Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

Posts

8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#1

8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

David Weaver

..out of curiosity this morning, I refreshed the bevels on two chisels and reset one to shallower with the jet light-dimming grinder.

3600 rpm, 36 grit gray wheel at 8". It's an efficient cutter and when grinding the filth off of old files, I noticed less heat than with the baldor (I suspect it's leaving with the sparks).

I have to admit that despite all of the discussion of burning bevels, it wasn't difficult to refresh the hollows of any of the tools without water (just testing heat by pulling the chisels across my palm) or reset the bevel on a sorby chisel (admittedly, they're soft) and I could get along fine with this grinder and sell the baldor.

The thing about it is that there's so much wheel speed and the wheel is so rough that with light pressure, the amount of air coming off of the wheel is significant and more than light pressure is never needed (i'm sure it would brown the chisel at the tip quickly).

I remember far bigger problems starting off with an 80 grit white wheel on a ryobi grinder, which was suggested at the time as a good choice for both lathe tools and hand tools. The issue with fine wheels like that being that they just won't cut with light pressure, and applying any with all of the tiny contact grains heats things up very quickly.

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#2

I don't agree with most of what you advocate

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Just to set a stake in the ground, I use a Baldor grinder, 120 grit wheel and 3600 rpm and grind chisel and plan bevels of any kind to just shy of the tip. If there is any doubt of this claim I will get Phil Smith to chime in as he does the same. We have taught and demonstrated to most everyone in the large club. What you have discovered is that with sufficient skill and experience what you have can be made to work. You have not discovered the optimum grinding set up for grinding chisels and plane blades.

(I suspect it's leaving with the sparks). What possible effect can what is turning the wheel have on anything about sparks? Indeed, shards of metal being milled from a tool is a significant means of removing heat from the work of grinding. But it is the wheel properties that are responsible for milling vs ploughing.

I have to admit that despite all of the discussion of burning bevels,

Anyone burning bevels is either/or employing the wrong wheel or the wrong technique for the wheel at hand.

The thing about it is that there's so much wheel speed and the wheel is so rough that with light pressure, the amount of air coming off of the wheel is significant and more than light pressure is never needed I do not understand what is being explained here. But for sure heavy pressure against a 36 grit wheel turning 3600 rpm is going to make metal go away fast. This is the set up I use for lawn mower blades.

I remember far bigger problems starting off with an 80 grit white wheel on a ryobi grinder, which was suggested at the time as a good choice for both lathe tools and hand tools.

could it be lack of experience at the time? I assisted a class with Bonnie Klein and during break she sharpened 60 lathe tools with a white wheel and the same of similar grinder (60 or 80 I don't know but I suspect for her it would not have mattered).

The issue with fine wheels like that being that they just won't cut with light pressure, and applying any with all of the tiny contact grains heats things up very quickly. This statement is simply not correct. See my opening statement. My tools are mostly CPM3V, a vastly more difficult steel to cut that what you are grinding. When teaching someone to grind tools my challenge is getting them to use a sufficiently light tough to maintain control of material loss.

Can you grind hand tools with a grey wheel and 3600 rpm? You just demonstrated that you can. If you have something else can it be made to work? Probably if you understand how to prepare the wheel. It this combination best? Not what I would recommend nor would the abrasive companies selling wheels. These companies spend fortunes developing wheels with the optimum properties for grinding hard steel. Seems to make sense to follow their recommendations and not try to use a wheel designed for heavy material removal and heavy grinding pressure for fine grinding of bevels.

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#3

Burning bevels

Jack Dover

Anyone burning bevels is either/or employing the wrong wheel or the wrong technique for the wheel at hand.

Is there any explanations on correct techniques I could read?

White 100 grit wheel, dressed, medium to low rpm, fingers sufficiently close to an edge, still puts blue\brown spots on my just water cooled bevels so fast I can't catch the moment when to take a tool off. Seems not to be a problem on a gray 80 grit wheels even on high rpm, but 100 soft white wheel should still work for plain chisels and planes, shouldn't it?

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#4

the trouble with the white wheel...

