Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Posts

Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#1

Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



I spare no effort to pick drawer fronts and sides that are complimentary of the piece and each other. I will commonly inspect 500 bdft of lumber to choose the show wood for a case piece. Wouldn’t everyone? Well, apparently not.

Warren, below, spoke of Period case pieces being made with figured, if not knotty, wood for drawer fronts and plain sides. This choice was claimed to be Period Fashion. This statement perked my curiosity. I have a book of Period Chester County furniture and another of furniture of the Connecticut Valley. Also have a copy of Sack but the pictures are too crappy to tell much of the lumber used. The MESDA book has both city and country southern pieces. Curiously, Greene County in eastern TN was a furniture making center in the 1800’s and I have seen some of this furniture.



As Warren described, the first picture shows a walnut piece with highly figured drawer fronts and plain sides. There are large knots in drawers 6, 7 and 8 and figure to be found around large knots or crotch elsewhere. Curiously, the lumber used does not seem to be from sequential boards. The drawers seem to be made from random pieces of knotty or figured near-knot lumber. Were they having a sale of rejects at the mill?



The piece in picture 2 has some of everything in the drawers-drawers 6 and 7 have large knots, yet other drawers are plain knot and figure-free.



Picture 3 shows a piece with plain sides and a variety of appearance on the front-knots, figure, plain.



The desk introduces a new theme, knotty sides and figured fronts that with the exception of drawer 3 have patterns that attractively go together.



In stark contrast to these pieces, the Chester County curly maple furniture I found pictures of were all fashioned from clear lumber, for example the piece in picture 5. Ditto for the cherry furniture. And with one exception the drawers decorated with inlay were not figured.

It would appear in some cases that material for drawer fronts was chosen to display garish figure, knots and all, and this fashion, if it was that, persisted from colonial times to 1850, the cut off for pictures in my book. I have seen the same in furniture from Greene County, TN and furniture in the MESDA compilation. In other cases it looks like drawers were assembled from whatever was available and fit.

All of the 200 or more pictures of furniture I found in the Connecticut Valley book were made of clear lumber. The Mesda furniture I have pictures of ranges from knot-free, to knotty and figured pieces like the Chester County furniture. The knotty ones were made in rural counties.

We rightly complain about the quality of lumber today but it is not hard to find lumber more defect-free than what I observed in the rural walnut furniture. Yet the rural maple and cherry furniture is knot-free in every case I found. It is hard to know what drove the decisions of what wood to use, and where, in the Chester County furniture and that in the MESDA collection from rural counties. However, there is a strong correlation of knots and rural. One has to wonder in Chester County and elsewhere, where was all the clear walnut used? Maybe by the 1800’s all the virgin walnut was gone. Were they harvesting yard trees that had been grown for nuts? Did the clear lumber go to the cities. Speculation of course.

And why does it appear that little thought went into drawer front selection, as evidenced by the pictures shown? Or not. Maybe customers liked the random bold patters that were created. But then why mix in plain? Given the care I, as well as others, use for lumber selection, it is curious. Perhaps in cases they used what they had on hand when an order came it.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#2

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Thanks for this. It poses an interesting question.

There are plenty of modern makers who choose lively/wild grain for show wood, but you're correct that those who do are consistent about it.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#3

Choices pose interesting speculation on wood sourc

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have been wondering how the people that made the furniture with its fashionable knots bought lumber. Few of the pieces in the Chester County book seem to have been built from lumber out of the same log. Only occasionally is there evidence that the lumber came from sequential boards from a log. I would have thought a cabinet maker might have purchased a log of lumber. But it more looks like they purchased individual pieces of lumber selected from logs. Who knows how lumber was graded? and priced. It may be that the mill sold clear lumber at high prices unattractive to the country cabinet maker. The FAS of the day went to the cities to be made into the kinds of furniture to be found in my Connecticut book, maybe?

