Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Video about using a buffer for sharpening

Posts

Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#1

Video about using a buffer for sharpening

Winston

I made a video about buffing chisels that shows how to do it, and has demonstrations that show how much better the edge holds up. Hopefully this will help spread the word to the masses:

https://vimeo.com/444232624

I also updated and organized the web site with results of my chopping tests:

https://chisel-test.netlify.app/

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#2

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

Joe shelton

Good video, thanks.

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#3

Excellent, excellent video!!


Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#4

Thanks, making it was a learning experience!


Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#5

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

Mike In Los Angeles

Has anyone posted tests with microscope photos etc comparing the edge of a chisel prepared with a loaded strop to the edge of a buffed strop? Asking for those disinclined to put a buffer inside. Thanks!

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#7

Absolutely superb, Winston!!


Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#8

My suggestion.....

David Weaver

If you want to use a loaded strop and you have a fine stone, you'll get there faster if you "roll" the final edge on the stone just a bit and then go to the strop.

It will be physically much easier to complete the job.

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#9

a video so well done..

David Weaver

.that it should be linked at the end of a clear article in a print magazine

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#11

Excellent video Winston, I might add one note,

Keith Newton

That a new buffing pad doesn't work as well as one that has been in use for a while. And it isn't necessary to add new compound every time you use it. It takes a while for the compound to permeate or fill the spaces within the fiber. Too much compound is just smearing the waxy compound around on the surface. There needs to be some traction for these ultra fine particles stuck on the surface to do the work. Pressing it down on a flat surface without corners while running ought to help charge the wheel.

I'm glad to see your setup and will need to get one of those little buffers for my axes. I've got a project coming up where we will be hand hewing some logs. I have an old broadax and double bit ax both of which needed a lot of work to bring back into shape. Wondering / researching what main bevel to try to achieve. I think it was the Kelly Perfect 3.5# info that said they used a rounded bevel. After having gone down the rabbit hole that William Duffield sent me down on the ax rodeo competitions, those guys are too protective, and I never found what they were using, but I'm sure it was a lot finer, and I'm sure they were only using some pretty soft wood. For the Ax though I'm betting the rounded bevel may have a lot to do with extracting the ax from the wood after its been buried with all the energy one can muster. I suspect it could become too stuck with a low angle flat bevel to pull out. It had not occurred to me how important this little micro-roundover might be for staying sharp longer.

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#12

Ax edges

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

An ax is something I enjoy swinging. I will use my favorite double bit instead of the chain saw for limbing or whacking 6" and less trees.

A file is an effective way to shape an ax head. Angle grinder works if there is major shaping to be done, then refine with a file. The bevel is convex and the angle depends on the use.

I usually polish the face with a fine India stone. I don't see buffing to be any use for an ax.

Lenoard Lee's sharpening book has an extensive discussion of axes.

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#13

Yes on files...

David Weaver

...except for the scandi axes that are near chisel hardness.

I don't keep any of those because they don't work with files.

Axes are an excellent illustration of one part severing and the other part geometry behind the severing. The older ones have a nice two-way rounded taper and a lot of the newer ones are flat (the scandi types are like that) top to bottom, or close to it, with the convexity on the cheek only going in the direction from edge to poll.

Some of them with very little. Those axes are made in an area where there are a lot of small soft birch trees and they won't free themselves easily from a deep cut. Once in a while, you can find someone trying to use them in earnest on youtube, marveling about how deep they seem to penetrate and then spending a lot of time getting the axe back out.

The really high end hard ones are often slack belted to shaving sharpness before they're sold, though.

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#14

Strop

Winston

I did test a chisel stropped at a high angle. Short version: it held up almost as well as the buffed chisel. It's possible that different/better technique could equal the buffed blade, but I don't know for sure. David Weaver and Steve Voigt noted that in their experience, strops get contaminated over time and that can cause small defects in the edge, but that may matter only if you're using the tool for visible finish surfaces.

https://chisel-test.netlify.app/#buck-brothers-stropped

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#15

Re: Strop

David Weaver

That's the motivation - a strop can be used (at least I'd guess) to generate the same profile with a lot of effort. Eventually, if it's used heavily after a medium stone, it will get contaminated with edge foil somewhere (if not before just with "shop dirt").

