What is a wire edge
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Is it the remains of the "former" tool tip that has yet to abrade away or is it metal pushed out from the edge by deformation resulting from the pressure of abrading?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
What is a wire edge
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Is it the remains of the "former" tool tip that has yet to abrade away or is it metal pushed out from the edge by deformation resulting from the pressure of abrading?
Re: What is a wire edge
David Weaver
I guess people would mistake the latter for the former.
It's usually the former (the result of abraded metal that doesn't let go at the edge because there is no support behind it for the abrasive to cut into it).
It is practically imperceptible (and is for practical purposes) after 1 micron diamonds or any good oxide.
I took a picture of a shapton cream edge yesterday, and those stones are so aggressive that I could feel a wire edge after lapping the back of an iron on it. The easy test to find edge deformation or a small foil is to take an edge and shave hair with both sides of it. If it shaves easily from both sides, then the edge is in good shape and the foil is gone.
With a shapton stone, if you use some pressure, the edge will shave better on one side or the other. After some stropping on bare leather, it will shave on both sides. You can alternate which side is shaving better before stropping just based on which sees the stone last. I used to sharpen planes so that the side that shaved hair well was always the same as the edge would be oriented in a tool.
Re: What is a wire edge
Warren in Lancaster, PA
When hardened steel gets thin enough, it loses its stiffness and bends rather easily. On an edge being honed, once it gets to a critical thickness it bends rather than being abraded. This thickness is dependent on the hardness of the steel; mild steel or steel that has lost its temper will have a thicker wire edge and very hard steel will have a thin wire edge. Possibly sharpening with a lot of pressure will cause a very slightly thicker wire edge, but this would be difficult to test.
On a smooth oil stone this wire edge will become like a piece of foil. If you keep abrading, the wire edge will get longer. One can easily do a wire edge 1/8 inch long if one has the patience. On a water stone with some loose grit floating around the wire edge tends to get beat up and will not persist as easily.
So.....
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The length of the "wire edge" reflects the amount of "edge rescission" (Kato and Kawai term that seems to fit), ie length of former tip that has been abraded away.
Thinking further, the bluntness of the sharpened tip will be determined by the thickness of this ductile feature when sharpening with the strategy of forming two intersection planer surfaces, front and back of the tool. One never achieves a point, always a wire edge.
More thoughts, a more ductile steel will not sharpen to as fine a point if sharpening is limited to flat abrading front and back. True?
To overcome the limitation in tip sharpness from the wire edge thickness breaking off, some edge refinement needs to be applied to abrade this edge away, not break it off.
Something I don't understand, the thinning of this wire edge by applying a finer abrasive. Seems thickness would be determined by steel ductility and pressure bending it, only.
Random thought, a Unicorn-Lite on planer and jointer knives might be useful. They are ground and a substantial wire edge is then broken off by various means.
Re: So.....
Warren in Lancaster, PA
There is a guy on U tube who says a sharp edge is "two highly polished surfaces coming and meeting to infinity". Perhaps he has a different idea of infinity than I do.
Another guy wrote a book saying "A sharp edge results from the zero-radius intersection of two planar surfaces" Can you imagine? zero radius?
This stuff makes me chuckle.
Re: So.....
David Weaver
yes on thinning the wire edge. I don't know what the right term is for it, but there is probably some deflection going on as the wire edge gets weaker and thinner if the abrading is done from both sides.
I don't know the exact reason for it, but finer abrasive will make a thinner foil than coarser abrasive, probably due to the rate of metal being moved around. At some point, the abrasive becomes fine enough that the edge breaks off when alternating sides.
The more aggressive an abrasive is (or if it's mobile like a rolling slurry) the sooner the wire edge becomes disorganized at a given size and comes off.
Re: So.....
Winston
> I don't know the exact reason for it, but finer abrasive will make a thinner foil than coarser abrasive, probably due to the rate of metal being moved around.
I think that the reason that a coarser abrasive makes a bigger burr/foil/wire edge is because larger particles stick up more and can bend the thin metal farther.
