Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

LN 62 in house....

Posts

LN 62 in house....

#1

LN 62 in house....

David Weaver

..will test on the cocobolo tonight.

My accusations of shady dealing appear to have been accurate!! (as in, listing an item as shipped and providing a tracking number that never changed from "pre-shipment in process")

I sold an expensive guitar last week and replaced it with a cheaper guitar (this got me in trouble as I have no shortage of guitars -rightly so for being in trouble).

I figured some time would pass before the LN plane would arrive, so no big deal on it saying it never shipped - maybe the mrs. would have time to cool off. Last I checked shipping status was last night.

It arrived just a bit ago and the mrs. dropped it at the top of the steps with intention!! Fortunately, it's well-packed.

Curiosity remains about whether or not it can smash out a 5 thousandth tearout-free shaving in the cocobolo test board like the late type stanley plane. If not, no big deal.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#2

Re: pre-shipment in process part deux....

Orlando in So. Fl.

My accusations of shady dealing appear to have been accurate!! (as in, listing an item as shipped and providing a tracking number that never changed from "pre-shipment in process")

....funny the same thing just happened to me. I was notified that a package was shipped on Saturday and when I checked Saturday night, Sunday, and Monday it said the same thing. Yesterday when I checked, it said it was going to be delivered Thursday. It got delivered today. :)

Re: LN 62 in house....

#3

Fun's over for now

David Weaver

It's exactly 1.5 thousandths hollow in the length according to a starrett edge and feelers. I'd love it if it was that convex, but that amount concave is intolerable.

I'll have to fix it.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#4

Re: Fun's over for now

Orlando in So. Fl.

I wonder if the .0015" is within their acceptable manufacturing tolerances and why they let it ship? I thought LN would be more apt to ensure total flatness than ship a plane with a hollow on the sole.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#5

0.0015” is LN flatness tolerance


Re: LN 62 in house....

#6

Re: Fun's over for now

David Weaver

It's right at their spec. I've probably had 2 planes hollow at the spec limit out of a dozen from ln. They do publicize spec, so I can't really fault them. Ideally, there'd be a slight bias toward convex, but that may be difficult to implement.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#7

Re: Fun's over for now

Orlando in So. Fl.

BTW, my post on the "pre-shipment" wasn't directed at you but at USPS who recently has dropped the ball on a number of items shipped to me.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#8

Re: Fun's over for now

David Weaver

No problem. I didn't take it as such. Pretty pleased they got the stone there that fast. I've seen reports of service issues, but the priority mail and first class here have been great.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#9

Concave vs. convex

Winston

> It's exactly 1.5 thousandths hollow in the length according to a starrett edge and feelers. I'd love it if it was that convex, but that amount concave is intolerable.

Are you saying that convex is ideal (that is, better than flat), or just that convex is better than concave?

Re: LN 62 in house....

#10

Re: Concave vs. convex

David Weaver

Its better than concave and since dead flat is out of the question, it's the bias you'd give yourself to work with.

It's pretty easy to do by hand, bias just a tiny amount on the convex side

Re: LN 62 in house....

#11

Re: Concave vs. convex

Steve Elliott

For using the plane a concave sole is worse, but for lapping a sole flat I'd prefer to start with one that is concave.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#12

Re: Concave vs. convex

David Weaver

Ditto that.

Convexity for me is usually only a problem if a plane shows up twisted, too (it takes a lot of it without twist for it to be a problem in use), but concavity is a cancel-out bias with hand lapping.

When I work the bottom of an infill now, I generally file it slightly hollow and then lap to the finish and it ends up with no light except for the last inch on each end when compared to the starrett edge.

I've been filing planes so flat that I thought this plane may be way out of spec (1.5 thousandths allows a lot of light if the light source is bright). My bronze 4 passes no light anywhere -they can't all be perfect, and the fitness, etc, for $245 or whatever these cost - I wouldn't be able to make any plane to this spec for anywhere close to that.

