welded bolster and vertical stria on the knife bill showed, as well as a very clear deep stamp (hand made japanese knives have no stamp like that - they're usually marked with a heavy electric engraver freehand).

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#16

Re: an example of no-man's land..

David Weaver

A solid middle of the road factory knife (in japan) is less of a risk than the hand made knives, especially for an average user.

This discussion promoted me to sharpen my $75 chef's knife yesterday, as I know it's been at least 6 months since I sharpened it (the mrs. objects to the way I sharpen knives). There were no large failures in the edge and the refresh took around 3 minutes (two stones on the IM 313 and the buffer).

There are two german knives in the same block - nobody has used them for several years that I'm aware of (the japanese knife can't go in the dishwasher, so it's never indisposed - my carbon steel knives are kept separate as they're inappropriately set up for someone who scrapes cutting boards).

When I was doing my go-around with knives years ago, I watched some of the more exotic custom spec knives on CKTG ($400-$1000). The comment sections were generally worse for them (overhard edges leading to chipping well beyond the initial edge, etc). We like things that are made consistently in factories, but none of us likes to admit it for some reason.

(my experience with well regarded high dollar chisels has been similar - they're not always 100% ready for general use out of the box. The issue is the same with high spec knives - usually too hard to have the toughness to excuse any mishandling).

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#17

Re: JKI and Maksim

David Weaver

Go for it on asking George anything about Japanese stuff, by the way. He's not much for guessing about things he hasn't looked into (and not much of a fan of Japanese goods).

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#18

Mass produced vs handmade

Jack Dover

I would personally go with a factory made precisely because of all that attention a handmade knife might require. While it's nice to own an exquisitely made item, my family has wildly varying degrees of respect to objects and their properties. I fix broken tips, broken handles and badly chipped edges regularly, and that's on knifes so soft that it shouldn't even be possible in theory. The most expensive knife in my kitchen is ~30$ Victorinox that I had sneaked in, a 75-100$ knife wouldn't get approved probably. However that would be a price range for my personal chef knife if I'd cook often.

Generally speaking I prefer mid-range tools, it feels like they provide the best price to quality ratio, quite serviceable and I'm less afraid to experiment with them. Sometimes I can go with clown cheap tools, which is fun for a bit, but usually a disappointment in a long run. I don't buy top of the line tools usually, because a tool is rarely a bottleneck, it's rather my skills. Or maybe my skills are insufficient to appreciate a premium level tool.

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#19

Re: JKI and Maksim

Winston

> and others who sell to europe and the US are kind of mark-up artists. Maskim would sell stones I could find in japan for $235 at retail for $800-$900 (there's less ability to do that with knives, but some).

I have to disagree about these sellers being "mark-up artists", at least when it comes to knives. There are several companies in the US and Canada now that import and sell Japanese knives, both factory and craftsman-made. There's too much competition for an unreasonable mark-up to be made. These are businesses that import things and sell them, and there's honest value in that. (I do recall seeing a fancy house goods store in Montreal selling a factory-made Japanese knife for 3x what it cost elsewhere and telling a fanciful story about it -- now that is being a mark-up artist.)

Many of the same knives can be found on Japanese web sites that don't cater to an international audience (web sites that are Japanese language only), and their prices for these knives is not substantially better. Maybe for someone who's really deep into this stuff, they can find better deals by ordering from Japan, but it's not exactly low-hanging fruit.

> The videos of traditional making go out, and then everything is sold kind of with that notion that it's all made that way.

I don't get the impression that most people think that a Tojiro or Mac or Shun knife is made by a blacksmith in a dark forge hammering a glowing piece of steel. (I made a distinction between factory and craftsman-made knives for a reason.) Now, there may be a common misconception that craftsman-made knives are all forge-laminated by the blacksmith, when in fact most of these knives are made from pre-laminated material.

As for the people selling Japanese natural stones, there may be a different story with regard to selling practices. I can't say I know much about Jnats, but since every stone is unique, and the market for them operates with very limited information, I can imagine that there's some less-than-fair stuff going on there.

Re: Follow up on Japanese Knife

#20

Re: JKI and Maksim

David Weaver

you could be right, though I tend to think they're on the way high side (I haven't looked specifically at their knives and crossed to listings in japan, but would guess a knife in the mid range from either would be about 50-100% higher than the cost in japan).

The one shining example of inexpensive in the US was chef's knives to go, at least relatively. They were the first seller that I can recall selling imanishi products at a price only a little bit above what they cost in japan. I haven't followed them for at least 8 years, so some of this could've changed. What CKTG seemed to be interested in was volume and making a private label brand of knives at the time (and they were often a bit adventurous, and some of them failures).

There's a tie in to imanishi here (who distributes a huge number of the natural stones and so many that they will often have uniform stones from certain mines - like atagaoyama and ohira tomae. These are useful here because there are grades of them but enough of each that you can price parallel grades).

