Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

LN 62 in house....

Posts

Re: LN 62 in house....

#26

Re: Oh, and the other board

David Weaver

bingo - the effective part of this plane that was actually inside that hollow amount was about a foot. So the 1.5 thousandth becomes 3 on one board, 6 on two.

I've done this exact scenario before. It's not possible to get a good joint. You might be able to get one that you can force together, but this is an ideal and most people have a habit (before they're experienced with planing) of planing the ends off of a board further.

I had an 8 that was somewhere around 1.5 to 2 thou hollow, it was an LN. I couldn't get it to make a decent joint that could be closed by hand at the ends.

That was a less severe issue at that vs. this plane (which was slightly less hollow but over a much shorter distance.

If the error is in the other direction, we can plane a flat board with the plane easily.

As far as Bill's mention of machining a plane, I'm guessing a surface grinder puts much more force on the plane than we will do. When I pushed forward against a scale with an infill, I saw downforce of plane weight plus 4-15 pounds or so. This was a static trial, it might be somewhat different in motion. It's just not enough weight to overcome the hollow. I've been there - and I tried to solve the issue by leaning on the plane (I wanted to love the LN 8, at the time that I got it, it was regarded to be the ultimate. 10 pounds of thick bladed magic. It had shortcomings other than that compared to the 7 -backlash, which is no big deal,but it was there and not there on other LN planes. I'm supposing the adjuster used on the 8 was made for a 7's blade thickness and that at the time, LN didn't make a separate yoke and stub for the 8.

The 7 was made so perfectly that it was ultimately sticky feeling in heavy work - it was so smooth, but you cannot overcome that kind of friction and despite the smooth commanding feeling in work, it was clear that it prevented me from getting as much work done vs. a less accurate and lighter millers falls 22 (that's now long gone, also, but it was a fun plane).

point being with all of this - sometimes a little matters, sometimes it doesn't. It depends on what way it goes. As far as complicating things, I must've had 10 or a dozen LN planes and only two were like this - the others were dead flat or unnoticeable. This one clipped the last half inch off of the cocobolo test piece in the video above - trouble from the start. After flattening it, with thin shavings, it will lay down a perfectly dead straight joint. This is the essence of making things good for hand toolers.

For someone without my experience, the practical solution is to get a stanley plane. Try it. If it doesn't work easily, sell it and get another one. I don't have to do anything to all of them, just some.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#27

Re: Followup  Question from PPA

Sgian Dubh

Like you Bill, I've taken one of my planes, a Record no 7, to an engineer for sole flattening, and he used a similar set up to the one you describe, including leaving the iron in place but withdrawn sufficiently prior to skimming flat with a surface grinder. That was close to forty years ago and I'm still using that no 7 - I tend to be loyal to my planes, most of which I've owned and used for anywhere between about eighteen years, and all the way back to my first planes purchased maybe fifty years ago. I find it interesting that David seems to go through so many planes, but I realise that's just his thing, and he describes here similarly interesting information about his experiments.

I use that no 7 of mine to prepare edges for panel glue-ups, both short ones and longer ones up to and over 2.5 m (~8+'), either to refine an edge after machine planing, or after rip sawing an edge, and from time to time (rarely in truth) even preparing an edge that's been neither sawn in the workshop, nor machine planed, i.e., still rough sawn at the mill prior to drying the board. I do find it interesting that you seem to be tolerant of prepared edges that even allow a slight gap at the ends prior to gluing up boards to make a panel. I've always been a proponent of the sprung joint for panel glue ups, having been taught that methodology when I trained, i.e., tight at either end and a tiny gap at the centre that a centrally placed single clamp with very light pressure applied will close completely, not that I use a single clamp to assemble panel glue ups.

Still, all this discussion of plane sole flatness, or lack of it and how to fix problems, such as convexity, concavity, twist and so on is useful, but I just want to raise an additional issue which has been mentioned in passing here, and that is the flexibility of a plane sole in use, especially longer planes, e.g., a no 7 or 8. I reckon that I can bend the sole of my no 7 in use by the simple expedient of twisting my hands towards each other in line with the planing direction, i.e., I can induce some convexity or concavity in the plane's sole, something I like to believe I have used occasionally to help straighten an edge.

I really don't have empirical proof of my ability to flex the plane's sole as I described. All I know is that it seems to work, and that I also seem to be able to occasionally use this perceived ability to my advantage.