This isn't the best analogy, but here goes: imagine you took a thin sheet of mild steel (say, 0.5mm thick) and dragged it with significant force across a bed of pebbles. The pebbles that stick up would dents and bend relatively large sections of metal. That's the large burr. If, on the other hand, you dragged it across a concrete sidewalk, the small concrete bits that stick up would cause much smaller denting and deformation of the metal, forming a smaller burr.
I've found that looking at electron microscope pictures from this blog has been helpful for understanding what exactly happens when you sharpen: https://scienceofsharp.com/
Just looking at some of the post history, here's a relatively recent one that looks at the abrasion and burnishing action from sharpening grit: https://scienceofsharp.com/2019/10/02/grit-scratches-and-sub-surface-damage-part-1/
Re: What is a wire edge
Sgian Dubh
I've no idea if this is relevant, but here it is anyway. I've mentioned privately to you that I more often than not begin sharpening by working the flat side of a plane iron or chisel - it might take up to eight or ten seconds. I follow this up with working the honing angle, the time taken dependent upon the condition of the cutting edge before I start. Then it's back to the flat face with the edge hanging over the edge of the stone and the first movement is a backwards drag, followed by some swirling about, holding the tool down firmly. At the latter stages of sharpening I usually do a few gentle drags of the tool backwards, one drag on the flat face, flipping and dragging on the honing angle, alternating from flat side to honing angle a few times, maybe five or eight maybe - never really kept a count. Lastly there's a bit of flipping the tool backwards and forwards against the palm of my hand.
Anyway, the bit I'm not sure is especially relevant, is that after the first part of the procedure, i.e., working the flat face to begin with usually raises a small but definite burr or wire edge on the bevelled or honing angle side of the tool. I've always simply assumed that turning the tool over and working the honing angle gets rid of the wire edge in the same way that it does when working the flat face after working the honing angle. Also that little wire edge tells me the flat side is actually flat: or, I suppose, that if the stone happens to be hollow, the flat side conforms to the stone's concavity to a greater or lesser extent. My own stones are nice and flat, but you might be surprised how many truly ropy stones I've had to work with when, for example, teaching people how to sharpen with whatever kit happens to be available.
Your buffing thing is interesting, by the way, and I'm experimenting with it, although I don't really care for the 'unicorn' descriptor, it seemingly having been ascribed to quite a number of things in commerce and industry of late. So far I've not come to a definitive conclusion on buffing bench chisels and plane irons, but it certainly seems to do a nice number on gouges I use for scribing (coping) architectural door moulding where they meet at inside corners. Slainte.
I've mentioned the splitting of the back..
David Weaver
..work to a couple of people, but didn't want to carry your bucket for you in case you wanted to do it. It felt like intruding or name dropping.
The biggest value (which we've passed back and forth) being that I have gotten many tools that were in use (used) and irons from folks in planes to refit and I can't recall an edge where the last abrasive used got all the way to the edge and removed the other scratches on the tool uniformly.
Which suggests that most people don't like spending a lot of time on the back, but as you say with the wire edge, it does the same thing whether you're working it from the back or the bevel, and even a shapton 12000 stone will create a small perceptible wire edge on the bevel side if it's used briskly on the back.
It's probably good policy for all beginners to work the back twice, because that's where they'll come up short first. I never did as much back work as I do now until I found a scope to view it and then realized that I have no reason to save 5 seconds on a minute process and come up short.
I don't teach anyone anything, but if I did, i would make all of the newbies do just what you're describing.
quite often, on steels that are very hard and don't hold an organized wire edge very well, the local methods are to alternate back and forth until any perceptible foil is gone (I don't know if japanese users strop anywhere, but if they do, some of them do in secret because dogma and ridicule are very strong over there). Their tools don't accept stropping the same way due to the hardness, and I've read more than one translated passage about finishing alternating back and forth with light strokes.
