Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Middle stone

Posts

Middle stone

#1

Middle stone

Howard Pollack

Does anyone know if there is a good "splash and go" middle stone available. Approximately 4000 grit? It will be used between a Bester 1200 and a Japanese natural finishing stone? Thanks. -Howard

Re: Middle stone

#2

Re: Middle stone

Robert Hazelwood

Maybe not what you had in mind, but I really like a soft ark to set up the finishing stone. I use mine with WD-40 but I've heard that some use them with water- can't vouch for how well that works. Soft arks are inexpensive and about as low maintenance as you can get. They do a great job of removing coarse scratches (from, say, a fine India or 1000 grit waterstone) quickly. I use mine with all tools, from western to Japanese.

I also have a Shapton 5000, which is a "splash and go" synthetic waterstone. It's a decent stone, removes 1000 grit scratches pretty quickly. My main problem with it is how "sticky" it feels sharpening full Japanese bevels- it really wants to grab the bevel and makes it hard to maintain a fluid sharpening motion. The soft ark with WD-40 is much nicer in that respect.

Re: Middle stone

#3

Re: Middle stone

Howard Pollack

Thank you, this is something I've been considering. Do you know if all soft Arkansas

stones are similar? -Howard

Re: Middle stone

#4

Re: Middle stone

Joe shelton

No, they aren't exactly alike. After all, they are a naturally occurring stone. They are generally consistent within the producer's range, and they work well.

I have one that is striated along its length, with one side distinctly softer than the other side. That's odd, and I like the duality because I use that stone between a fine India and a hard Arkansas.

Every soft Arkansas I've used has been a good stone.

Re: Middle stone

#5

Re: Middle stone

Wiley Horne

Hi Howard,

I really like the Sigma 2000 for this. It’s a very noticeable jump from the Sigma 1000 or Shapton 1000, and I experience no problems going from Sigma 2000 to Sigma 13000.

The Sigma 1000 + Sigma 2000 was originally recommended to me by So Yamashita as a front end ahead of finer natural stones. It works well in my experience.

Wiley

Re: Middle stone

#6

Sigma 6000 Power

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Leagues ahead of the Shapton Pro 5000.

I use the Sigma 6000 after a Shapton Pro 1000 (better than the Sigma 1000?) and then go on to a Sigma 13000.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Middle stone

#7

shapton 5k

David Weaver

The shapton 5k gets a lot of abuse. It's like a finish stone that's not a finish stone...

....until it's been wet a while, and then it works really well. A more dry feeling matrix (a little open) would've served them better and the grit rating is misleading - it's the same fineness (or finer) than a lot of 8k grit stones

Re: Middle stone

#8

Re: shapton 5k

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, I used the Shapton Pro 5000 for some years, and hated it. It would load up, stop cutting .. perhaps I had a bad one. It was followed by the Shapton Pro 12000, which is a nice stone. Moving to the Sigma Power 6000 was such an upgrade on the 5000 that I have zero interest going back even to try it out again.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Middle stone

#9

Re: Middle stone

Robert Hazelwood

There is probably a fairly wide range of densities under the soft ark label, being the middle ground of the range. Density basically controls how fine a stone can get once the surface has worn in- denser being finer.

When I bought mine, in about 2016, I considered two vendors- Dan's & Natural Whetstone. I was following David Weaver's advice on this since he has owned most all of these stones at some point or other. What I remember is that according to him the Natural Whetstone was faster cutting, slightly coarser than the Dan's. Not sure if due to density or as-shipped surface finish. For what I wanted out of a soft ark the Natural Whetstones sounded better, and was a little cheaper as well.

I've been really happy with it. I suspect the Dan's would be very good, too. You can also consider "Hard" arks from various vendors, if you want something a little slower/finer. You can always make an ark more aggressive by abrading the surface a bit with a diamond plate.

Re: Middle stone

#10

Re: Middle stone

David Weaver

chosera 3000 on a base. It's an ideal middle stone - it seems to be "just OK at things" because it's not that fine and it's not that coarse.

It's suddenly a great fit between a middle stone and a finish stone. If you can find gradings, you want something around 4-6 microns.

Those are usually stones that nobody likes unless they're being used in a rotation.