I just thought I'd throw that technical wrinkle into the mix just to see if it muddies the water a bit. Slainte.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#28

Re: Followup  Question from PPA

David Weaver

here's what you guys are missing -experience finding planes that don't work combined with measuring why they don't

Where your supposing breaks down is when the plane goes off the end of the board. You can't support both ends of the plane and as it's going on the end, the idea of flexing the plane gets harder and harder. Are you going to be able to flex the toe of the plane up when there are 2 inches of it left ahead of the mouth?

No, you can't.

The reasonable person who doesn't build tools as I do moves on or has a couple of planes, favors the one that works best and sells the others or leaves them on the shelf. If I can't plane even a flat joint with a plane like the one I flattened yesterday, neither can anyone else on the board.

When I had the LN plane , I tried pretty much walking on it tip toes with weight on the plane - it still planed the ends off. My tendency in regular work is to plane a board hollow with through shavings -I'll bet warren does the same thing, and probably so does brian holcombe.

You just can't fix an issue like this by bearing down on the plane (which would be dumb) or stop shavings or any other such nonsense.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#29

Edge jointing accuracy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When hand tool enthusiasts discuss minutia I withdraw because I don't have the hand tool expertise to join the fray. But now we are discussing a topic, panel gluing, where I expect I have vastly more experience than most, and as much as any. I did some quick calculations and several thousand bdft of lumber have gone through my shop and a lot of it has been turned into panels of one sort or another. I have a clamp rack with 4 dozen panel clamps hanging on it. At times all have been in use assembling panels. I have never had a edge joint fail that I know about.

If you have been fretting over a few thousandths of an inch of gap in a panel before the clamps are tightened you have been needlessly fretting. But likely you have because you could, not because you needed to. You probably even enjoy striving for perfection in making edge joints. I get that part. You need to understand that if you have always strived for perfect joints you don't have any experience in knowing how imperfect is good enough. You likely work on a time scale that enables each joint to be prepared perfectly.

I have never assembled a panel with hand planed joints. I didn't have the skill, and probably still don't, to prepare a board edge for gluing. But that does not disqualify me from a panel assembly discussion. If you imagine that running a board across a power jointer results in a perfectly straight edge you haven't had much experience using a power jointer. If the edge is not perfect then what? Well, you learn what is good enough or you don't get to make much stuff.

There is a technique for fixing a convex edge with a power jointer but it is one I rarely resort to unless the edge is severely bowed, and it doesn't always work(for reasons I have never understood). You learn the degree to which imperfect is good enough. You learn when it comes to clamping. If intermediate clamp pressure mates the joint it is good enough. Thousands of edge joints have proven this fact to me, and anyone using a power jointer.

The stress in a joint pulled together does not last for infinity. Wood cold flows and relieves stress. Bridge a board across two saw horses and set a cement block in the middle for a week. Remove block and note the board does not return to straight. If the pulled together joint stays together when the clamps come off there is nothing that will cause the stress to pull the joint apart next week.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#30

I'll give you a simple case where this gets ..

David Weaver

..difficult - 8/4 guitar blank, 20 inches long, glue joint front and center and part of the body indefinitely, and too short to clamp together easily (the result is usually a visible glue line at one end of the joint).

As for the rest of the working, if you're preparing a joint by hand and you can prepare it straight and deal with none of what you're talking about (and halve or quarter the clamping, or even make it a rub joint), there's no reason to deal with reverse spring.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#31

Way different with hand tools, by the way

David Weaver

the guy who got me into woodworking has a long bed 8" delta jointer with a spiral head. I have no idea what kind of error it makes, but it never makes anything like a short 8 inch step down of several thousandths of an inch. I had a 6" jointer that was fixed bed and way out of parallel - even on short boards, it couldn't make a gluable edge, so when I did have it, it just knocked the roughness off of boards and I was forced to finish them by hand.

I'll give you a case of how much different hand woodworking can be, and I would appreciate if warren would comment on whether or not he thinks this is a reasonable technique.

I join rough boards. Learning the cap iron allowed me to get rid of the nonsense of orienting a board correctly for aesthetics and cupping, but worrying that I wouldn't be able to plane it, so I can usually tell what looks good from rough. Quite often, my wood is 5/4. if any of it is a little bit bowed or twisted (but not enough to worry about planing out), then I change little. When you use hand tools a lot, you feel square, at least reasonably close. I'm *sure* warren feels this if I do. I didn't read to find out that you get to this point, it just occurs - you can see and feel square a lot better. So slight mismatch isn't a big deal.

