Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

worth the extra cost?

Posts

worth the extra cost?

#1

worth the extra cost?

McKay

I just discovered a crack in my favorite #4 Stanley. I have a number of Veritas planes and I really like them. The problem is that the #4 is not available for another month and I need the plane. Lie Nielson has a brass #4 for an additional 125$. For those of you that have experience with both, is the additional cost worth it? The Stanley with the hock blade and cap have performed beautifully for $200 less than the LN. What say you? Thanks in advance.

Re: worth the extra cost?

#2

Re: worth the extra cost?

Curt Putnam

IMO, new Stanleys are garbage. Other folks can tell you what you might want is a refurb. I have a #4 ground by Tablesaw Tom and a bronze LN # 4. The LN is far more precise. I enjoy using precision tools and I craved one of these planes for 15 years before acquiring one. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

Re: worth the extra cost?

#3

I have both...

David Weaver

the bronze 4, as well as a pair of stanley 4s. One old, and one later with beech handles and a blue body (and stamped adjuster yoke)

I like the later blue stanley better than any of the others - it adjusts smoothly, isn't too heavy and isn't nearly as sticky on wood as the bronze LN.

The LN certainly does the tiny adjustments to make super thin shavings more easily, and I flattened the stanley planes, but for day to day work, I'd still rather have the stanley planes (they're less nose heavy, too).

Not a fan of the A2 irons in the LN, either. They are probably the best of the A2 irons, but just not a fan of A2 irons in general.

Re: worth the extra cost?

#4

Stanley #4  $30

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have seen, and bought, Stanley #4's in good user condition at Old Tool events for as little as $25. Certainly for less than $50 you can get an excellent user replacement from a reputable tool dealer.

Re: worth the extra cost?

#5

PS c

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I likely have one I bought for someone in the club in case one was needed should you be interested. My cost plus shipping.

Re: worth the extra cost?

#6

Re: worth the extra cost?

McKay

I agree that the new Stanleys are not a good plane. I did not even consider the new Stanleys, WoodRiver and the like. The old Stanley needed the hock blade and chip breaker to be a really bullet proof plane. My question was directed to those who have used a brass LN ($350) compared to a steel LV. ($230). The brass LN is available but the steel LN is not.

Re: worth the extra cost?

#7

Re: PS c

McKay

Thanks Bill. I have one back west that I could have sent, but hey... I talked my wife into a new plane :D

Re: worth the extra cost?

#8

You may be disappointed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have a LN #4 and I don't particularly like it. It is too heavy compared to a nimble Stanley #4 and the handle does not fit me as well.

Re: worth the extra cost?

#9

Re: worth the extra cost?

Robert Hazelwood

I have the ductile iron #4 and really like it. It's heavier than a Stanley but it's never seemed like a big deal to me. The bronze is heavier, supposedly.

I don't like A2 either, so I replaced the LN iron with a Hock O1. This requires a bit of filing on the chipbreaker slot. Not a big deal, but I suppose most won't like the idea of replacing the iron on a brand new $300 plane.

I would favor the LN over the LV for a smoothing plane due entirely to the adjuster. The Bailey adjuster is the only one I know of that is actually an improvement over just tapping the iron around with a hammer.

Re: worth the extra cost?

#10

Re: worth the extra cost?

David Weaver

If you bought the bronze, keep the paraffin handy. If you use it for mostly finish work, the weight won't likely bother you and the feel is smooth like a cadillac.

That discussion is sort of like power steering - my mother had an early 90s oldsmobile, and one of my employers had a cadillac from around the same time. You could've flung the wheel and it would've spun lock to lock. If you hit something on the road, the steering wheel didnt' so much as flinch.

But sometimes you want to be able to feel what you're driving over (i can feel tearout occurring at small levels far better with the stanley whereas a stroke over the same wood will feel tearout free with the LN, only to find upon inspection that both surfaces look about the same).

Re: worth the extra cost?

#11

Re: worth the extra cost?

roger lance

Since any assessment you might get will be largely subjective (performance, feel, balance, cost difference, etc, etc).....I'd suggest that you find an owner and actually use that plane yourself to get an insight as to weather or not it works for you.

LN usually did a tool tour around the country in years past to give potential buyers just such an opportunity.....this year, I don't know what they'll do.

Re: worth the extra cost?

#12

good suggestion, and what's.....

David Weaver

.what's the real cost exposure?

I don't use premium planes much, but I don't mind keeping one on hand as it's just money in suspense.

It's hard to get an idea of a plane's fit for someone (vs. mine or bill's or anyone else's) without getting it on the shop for a month or two.

If it's undesirable, stanley planes go used for about the same as their cost (adding on replacement cap irons and irons is a loser money wise unless they're sold separately from the plane when unloading), and LN planes will easily bring 80-90% of new without being forced to go to auction sites to sell.

For something that may become a go-to tool, trying one of each for a while is worthwhile and will settle a lot of potential future questions.

I forgot why I have a bronze LN 4, but remember now - when you make an infill, the feel of those planes and their performance on tiny shavings is a good bar to aim for. There are a lot of older infill planes that don't really come close without a good deal of experienced refitting and flattening.

Re: worth the extra cost?

#13

Re: worth the extra cost?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have a number of Veritas planes and I really like them. The problem is that the #4 is not available for another month and I need the plane. Lie Nielson has a brass #4 for an additional 125$. For those of you that have experience with both, is the additional cost worth it? The Stanley with the hock blade and cap have performed beautifully for $200 less than the LN. What say you? Thanks in advance.

Hi McKay

I have a Stanley #4 (actually a #604), the Veritas Custom #4 and a LN Bronze #3 (with a #4 handle).

The Veritas and the LN have a similar mass in my hand. The Stanley feels larger than these two. I have a largish hand, but prefer #3-sized planes.

These planes are significantly different that personal preference is really the only way to choose between them. In terms of performance, they all work much the same. However, there is more to preference for using a plane than performance, per se. How it feels in the hand, for one, is more relevant.

For myself, the Veritas has the lowest centre of effort and feels the slipperiest, while the LN has the nicer (Stanley) adjuster. The Stanley always surprises me when I use it, mostly how sweet it can be. Both the Veritas and the LN use PM-V11 blades, while the Stanley has a M4. Of course, the Veritas are customised planes. Nothing I own is really the same as anyone else's.

This is not much help, I'm sure :)

Regards from Perth

Derek