Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Cr-Mn vs. Cr-V chisels

Posts

Re: Cr-Mn vs. Cr-V chisels

#26

Heat treating

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I did not know the best place to put this reply as it pertains to several previous posts. The quality aspect of the chisel as far as the steel goes will be in the consistency of the composition, and especially important, the consistency of the heat treating. A large number of temperatures and times need to be just right to produce a quality tempered steel with the optimum properties.

I analyzed a Chinese plane blade for David and found it short on the expensive alloying elements. That quality parameter is easy to check in seconds and any modest sized company can do it. Checking heat treating entails testing for hardness , toughness, grain structure, etc. Not cheap to do. Easy to "cheat".

Re: Cr-Mn vs. Cr-V chisels

#27

Variables that change for chinese tools

David Weaver

Chinese planes are a good example. Luban/Wood River copied most of the elements on LN tools early on. Subsequent revisions took out bits and pieces that were similar to LN more so than bedrocks (probably the patterns on the frogs, etc, LN's planes are more modern and sort of squareish with rounded corners - kind of ugly compared to older design, but few people grasp that now).

However, the A2 irons were the bees knees in the original LNs because they do, when sharpened properly (to where they won't chip) outrun hard water hardened irons and soft O1 or chrome vanadium irons by about 50-60% in footage (the last half of that gain is pretty miserable, but so are we as hand toolers).

A2 steel is not hard to find. You don't even have to have domestic A2, but the first planes got water hardening irons instead because it's common in china.

I would be surprised if pfeil was using a direct equivalent to the ultra cheap Cr100V or Cr60V that is common in china (1/2% carbon steel). The modifications that I'd expect them to make would be spending a little bit more to make steel that hardens more accurately in less than ideal conditions, and to make steel that is more stable (the cr60v type HF chisels are flat enough for me, but Pfeil and LN types will do more post-hardening clean up and count costs).

As for production, just about every chisel I've ever seen except for boutique or japanese now is drop forged in two or three steps with the last step being a trim die. It makes a good chisel. People don't like the term because you see it on all kinds of stuff. Razors have been made this way for eons, probably since they perfected making modern razors with a thin grind in the late 1800s. More recent steels in razors so far as I can tell sharpening them are lower in carbon, though, and to a slightly lower hardness standard. I'd imagine this is to make it easier to cut down on the skill and time needed by cutlers.

If pfeil spends an extra 50 cents to make their drill rod blanks better, it would be a bridge too far for most of the chinese-made chisels. If the luban chisels cost the first level of distribution more than about $10-$12, i would be surprised, but they are sold between $60 or so and $80.

I've seen the transformation in the woodworking market since I started in 2005 and now - everything that was $100 before may have gotten to the distributor at half of that. Now it's more like 10 cents on the dollar to a quarter so that all of it can fit in the nonsense "return it for any reason" policies, and so that it's not so critical that it turns over in stores or web stores so fast (or if it goes unsold).

Rockler was 2 minutes from me until a couple of months ago. I got a notice in the mail that they were moving. When I started woodworking, they had a decent array of synthetic sharpening stones, pastes, compounds, they had hock plane irons, etc, two cherries chisels and japanese chisels on the low end. I couldn't name anything that they have for hand toolers at this point that was stocked in the store. Everything that had a western origin that wasn't proprietary seemingly disappeared. Anything in the finishes that had a western origin was marked up enough that if they also had it at home depot, it was cheaper at home depot than it was with the 25% off coupon at rockler.

Too many expenses and people can't resist saving 50 cents. How much do you think it would cost to hang those chisels on a rack like they do with straight razors and heat them in molten metal and quickly quench them by the hundred. They'd be protected from their elements migrating in the heat and fully quenched end to end instead of splashed. What would it cost, another 10 cents a chisel? The hardness spec could be nailed literally to the number (iles is pretty much right on the money and their spec is a single point. I could hit a hardness spec in my garage within a point).

It does a bit of a disservice to pfeil to believe that the chinese copies are exactly the same as theirs, as I've had about five sets of chinese chisels and none have been as good. The cheap sets are usable, decent, great for the price, but they are not equal.

They also appear to be more a copy of bahco/german/or other chisels. Bacho's chisels are spanish made now (ex mifer?). We're already jumping to conclusions if we think they're even copying pfeil.

Re: Cr-Mn vs. Cr-V chisels

#28

They overshot...

David Weaver

..their hardness spec by 5 points. I've burned those irons on a stone before just to see what happens and they reharden fine. They're definitely HSS, but not a spec that we're aware of because they trimmed cost where they could.

I've never had one that was soft, they're slightly less hard than the one I sent you and most are about like that one, and I tried to set up one the other day that was an order of magnitude harder. IT must've been completely untempered as it won't hold an edge. The honing is so slow on diamonds that it's almost unbelievable.

I'm not surprised that they'd copy the shape of a bahco or schlieper chisel, but I doubt any are the same quality.

Re: Cr-Mn vs. Cr-V chisels

#29

Still bad after grinding it back

Winston

I'm not sure this chisel is redeemable. I ground it back maybe 2 mm, then honed to 25 degrees and buffed.