David Weaver

...early on is that I was advised that it was friable (it wasn't really in light grinding) and nobody mentioned that I would need to dress it. Mine quickly got glazed and then it burned everything.

After that, I got one of the T shaped diamond dressers and then it was OK, but it wasn't as good as a very coarse gray wheel (Which would glaze easily, but you just don't use it long enough for it to glaze. My cheap gray wheel was either 36 or 46 grit - if you dress wheels for a second each time you grind, it's better than the white one).

The point of this isn't to get into the long settled discussion about various wheels, it's just to point out that if you posted on any forum that you had an 8" high speed grinder with gray wheels and you wanted to grind tools, you'd be advised not to use it (certainly against advising the purchase of any such thing).

My point was really the last one that you make - if you can grind a tool cool with one setup, you can probably do it with all of them. I just have no interest in fine wheels (unless they have CBN, but I can burn the corners of tools on CBN with a heavy hand, too).

The coarser a wheel is, the more room you have for it to continue to run reasonably cool (Without being expensive) than one that's fine. Unless you also have something else you're grinding where you can lean in (if you have mild steel or heavier steel that you need to do significant grinding on, you can get a white wheel to shed particles).

As far as when I burned a couple of tools on a white wheel? I'd say in the first two weeks or a month that I used one. I had a tormek at the time but hated using it (I must've used one, though). Someone mentioned a T dresser on one of the woodworking forums as being unsuitable for anything (they're 10 dollars and easy to use vs. the fairly expensive single point large dressing tools), and I bought one, and still can't figure out why they're unsuitable for dressing wheels.

Once I dressed the white wheel, I dressed the coarse gray wheel on the other side of the grinder and liked it better.

I don't really have a place for woodworking for 3V or any of the steels with a lot of vanadium (except for turning tools, but I have some indifference about those needing to be super long lasting, either - they're quick to sharpen/grind freehand). V11 does great in clean wood for wear resistance, but even at that, for what I typically do, it's a detriment more than a benefit (if you're working by hand, everything before smoothing is the volume of the work and the smoothing is done in a flash). 3v is heat tolerant, though, and as much as LV won't tell folks that V11 can go to higher temperatures, it retains much more hardness if the tip is accidentally browned than would most simpler steels (I believe it's 58 hardness on the tempering chart at 800F).

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#5

same experience as me

David Weaver

those white wheels are intended for turning tools from what I understand. They generate a fair amount of heat for the speed that they grind and are outclassed with turning tools by CBN (or just using a coarser gray wheel and doing a quick hand hone to the tip of a turning tool and getting a far better edge than the grinder, anyway).

coarse gray wheel and dressed (or brown - a luxury wheel compared to gray :O ) and I think all of about $15.

The other thing I hated about the white wheels is the rare time you had to dig into something, then all of the sudden, you could feel the abrasive being released off of them as it went all over the place.

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#6

busy cutting up two deer for freezer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

will answer in detail by tomorrow. In the mean time read my article in the articles section on grinding wheel selection and ask more questions if needed.

"White" indicates the aluminum oxide composition. Color provides only a hint of whether it will grind cool or not. But of greatest importance is the bond hardness.

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#7

probably not clear from this post...

David Weaver

..if you have a 46 grit gray wheel, dress it and use it instead if your white wheel. As long as you keep it dressed, you'll be super pleased with the way it works. The $6 wheels that came on my ryobi were better for day to day bevel grinding than the white wheel that i "upgraded" to from rockler (which has since moved).

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#8

Re: probably not clear from this post...

Jack Dover

Initially a white wheel was for my hand cranked grinder. The main bedroom is right over my shop and I tend to work late, so anything that's making noise shouldn't be used after 10pm. However this white wheel is too slow on a hand cranked grinder, so I switched wheels with an electric grinder. Hand cranked is working better now with a stock wheel that's badly out of balance, but that's another story.

That original wheel was marked 80 grit and it's leaving very deep scratches. When I manage to grind a hollow correctly on a soft white wheel it would last 6-8 sharpenings before needing to be refreshed. A gray wheel would produce a hollow that lasts 3-4 times. The wheels are the same diameter, it's just getting gray wheel's scratches out would take a good portion of a hollow too.

