Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Unicorn summary requested

Posts

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#26

Re: an article is coming.. One issue that I see...

Wiley Horne

Hi John and all,

Do you have a drill press? I wanted a slow speed for more control, so chucked a 4” wheel in a drill press rigged for 1100rpm. Worked fine.

Here’s the cheapie drill press:


I got this result on a Japanese mortising chisel—the scale is 1 gradation = 0.01” (10 thousandths):


The unicorn is a little less than 5 thousandths, gotten by presenting chisel to wheel at 10-15 degrees. That’s in the range I wanted—more angle of presentation makes shorter curl on the tip. That unicorn increased the cutting angle by 3 degrees, from 33.5 degrees to 36.5 degrees. I get the cutting angle by sliding the chisel across my bench, and finding the lowest angle where the chisel bites into the benchtop.

Wiley

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#27

Response on old chisels

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Given how trivial it is to make what appears to be an equivalent convex edge with a flat abrasive it is reasonable to imagine the benefits of this profile were blundered into before.

I can do a test of the theory. I have a boxed set of socket chisels from a cabinet maker in NE PA. He worked in the early part of 1900's. His son said his chisels were as he left them. I will see, without the aid of a microscope, what the tip looks like. If it looks profiled I will find someone to photograph it.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#28

Results

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have chisels from 1/8" to 2" in a set, Jennings. (they are for sale if anyone interested)

Most of the chisels are sharpened with a convex profile over half or more of the tip side of the bevel. Some have the"glint" at the edge, from wear or Unicorning, I do not know. Two have a tiny back bevel, just a glint along the back edge. None of these chisels are sharpened as the intersection of two planes.

More observations are going to be necessary to explore the possibility that chisels of old were Unicorned. Someone in the club bought a tool chest from a cabinet maker's estate in Syracuse, NY. I'll ask if he messed with the chisels.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#29

vintage japanese chisels

David Weaver

Most of the vintage japanese chisels that I get from japan are sharpened with some kind of convex bevel that steepens at the edge. I've never gotten one that's window pane flat like I have been sharpening mine until recently.

Quite a few of them are pretty blunt, though.

The english chisels are sometimes sharpened pretty flat, and sometimes they're not (the types that ebay.uk has made it possible to get reasonably). Some have long primary bevels and a small final bevel (but it's usually fairly worn, suggesting someone has used them a little bit since the last time the neat long primaries were reset).

I'm sure this was done before, it's just a matter of what percentage of the time and how can we tell the folks who used it on chisels used the chisels a lot if the chisels are full length.

I've been doing "the roll" for years on the stones. Lifting the last little bit to protect the edge and shallowing the primary bevel (or not steepening it for hardwoods) and then stropping. When you and wiley requested that I relay the primary bevel angle on my chisels, it was set like I would normally set it. I was shocked to see that it measured 19 degrees. But I've see flat bevels that were made shallower than that on English sets.

The roll is valuable even outside of all of this because it ensures that the finest tool is working all the way to the edge. Part of the thing that drove me to that was starting to look at edges and realizing that if I did the roll, the edges would look better and I'd never have any surprisingly unfinished edges.

But there are a lot of variables we don't know. When I get a neatly matched set of english chisels in a roll and they've been well used but the bevels neatly cut (and shallow), could the user of them have used them only for a specific task? The tyzack chisels have two that were used more than the others. One of them, the owner hooped after the handle got a bit shorter than the others. The finish on the full bevel suggested that they were carefully kept that way (it wasn't a coarse grind).

It's just hard to guess and discern any real pattern with all of this, but it's nice that if it was very common in some variation that laziness can lead us back to it.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#30

This sounds familiar

Jim Matthews

"The finish on the full bevel suggested that they were carefully kept that way (it wasn't a coarse grind)."

I suppose this approach means the user assured a continuous curve to the bevel, which reached to the very end. A full convex bevel is easy to examine without magnification.

The honing passes are "into" each stone and stropping is opposite (toward the user) to tease off the burr. Paul Sellers taught us this approach, probably handed down from the generation that made your refitted (new hoop) chisel.

The advantage of a buffing wheel is obvious - the stropping step is nominally 30 strokes at significant down force.

A buffing wheel substitutes angular momentum and saves my hands for work.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#31

I would add....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A buffing wheel substitutes angular momentum and saves my hands for work.

and it seems to be fool proof.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#32

I've seen that bevel often...

David Weaver

including on japanese tools. as long as the user has the discretion to stop at a certain angle and go to a coarser stone if progress isn't being made without going steeper, it works well.

The tyzack chisels that I had and one plane in the past were different, though, which is why I mentioned them separately.