In many cases drawers were made from lumber cut near large limbs to include figure and even the knot itself. In other cases a board with an unattractive, by today's standards, round figureless knot can be found in the midst of a drawer or panel side. One picture shows a drawer pull installed unattractively off center from a knot that must be 4' in diameter. What motivated the maker to buy and then employ these boards. Certainly not aesthetics. Cost? Maybe this furniture was Ikea of the day. As tastes refined I can see why little of the original survives today.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#4

Re: Choices pose interesting speculation on wood s

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I suspect that your idea of refinement and aesthetics is not the same as a wealthy gentleman in 18th century Pennsylvania. The figured walnut in these chests is so much more work to prepare that no one would use it at all unless the buyer wanted to pay for it. Here is a chest from Philadelphia:


Note that drawer fronts that were carved were made in straght grain wood, partly because the carving is easier and partly because the figure would detract from the carving. I haven't seen your Connecticut book, but I would guess that a lot of the chests had carvings as the main decoration.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#5

I don't understand your point

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You post seems to not be in any way related to my discussion of furniture that employed knots large and small and unrelated figured and nonfigured walnut wood in show surfaces. Yet the cherry and maple Pieces I could find were made of the best wood selection to yield a harmonious appearance.

What was your point in showing a picture of highly refined furniture where great care in wood selection was employed? I already provided that contrast with the furniture in the Connecticut Valley book and the refined furniture in the MESDA collection. Why was this care largely lacking out in Chester County? Lumber cost? Unrefined taste of maker or customer? Fashion?

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#6

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

David Weaver

I'm suddenly having severe trouble sleeping the last few days and have no fire for this discussion (wouldn't anyway, don't know the subject), but could the answer be something as simple as what's on the cabinets front and center is what's stylish?

I think they all look wonderful but from the view of someone who doesn't make furniture, I would have to guess large knots were a style thing by a maker or in an area.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#7

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would have to guess large knots were a style thing by a maker or in an area.

If so this style persisted in walnut, seemingly unique to walnut, for 100 years and was largely confined to rural furniture by my small sampling.

This furniture is the way it is because- it was the fashion, it was cheaper to make, the client didn't care what his sock drawer looked like, the maker didn't have another lumber choice, other?

Some of the figured assemblies do look like some care was taken to create a harmonious appearance. In what I will call the city furniture the result was more harmonious and attractive by today's standard. It simply seems the city maker had a greater selection of wood to choose from to achieve the result. Why? Price? Demand?

But consider this piece.

I would guess that enormous knot lies beneath the pull not from fashion but from lacking a better board that wide to choose from. If true, why the lacking?

The choice is even more puzzeling in this MESDA piece.


What would have motivated the maker to place that huge knot to the left of the drawer? This board had a mate. If someone thought a knot here was stylish the adjacent board , if available, would have been used to create a flanking knot providing some sort of symmetry. As it is it look like a pimple on the nose of a Miss America finalist.

Looking at the door panels, the right one should have been reversed. I think the maker of this piece was skilled with his tools but lacked an eye for harmony.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#8

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Of course the wood was selected because that is what the client wanted. Only someone with no experience working figured wood from rough lumber by hand would suggest otherwise.

A drawer front like this is a lot of labor even with straight grain timber. You have to flatten a side and and plane to thickness, make rabbets on three sides, cut half blind dovetails, make a groove for the drawer bottom, smooth the front, and make a quarter round moulding all the way around. With figured wood, every single step is considerably more labor. The idea that someone would choose this wood to save on material costs is laughable, to say the least.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#9

P.S.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Of course in the 18th century there were chests made in Chester County with plain drawer fronts. They just did not make it into Mrs. Schiffer's famous book.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#10

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

David Weaver

seen mostly in walnut thanks to walnut's stability?

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#11

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I know enough about making drawers to observe that the huge knot and its associated complex grain lie well away for all the operations you describe, except flattening the front face. Hence, the knot will have no effect on the cost of making these parts of a drawer. Without a much better picture I can not determine the refinement of the flattening, nor if a later refinishing refined the original even more. I have seen gobs of torn grain around knots found in Period Furniture that shows up in antique shops. In conclusion, there is no evidence that inclusion of the knot increased the labor cost of making this piece.