Wire edge discussion is interesting. People would know more about it and understand more if they all had to start with faster cutting and coarser stones, but the abundance of very fine cutting stones makes it easier to get by without understanding it and the trade off is that instead, people don't finish the work on the back with fine and slow stones.
people who have ...
David Weaver
....never taken a mathematics class often have trouble with what infinity actually means.
lack of exposure....
David Weaver
I do suffer from a lack of exposure to pop culture. I did a quick google to make sure that there wasn't a widespread profane use for the term unicorn.
There's always an urban dictionary use here or there that *is* profane, but I didn't see widespread use of anything.
I have a similar distaste for names like "scary sharp" or "ultimate" sharp.
I could've annoyed myself and others by requesting it be called "amazing" sharp or "best time ever" sharp. I have some distaste for the over use of both amazing and best ever. Everyone is constantly experiencing amazing things, or having the best time ever (which is quite a feat, as hundreds of amazing things would lead one to believe all are quite typical, and having even any significant number of experiences be best ever would lead to one wondering why the prior best ever was so substandard).
I expect a guru somewhere will show the thing and use their own name for it to pee on the tree i peed on first (in dog terms) and claim that they did so because of the name when they're really just trying to make the next dog that comes by smell their pee instead. It's happened a couple of times where I've put a video up and then someone made a golly-ghee of the same thing without ever mentioning that they don't think anyone will notice that they copied a relatively low-view video such as the ones I make. I'd prefer that they have the courtesy to mention they are using a tree that I found, and that it's OK for several dogs to pee on it without all of them trying to make it look like they found the tree.
Re: So.....
David Weaver
Those are fantastic pictures. I don't know if most folks will be as giddy about them as I am, but bill asked yesterday whether it's cutting or moving steel that's mostly occurring and all I could guess is that the stone is doing some of both and that all things do some of both, but how much and what kind is the question.
and it'll probably be dependent on abrasive size, steel type and steel hardness.
the picture of the row that was cut previously having its tops folded back in on itself is wonderful to see. I suspected some of that i'm sure most have - from steel being pushed back into grooves but didn't expect it would look so neatly done.
So, now are we back to "Weaver Profile"
I will be spending some hours studying that site
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Thanks for links.
David.....did you note the burnishing discussion of sharpening....
"These numbers suggest that most of the grit-steel interactions are simply rubbing and ploughing (and burnishing) with minimal metal removed. The surface finish, or “scratch pattern” is determined more by the character of burnishing that occurs than by the dimensions of fresh scratches."
I'll bet the Washita surface pattern we discussed is a result of burnishing from the not pointy, relatively soft abrasive compared to aluminum oxide..
Re: I've mentioned the splitting of the back..
Sgian Dubh
David, I must admit I'd never considered my sharpening order (flat face first usually ... but not always) followed by honing, then flat face, etc being any kind of specialist 'bucket' that I'd mind you carrying. I don't think it's anything special, it's just a way of sharpening, and I don't know how I came about doing it that way. I may have been taught it, or I may have worked it out for myself.
I do it because I simply generally like to keep the flat face flat for work with both bench chisels and plane irons, and starting on the flat face and working up even a hint of wire edge on the bevelled side seems to be a pretty reliable way of pretty much ensuring that ... all depending on the condition of the stone, but even with a horribly dished stone I can usually manage the flat thing through being a bit creative on how the tool is applied to skate park like surface, ha, ha.
Still, your buffing thing, at my first play around with it the other day (I'm reluctant to say 'unicorning') seems like it may play a useful role in getting rid of any last traces of filmy wire edge leading, probably, to improved sharpness, and perhaps durability. Time will tell. Slainte.
Re: lack of exposure....
Sgian Dubh
"I expect a guru somewhere will show the thing and use their own name for it to pee on the tree i peed on first ..."
There's always that possibility, and what can you do about it? Not much I guess, but it wouldn't surprise me if it happens, and at that point I suppose you can either shrug your shoulders and let it pass, blow off steam about how you wuz robbed, or all sorts of reactions in between.
