Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Success with a making a shallow ura

Posts

Success with a making a shallow ura

#1

Success with a making a shallow ura

Winston

I ordered some 120 grit "Aggressive buffing compound" from McMaster-Carr. The abrasive size is 120 microns -- much bigger than the 5 micron stuff I was using earlier. It came in a giant 3 lb sausage-shaped tube. I really only wanted a couple ounces of the stuff, but this is what I got.


This time I used it on a Dremel, with a 1-inch diameter felt wheel. It threw off some sparks when it contacted the metal.

Not the prettiest result, but it actually worked. I then worked the back of the blade on a Shapton Pro 12000, and this is what it looked like:


Only the edges contacted the stone, which is exactly what I wanted.

I probably used the Dremel on the blade for around 5 minutes. I first used with a 0.5 inch felt wheel, and it was way, way less effective than the 1 inch wheel. I think it loaded up and got hot a lot faster than the 1" wheel. I'd bet that a larger wheel would work even better.

One more thing I should mention: It's probably not a good idea to do this for bevel-up planes in general, since it'll reduce the contact area with the bed. This blade is actually for a (bevel-up) block plane, but I only used it for testing to see if this would work -- I gave away the plane a while ago.

If anyone else decides to try this, I'd like to hear how it works out!

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#2

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

David Weaver

curious about the compound - mcmaster's page says that those types have a binder that is more or less a glue for the wheel so that the grit binds to the wheel and doesn't just fly out like it does with a wax stick.

Did it seem to maintain its cutting power?

The beauty of experimenting with things and insisting on success is twofold:

1) now you have a quick inexpensive method that won't crack an iron and you can employ it whenever you want

2) since you came up with it, you "own the knowledge" and won't forget it

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#3

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

Winston

> curious about the compound - mcmaster's page says that those types have a binder that is more or less a glue for the wheel so that the grit binds to the wheel and doesn't just fly out like it does with a wax stick.

>

> Did it seem to maintain its cutting power?

I had to recharge the little felt buffing wheel maybe 2 or 3 times. Not bad, considering how tiny the wheel is.

The stuff says it's made with glue instead of grease/wax. I wouldn't say it feels sticky at all, but it does seem to stay on the wheel reasonably well. It's also water-soluble -- a quick rinse under the faucet easily got the stuff off my hands.

I still would like to try again with a somewhat larger and slightly softer wheel. I'll have to look around to see if I can find something like that. Ideally I'll be able to create a hollow that looks aesthetically pleasing in addition to being functional.

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#4

More experiences making a hollow on a blade

Winston

I've tried a few other things to make a hollow on the backs of plane blades.

First, I should mention that with the Stanley blade I tested before, I was able to completely remove the hollow by working the back of the blade on a 1000 grit Shapton stone for about 2 minutes. So if you do this to a blade, the hollow is shallow enough that you can undo it if you want. In normal sharpening, it should be easy to have the flat area move back with the edge. I'll certainly never have to tap out the blade, like a Japanese plane blade.

First, I got a small 3" cotton buffing wheel, as well as a 3" hard felt buffing wheel, mounted them on a full-speed (3450 rpm) 6" bench grinder, and used the wheels with the same buffing compound. I had hoped that the larger wheel (compared to the 1" dremel wheel) would make it easier to create a smoother-shaped hollow on the back. (I figured that too large a wheel, like 6", would make it difficult to work close to the edge and sides of the blade without actually touching them with the wheel.)

The result is that both wheels were completely ineffective, and didn't remove material fast enough to do anything. I suspect that the much smaller contact area of the small Dremel wheel allows much more pressure (force per area), which removes material much faster. I think the surface speed is also much faster with the Dremel, because the rpms are so much higher. With the Dremel, it threw off some small sparks; with the felt and cotton wheels on the bench buffer, there were no sparks. And the material removal rate was way to low -- after using the buffer on the blade for almost 10 minutes, I took the blade to the 6000 grit stone, and after a few seconds on the stone, almost the whole back, except for a small area in the middle, was showing scratches from the stone. So the hollow was just too shallow.