At any rate, this one seems to be high mostly just at the tips, too, it's not mostly flat with a short hollow in the middle, so it'll probably take less than 15 minutes to get to a tiny fraction of the LN spec for flatness.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#13

Picture of the concavity

David Weaver

apologies - the mrs. is unhappy with me so I wasn't going to ask her to hold anything for this picture. I was holding the phone with one hand and trying to hold the plane up to the light and the straight edge at the same time (which is a good way to drop both) with one hand.

The result is the camera doesn't see the light as important to the photo, so it's blurry at the bottom.

You can see the light passing through, but lack of focus makes the starkness hard to see, except if you look at the mouth you can get some idea. It looks like * a lot * and if you have a flat board or one planed slightly hollow by a try plane, it'll take a lot of shavings before this plane isn't snipping the ends off of a board - let's say half a dozen. No gluable edges can be made with a plane like this, either.

It's tempting to let a machinist or chair jockey tell you that the casting will flex more than a thousandth under our weight (it might, but it won't always - it'll always be a problem in finish work).

Since I won't be keeping this plane, it's a bit of a dilemma in terms of value - I think that a LN plane that's lapped (and perfect) will bring less value than one with this issue untouched. When I had an 8 that was about this concave, it was impossible to use to create a good gluable edge, and I chickened out on fixing it (this was a while ago) for fear that it would knock a lot of value off of the plane,and sold it as-is (nobody seemed to care - it sold quickly on ebay at 90% of new price).

I could ignore it and plane a board convex and do all of the testing with this plane, but I can't pass it along to a new user like this, so I will fix it. If it knocks $25 or $50 off of the value, I don't care. I also don't feel like it's ethical for someone like me to bother LN (even under normal business conditions) when I can fix the issue quickly. I don't like return culture, and I like their company culture. That makes treating it like any other plane pretty easy.


Re: LN 62 in house....

#14

Re: Picture of the concavity

Bruce Mack

"I also don't feel like it's ethical for someone like me to bother LN (even under normal business conditions) when I can fix the issue quickly. I don't like return culture, and I like their company culture. That makes treating it like any other plane pretty easy"

I like your principles.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#15

Question from Practical Planning Anonymous

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

LN sells planes with some specification for flatness. There seems to be a fuss that a delivered plane is at the extreme of this specification.

I am trying hard to format a question that will result in an answer I can understand. It is an important question. I, and perhaps other pedestrian planers, are never sure how to respond to these kind of fusses. How to tell when they significant, or can they be safely ignored. A go at a question......

If I bought this plane I would not have had any means of reliably determining how flat it was. I would have just put it into service. In using the plane what would I have detected that would be different from a plane that:

1. Was dead flat?

2.Was convex at 0.0015?

and related question

Had the planing experts not made the measurement and just used it what would they have detected that was different from a plane:

3. dead flat?

4. convex by 0.0015?

Re: LN 62 in house....

#16

Re: Question from Practical Planning Anonymous

David Weaver

I found this plane wasn't flat not by checking the sole, but putting it to the cocobolo test board. four or five shavings and it was still taking the ends off of my test board and not the center.

I know from experience of failure (not supposing failure) that this amount of concavity will make it impossible to joint an edge and continue on, and everything this plane smooths will take a while to get the ends clipped off of the board that it's planing.

If it had been off in the other direction, I'd have never checked it as I wouldn't have had reason to. If It hadn't planed the ends off of an already flat board, I wouldn't have had reason to.

Most older planes are off around this much, sometimes more. Sometimes due to wear, etc. If you're truing boards or smoothing really finely, this kind of thing can start to cause problems. The concavity is over about a 10 inch space, so on a 20 or 30 inch board, it gets to be a real problem. On two that you're trying to join together with the same error, it gets to be a huge problem.

I think little things like this cause a lot of people venturing into hand tools to think that things are difficult.

