Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Unicorn summary requested

Posts

Unicorn summary requested

#1

Unicorn summary requested

Steve Voigt

Folks, I have spent the last week packing and moving my home and shop, and before that buying a house on extremely short notice. As a result, I've had no time to check in here for a couple weeks, and am now confronted with several hundred posts on unicorn profiles, and it is all a bit much to make sense of.

Can some kind soul(s) provide me with a nickel summary?

Questions: I gather that you push the chisel into a rouge-charged felt or cotton wheel for…how long?

Are y'all going straight from the grinder to the buffing wheel, or honing the chisel as usual on stones?

How does one control the angle of the final buffing?

Has anyone tried/been able to duplicate the same results on a strop or stone? In other words, is it the geometry that matters, or is it primarily the medium of the buffing wheel that matters?

I admit that my eyes glaze over and my brain stops working when I see micro-photographic images, but my interest is piqued by claims of superior performance on substandard chisels. Derek's paring pics in the last thread were quite persuasive.

Thanks all in advance for your indulgence.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#3

Re: partial answer by email

Steve Voigt

Thanks Bill!

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#4

Re: partial answer by email

LuckyLuke

Can I get one too?

too many posts on the subject, getting confusing... This needs to be turned into an article at a minimum...

Can I use a hard felt wheel for this purpose?

Thanks!

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#5

My take

Winston

Here's my take on all this. I know others have a their own perspectives.

David found that buffing a chisel can greatly increase its edge durability compared to normal honing on stones. This result has been duplicated by me, Bill, Wiley, and Derek. In my testing, when chopping through maple, we're talking about preserving a shaving level of sharpness at least 10x longer than a normal flat-honed chisel.

Many of us believe that the bevel angle very near the edge (like within .002") is the key to the durability. For one chisel, I honed it to 30 degrees on stones, then buffed it, and in a microscope photo of the profile, I saw that the angle very near the edge was as high as 50 degrees, but that was only within .001" of the edge. David took a similar photo of his buffed chisels, in which the angle was slightly shallower than mine, and the microbevel was somewhat longer.

The durability also seems to not come at the cost of cutting ability. The chisels I've buffed are sharper than any other method that I've used. (Normally I finish my chisels at 30 degrees on a Shapton Pro 12000, using a honing guide.)

My theory on this is that ease of cut initiation depends on the size of the apex, much more than the angle at the apex, and that buffing results in a very small, uniform apex. I also think that the majority of of the resistance from cutting comes from wedging from the contact area further away from the edge, simply because there's so little total contact area within .002" of the edge. What buffing does is create a profile that's strong only where it needs to be -- right at the edge -- and everywhere else it allows a shallow angle that provides for low cutting resistance.

I made a video about how I do it here: https://vimeo.com/440866741 . However, that it turns out that I didn't buff that chisel enough, which I found when I went to use the chisel. Returning it to the buffing wheel for a few more seconds fixed that. (I have a bit more info about this in the video's description.)

Others have been using bench buffers and other types of compound. We're still trying to figure out the best kind of wheel and compounds to use -- not necessarily for maximum performance, but primarily for ease and reliability of sharpening.

Regarding stropping: It seems likely that it's the high angle near the edge that really matters for durability, and that buffing is not the only way to achieve this. Bill has stropped a chisel at a higher angle, with good success in a dovetailing project. I just tried stropping at a high angle, and some quick informal testing suggests that it also results in a very durable edge. In my case, I stropped it on green compound at about 40 degrees, until I saw a micro bevel that was around .003".

At any rate, there are still many things that we're trying to figure out about the unicorn profile, hence all the posts about it. As we learn more, we'll be able to distill that knowledge into something that's easier for people to digest.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#6

an article is coming..

David Weaver

..no hard felt.

The koch system (which this caused me to re-look at) uses hard felt for grinding and soft felt for honing, but it uses the felt at low speed.

I have used a hard felt wheel off and on, but for something this fine and at the speed of a bench top buffer, it can damage an edge. Or I should say more specifically, I've damaged edges with it.

A review of the koch wheels found that those, too, would damage edges at high speed (and those are small wheels).

Felt has a lot of persuasion when loaded with abrasive and can draw a wire edge, too.

From the forthcoming article:

The method is simply this (for chisels and gouges other than mortise chisels):

• A primary grind of 20 degrees

• A freehand honed secondary bevel only slightly steeper; low 20s to a maximum of 25 degrees

• Buff the honed edge with a buffer for about five seconds on a stitched cotton wheel that has been charged with a relatively fine (super fine isn’t needed) aluminum oxide-based buffing compound. Buffing is done approximately at 45 degrees. The buff doesn’t cut like a stone, so you don’t end up with a 45 degree microbevel.

