Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Posts

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#26

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

don't confuse "curious" with judgmental. As a matter of fact when I become curious it means I am in data collection mode. People that have reached a conclusion aren't still seeking data. Also speculation signals the same quest.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#27

It's a gigantic blank..

David Weaver

..by the way...huge!

My tastes in guitar are out of style or mimicked by cheap guitars, definitely not contending there's anything special about what I like (pretty much a straight kind of plain body blank without much work to do, and a simple setup all around - simple finish, simple (but good) pickups, and simple wiring).

When someone takes a slab like the one you have there, stabilizes any cracks in it and then does something artistic with it, it looks better than what I make.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#28

Some more data- Amos Darlington

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Between 1819 and 1833 this Westchester Co. shop made 798 pieces of furniture which sold for a total of $6286.55 (the shop kept good accounts). There are pictures of some of this work and not a knot to be found. More on Amos later. The woods used and prices are interesting.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#29

And some very interesting data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The pictures in the Chester Co furniture book are arranged alphabetically by maker, ending with pieces where the maker was unknown. The knots concentrate at the end of the pictures, employed by unknown makers because the pieces are not branded or signed. The appearance of knots where the maker is known, knots and makers with "joiner" in the makers bio strongly correlate.

Where the maker is known and the piece branded with the shops name, presumably indicating a larger more established shop, not a knot to be found, and harmonious appearance if figured wood was included. The handsome curly maple piece shown in the original post is from one of these shops.

In the above context "knots" are obvious inclusion of a knot with a distinct center, and not figured wood near knots and crotches.

If if not obvious I have a passion for wood that equals David's for sharpening stones.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#30

Re: And some very interesting data

David Weaver

so, theory being that in general, a joiner may find less "fine" fronts suitable, and may also be the kind of person (using a lot more wood) that could have quantity of wood over quality?

Was joiner use the same way as England ("will make many things" rather than specialization?)

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#31

Re: It's a gigantic blank..

Mike In Los Angeles

A widow made me take that slab away with a Unisaw I bought a few years back, along with a ziricote log and a ton of stuff. I haven’t found any use for it but who knows. Way too much figure for me, but if I don’t trade it for something maybe it’ll make necks.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#32

Re: Some more data- Amos Darlington

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Between 1819 and 1833 this Westchester Co. shop made 798 pieces of furniture

Amos Darlington (1764-1828) lived in West Chester which is in Chester Co. PA. Westchester County is in New York. His active working time (1796-1828) came much later than the pieces being criticized of late. He probably wasn't even born when some of these older chests were made. Amos Jr took over the shop after his father's death. You are talking about two very different eras.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#33

Re: Some more data- Amos Darlington

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Westchester County is in New York. My wife taught middle school science there. It is easy to get all these Chesters confused. I never know where I am at when I am there.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#34

Re: And some very interesting data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When I was a boy I knew a man named Seth Pancoast. My father once remarked that there had been Seth Pancoasts in Marple Township since before the revolution.

I was rather interested when about 25 years ago I saw this small entry in the Chester County Furniture book:

Pancoast, Seth, Marple Twp, joiner.

This comes from a 1764 Tax List. I remember wondering if this joiner had made things I was familiar with, like doors or windows on old buildings or the benches in the Quaker meetinghouse.

Since then a high chest made by Seth in 1766 has come to light. One of my customers once owned it. Now people are calling Seth a cabinetmaker. In the 18th century cabinetmaker and joiner were used somewhat interchangeably. Often the same guy uses both terms to refer to himself.

Here is what a Chester County "joiner" was making in the 1760's:


Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#35

Re: And some very interesting data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is a handsome table by him in Winterthur, again in curly maple, and knot-free. From the number of pieces in the record made from curly maple it must have been more than average abundant there. I don't know about maple but I was told by a forester that curly birch is an inherited trait. Find one tree and neighbors are likely to be curly too.