Talking of funny names for processes, I've never really understood why the 'Scary Sharp' nomenclature became attached to using the decades old, possibly centuries old trick of grabbing a bit of sandpaper to do an emergency sharpen up job on site when you'd been daft enough to leave your oilstone in the workshop. I recall coming across what's said to be the original description of Scary Sharp maybe a decade or so ago written, I believe, by someone that put it up on the long defunct Badger Pond. It did seem to be a lot of trouble just to get chisels and plane irons sharp, but it appeared to work for him, and it's got its fans and adherents now; it works, even it is a majorly tedious faff that I can't be bothered with having to work through all those bits paper and the inconvenience of it all. I always seem to associate the technique for, as I said, just to get you out of a hole when you'd mislaid your regular stone, or maybe at most, a couple of stones, one medium'ish, and one fine, or something like that, ha, ha. Slainte.
Re: I will be spending some hours studying that si
Warren in Lancaster, PA
The finer scratch model does not work the best for polishing. I wrote this on this forum 10/29/2010:
We use the finer Arkansas stones to polish and finish the edge; abrasive removal of material is not really important at this stage.
David Barnett wrote this on Sawmill Creek 5/21/2013:
Depending on the steel and its hardened and tempered crystalline state, one may determine a point where shifting from diamond to oxides may be desirable. As a rule of thumb, I stop at 1µ diamond and shift to .5µ chromium oxide.
Diamond conforms to the ever finer scratch paradigm; oxide polishes to the Beilby layer flow paradigm*. For those unfamiliar with Beilby flow, it explains, among other things, why some species of crystalline and non-crystalline materials can be polished by oxide polishes that may be softer than those surfaces being polishing; in other words, why iron oxide—jeweler's rouge—can polish the outermost molecular layer of hardened tool steel, rearranging and disorienting its crystalline alignments into a smoother amorphous surface.
Intelligent abrasive sheet sharpening
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The problem with the popular proposal was that it was advocated by someone that didn't know about abrasives, nor the best was to use them. I'll lay down a challenge that I can sharpen a flat bevel chisel or plane blade in less time and for less money over the course of several years with abrasive sheets intelligently chosen and employed, at least through the refinement of 2000 grit silicon carbide.
One glass plate 12 x 12 will hold 8 grades of paper in 3" strips. This format covers grits from 180 to 2000 on one plate in the close spaced steps recommended. Coarse material removal is on a separate plate of 80,100, 120 zirconia abrasive. Using paper with zirconium abrasive instead of the inappropriate silicon carbide vastly prolongs the life of paper and enables rapid cutting of even the hardest steel. By spacing the grits as recommended by abrasive manufacturing company's tech services, time on each abrasive grade is seconds, total time seconds not minutes. One plate to deal with for routine sharpening, it is always flat, and at most a mist of water involved.
If I had not introduced hollow grinding as an initial step I would still be using paper. I go back to abrasive sheets for tool formats that I can't register for hollow grinding.
In summary, it got a deservedly bad rap because of ignorant implementation.
it's good policy..
David Weaver
..I think (not sure) that someone in the past had students or a habit of not doing the back work, as you say - if you can keep the back flat or at least flat to being abraded to the edge, then handling the wire edge even with a relatively coarse edge is no issue.
In order to get people to address it as habit, making them do it twice is a great idea. Nobody taught me to sharpen as the guy who got me into woodworking couldn't do it. I begged a charlesworth sharpening video off of him and learned the method, it worked, and then I quickly started searching for faster ways to do things, so I am in the weeds as to what is ever taught and what's not.
I'm wary about talking of what things other people do as often folks feel like someone is talking about them and if I get a detail wrong, then scolding is next (yuck). I don't gather your the type, but it's just a personal thing.
it's not for protecting revenue
David Weaver
...and I'd prefer my name was left out of naming methods, of course. That's embarrassing.
It's more an offense at how folks will generally just take stuff, use it to build a personal brand (that whole term is offputting to me) and generally fail to credit anyone for anything.