I've gone back to the 1" Dremel wheel and used it on a couple of blades. One of these is from a WoodRiver bench plane, which is made from T10 steel. My understanding is that this is a pretty simple carbon steel. It took a bit more time to put a hollow in this blade, compared to the cheap Stanley block plane blade I used previously. Maybe 5-10 minutes. The result looks slightly better than my previous attempts. (This is hard to photograph well -- it actually looks a bit better in real life.)


Again, this dramatically speeds up honing the back, especially when combined with David's advice to focus pressure right at the edge. The cutting edge and sides get polished very quickly on the stone; the middle doesn't.

I also tried this on a Chinese HSS blade. I think it's the same kind that David has talked about -- it can be used in a Stanley-style plane, and is painted green. This technique was completely useless on that blade. I couldn't make a dent in the steel with the Dremel and 120-grit buffing compound. It just polished the metal, but it didn't remove enough material to actually be useful.

I like the practical result of doing this, but I still wish I had a better method, one that produces a nicer-looking hollow and is effective even on more difficult steels. I think it would require a wheel that has some give like the felt wheel (a grinder wheel is way too hard), but also is more abrasive than this buffing compound on a felt wheel.

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#5

Re: More experiences making a hollow on a blade

John Aniano in central NJ

Winston,

Interesting method you've come up with!

I'm thinking out loud here- how about using a Cratex-type abrasive wheel? These are a moderately hard rubber wheels with imbedded abrasive particles. They come in different grits and rubber hardness and are mostly used for deburring metal edges. They would probably work pretty well to remove metal to create a hollow region. They are available in Dremel-sized wheels as well as larger sizes for bench grinders (4" & 6" diameter). McMaster Carr sells them in various diameters and thicknesses but I'm sure other vendors carry them.

Over and out,

John

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#6

Re: More experiences making a hollow on a blade

Winston

Interesting idea... I dug around and found that my Dremel came with a hard rubber wheel with abrasives. At least, that's what I think it is.


I tried it out, but it seemed about as hard or slightly harder than the felt wheel, so I don't think I'll get better control with it. And I'm not ready to pay $30 or more for a bench grinder-sized cratex wheel, at least not yet.

I also tried out a small sanding drum on the Dremel. That was also too hard. With these moderately hard wheels, it would require more precision than I'm capable of to get a nice-looking result. Here's what the back of the blade looks like after a quick pass (about 2 seconds each) of the rubber abrasive wheel (marks parallel to the length of the blade), and with the sanding drum (marks parallel to the edge).


But this got me looking for other possible abrasive wheels, and now I'm thinking that a sanding flap wheel might do the trick.

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#7

Re: More experiences making a hollow on a blade

Wiley Horne

Hi Winston,

For impossible jobs, multi-tools are something to think about. Maybe a multi-tool with carbide grout cutting blades:

https://www.amazon.com/Universal-Oscillating-HEMUNC-Semicircle-Triangular/dp/B07W1CD1WT/ref=sr_1_9?dchild=1&keywords=Multi-tool+grout+cutter&qid=1600757016&sr=8-9

You’d have to fixture the work piece, plus make some kind of tool rest for the multi-tool.

You did great on the high-carbon blades; it seems only the high-alloy are a problem.

Wiley

Wiley

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#8

Deburring wheels

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Go to any of the tool room suppliers (MSC, Travers, McMaster Carr, etc. ) and look at wheels. Something there will be optimum squishy and fast cutting.

The Chinese blade is a cheap Chinese version of M2 steel (tested David's blade). Used in planer knives and jointer knives. In another league of abrasion resistance.

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#9

Tested Plus...

David Weaver

..I've probably typed it here many times, but those blades were spec from the seller at 61 hardness.

I believe Bill's test found the one that I sent him above 65 hardness. They're very hard to abrade on the back.