This is after paring maybe 6 inches of pine end grain:


If there's a real chisel inside of this chisel, it must be even deeper inside.

Re: Cr-Mn vs. Cr-V chisels

#30

it could be deeper...

David Weaver

...or they may have forgotten to install the chisel inside the chisel.

I don't know how much was ground off of my chisels because they were used to do a bathroom and kitchen remodel (to scrape grout, etc). A lot got worn off of them.

Rehardening would probably solve it, i'd bet the issue was hardening and not stock quality (which could be low, too, but not to cause something like that). The buck brothers video on how its made shows a pretty slick system for hardening and tempering, but it's easy to see that if it went too fast, or the water wasn't running right, etc, that a huge number of crappy chisels could be made.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8fAIdYZYU20

Re: Cr-Mn vs. Cr-V chisels

#31

Life’s too short

Wiley Horne

and too long, for that chisel to be on your bench. But. It can do yeoman duty as a paint-can opener, broken tile remover, and so forth. Everybody needs a couple or three of those.

Wiley

Re: Cr-Mn vs. Cr-V chisels

#32

but something for nothing....

David Weaver

...it's such a strong draw. It's what leads us to get impatient with strong chisel edges once they've performed well for a while (I could just set this a little lower and it would cut better.....then blam, a corner leaves and back we go).

I vaguely recall wanting to get these chisels to beat on and modify. I figured they'd be junk until i found the chisel in chisel. Then, that part is just subpar.

Years ago, I ground a "dovetail chisel" out of one, and found that it wouldn't hold its corners. I got it out last night (another became a scraper to bed japanese plane irons quickly, two others got abused chiseling grout after removing old tile). I unicorned it last night, pared a bunch of wood with it this morning, and now the corners remain. Works great. Soft enough that it takes kind of a poor edge on stones and has a wire edge that doesn't tease off that easily.


The road to youtube millions if someone ever wanted it is the something for nothing gimmick. Like Wandel and Heisz or lots of those other guys - "just make everything from scrap wood". The videos is what they're really making.

If someone had the stomach to buy these kinds of tools on a regular basis and make biased tests and show them "beating" expensive stuff three days a week (And then post a patreon link and amazon references, and turn on youtube ads), I'd bet there would be a six figure reward on an annual basis. Yuck. IT would take someone good enough to do that, but who somehow wasn't offended by the gimmick, too.

Re: Cr-Mn vs. Cr-V chisels

#33

Yabbut

Wiley Horne

Doesn’t look like Winston’s going to find the chisel inside that one. Of course, he can grind it back another 1/2” looking, but I think we should give Winston permission to bless that one to the rough carpentry/demolition pile.😀

Wiley

Re: Cr-Mn vs. Cr-V chisels

#34

The most sensible conclusion...

David Weaver

..that's certainly the most sensible conclusion.

I could mention hardening and tempering, which would cost about $100 of setup to do well :) and probably removing handles to get an accurate temper for more than a small part of the edge.

Something for nothing often becomes something for more than something and ignoring the latter and still regarding it as nothing is ignored.

(which is why I usually tell people to get the Iles Mk2 chisels if they ask what chisel they should get to do general cabinetmaking type stuff - dovetails,, etc, anything shy of cutting mortises).

Even then, you run into the far opposite end - the "they have imperfections in the bevels (somewhat hand finished), and only the very best will do" crowd. :b

Re: Cr-Mn vs. Cr-V chisels

#35

Well,

Wiley Horne

I notice you (and Alex. Bell and Wright Bros., for that matter) have made some terrific discoveries pursuing long shots, and things sensible people judge to be no shot at all.😀. So don’t stop!

Wiley

Re: Cr-Mn vs. Cr-V chisels

#36

Re: but something for nothing....

Winston

> If someone had the stomach to buy these kinds of tools on a regular basis and make biased tests and show them "beating" expensive stuff three days a week, I'd bet there would be a six figure reward on an annual basis.

Well, I did make a video that showed the $7 Buck Bros chisel beating the $100 Veritas. I'm looking forward to my six figures rolling in.

Re: Cr-Mn vs. Cr-V chisels

#37

objective tests don't count

David Weaver

You couldn't keep it up three times a week with legitimate ones!!

you have to develop the skill of getting something that doesn't work at all, suffering through something with it and going "it works great!!!".

warren told a funny story about a guy selling new crudely cut gouges, trying to pry an endorsement out of someone who just couldn't take it any more. "They're terrible" or something to that effect.

In the world of guitars, the something for nothing gimmick is strong. like the chisels, you can contract with a factory to get your brand on guitars and then blitz social media and youtube. Guys plug in a guitar and play it (something a $175 cort does just fine), compare it to a $3000 US made guitar, and talk about how great it is. Sometimes you can hear dead notes on the fingerboard when they're playing, but they're given click through revenue on the guitars and sometimes paid cash on top of that to say that they're great, and they have extremely loyal audiences in their comment sections. It's really strange!!

(I like V11 in plane irons - chisels I'm undecided, but I"m glad to have the choices available and be able to accommodate the "lowly things" like stanley 4 palnes).