Here's an example of ohira tomae prices (I never checked maksim for these):

* hida - $400 (may be more if they still have some). These are always marked "Ippon sen", or specially selected or something like that

* CKTG - $235

* Heavy Tool (a retail store in japan that lists on japan yahoo) $150-$165

I had one of these from hida and eventually sold it for half of new cost or thereabouts. Out of curiosity, I bought two from heavy tool - same stone.

Atagoyama is where I was flabbergasted by maksim. I bought an atagoyama (imanishi marked) stone from heavy tool, new at retail, for $235. It cost a fair bit to ship the stone because it was over 7 pounds. Maksim has the same stone listed for about $800 -$900 (several listings). These are ubiquitous and a lot easier to compare than something like nakayama suita, etc, where there aren't tons and there definitely aren't big ones. Atagoyama was a surface mine and they were actually very good stones (finer than the ohira tomae), but i think their common availability actually hurt their reputuation. So's page relayed information about the mine and the uniformity of the stones, and thus the ability to easily cut them into stones at 3kg or bigger. Their fineness makes them a bit slow, but all truly fine japanese finishers are slow. If they get a reputation for being slow, it's unfair.

One final example - ogata planes. There are two dealers at least selling these right now. Ogata supposedly retired (and if he did, he had an enormous stock of unsold planes). One dealer in japan who specializes in foreign sales had the same planes (ogata has a couple of designs that he repeated, so you can compare them). Before these dealers carried ogata's planes, I got one from alex gilmore with subblade for $265. This is where a mark up artist comes in. A plane isn't selling in japan, the maker keeps making irons, builds a big stock and retires. Create a narrative and the dealer in japan begins to sell them for $450-$500. Then, Japan woodworker lists them in their catalog for $780 and claims to be the only place that you can buy ogata's planes because "he retired and they bought all of them" or something similar. I wonder how much of that ogata received. I'm guessing less than $200 per blade and subblade, but that's just a guess. (this is to be expected from JWW - their listed prices were double Stu's for the same plane from tsunesaburo)

The dealer who specializes in selling to people who speak english then removed the listings from his site and ogata's planes reappeared at $780. That is the price for the exact blade and subblade that I had including a dai. I thought $450-$500 was a little high given that alex could apparently go over and get some and come back and sell them for $265 so, but that's life - dealers in japan who speak english generally charge more (some who sell both in and out of country sell for 50% more to foreign customers, but their foreign customer price is still below what most foreign-only dealers charge).

(I tracked down the ohira type 30 tomae mentioned above on maksim's site - it converts to $512 right now without vat)

All of that said, it is fair to say that's just business. CKTG is the only retailer I'm aware of who gets a bunch of stuff from imanishi and only marks it up a little bit. They are often out of stock because of that. I think it's also fair to say that the strategy on stones is likely a lot worse than knives, as stamping is a free for all over there except for a few stamps, and stones that I would've bought on yahoo japan for about $75 are now stamped with maruka stamps (bright purple) and sold for $400-$600. I usually resold those for about $100, and I think a dealer trying to make a profit would've needed to sell them for $150-$175 to cover costs and deal with returns. The whole stamping thing is an entirely different issue, but

https://www.chefknivestogo.com/atmequ.html

(actually, the stone that maksim is selling for $512 is a couple of grades lower than the one in the CKTG listing. Here is an example of koppa that should sell for about $80 being marked to over $400 with public domain stamps - 15mm thick is generally thinner than most koppa)

some of this could be happening at the distribution level, too, but not all of it. I'm being polite by saying that (the distributor may be doing the stamping and some of the marking up).

I included JKI in the lists because (if I recall correctly), they had a bunch of alumina private label stones created and sold them for double the price of an imanishi synthetics. The narrative that goes with that is to say that there's something special about the private label stone, but a more realistic assumption is that private label stone sellers aren't satisfied with the margins on common stones distributed widely. The private stones aren't any better.

A few (like fujibato and takeshi kuroda would have private label stones made, but in the case of theirs, they were cheaper than the branded stones. I bought a few of those from both, and in each case, they were very good. At the same time choseras came out and said the magnesia binder was very expensive, fujibato had a magnesia binder 6k grit stone made, no label, and it was $38 with free shipping from japan. I think he was trolling them. I still have that. I wish he'd have chosen a 10k grit range stone, but 6k finish is probably more typical for knife people, and that's likely most of his market. If fujibato carried or ordered anything that the above mentioned ogata seller also sold, fujibato's price was generally about half - I see fujibato isn't carrying iyoroi's specialty chisels right now, so I can't make an easy comparison, but there are people who buy from the high priced dealer i'm mentioning and I'll let it rest, same as I haven't taken much of a look through maksim's knives, I don't think he deals many of the high volume knives that sell for not much - a quick browse at the bottom of a listing states that he doesn't carry anything in knives that's mass produced - perhaps the stones are his profit center, don't know).

(I just browsed a couple of CKTG items to see if they're still operating on the same philosophy and see prices close to what are charged at retail in japan for rikizai knives. Cheers to them for choosing to sell more at a lower margin to get to the same place).