Who knows what naniwa calls those stones and what they're priced at, though. They used to be about $95, so not cheap. (just checked amazon - $110).

Naniwa made some kind of excuse about their cost, shrunk a version for the US market ("professional") and then continued to sell the typical chosera stones in japan (after saying they were too expensive to make). I heard from someone over there that they're aimed at kitchen shops more than woodworkers, so the price is higher. I don't buy the excuses as to why the price is higher ("cost so much to make") as their snow white stone is identical in feel to the choseras and a fraction of the cost.

Their progression is more tailored to knife sharpeners, too, basically the 3/5/10 are 4, 3 and 1.7 microns, and they get softer as the progression gets to finishing (which is handy for knives).

Re: Middle stone

#11

The progressions...

David Weaver

..I never heard what shapton intended with that stone, but the size of the 5/8/12 is an indicator.

They're intended as a progression for full bevels, at something like 3,2,1 microns.

The mislabeling of them is the fact that they're all kind of finish stones, and the 5k gets people to believe that it must be a middle stone (after all, the number is closer to 1k than 5k).

They are good stones if soaked, but sticky and loading stones if just splashed (the 5ks, that is).

Numbers given to stones are confusing in japan. The chosera 3000 is 4 micron, the shapton 5000 is 3. They behave like their grit size and not like their name. The chosera is also like the shapton in that it's like two different stones wet or dry, except that it's tolerable dry whereas the 5k doesn't work well if used a couple of times.

Shapton's instructions on all of their professional stones (to my knowledge) suggest a 10-15 minute soak. They go from being hard and grippy to smooth (and give up more abrasive faster, and thus would need more flattening). I would expect that their instructions for soaking are to please people sharpening knives.

All of the different stone makes have oddities within their lines, too. The bester 1200 is a fantastic medium stone for anyone who will soak a stone. It's better than perhaps anything else I've used in japanese middle stones. The 1k is soft and slower. What's the deal? I can't read japanese, but I'd bet bester intends the 1000 for knives as it slurries and makes an even scratch pattern, despite not being that great a hard grinding on a small area and easy to damage (tools).

Re: Middle stone

#12

Re: soaking

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, soaking is an option, not a prerequisite in using the Pro stones. Shapton (Japan) actually state “ Shapton stones do not need to be soaked except the very first time after purchase. We do recommend that on first use, you pre-soak the stone in water for five to six minutes to secure even smoother sharpening.“

The reason I went to Shapton in the first place was that they are splash-and-go. Soaking may well improve their functionality, however I suspect many choose them (like Sigma) because they work with minimal prepping.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Middle stone

#13

Re: The progressions...

Robert Hazelwood

I didn't know Shapton recommended soaking their Pro stones. I purchased mine because the scuttlebutt on the forums was that you could just spritz them, which seemed like a huge advantage over the King stones I had.

The 5k always felt like sharpening on a wet tire. And as Derek said, it loaded up quickly. I ended up flattening more to remove the loading than to true the stone. I have tried soaking it for a few minutes but not as long as you say. I believe you when you say it improves the stone, but to be honest I don't have any desire to mess with synthetic waterstones anymore, at least on any regular basis. No sink in the shop and don't feel like messing with stone ponds or whatever.

What I've found is that fine india > soft ark > translucent works great on my WS#2 chisels and plane irons, leaves a nice kusumi finish. Works great on my Blue #2 Gyuto as well. But I'm not aware of anyone else who routinely uses Arks for J-tools, so maybe I am missing something.

Re: Middle stone

#14

That and context

David Weaver

OK, i hadn't read that part. Just noted that if there ever was a use for the 5k stone (when flattening, which I usually skipped even for that because it took about the same amount of time to go from 1 to 12k), I soaked it. It became wonderful to use.

It occurs to me that I've missed part of the use on large wide areas when talking about knives as the reason for the compacted progression in seemingly middle numbers...

... there are a lot of videos of luthiers and others in japan actually working up full bevels on planes, something that takes a long time. It was enough to put me off of using japanese planes - you have to coddle them if you want them to look nice as a small nick can be 10 minutes of sharpening with a person who has even the heaviest of hands.

But, this oddball combination of coarse grits and then a bunch of fine ones in a row comes into its own refining the large bevel on japanese planes before going to a natural stone at the very end.