I don't know if anyone would care about that - bill reminds me that there are plenty of folks who aren't finishing with tools, so they won't care about those kinds of things. For finish planing, we actually do look at the shaving while planing (even if a lot of people claim that they don't and it's a waste of time) because it tells us what the plane is doing. If the shavings split, it's an annoyance for something that we'd like to observe.

What sellers does with a strop would be more easily done (with much less effort) first with a fine stone and then with a light stropping. The fine stone doesn't need to be large if it's only used for this, and it doesn't need to be expensive.

All this aside, the buffing wheel just does it so well and so easily, even if it's just a $10 arbor kit and wheel as you've shown. For a long time, I had a peripheral irk that I couldn't quite finish an edge to match a buff, but the counter was that the buff doesn't control geometry well. The key turns out just to use it for its strengths and avoid what it doesn't do well.

The biggest trouble when talking about sharpening with most folks is we all have our investments. I invested in figuring out the benefit of the edge roll without making the entire chisel feel blunt. It seemed like the best compromise. People who take a sellers class (I've gotten messages through the youtube system from people already who have invested a lot of time in working the full bevel of a chisel and they want to know how to adapt the method to a chisel without dealing with the two separate bevels - they don't want to throw away what they've learned or deal with the black box at the edge that the buffer really is without a microscope).

All of the sharpening methods work, just like all of the different types of stones work, thus the buy in rate for something that's demonstrably better is so slow. As much as I've tried to perfect doing all of this without something plugged in or using a battery, the version that is "dumb" and not precise at the edge is better.

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#16

for some kind of buffing...

David Weaver

...all that aside, my wife was complaining about long shallow scratches on her car. Someone appears to have brushed along the car with a coat or something not that severe (maybe the plastic on a shopping cart). I have one of those $10 kits, but from ebay, and it's got a bunch of little buffs on - including two 4" wheels. I thought I'd never use it. I bought it for guitars or razors or something, but it's too dangerous for both because of the moving hard metal parts that can contact things when used for that.

I would've rubbed those scratches out by hand, but I dug that kit out inspired by the "winston" setup, and put a glazing polish on the buff and removed the full length light scratches in less than 10 minutes. Now, I'm obligated to remove the rest on every kind of anything around here.

I've also used the (Bench) buffer itself in the past to restore hardware in the house that would've been thrown away in a use. If I didn't have it here, I wouldn't have thought to do it and it would've seemed like buying a buffer was a waste of time. But the wheel paid for itself in one shot (and will improve marital happiness), and the buffer paid for itself several times over long before using it on tool edges.

The kit that I have is the kind of thing that shows up with an ebay search string like "drill buffing kit cotton".

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#17

Re: Strop

Steve Voigt

Thanks for the video, Winston. It is very informative and well done. I will work on the stropping approach a bit and report back when I get a chance.

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#18

Great Video - Left a Burnniing Question

Curt Putnam

How does a Unicorned Buck Brothers compare to a Unicorned PM-V11 chisel?

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#19

Re: Great Video - Left a Burnniing Question

David Weaver

Similar edge holding but v11 is slicker through wood.

And then twice the work to sharpen or grind.

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#20

Re: Great Video - Left a Burnniing Question

Winston

I actually did test a buffed PM-V11 chisel. Short version: like the buffed Buck Bros chisel, it had essentially no damage in the test. It did require more buffing to get a similar effect.

https://chisel-test.netlify.app/

It would require a longer or more punishing test to see if there are differences. I suspect that what would happen to the edges in a longer test is that they'd just gradually get dull instead of failing via folding or chipping, but that won't show up well in these microscope pictures.

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#21

two approaches

David Weaver

1) fine stone light round over (like the file chisel I sent you a while ago), and then strop (which I didn't do -that edge was just rounded over on an inexpensive dans "hard", not their really fine stones. Their hard is just a fine soft arkansas).

