Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

pmv11 or a1

Posts

pmv11 or a1

#1

pmv11 or a1

McKay

I found a crack at the mouth of my favorite plane and I need to replace it. I do not know which steel to order the blade in. I have read somewhere that pmv11 can only be sharpened with ceremaic stones. Is that True? Thanks in advance.

Re: pmv11 or a1

#2

Re: pmv11 or a1

David Weaver

O1 - sharpenable on a wider range of stones, often not as hard, or a little overhard where available new

A2 - air hardening steel usually around 61 hardness average. Sharpens well on diamonds and stones with alumina (your term of ceramic stones is more or less this).

V11 - same as A2. Grinds a little bit more slowly.

For practical purposes, V11 obsoletes A2, but not O1. If you're doing purely smoothing in clean wood, etc, V11 is the best there is if you're looking to extend sharpening intervals.

As soon as the work gets a little bit rougher (planing rough wood, wood that has dirt or knots, etc) you'll start to have some disdain for V11s abrasion resistance. A2 is similar without the edge life benefit that V11 gives. It lasts only a little bit longer in ideal conditions, but chips more easily than O1. I think we're going to find that V11 chips more easily than O1 at similar hardness, too, thus the comment about rougher work.

Re: pmv11 or a1

#3

Re: pmv11 or a1

Wiley Horne

Agree with everything David said. You asked about sharpening: If you hollow grind, your best choice is between PMV11 and O1, as David said.

If you don’t hollow grind, use O1 because you don’t want to do full-bevel sharpening on alloy steel—even O1 which is lightly alloyed will want a Shapton 1000 or some really fast stone for primary bevel.

If you do hollow grind, and use oilstones, I think you’re better with O1. If you are willing to consider Shapton 1000 or some form of diamond, PMV11 is a great iron, as David has demonstrated.

Your question is right on the money: It’s not so much about the steel, as about how you want to sharpen.

Wiley

Re: pmv11 or a1

#4

Thanks David


Re: pmv11 or a1

#5

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is your favorite plane? Does the crack affect the plane's use?

Re: pmv11 or a1

#6

I have made a similar comparison

Jim Matthews

I have two larger planes, with nearly identical iron sizes.

The equivalent of PM V-11 was provided by DW made from Carpenter's XHP steel.

The finish I get off that blade rivals my ridiculously expensive Japanese planes - but without all the expensive stones, fussy prep and messy cleanup.

As mentioned above, PM V-11 may take longer to hone but the edge is finer and more durable. Link below shows difficult grain shimmeeing after a few passes on "Dynamic Wonder" steel.


img

Re: pmv11 or a1

#8

Re: I have made a similar comparison

Joe shelton

"Dynamic Wonder"! Took me a moment, but I got it.

Did you rub glycerine on that boahd?