They had an extremely gradual long bevel, and then the very tip was honed steeply. The bevels were close to flat. It makes me think that someone really wanted them to be as thin as possible for a reason. Like perhaps someone working making only drawers and wanting to keep the waste between tails from bunching up as it was severed.

I had one other plane that was in a pair of well kept planes that didn't look to have ever been mangled by amateurs. It also had a super long thin bevel, and then a very deliberately (but neatly) kept much steeper secondary/final angle. I assumed at the time that someone figured that if they kept the primary very long, they could use the plane for a while (on site or during work hours) without spending much time sharpening.

I have no idea if I'm right on either of those guesses. Those are the only two that I can recall getting with bevels like that. The angle for both must've been on the order of 15 degrees, and flat.

I also assumed that the plane iron would fail due to lack of support, because that's a popular thing for people to argue about. A user whose name starts with S (not posting here) used to constantly assert that a hollow bevel or a thin bevel is weak, which really misleads beginners. If a bevel is weak, we will find that it is. when I got my first 6" grinder, the discussion about how much stronger a 10" tormek bevel would be was very popular ("the hollow isn't so deep and it won't weaken the edge"). I got the grinder anyway, but also a tormek. The tormek is a huge pain for day to day work where we're just grinding and then honing on stones. Never did chase damage up into the chisel bevel.

At any rate, I used that plane for a while just honing further into the thin bevel and it never failed. Once I found the planes that I wanted to copy, I sold most of the rest of what i had, and that one is long gone, but the bevel was honed off, anyway.

It's far more common to find japanese and older tools rounded like you say. I would guess that examination of bevels would find some marks from silicon carbide stones in the rounded bevels - they work really well for that. New carborundum in an oil bath for the bevel side of tools is really super for chasing a full bevel.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#33

Re: I would add....

David Weaver

>and it seems to be fool proof.<

Bingo, and the bits learned with it on chisels and now plane irons are so easily usable on just about every other kind of edged tool one can find other than a straight razor or a scythe.

The gentleness that the buffer displays at the very edge while still being able to cut pretty fast is really incredible. It just took off and on tinkering for 10 years to figure out a way to keep it from making a steep fat rounded over edge (as leather on a full bevel will lead to).

Wiley is somewhat responsible for this, too. He pointed me to that SGPS pocket knife, and the thing would absolutely not take a good edge off of anything but the buffer. All of these little things contribute. I think 95% of folks who read about the method will think it sounds complicated and be averse to a buffer.

Anyone who tries it for a week and who is honest about the quality vs. a method that they may have a semi-religious attachment to (referring to folks who may adore or despise some woodworking gurus and run toward or away from them in silent spite) will admit how much better it is.

Pretty much everything where the method steps up performance has been touched (Steve V. mentioned the buck chisels - the incannel gouges that I have are buck. i LOVE the way they look and their proportions, but the edges can be a little fragile. Yesterday when I was counting the english branded chisels that I have, I found that I have something like 20 buck brothers chisels, excluding gouges. I don't remember getting all of those, but the steel is so fine in them, and the slight lack of hardness is sort of a deterrent. The fineness draws you back in, though - now, it's solved).

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#34

P.S.—6 seconds buffing time

Wiley Horne

on edge shown in photo. 1 micron green from McMaster. 3 wheels for $12 from Amazon.

Wiley

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#35

Drawknife

Larry Barrett

I use a drawknife a lot. I bought 'Winston's' buffer from HD and am trying it out on several drawknives. So far they are sharper than I have ever been able to achieve before, and cut nicely. It will take time to see how well edge holds up.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#36

Another good use

David Weaver

it's nice to have a strong edge on a draw knife without having a fat edge.

It's also nice to finish the edge with a buffer after a mediums stone rather than working the very long edge around on a bench stone or with a block with abrasive on it.

Thanks for pointing that use out. I hadn't thought of it.

This is also another point where some kind of buffing medium finds use for those resisting buying any kind of buffer or arbor to buff.

I didn't buy a buffer for this process, at least not how we're using it. It is one of the ideal tools for the theory of spontaneous junk (if you keep enough junk around, eventually something useful will occur or spring from it).

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#37

Re: I would add....

William Duffield

What about turning tools (but maybe not scrapers :D )?

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#38

Reading some avid turners...

David Weaver

...I'll see people mention things like CBN wheels putting a great finished edge on a turning tool.

Without trying to wake warren up, I don't use a pole lathe, but do hone all turning tools. If someone never works with a honed skew, they're missing out.

And I'm no good at turning, but can still appreciate it. I haven't had any significant damage to the honed edges of skews, but they're double bevel and I round the tip a little bit with the stones to make sure the fine stone finish gets to the edge. .....so I guess they're two horned unicorns.