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#10

I'd try an angle grinder with flap wheel  *LINK*

Keith Newton

It would cut faster with less chance of digging and be easier to control, plus cheaper than cratex.


https://www.grainger.com/product/23Z558?gclid=EAIaIQobChMI-8fiooH96wIVE9bACh2H3wH7EAQYBCABEgJfV_D_BwE&cm_mmc=PPC:+Google+PLA&ef_id=EAIaIQobChMI-8fiooH96wIVE9bACh2H3wH7EAQYBCABEgJfV_D_BwE:G:s&s_kwcid=AL!2966!3!264502115998!!!g!436809507569!&gucid=N:N:

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#11

Re: Deburring wheels

Winston

It looks like there are a lot of choices when it comes to deburring wheels at McMaster-Carr and MSC Direct. The bench grinder sized ones are really pricey (like $80 and up) so I'd probably get a small one that I'd mount to a drill. Those ones are less than $10.

My goal is to remove around .001" of steel from a blade. Something that's a bit squishy but still has abrasive power is what I'm looking for.

It's not obvious from the picture I posted earlier, but that HSS blade is slightly convex, so it's hard to work the very edge on stones. I was able to make some progress flattening it using a diamond plate, but I'm still not quite to the edge.

If I'm able to figure out a good method, it should be useful for not just creating a concavity to the back of a blade, but also for removing convexity, like this blade has.

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#12

Why?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was going to send this note by email but then thought maybe I am not the only person that is flummoxed by this quest. As I understand, the idea is to make abrading the back of a plane blade easier because some of it is already ground away from hollowing Fair enough given it works well for bevels.

The question comes from in what situation is re-abrading the back of a plane blade needed? Long ago I flatened, slowly, the backs of the plane blades I used regularly and never needed to do it again. After about 3 of these episodes I decided at $3/hr return on labor it was cheaper to buy a plane blade already flat and never again need to abrade the back (other than superficially to aid burr removal). My puzzlement is under what circumstance are you needing to re-abrade a plane blade back?

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#13

Re: Why?

Winston

This quest is sort of a follow-up to an issue I had where I was having some residual burr at the edge of plane blades. The burr was there, I believe, because the back of the blade is convex at the very edge and the stone wasn't working the edge very well. This is true even for a blade that is otherwise flat: the edge has a slight convexity to it. This is due to the wear on the blade from the shaving passing over it. (This is also informed by the wear bevel photos from Kato and Kawai.)

So, even with a "flat" back, a plane blade is not quite flat at the edge after some use, and it doesn't have good contact with the stone. That's one reason why people use the ruler trick.

David advised to increase the pressure at the edge when honing the back, and that definitely helps -- I've been getting a better edge from doing this, and the difference in the resulting surface is noticeable. But at the same time, I'm curious about how to create something like an ura that's present on Japanese plane blades, to make sharpening faster and easier. I'm also hoping that this will provide a faster and easier way to fix a convex back of a blade than using sandpaper.

So basically: I'm curious. It's not a necessity -- obviously, people have gotten along without doing this -- but I'm hoping it'll provide some improvement.

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#14

Re: Why?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

convex with the convex axis orthogonal to the blade edge? What is estimated length of the, let us say, "arc"? If from wear I presume mm? Can you see it with scope?

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#15

Re: Why?

Winston

It's visible with the microscope and to the naked eye.

This is a (bevel down) blade after being used. The blade has been worn away enough that side to side scratches are gone.


This is the same blade after being sharpened, and with the extra pressure at the edge when working the back. There's still a bit of reflection at the edge because of the convexity there. (Although, I did manage to still get a sharp edge because of the extra pressure at the edge.)


For reference:

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/page/3/md/read/id/495770/sbj/back-wear-bevel-up-vs-bevel-down/

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/page/3/md/read/id/495675/sbj/success-with-applying-extra-pressure-near-the-edge/

I actually noticed this happening a while back and mentioned it in passing here maybe a year ago, but I didn't follow up on it back then.

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#16

Digging in to the issue

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

what is the estimated length of this arc? the reason I am asking ......

As I understand the problem,wear on the flat side rounds over the edge. You are proposing eliminating the rounding by abrading the flat side. The alternative and what I think I do is to abrade back the edge to eliminate the wear. Is that not what the burr is all about? You abrade back the tip until this rounding on the back side is gone as evidenced by the burr rolling up on the back side. If I can't be rid of the burr I interpret the situation as I have not abraded the bevel enough. I abrade away on the bevel to move back the tip to be rid of the rounding.