All of the above is typical.

On a longer 5/4 panel, I generally plane the edges of each board without checking anything other than a spot or two for squareness (I know the boards will be slightly hollow, because that's what I do). I lay one board on top of the other, check the joint (the gap, as well as whether or not the two boards are in nearly the same plane). This happens *very* quickly, just as preparation of the rough edge, not as a separate step.

It's uncommon for anything to be far off, but minor changes may need to be made (like the boards are slightly too hollow - common). without removing anything from the vise, I make changes to the bottom board with a smoother (usually clipping the near and far end to lessen the spring, perhaps a little bit of change in tilt so the boards are planar), add glue while the bottom board is still in the vise, clamp (never has to be that heavily clamped) and then loosen the vise and walk away with the panel and repeat with the next pair.

This tuning step is less than a minute usually, sometimes (often) not needed at all. If I have to match plane something narrower, the process is a lot alike - there's no need to constantly check or recheck things or handle both boards.

I avoided thin joined panels on the last case by saving boards that were big enough for those panels, resawing and thickness planing them.

If the tools work like you expect them to, it's not difficult. if someone working by hand wanted to match plane a joint and they had a hollow plane, they'd give up on it. I have no real issue with people using power jointers or whatever else they want to use (router table gimmicks, etc, to get a jointed edge), but no interest in it because as soon as something isn't compatible with the tool set, then you're left taking risks or buying more.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#32

I agree without reservation, with some questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

With the required planing skill, and plane, I acknowledge that it is easy to prepare perfect mating joints, so why not? No argument from me on this point.

With a power jointer it is hit and miss getting near perfect joint, so you soon learn what is good enough and it is a damn site worse than what you strive for.

The issue unsettled is the person that buys a LN plane within the LN specification but not yours. What is their situation? Can they prepare good enough joints? Should these buyers test flatness upon arrival, somehow? Should someone that has never flattened a plane before attempt to flatten their new $200 plane if it is out 0.0016"? Does LN deliver planes that are unsuitable if your are unlucky? These are the questions the onlookers may be interested in.

Some experience. When the "you- need- to have- a- dead flat- plane- bottom" movement swept through our club the participants all wound up with severely convex plane bottoms, me included. Some of us took a trip to the machine shop for rescue. The experience left a lasting memory.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#33

Re: Followup  Question from PPA

Sgian Dubh

David, when I talk about my perceived ability to flex a plane only comes into play inboard from either end of a board edge. Generally I prepare edges already straightened on the surface planer (jointer); not always, but that's the most common time for hauling out my no 7 plane. There's sometimes a bit of snipe to deal with on boards off the surface planer. If the boards are long and heavy, such as those that are commonly used for eight or ten person refectory type tables it sometimes the case that a bit of extra straightening with a hand plane is beneficial, even it's only to remove planer ripple on each of the mating edges.

Anyway, I usually start by working from the middle of the length taking longer and longer passes with the plane until I get to just shy of either end. This creates a bit of a hollow, and it's during this stage if the board's edge seems to need it that I have very occasionally tried to flex the plane's sole to emphasise a bit of convexity. I'm not sure that I do actually flex the sole, but it feels like I do, so it's really just an impression. After this planing in the centre bit, I put the two edges together, see if there's a gap in the middle, and adjust the gap to almost nothing by setting the plane to a finer cut and take full length passes along the edge to bring the sprung joint to a tiny gap, something that will close with very little pressure. Both board edges usually get this treatment until I'm happy, and it doesn't usually take long at all, maybe three to five minutes per joint.

Like you, as you mention in another post, I have pretty good instinct for being aware of when I'm planing at right angles to a board's wide face(s). Slainte.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#34

Re: Followup  Question from PPA

David Weaver

I was getting a little snippy with bill and you regarding this, and i'm sure we flex the plane a little bit. My point is just from experience and actually checking what causes problems and what doesn't, you cannot plane a board hollow or without ends falling away if you even have 2 thousandths of continuous hollow in a metal plane.