Thus, not a recommendation for the stone unless someone is actually using it in context. By itself, it's not that fast, and it's still coarse enough to leave a wire edge that has to be dealt with.

What I realized later (And didn't understand early on) is that if one is going to sharpen full bevels or work full bevels on anything is that an IM 313 is far faster (medium crystolon, fine india and then washita - even on very hard steel) than any waterstone combination and can be followed directly by the finest oilstone or natural waterstone that one could come across.

I think the synthetics are fiddly in big gaps unless they're being used for microbevels in a guide or honing directly on a hollow grind (even there, they struggle if the microbevel flats have any significant size).

Re: Middle stone

#15

interesting!!

David Weaver

that literally right after I posted my last post to derek (about finding out that an IM 313 was better as a progression than waterstones), your post says the same thing!!

:)

That makes two of us. When I'm using japanese chisels or setting up a set of them that was used, a shapton progression would be intolerable. medium crystolon/fine india/washita (a soft ark is fine) leaves a wonderful looking finish, functional sharpness is already there, etc.

My early years on the forums were full of people trying to find a waterstone that does good coarse work. Nothing comes close to a medium crystolon on oil, and nothing touches sandpaper on glass for the initial coarse back work. Coarse diamond stones and waterstones are a rabbit hole with no rabbits in it.

Re: Middle stone

#16

Friable means more mess...

Jim Matthews

The hard stones (like Spiderco, Shapton on glass) always seemed ineffective to me.

I backed into a set of Shapton "Pro" stones and all of them generate a slurry.

Each achieves the next scratch pattern in about the same amount of time.

I keep them around for my Japanese blades, which are wider than my Arkies.

That broad base makes handling easier.

****

There's no escaping the mess with waterstones - the ones I can use successfully make a mess. The ones that leave little mess - I can't get good results.

I suspect the hard formulations are really for knives.

Re: Middle stone

#17

Re: Friable means more mess...

David Weaver

The really hard stones on the fine end of the range are used just for working the tip of the edge.

The softer fine stones are generally for scratch removal and cosmetic sharpening (thus a lot of japanese knife fans like a fine but soft natural stone - that's part of where I got the name unicorn..

"hi, I heard you sell stones. I've been looking for a long time for a stone that has a soft feel but isn't too messy and brings the hagane up to a super bright polish, works fast and leaves a really really strong matte finish on the jigane".

OK, you're looking for unicorns. I sold stones to people like that by showing them (when I had a bunch of stones on hand) what was possible. want a super bright finish on the hagane, then the stone will be fine enough to start to polish the jigane a little bit. want a hazy jigane, then you'll have to put up with a tiny bit on the hagane - at least. want no scratches in the bevel at all? Then the stone needs to be soft enough to generate a slurry and have particles rolling at the same time so that no prominent scratches form.

Want a nice haze and a super keen edge? get a really hard stone that's really fine and if you have to tell yourself that you're not putting a microbevel on because it's forbidden in japanese dogma. Let's just say you're "using it for about 10 strokes to chase the burr instead at a slightly higher angle than the rest of the edge, and leaving it really tiny so that it can't be seen easily. the knife edge will hold up better that way, anyway, and someone will have to look closely to see it".

Sounds like the unicorn. There's no unicorn stones, but there are unicorn methods.

Sorry for the tangent! the harder stones always cut slower and will always be at odds with full bevel sharpeners. Coarse harder stones are usually not so bad because they're still cutting fast, so a typical full bevel progression starts with harder brisk stones and then works toward closely arranged stones that increase in softness as the progression moves along and then the final stone will either be soft or potentially very hard depending on how it will be used (full bevel for a finish, or intended to be biased toward the tip).

For a freehand sharpener, it's always better to spend time on the coarse stones with really coarse stones instead of being stuck in a certain type. waterstones are regarded as faster than oilstones. freehanding on medium crystolon and india and then removing most of the evidence of india on an oilstone is much faster than waterstones. Then the needle edge sitters are set up to spend their time making things prettier if necessary.

like tools, the stones need to be accommodated.

Spydercos are a real oddball because they're all hard. Unless they're maintained in a way that takes a lot of physical effort, they'll never work a large area well, and if they are set up to do that, they aren't that fine.