Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

LN #4 Cap Iron Profile

Posts

Re: LN #4 Cap Iron Profile

#26

Re: outside of your back and forth..

Jérôme

> ...with larry and mention of the double iron, I saw only two references anywhere else to practical use of the cap iron before 2012.

As you often say yourself, "I am not trying to sell anyone anything", but I find old books interesting and google books allows us to access some ancient knowledge, such as "manuel du tourneur", 1796, by Louis Salivet, a Roubo contemporary. In this book, he attributes the double iron to the Germans and recommends to set it so that the iron protudes "imperceptibly", at most "quarter of a line" (1/12 of a French inch, say less than .5mm). He mentions that the double iron must bent square then honed to meet the blade (That would represent a final ~80° angle ?).

The expected benefit is explicitly to reduce tear out.

He also goes on to mention that one can get the well prepared adjustable screwed iron+double iron sets at “Bergeron". This could mean that the practice was well known at the time.

See https://books.google.fr/books?id=Ssk9AAAAcAAJ&dq=Double%20fer%20rabot&hl=fr&pg=PR3#v=onepage&q=Double%20fer%20rabot&f=false

In a more recent book (https://books.google.fr/books?id=Zu0OB-uKo8MC&dq=Contrefer%20rabot&hl=fr&pg=PA181#v=onepage&q=Double%20fer&f=false), the author says that for difficult woods, with a wooden plane, the wedge could be inserted between the iron and the cap iron, as to increase the angle. But he also goes on to find this technique too inconvenient. He also mentions that the tip of the cap iron is "rounded" (unicorned maybe ?)

On the other hand, Roubo only describes single iron planes, smoothers featuring a 60° frog and a 0.5mm mouth. Also metal sole bevel up shooting planes, and lots of scraping planes.

There are also many old patents, French, German, English ..., that describe and illustrate "concepts planes", with adjustable frog angle, metal pieces, etc. They also describe the expected benefits of their invention compared to their era "standards".

I find it fun that some predicts that "no arm could ever swing an all metal plane all day" :)

Again, I am not giving advice or opinion, I just share links to publicly available treasures.

Re: LN #4 Cap Iron Profile

#27

will you repost

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This interesting information is going to be lost buried in this thread. Suggest you repost under a title that will describe this information.

Re: LN #4 Cap Iron Profile

#28

If you would be so kind...

Jim Matthews

Please start a new "thread" with your included links.

That will make it easier to reference.

****

What we lack, in our hysterical record, is much in the way of recounting a journeyman's regard toward their tools and how they selected them.

I suspect that was a none too subtle attempt at protecting intellectual property.

That proprietary attitude traps us, today.

Kudos

Re: LN #4 Cap Iron Profile

#29

Results matter

Jim Matthews

Excellent photo.

The difficulty is in translating how a plane that works feels compared to one that works beautifully. There's no standard for comparison, or baseline for performance.

I suspect this is why Kezuroukai competitors return - they all get a crack at the same board.

The excellence of your results are displayed in your desk.

Re: LN #4 Cap Iron Profile

#30

Re: outside of your back and forth..

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think Bob Strawn's post on 3/2/2012 was very influential.

https://sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?182885-Question-for-plane-gurus-woodie-build-single-blade-or-blade-chipbreaker

I see a big difference in David Weaver's perspective between that date and his post on this forum a few weeks later. 3/24/2012.

https://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3001/page/4/md/read/id/446436/sbj/warren-an-update-on-double-irons/

Re: LN #4 Cap Iron Profile

#31

Salivet

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Planemaker Steve Voigt has referenced Salivet's work numerous times. As have I.

Re: LN #4 Cap Iron Profile

#32

Re: Salivet

Winston

> Planemaker Steve Voigt has referenced Salivet's work numerous times. As have I.

Jerome is sharing information that he finds interesting. He's not trying to claim credit for being the first to mention it.