It's just a matter of what is. Supposing doesn't fit because there are all kinds of logical traps, just like there were for an engineer with a pallet furniture channel (no kidding, he was actually doing videos about pallet furniture, I'd guess hoping to catch on enough to sell plans) who supposed he could easily put the plane on two blocks of wood and measure more than 2 thousandths of flex. He could've pushed the center of the plane down a hundredth and if the plane was convex, he still would've gone to a piece of wood and planed the ends off. The thing he was lacking was sense to realize that you can't always guess your way through what will happen. But, he was making pallet furniture, so how would he know. Most of the issues I've had with people leaving comments without trying things have come from people who either worked as woodworkers (but never that much with planes) or engineers (who often believe that the rest of the society has no grasp on technical issues).

To actually measure a plane and then repeat what I tell people seems to be a bridge too far, and sometimes there's no opportunity. If it's the latter, it's generally better to defer to someone who generally provides proof of everything they say (I do).

If I had, perhaps, 5 total hollow planes out of 50 (i've had more than 50 metal planes, but don't know if it was 100), only one was visibly hollow (without a straight edge - you can see a hundredth of hollow in a plane sole), the rest show up in use. The average person who has ten planes may be exposed to one or two, cast off the plane and discard it.

Or make some stupid conclusion about the frog needing work or needing to buy a thicker blade and chipbreaker. I have addressed issues with exactly one frog out of all of those planes - a tiny booger of slag on one frog that was easily filed off. Someone used the frog with a dot of slag on enough to put significant wear on the plane, but I found it annoying because the iron teetered.

What drives me a little batty is 5 people will tell me they could plane a flat board with a plane like that. 5 years later one of the five will have come across a hollow plane and they'll return a comment like "you were right, I couldn't make a suitable edge joint with a plane that was a little hollow". What does it do for me? Nothing. I wasted my time the whole time. The only reason I have categorized what's a problem and what's not is because I make planes. Even if I'm making a metal plane for myself, I feel like there's no real benefit to making a plane and not spending 10% more time to do the little things that make it perform better than a plane I could buy, or at least as good.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#35

no

David Weaver

you couldn't prepare a suitable edge joint with the plane as I received it in anything longer than very short boards. I couldn't prepare an edge joint in a shelf that I now have in my daughter's room with a LN 8 that was concave by about .002". I took the plane to a friend who has a long starrett straight edge as well as a 7 that worked fine (also LN). The 7 was able to make the joint easily, dead flat.

It took several shavings and not super thin ones to get the LN 8 to take a full shaving, and then I would try to defeat the bend by bearing down on it. It didn't work.

The plane that I just received is shorter. It clipped the last inch or two on both ends of the cocobolo blank and I guessed that it would be hollow right away - it would be problematic planing a joint - think about it as having a good even joint end to end and then intentionally taking three or four reasonably heavy smoother shaving off of each end of two boards. The gap ends up being fairly large, and I think the mechanics make it steeper at the end (which is even worse).

My curiosity moving on from that is what do people do when they get a tool that looks great and they can't create a joint. Do they try another one, find it works differently, or do they determine they can't plane a sprung joint or even one that's level.

(I've never had a joint fail, either, including a couple that were a little high on the ends before I started working mostly with hand tools. If they are clamped together tightly and there is a solid glue line (even if it's a couple of thousandths) you'll get away with it. I really don't like seeing a visible glue line, though.

edge joints and mortise and tenon joints are something where people always suppose they'll fail if they aren't perfect, but the only legitimate claim I ever heard about edge joints failing was from someone on another forum who worked in a shop where one of the other workers put panels in a panel clamp, let them dry a few minutes and then got the itch to make the joint more accurate by malleting parts well after they were first clamped. That sounds stupid, but I'd bet more than one beginner has found a glue up that was less than perfect 10 minutes later and then decided to loosen the clamps, tap it into place and do so without freshening the glue.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#36

other outcome...

David Weaver

forgot about these days of return culture. If you can't plane a joint with an LN plane the way you want to plane it, you can also just return the plane.

I don't know anything about machining, so I don't speculate much, but I"m guessing they aim for dead flat, and most of the planes that I receive from them are that (or I don't know they aren't because they're ever so slightly convex, which I wouldn't notice). Making the target a little bit convex would make for better users on average, but I also don't think the planes that they sell really get that much use.