So it looks like there are two variables here: a junk stock wheel and my technique. Using lighter pressure when getting close to final edge is something I should definitely pay attention to. Getting a decent gray wheel is also a great idea, maybe McMaster has better (or at least balanced) wheels. Just wonder what to do with all these wheels I'll have laying around? Was thinking into breaking them and making profiled slips and stones but they seem to work in a grinder only, and not so well for manual sharpening.

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#9

save the extra wheels ...

David Weaver

..in case you ever want to make some tools and not change the profile on your "good" current wheel (even if good is the "good" wheel is one of your cheapest).

If you're not grinding the tip off, I"m not sure why you're getting so much damage to remove at the edge. This is the stock 36 grit wheel finish with a light touch on the high speed grinder.

https://i.imgur.com/rtPtCku.jpg

I actually did grind the edge all the way off on this chisel (it's an old large ward firmer that I don't actually use).

Point being not that you're doing anything wrong, but with the setup you're using, you'll adjust what you're doing out of innate natural laziness involved in getting good results - the results will just get better. Don't know how else to describe it than that.

If you're using wheels, i'll send you a pink camel 46 grit wheel if you send me your address. I'm not ever going to use it, and it's an I or H type wheel that works pretty well without much grading.

I got a second high speed grinder dropped off on my door step today and order a 24 grit regular wheel from mcmaster that should also show up today (mcmaster's page has wheels for steel and then non-ferrous, and then two separate versions - fast removal and not. I didn't look that close at their explanations, so they may provide more standardized details - but one of the reasons that I like them is when I prefer not to learn that much about what I'm buying - and that's the case here - their generic explanations are good enough for me, and I wanted to order a couple of other things from them, anyway).

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#10

Re: probably not clear from this post...

Oskar

Jack, I also use a hand cranked (well, foot cranked now - made a pedal for it) grinder and I invested in a CBN wheel to replace the original non-descript wheel. I would recommend this strongly. It works very well. Only thing I would change is choosing a crowned CBN wheel instead of a flat.

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#11

scratch depth and wheel speed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Because it was easy to do for my situation I bought a 3 phase grinder and run it off a VFD that serves other 3 phase tools. Hence I have infinite variable speed grinder. The slow speed was handy when learning and teaching. What I found was that the scratch depth for a given wheel increased as the wheel speed slowed. I get some impressive scratches from my 120 grit wheel when it is barely rotating.

If what I found is generally true a hand grinder will leave coarser scratches than a power grinder for the same wheel.

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#12

experience with the new to me grinder matches

David Weaver

I expected deep scratches off of a cheap 36 grit wheel, but the wheel speed is so high that there are none. If you leaned into it enough to try to force them, the chisel would change colors in a hurry, but it's not necessary, anyway.

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#13

Re: probably not clear from this post...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Only thing I would change is choosing a crowned CBN wheel instead of a flat.

I am curious to know why?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#14

Re: save the extra wheels ...

Jack Dover

I definitely want to make my own tools at some point, and some cutters even before that, good point, will keep the wheels.

The gray wheel I was talking about was the wheel that came with a Delta 6" grinder. I have scraped its label off, but a label on the other wheel doesn't have any specs anyway, there's just one word "Delta" on it, so maybe it's coarser than 80 grit. This wheel wasn't producing an even scratch pattern, not like yours in the picture. There are a few deep scratches and grinding those out on a diamonds\oilstones would take a significant part of a hollow off (no burning though). With a white wheel I could hone a really narrow band of shiny metal at the edge, it's just getting these small blue\brown spots every now and then kinda bothered me. It's really hard to tell by a naked eye, but looking at that coarse gray wheel I think I see some bigger crystals that are of a different, darker shade than the rest of a wheel, but that could easily be my imagination and bad lighting. The other original wheel is finer and better in this regard, but still badly out of balance, so I just assumed these are the cheapest wheels Delta could score just to make a grinder technically functional.