I believe this is enough of an error that if you had an accurate jointer and planer and then came back to finish plane this board, you would have trouble with it. I've corrected it already now in about 20 minutes - i wouldn't have known what was going on 12 years ago, and encountered this on a #8 when I had a LN 7 at the time. If I planed any board or joint flat with the 7 (the 8 was actually just outside of LN spec according to my feelers), I couldn't plane the board with the 8 - it would take several passes until the ends were clipped off and the board matched the sole, and then I couldn't get an edge glue-up either flat or concave - the ends of the joint were always a little apart. No amount of heavier or lighter shavings or experimentation would fix it so I sold the plane and said it was concave about the amount of spec. A #8 is about twice as expensive as this plane and I didn't have the confidence to fix it (they are far harder to lap, but I can do it now) and then have the plane be saleable if I didn't want to keep it. The #7 LN that I had was so dead flat that it ran circles around the 8 - it was uncanny. That was just around the point that I sold my jointer and large tablesaw and it was a practical handicap.

I got ridiculed at the time by a lot of "real woodworkers" who learned from tage frid at the time. "Taig frid used planes flattened on belt sanders" or some such nonsense. I later posted an omnibus on youtube about hand lapping planes and the equipment needed and took an equal amount of crap from power tool users who claimed to be engineers. All they lacked is knowing what they were talking about, but they didn't lack confidence.

Whoever gets this plane after me will think that it fell from heaven, but it would've been problematic if I sold it as-is.

I don't know what LN thinks about stuff like this. If there was a way in machining to make the error 0 to +.003" instead of -.0015 to +.0015, the planes would be better. But their buyers are likely not educated enough to understand why (on average) and someone with a straight edge and feeler gauges would return a 2 thousandths high at the toe and heel plane, having not idea that what they had in their hands was a gem biased in their favor for actually getting work done.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#17

This doesn't...

David Weaver

..apply to short planes used with a cambered iron.

(I make this mistake about flatness somewhat often, too - the stanley 18 that I grew to despise was worn hollow in the center, and especially eroded in front of the mouth. On curly wood, it was a right b*tch to use. It was senseless faffing as putting it on the glass lap - it's small and the cast is soft - took all of 3 minutes and it will do anything now. The tiny shaving that I took in the "missing link" picture, it wouldn't have come close to. It struggled in some cases to make functional shavings for finish work. I'd bet it was originally being used in construction and either that wear wouldn't have worked or someone cast it aside when it seemed to no longer function well).

Re: LN 62 in house....

#18

Re: Question from Practical Planning Anonymous

Robert Hazelwood

It's amazing how much resistance there can be to sole flattening on most woodworking forums, and how much the difficulty is overstated.

But I agree with David, for the "practical planer" a concave sole is one of the more serious problems you could have, impossible to work around in many cases. Luckily its the easiest sort of sole condition to correct via lapping.

I would lap this plane, finishing with some careful (very straight) strokes on 220 grit to try to blend in with the surface grinding. Then sell it with some photos of the sole. I wouldn't discount the price on account of some CNC surface grinder tooling marks being removed.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#19

Excellent!!

David Weaver

I just posted my process, and literally....cosmetic finish on the sole at 220 grit.

I agree on (not) discounting - I did an attractive job on this one and will sell it for the better part of new price.

it's always nice when you figure out what you want to do and come to a nice standard, and then find someone else with experience pretty much figured the same standard is about right.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#20

Re: Question from Practical Planning Anonymous

Mike In Los Angeles

David, are you able to post a link or otherwise direct me to the YouTube clip where this is covered? I’ve taken so much aggravation on the subject that I’m pretty hesitant to bring up anything about it.

Planing is probably not best learned online, but that’s what we have now. Starting from scratch, it’s very hard to know when the tool is the problem, or part of the problem.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#21

Re: Question from Practical Planning Anonymous

David Weaver

I went through my videos - it's from 5 years ago. I've gotten better at convex planes, but the rest of the information is relevant.