My english friend would notice if they were out of spec, but he'd check them for spec because he's a mechanical engineer. He's still upset that an older powermatic table is out of flat by 6 thousandths of an inch (Convex). My first table saw was hollow in the center double that - a cabinet saw. That saw is long gone, but I don't remember it hampering me too much because it also had 2 1/2 thousandths of runout at the bushing and it couldn't make a clean edge on a board without modification. Having learned from my english friend, i called delta at the time and they said "2 1/2 thousandths at the bushing is exactly at spec, so we can't do anything for you"

It never burned an edge, I'll give it that (that's nearing a hundredth of flutter at the teeth. I measured something like 8 thousandths of runout at the bottom of the gullets). Just like with hand tools, I didn't measure to find that out, I measured it when I couldn't saw a clean board edge.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#37

Re: Followup  Question from PPA

Sgian Dubh

I agree that a plane with a concave sole is going to make it either difficult or impossible to straighten a board edge, and for the reasons you suggest. I've certainly had experience of planes that really wouldn't work as you describe, usually badly abused clunkers that are quite common in educational workshops. The problem with tools in educational settings, e.g., college joinery courses is basically down to the fact that no-one maintains them or tunes them up, and the students abuse them. No-one maintains them because management consistently understaff their workshop facilities and they includes some airy waffle about technicians or teaching staff being tasked with looking after the tools, whilst not allocating designated time for the staff to do the job.

As to my own planes, I've taken time to check the soles and flatten them if required, and with the exception of my no 7, already described earlier, firstly with a straight edge followed by the simple expedient of sticking a long length of 80 grit paper on to a long flat surface, such as a surface planer table, and doing a quick rub to see what kind of scratch pattern develops, and where on the plane's sole that scratch pattern shows up. That's followed by either doing no more because the sole is okay, or doing maybe five or ten minutes extra abrading to take out high spots (and usually moving on to paper with finer grit, but not always). The chances are that all my plane soles are slightly convex, but I don't check with accurate enough measurement tools to know for sure. However, all the planes that matter to me in use work fine, and that's really all that matters to me.

As to being able to flex a plane in use, specifically my no 7, not others I use, I try to do so on rare occasions, but I can't say for sure that I succeed. All I'll say is that I seem to be able to achieve a slight difference in the plane's action on the wood but it's an entirely subjective impression. I'm certainly not going to try and convince you that you are in error to say that a plane's sole can't be flexed in use to any appreciable degree. What I do know is that I can get my planes to do what I want, or need, them to do, and in the end what else really matters? Slainte.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#38

what you said...

David Weaver

...that's all there is to it (the lapping).

Finding a flat surface, run a plane across it, see what happens with the scratches. If they're only on the toe and the heel and the surface is truly flat, well - you've got to rub the plane on something until the scratches cover at least most of the bottom.

Simple as that.

Lapping is a lot about doing what needs to be done and not more (but most of woodworking is like that - nobody gets credit for doing five things if one is necessary and the other four are a waste of time. the art of getting good at something is learning to do the 1 and avoid the others).

I disclosed measurements of this last little exercise for clarity. I think it gets confusing when we start talking about precise measurements. I recall warren mentioning at one point that in some places, four thousandths is nothing. On a rub joint, it prevents a rub joint. It's not a matter of measuring precision so much as it is understanding fit.

I'm learning from testing these planes that I don't mind a flat plane. I actually prefer one that's a little bit concave, though, as it's easier to generate the hollow in a board just as a matter of cleaning up an edge (no stop shavings are needed), and if a board is too sprung, it's faster to take the ends off than the center. I guess laziness has led me to that.

This whole thing is being inferred as difficult or fiddly because it deals with small measurements, but the important point at the outset was that this plane clipped the ends off of a flat board, and I corrected it in 12 minutes. Now, it's great. Whoever ends up with it will notice nothing other than that it works.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#39

Re: what you said...

Mike In Los Angeles

You must have meant “convex.” One of many things I don’t know is whether the highest point of the convexity ought to be in front of, or behind the mouth. I have a guess but whats your experience?

Re: LN 62 in house....

#40

Re: what you said...

David Weaver

I probably got things mixed up there.

Mouth erosion can be a pain on something like jointing edges (it doesn't affect too much on faces of boards). It's the same effect as having a hump behind the iron in some cases, which isn't good. If the mouth area is convex, you want it to be evenly convex in front of and behind the iron.

Of course, the simple act of lapping with the plane as if you're planing will show when there's bad mouth erosion. Even at that, all mouth erosion doesn't need to be removed, just most of it. As soon as scratches appear in an eroded area (without them becoming deep and even), that's usually good enough.

What bill said about club members lapping the crap out of their planes (some that may have already been convex to start with) is also true - a little bit of convexity is nice. when it gets to be the better part of a hundredth, it can start to get annoying.