Re: LN #4 Cap Iron Profile

#34

Re: outside of your back and forth..

David Weaver

I have to admit I didn't take anything from Bob strawn posts and I'm not sure anyone else did because he was experimenting with lots of stuff and I couldn't tell what was useful. I'm sure I'm on record as having said this same thing- at the time Bob was also posting about sharpening on strips of very thin steel and some of those things seemed like a dead end.

One singular thing led me to use a millers falls plane in isolation for two weeks- the desire to work by hand and the failure to do it productively with single iron planes. Repeated failure. I started fiddling in February 2012 with a smoother that I bought Christmas a few months before.

The only person I conversed with was chris Griggs via pm on the blue forum. I told him exactly what I did and he said it worked for him , too. I still was miffed a little and wanted to figure out how to use the high angle infill I'd spent 80 hours and $250 making because I hadn't spent enough time dimensioning yet to see that the slightly longer sharpening and setup time was canceled out many times over by the volume of work the plane could be pushed to do between sharpenings.

I just don't learn well from other peoples' details. Nobody gave me enough to go on, so I employed a personal two week rule. If someone is material, it'll be discoverable in two weeks of isolation from other methods. It took less than one to get a feel, and one to better my infill, and maybe one more to have a sense of what looked right.

I never saw anyone else write the set rules as I did in the article and saw a bunch of people suggest copying the video geometry and settings, which I could tell by feel was a bad idea. It takes machine power to use those settings. If I hadn't wanted to dimension by hand, I'd have never learned it from anyone else and I doubt few who don't dimension by hand get a solid grasp of it quickly.

The cap geometry that I came up with for the article by experimenting has stood the test of time and bill later confirmed that the professors said *no* to using the video as a guide for hand tools. One thing remains a curiosity- why you never stated a simple set of parameters for using the double iron as I stated in the article. Why didn't anyone else? I think the reason nobody else did because almost nobody dimensions by hand even though lots say they do.

Looking back at Tom's posts, his method applies a lot like Kato and kawai's plane instructions but it went over the head of people not using Japanese planes.

It's not that hard to explain how to get an initial feel for the cap iron set and I'm still confused as to why you never did it other than to use words like "subtle and complicated ". That way oversold the difficulty.

Re: LN #4 Cap Iron Profile

#35

comparing 4 1/2s

David Weaver

I don't know who made this marples, but it looks a lot like a record, which in turns looks a lot like an early 1900s stanley.

Flanked on both sides by two stanley 4s.

The biggest difference between these three (which compares to your thoughts on feel) is that the 4 1/2 uses the tall handle used on jack and bigger planes. It doesn't look like much, but 1/4th inch of handle height is huge and probably accommodates 1/4th of the population.

I believe the one on the right is type 19 or something (but I'm not going out to look at type studies) and the one on the left is not too many types below. I like the later stanley smoothers better than the earlier ones - the adjuster wheel and frog design are more practical.

I've had something like 10 4 1/2s and never keep more than one at a time in most cases. This one that I Just flattened yesterday had a lot of wear, but it's super smooth adjusting without resorting to the absurdly slow LN adjuster. It's on the high end for weight of stanley copies - less than an ounce away from a round 5 pounds. Any time I use a heavy 4 1/2, it makes for an obligatory feeling to increase shaving thickness to get something done with the weight rather than just pushing the weight around.

All three of these are nice users. I don't intend to sell the marples plane. It'll probably happen in a year or two, anyway, as I'll get bored with it, but the blue stanley is here forever.

sorry about the turned picture. The resizer feels the orientation is better that way and if I rotate it and save it in windows photo app, it'll go above 100k and not load. It's good enough to see what's needed.

I've never made a wooden plane for someone without knowing what size their hand is - it's essential.

AS for big hands on 4s, pinkie off the side and index finger forward and a four should still accommodate. If that outside pinkie should ever meet an object on the bench mid work, though, swearing will ensue.