I'm more offended when I see it happen and someone else's stuff gets stolen, especially if the someone else really was the original source and derives income from their work.
Is a Wire Edge Neccesary?
John Aniano in central NJ
Bill, et. al.,
Along with this discussion I'll pose the following question: Is a wire edge necessary to create a sharp edge? Or is a wire edge an artifact of over-abrading one or both steel surfaces (back and/or bevel)? Each time a wire edge is created, steel is consumed that could have been a sharp edge. I can envision that one can form a sharp edge without a wire edge having to be created. Just stop abrading at the proper time to achieve a sharp edge. Easier said than done, I know, but I thought I'd ask the question...
John
not necessary...
David Weaver
in fact, some of the older techniques for caring for straight razors advised not to sharpen all the way to the edge. Rather, keep the edge in good shape and remove the material just behind it.
This sounds odd to someone who is thinking "the edge never moves back then". It does, in fact, on planes at least - it wears back.
One of the good reasons to protect the edge of a plane from damage (if the sharpening method can accomplish that) is that you can come up just short sharpening the iron and still get good results planing. The real reason to raise a significant wire edge in some cases with planes is to get rid of the damage. Same with chisels.
I don't know how successful people ever were with razor hones, but most of the 2x5 straight razor hones were made of 1200FF abrasive. They scratch up the bevel of a razor and can look pretty ugly. The instructions in them say to use them something like 2 to 5 strokes per day with soap as a lubricant. The objective is to do a little at a time, shave, see if things improved and then stop when they do.
they have a comment in them sometimes "do no more than 5 strokes per day to avoid overhoning".
This overhoning term has gotten legs on razor forums and people use it left and right for all kinds of things that have nothing to do with overhoning, and people new to shaving are using 1 micron stones talking about "overhoning and damaging the edge".
It just simply means honing the entire edge off of a razor. using 1200FF abrasive, one can understand why you'd want to not "overhone".
Re: So.....
Winston
The person who writes that blog appears to be concerned with the "sub-surface damage", which, as I understand it, is metal where the grain structure has changed due to burnishing.
I wonder how this "damaged" metal differs in how it behaves -- is it harder, tougher, chippier, etc? Although maybe it doesn't matter for woodworking, since the scale of the damage is so much smaller than the damage done by a blade contacting wood. I think the blog author is mostly interested in razors, and maybe it matters more there.
Re: Is a Wire Edge Neccesary?
Wiley Horne
Hi John,
David mentioned ‘removal of damage’ as a reason for grinding back to a wire edge. This is to expand that thought. In regard to plane blades; chisels another matter. The picture below is a good accompaniment for Warren’s excellent analysis in this thread.
Steve Elliott did some wonderful work some years ago, when he figured out how to photograph the edge of a plane blade at 100 l.f. intervals, as he ran it to failure. His goal was to get an actual picture of wear, and specifically what was called the wear bevel. He succeeded! Here is a link to the page on his website where he discusses this work:
http://bladetest.infillplane.com/html/wear_profiles.html
And here is a smoothed drawing of what edge wear looks like:
What I find is that grinding back a plane blade to a wire edge gets you past the worst of the wear bevel—it grinds it away. Restores both sharpness and clearance.
Wiley
Re: Is a Wire Edge Neccesary?
Warren in Lancaster, PA
This is a rather complicated subject. Here are two considerations.
The edge becomes rounded with wear. You might think that the burr starts when you have eliminated that wear. Actually though the burr usually starts just before your sharpening bevel gets to the flat back. So it is possible to feel a small burr and have it remain on the back side even when you abrade the back. When you feel the burr you are close but maybe not all the way.
Another consideration is that if there are microscopic chips or damage to the edge you want to sharpen past this damage. It could be that 98% of the edge is intact, but you want everything. In that case the intact edge will start to have a burr before you have eliminated the damage.
Both of these considerations are usually small factors on an edge that needs sharpening.