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#17

To completely get rid of the rounding

Winston

In the picture of my blade, the worn area on the back is about .005". Removing that by honing the other side of the blade requires removing a lot of material. Assuming a 30-degree bevel and doing a little trigonometry, to completely remove that area by honing the bevel, that involves removing .005" / 2, which equates to removing about .0025" of material from the bevel side.

Here are some pictures from Kato & Kawai. (Not really important for the purposes here, but the picture on the left is what happens to the blade when the cap iron set very close, the other is with the cap iron set further back.)


The upper side in the photos corresponds to the the upper side of a blade when it's installed in the plane, and the shaving passes over it. In a bevel-down plane, that's the back of the blade, and the other (lower) side is the bevel.

Now, if you only remove material from the bevel side, this is how much stuff you need to get rid of, in red.


If you remove material from the bevel (lower) and the back (upper), then this is how much material you need to remove.


(Note that you could remove more material from the bevel side, and that would reduce the amount of material that needs to be removed from the back side, if you go far enough.)

In practice, it's much easier to remove material from the bevel side, because it presents much less area to the stone than the back of the blade. But I don't generally remove enough material from the bevel side alone to fully remove the worn area on the back, and that's why there remains the tiny little rounded off portion near the edge. (I know I'm not the only person who has noticed this -- others say they've seen it as well.)

What I'm trying to do is make it faster and easier to completely get rid of the worn edge. Japanese blades are made with a hollow for this reason.

Regarding burrs: I think it's possible, even with a slightly rounded back, to form a burr and remove it, and it helps if you apply extra pressure at the edge. But there are burrs, and there are burrs. It's still possible to have a burr that you can't see with the naked eye, and can't feel with your fingers, but which will still have an effect on the planed result. And even if you are able to completely remove a burr, it's still nice to make that process faster.

(I realize that all this may not be of too much interest to members of Practical Planers Anonymous, but I find it worth exploring.)

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#18

Re: I'd try an angle grinder with flap wheel

Winston

I'd give it a try, but I don't have an angle grinder. Although from the videos I've seen of people using angle grinders, I'd worry that it would blast away material really quickly, and possibly send the blade flying.

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#19

Hand scraping?

Jim Matthews

I wonder if handscraping would be possible, and more efficient?

I'm finding that machine processes are fast, and use them for coarse work.

When approaching my finished dimensions, working by hand is slower and more precise.


img

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#20

Re: Hand scraping?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Good idea, Jim!

A carbide scraper should work well. M4 might be easier to find and prepare.

Hollow grind a camber on one side ... you would need a diamond (for carbide) or CBN (for M4) wheel to do this.

The diamond disks are available cheaply on eBay.

Everyone should have a CBN set up anyway :)


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#21

wheel correction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Tungsten carbide tools can be ground with silicon carbide wheels. it's all I ever saw in machine shops for decades for hand shaping/sharpening carbide tooling. The shops making the tools used diamond abrasive. Don't know what the situation is now.

M4 is readily ground with aluminum oxide wheels. I have M4 lathe tools and sharpen them routinely with a common white or pink wheel.

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#23

More questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am still trying to decide if I am missing the boat in recognizing some flaw in my approach to sharpening. Why does one need to remove all the concave wear on the area ahead of the cap iron and restore this surface to a perfect plane at each sharpening? I think your picture analysis of the need is flawed. All that needs removing is the rounded tip to restore a sharp edge. If the area behind is concave to the tune of microns why does it matter?

K&K explored searching for a steel that would wear a concave profile on the flat side in a pattern that would self sharpen the tip. They were marginally successful.

Blades are greatly longer than they are thick. Seems to me removing metal from the tip to remove the wear that is necessary to remove is the better choice.

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#24

Re: Hand scraping?

david charlesworth

Jim,

That is a engineers scraper for working on flat surfaces.

Re: Success with a making a shallow ura

#25

Re: Hand scraping?

Jim Matthews

Indeed it is.

I'm curious is it could be used to "excavate" a hollow in the back of a plane blade.