Embarrassing to admit, but the package on a white wheel does say "for high speed steel" in big letters and "other hardening steels" in a fine print. It does produce a lot of heat with even a moderate material removal — paid attention to it while grinding a safe edge on a file yesterday, makes total sense now. It doesn't have any specs on a box either, but digging through the Norton'd website I found another white wheel type NOT marked for HSS. Should do a better research next time.

Really appreciate your offer, very kind of you, I'll shoot you an email in a bit. For what you do for the community it's us subscribers should be sending you stuff, not the other way around.

I will tinker with my setup more. I think I'm pretty close, just had unreasonable expectations for white wheels. Maybe I could still balance a finer gray wheel - it grinds ok but vibrates so much a grinder walks itself out of the doors. Low rpm setting brings the vibration down, I'm just concerned that this wheel might shatter, or destroy bearings, or both. But I still have options.

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#15

CBN on a hand cranked grinder

Jack Dover

Totally will get a CBN wheel at some point. It's just either my hand cranked grinder or the wheels I have, or both of these are out of balance — it seems impossible to find a wheel that would run smooth even after lots of truing and dressing. Maybe it's tolerances in shafts and wheels openings, maybe it's those telescoping bushings — I don't know, but I was afraid that I might buy a CBN wheel and it wouldn't run true on this grinder. Other than that it would be a perfect setup lasting a lifetime. For whatever reason this grinder has an open window on top of the gearbox and grits get right into it, CBN seems to be perfect precisely because it doesn't shed.

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#16

Oh by the way, any pictures of a pedal?


Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#17

Re: probably not clear from this post...

Oskar

Hi Derek,

maybe I´m plain wrong about this, and a crowned wheel is not the rigth answer. I freehand everything, and the toolrest that is part of the grinder is not good at all. I guide the tool with my fingers acting as a stop against the rest. Hollow grinding carving knifes, drawknifes, hatchets etc, where the edge is longer than the width of the wheel, there is often a dig-in of the corner just at the moment I put the tool to the wheel and it is not perfectly aligned. Not a problem at the beginning of the grinding, but really annoying when I get close to the edge and the corner eats it self in, even if it is just a minute amount.

I imagine a slightly crowned wheel more forgiving in this respect. Could very well be that my technique is bad.

Any opinion?

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#18

Re: Oh by the way, any pictures of a pedal?

Oskar

Will try to remember taking a pic next time. Please remind me if I forget!

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#19

Re: Oh by the way, any pictures of a pedal?

Oskar

Here is the pedal conversion of my hand cranked grinder. Not fancy but it works. Everything lives hanging on the wall when not in use. There is a peg on the shaft which locks into the beechwood block. Some day I like to replace the wood with metal, since this peg is slowly eating itself into the wood and causing play in the action.



Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#20

Pretty cool, I should convert mine.


Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#21

Re: Oh by the way, any pictures of a pedal?

Wiley Horne

Hi Oskar,

Thanks for showing! It’s ingenious, and I can imagine your making many adjustments to get the whole assembly working right.

Question about the angled piece at the top of the connecting rod: Is the purpose to present a wide flat face to the beech block to minimize friction?

Wiley

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#22

Re: Oh by the way, any pictures of a pedal?

Oskar

Hi Wiley,

not really. Cobbled it together and it actually worked right away - good enough to not spend more time on it :) . Thought two minutes about the length of the crank arm, in order to get a reasonable amplitude for the foot motion. The assorted screws in the beech block are there to either fix the block to the shaft and peg, or added to protect the block from splitting.

The angled piece has no such function. It can't be seen from this angle, but on the joining bolt there is a spacer in between the arm and the rod, giving clearance as there is nothing stabilizing the pedal against sidewards motion. The angular shape is new. The first piece of plywood I used was not much wider than the rod itself and it broke right at the drilled hole recently. So I just made a bigger piece, with more meat around the hole.

Oskar

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#23

Re: Pretty cool, I should convert mine.

Oskar

you should, it is very convenient!

Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#24

Re: Sweet!


Re: 8" high speed - gray wheel - refreshing hollows

#25

Re: Sweet!

Oskar

Thanks Steve!