Is there any evidence to suggest customers were involved in wood selection for their furniture?

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#12

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

David Weaver

Even tolerating some tearout, the one thing that a knot like that does is require use of a try plane for thicknessing instead of a jack plane. It adds some time.

When I get a #1 common lot vs. FAS, there's a fair amount of stuff in the lot that won't tolerate a jack plane unless the cap is set close enough to make it work at the same speed as the try plane.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#13

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Hence, huh. You can hence all you want, but if you don't know what you are talking about it is mere sophistry.

Get yourself a highly figure board like the one you show in the upper left of the Chester County chest. Plane the board from rough. For extra insight use wooden single iron planes. Make a lipped drawer with an ovolo moulding all around with a nice moulding plane. And make some halfblind dovetails and a groove and then get back to us.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#14

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Rafael

Bill,

I think it's a stretch to infer lack of care in the choice of lumber just because the examples you are showing don't agree with our contemporary aesthetic preferences. We can speculate about their motivations, but we should be careful not to inject our own notions about what's proper design.

In my father's workshop, in the 70s, 80s and 90s, they routinely used Honduran mahogany for many of the high end pieces he made for his clients. They finished the pieces with something they called "pore cover" which was a very thick stain and other materials that filled the pores of the mahogany that basically hid all the wood grain. In retrospective I wonder why they didn't leave the wood grain visible, but that's what they did and what his clients bought. I have some of his pieces at home and they show that same treatment. I don't think there is a right or wrong, that's just how they did things.

Cheers,

Rafael

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#15

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think it's a stretch to infer lack of care in the choice of lumber just because the examples you are showing don't agree with our contemporary aesthetic preferences. We can speculate about their motivations, but we should be careful not to inject our own notions about what's proper design.

I may be having difficulty with my communication skills again. Warren answering questions I didn't ask adds confusion. I reviewed what I wrote. I failed to find where I inferred or injected anything. I hoped to be asking questions. I'm not convinced all the knots were fashion driven. But if not what, and why confined to walnut?

Economics is usually at the bottom of most decisions. I have no idea how lumber was produced and marketed 1750-1850. Having been in the business of marketing lumber it is easy for me to speculate this factor was important.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#16

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

David Weaver

A friend's dad (showy kind of guy) got a new mahogany table and chairs back in the 70s here and paid a mint for it.

It was pore filled as you describe and mostly one color, or all. I had trouble understanding why it was so desirable.

Thinking back to the clamp down on good mahogany wood, I'm suspcious about my timeline - there was mahogany in guitars in the 70s, but it was often supplemented with maple necks, and a lot of guitars were a pancake of 4/4 material with a filler strip between them.

The mahogany that I've seen more recently is a whole different animal - light weight, wide growth rings and a lot of it probably comes from indonesia or fiji or somewhere in india. The fiji wood isn't very old -maybe just under 80 years old and younger.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#17

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Eric Rathhaus

Bill - I really like that piece. beautiful work!

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#18

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Rafael

Bill,

Here are some of the statements you made:

"it looks like drawers were assembled from whatever was available and fit"

"why does it appear that little thought went into drawer front selection"

"Given the care I, as well as others, use for lumber selection, it is curious."

Beyond noting what the surviving pieces look like, I'd be hesitant to assume the reasons why they chose the lumber they chose without additional sources of information. What you or I may consider important in our time may not apply to that period. Maybe they really were into knots ;-), who knows.

To get back to your main point, why they chose what they chose, maybe the answer is staring us in the face in the examples you showed us. Maybe they used knotty, figured lumber because that's what they wanted. Maybe clear straight grain was boring to them.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#19

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Rafael

When figure was shown, my dad would use mahogany veneer. My brother and I brought a bunch of his pieces to the US. I have a solid mahogany and mahogany veneered desk from him. Unfortunately the finish on the top has minor damage and I will have it repaired in the future.