2) strop only

I've been rounding the tip of a chisel for a while and the same edge protection is had if it's done right (without much change in behavior of the chisel - maybe an improvement for the average person because it ensures the sharpening is completed at the edge).

It's much less physical work to do the fine stone than just a strop, and if there is a contaminant on the fine stone, you can easily feel it. On the strop, not so much.

The slower and finer the stone, the better (a broken in spyderco would be great. I use a japanese equivalent stone labeled "barber oil" that appears just to be a white alumina stone fused solid. Its work under the microscope shows that it's almost as fine as 1 micron diamonds, and about twice as fine as a completely dead dan's black).

https://i.imgur.com/eINT4NZ.jpg

quick compound on leather after this stone would negate the difference between either it or a hard ark, though.

physically duplicating the same though without the stone, though, is an obnoxious amount of work to do each and every time.

Leaving the file-chisel at a too-high hardness was chasing getting the white stone to cut finer and finer without leaving a wire edge.

The buffer just does an end around past all of that stuff, but a plugged in buffer may not please purists or work well outside the shop.

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#22

Thanks David and Bill, *LINK*

Keith Newton

I of course use a file to work the main shape of the ax and adz blades, but have then followed with fine diamond plates, but still think I want to polish the final edge with the compound. If it improves the edge holding of even cheap chisels, I see no reason it shouldn't improve the ax edges too.

I went looking online for a buffing pad for a 4" angle-grinder because I think laying these large blades over the edge of my workbench, I would have better control with the grinder than I would with a drill.

I ran across the disk linked below, but noticed they are 16mm ID, which is well below the 7/8" typical for angle grinders, but started wondering how or why they would even offer them is there was no way to mount them. Even in the reviews some were complaining. But then I went out and removed a cut-off wheel from one of mine, I found that the shaft under the big washer/ bushing that the normal wheels mount on is just over 16mm, so they ought to work without the bushing on the shaft, although I would like to have a larger washer behind it.

Since y'all seem to still be in the experimental stage, I thought this may be worth a try.


https://www.amazon.com/Keadic-10-Piece-Polishing-Buffing/dp/B07PCJ5P98/ref=pd_lpo_469_t_1/137-3733575-9590929?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=B07PCJ5P98&pd_rd_r=287de8d9-95ef-490a-9f2d-f9897c959ae2&pd_rd_w=1PJmw&pd_rd_wg=lt6OV&pf_rd_p=7b36d496-f366-4631-94d3-

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#23

Eventually becomes an irrelevant question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If a chisel is used much its ergonomics trumps the steel it is made from. The most important benefit of Unicoring a chisel is to make you favorite chisel better. Any Unicorned chisel is now good enough. We can choose by ergonomics and price because the differences in edge retention are now not significantly different.

I built all the drawers for a desk with a Unicorned Narex without interim sharpening. That feat is good enough for my needs.

Re: Video about using a buffer for sharpening

#24

Re: Eventually becomes an irrelevant question

David Weaver

that's true.

all other things considered, I found the japanese and V11 chisels to get through the wood a little bit slicker than the sorby, and just slighly better than the AI chisel, but in isolation, the difference may not be that much.

The average person may value how much more easily the softer chisel grinds and sharpens once the edge failure is removed and refer it over V11.

The other interesting thing with the japanese and V11 chisel is that they didn't feel quite as bad with some edge damage, but the reality is that would accumulate and eventually cause a problem. I was a bit shocked by the V11 edge photo at 25 (slick feel, lots of damage), less so by the AI (I could feel the damage) and shocked to see the damage on the 30 degree japanese chisel (lots of damage, still chiseling reasonably well).

What I got to learn with this is that once you start getting damage several thousandths thick, most people aren't going to do enough sharpening to get rid of it and it will be carried forward for a while, even when enough of it is sharpened out to not see it. When the honing rate of the metal halves, but the damage occurs at the same rate, then it really becomes a matter of using a partially stale edge all the time. I have excellent eyesight (better than 20/20, and closer to 20/10 at distance) - I cannot see very small uniform edge damage in any light angle that the microscope can still see well.