What I didn't know at the time, though, was that I had gotten a new phone, and was moving all over the place. The stabilization on the video made people very seasick (and I was a little harsh on the fellow on the blue forum who insisted that nobody should ever lap a plane by hand and that they'd ruin one - to send one to him instead. I think he felt like he was giving an honest answer, but didn't know that it wasn't good advice for anyone who has the skill to work wood with hand tools). I didn't name anyone in it, but it sounds like cynical me when I allow it to run in the background and listen to the audio.

send me an email at my address here - the video is marked private, but I may be able to figure out how to send you a link to view it (I need your email address attached to youtube). The reason I don't just pop it back up is people seem to be able to find things like that, and though I did get a lot of grief for suggesting that a few thousandths of concavity is a problem, now I remember that the real reason that I took it down was a rash of comments from folks saying they were getting seasick watching it. If you bob around on a yoga ball while you watch it, I don't think you'll notice, though.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#22

Re: Question from Practical Planning Anonymous

Mike In Los Angeles

Just emailed you, David. Thanks in advance, I’ll deal with the bounce. Your cap iron video eluded me for a year or two for similar reasons but eventually I felt like I needed to know what was in it.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#23

Followup  Question from PPA

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If the plane bottom is a uniform arc up xxx" in the middle I can imagine the plane would plane an arc on what began as a straight board edge. And if one were to continue planing, for some reason, the arc would grow. But unless doing a plane blade test there is no reason to keep planing beyond getting the fist full length shaving. So we only need to consider this defect as potentially significant.

I once had a plane bottom surface ground. The machinist doing the work did a lot of fixturing to make the bottom rigid before grinding. He either believed or tested that the bottom of a Stanley #5 was sufficiently flexible that stiffening was essential before grinding.

I have been told that planes wear near the blade because the plane bottom is flexible and gets pulled into the wood surface at this point, resulting in more wear. Seems reasonable explanation for wear at this point.

So, what happens if I am planing the edge of a 2' long board with a plane whose bottom is 0.0015" up in the middle in a uniform arc? I can see that the plane will have a tendency to plane an arc. But when the board edge is just shaved end to end, the arc on the board will be no more than 0.0015" convex, and it will be less if the bottom is flexible under the conditions of shaving thickness. So what?

If the above assumptions are reliable, what is the significance to edge planing? The potential significance is edge gluing this board into a panel. I have glued hundreds of panels and never had one fail. I will venture that no one on this Forum has glued as many panels as I have. While I am a novice at planing I am not at panel making. I feel I have ample experience to know what is significant to worry about when it comes to edge straightness.

Edge gluing a 2' long board 0.0015" convex does not present a problem assembling a panel from it. I don't think I could even detect this lack of straightness. Even when gluing 8/4 panels the boards are sufficiently flexible to pull bow out of boards vastly more than a few thousandths of an inch. The glue line will even successfully bridge this sized gap if it was not pulled out. The whole reason Franklin recommends 150 psi clamp pressure is to ensure less than straight boards are pulled into submission and the excess glue is squeezed out.

Why is this discussion worth having? Because woodworking should not be sold as being more difficult than it needs to be. Doing so discourages new comers to woodworking, hand tools, planing, take your choice. I've been there and I was misled.

I remain open minded about the significance of the bow in this plane. So far I have not been shown where it matters for practical woodworking, either because I have yet to understand something I don't know, or its not. Appreciate that 100 Forum observers are off to measure the bow in their planes, more or less reliably. They then may launch into needless and RISKY grinding on them. Been there and done that too. Don't mislead them.

Re: LN 62 in house....

#24

Re: Followup  Question from PPA

Wiley Horne

Bill,

I don’t believe you have ever edge joined two boards which were 1.5 thou of daylight apart at both ends. The boards would seesaw under your hands. 1.5 thou in the middle would be OK and good in most cases.

Wiley......arguing about 0.0015” :) :)

Re: LN 62 in house....

#25

Oh, and the other board

Wiley Horne

would also be 1.5 thou of daylight at the ends. 3 thou at each end of the join. You just wouldn’t do it—we’ve all seen your meticulous joinery!

Wiley