I'm pretty sure the species of mahogany in Peru is of the Swietenia macrophylla (honduran) species. I think it was pretty common back in the 70s. I remember a shipment he got a large planks when I was a kid. He kept a large one, I think 4"x 2.5' x 8', as his bench top. It's still there, we haven't figured out what to do with it.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#20

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

David Weaver

I recall peru being one of the four common current sources (though it may not be as common as it was at one point). The honduran is only of interest to me due to the fact that the new "junky" stuff is still very resonant in a guitar and about ideal weight for that resonance (70s guitars were heavy for sustain).

It may have been indonesia, peru, sri lanka and fiji - I can't keep straight which of those actually market swietenia macrophylla.

I know fiji does. I know that in the restricted zone, there may still be some allowance for snags and downed logs (or maybe only the latter).

I don't see many straight honduran quartered guitar blanks these days.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#21

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Mike In Los Angeles

This stuff interests you?

EA823-F72-757-A-46-A8-ADFC-AD1462-F8-BC90

D1-FF5-B16-79-D3-44-C5-8294-339-BAF560-F1-C

322755-A6-182-E-42-BA-AF29-84-C6-CE12-A7-FD

4-A389-B3-E-B39-C-4-B5-E-B8-BD-E9-D10-FD07-D1-D

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#22

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

David Weaver

That stuff is too wild for me, but from what I can tell, that's what's in now.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#23

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

Mike In Los Angeles

Yea I told you I can’t stand fancy anything. A guy practically paid me to haul off all the Honduran siding from his living room. It’s about 3/8” thick, 3-6” wide t&g boards mostly 10 feet long or so. If you’re gonna do an acoustic or something let me know and I’ll send you some. That stuff is plain as can be.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#24

some data to test hypotheses

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Maybe they used knotty, figured lumber because that's what they wanted. Maybe clear straight grain was boring to them.

What we probably know-

The "they" and the "them" were makers and customers living a days wagon ride from Philadelphia. The people that study this sort of stuff say the furniture makers mingled, bringing the latest fashion from port to country.

Period advertising shows competition between makers in Chester Co and the city. A competitive advantage advertised was the benefit of free delivery and other advantages of shopping locally. Claims usually made for equivalent quality, lower price. What's changed?

Some Chester County Furniture is knot-free, figured but with harmonious figure, plain grain next to knots and figure, knots in sides and clear fronts, every permutation you can imagine. I have never seen a curly maple piece with a knot from anywhere. None of the Chester Co pieces from cherry have knots.

One theory will not cover this range variety.

The Period furniture we desire today was probably made for the wealthy and was probably show off pieces. It has survived because it was not used daily to store socks. Rather it presided over the parlor to please the owner and impress the guests. You rarely see anything but carefully chosen lumber for these pieces.

What I don't know is what did the furniture were they stored their socks look like.

What we would regard today as unacceptable knots show up in Chester Co furniture over at least a 100 year span. They show up in Greene County TN furniture, rural south furniture. I don't have rural New England books. My book of rural Canadian furniture is knot-free but there are no walnut pieces shown. Knots and walnut seem to go together.


Indeed some might thing that a knot in the midst of this inlay scene adds to its beauty. Or, the maker didn't have a clear board wide enough. For someone that sold lumber for 30 years the choices remain curious. I have found some 1800's lumber marketing data but not studied it yet.

Re: Wood selection for Period drawer fronts

#25

Re: some data to test hypotheses

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill,

This is a terrifically good thread! Thanks for raising.

To my eye, the inlaid front of the slant desk benefits greatly from the knot. In fact, I think it’s a brilliant design, in part because of the knot, which looks like a deep pool of water with ripples, which in turn ties in with the running-water motif flowing laterally across the center of the top.

I get that if you like a calm zen-like grain, the whole affair is a clean miss. But for its style, it seems grand to me!

Wiley