The buffing wheel should be a stitched cotton or yellow cotton with shellac with somewhere around 1/2 inch of free loose cotton after the last stitch.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#7

slight correction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I did not simply strop. 1 micron diamond followed by strop. But critically, I think, I had in mind the profile I thought was necessary. As I pulled the chisel across the diamond plate I increased the angle (5-10 degrees) in a rolling motion to create what I hoped would be a convex bevel, like an airplane wing . About 5 strokes on each as I recall. The more aggressive cutting action of the sharpening step was probably critical. The strop may or may not have done anything important.

I was needing to make drawers and this exercise was more geared to getting a chisel prepared to make drawers than acquiring fundamental information on the process. It worked for making 5 drawers but didn't glean much information to guide others.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#8

Alternate suggestion for beginning

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For a first try at this technique don't change anything about whatever sharpening you currently use. Add the buff as a last step. Advanced implementation could involve changing making the chisel grind more acute or eliminating some of the preliminary sharpening steps.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#9

Ride, don't walk

Bruce Mack

I know the probity of you guys and have learned from you. I've acquired the Ryobi kit used by Winston and look forward to transforming my handsome but metallurgically challenged blue-handled Marples set.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#10

Re: Thanks all

Steve Voigt

Thanks very much for the info, everyone. The discussion you all are having reminds of the double iron discussion, circa Spring 2012. I tend to be reflexively skeptical of the claims of the last couple weeks, but I was skeptical in 2012 (as were others) and it didn't take long to realize that the claims were true.

It'll be a while before I get back in the shop, but I'll experiment and report back if it's still relevant.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#11

it will be

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

but I'll experiment and report back if it's still relevant.

It is not easy to try something new when you have been doing something successfully already. The benefit of better is remote from the reality of I need to get XXX built. It is all to easy to rationalize that it won't help me. However, when one sees leaders like yourself adapting, or rejecting, it provides confidence to make a decision.

The second reason to report is the likelihood you will do something more of less different. These differences explore the range over which something works and identifies optimum conditions.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#12

Phrase of the Month

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"metallurgically challenged "

Love it. I need a box with this label to store some chisels.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#13

hey now...

David Weaver

....I only do the most convincing of old wives' tale creating!!

My slight of hand technique changes may not bring any gain, but they really get people to believe that there's one!!

(in this case, the method does significantly decrease sharpening frequency, and it's fast - 30 seconds for a refresh. The biggest gain from it, though, is in making really cheap chisels capable of heavy work or paring without damage, and in harder chisels, eliminating some of the seemingly random small chipping).

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#14

marples chisels...

David Weaver

Marples chisels are notoriously off...

some of them are soft, some of them are 4 decent chisels with one soft..

and rob streeper found that some of the newer chinese marples chisels are reasonably hard, but when faced with hardwood, they appear to be not-so-great metal that's just made hard.

The biggest gains with this method are made with marginal chisels. I haven't yet found a hardened chisel that won't hold up well chopping hard maple, including an older harbor freight chisel that I have that's probably similar to the golly-ghee aldi chisels that paul sellers touts. Those chisels are soft and are no match for something like an ashley iles chisel, but when both are "unicorned" suddenly, the performance gap is not very large.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#15

Pros and Cons

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I am enthusiastic about the method for chisels. Not only adding a durable edge to cheesy blades, but also for refreshing and enhancing decent chisels in use. Further, I refreshed and enhanced lathe chisels today - what a great, quick way to keep chisels, flat and turning, in play.

I am less enthusiastic about hand planes. I experimented with a BU smoother and the results were logical: buffing increases the bevel angle. This is not a bad thing - within reason - for BU planes. A block plane still cuts end grain. However, a BU smoother, with a high cutting angle (e.g. 50 degree secondary bevel = 62 degree cutting angle), then buffed, creates a roughly 70 degree secondary bevel (= 82 degree cutting angle), and the plane turns into a scraper. [I have photos to demonstrate this]

With a BD plane, the shavings became stringy and lose integrity. Planing becomes unpredictable. I would far rather take the blade to the stones and re-hone than buff.

What became clear to me is that there is a need to develop a method where the angle created is controlled. Perhaps it is not the act of buffing, but the creation of a steeper micro-micro bevel reinforcing the edge. It is also just another tertiary bevel, and it is this which adds sharpness at the same time. If this is so, then can one simply use a very fine stone/grit to do the job?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#16

I have described doing this twice here

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As far as we know the shape of the tip is what is important. I think the deformed shape of the right stiffness buffing wheel creates a useful convex profile. Of course this profile can be created on a flat surface by rocking the blade. Been there, done that and reported earlier, and summarized later.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#17

Planes...

David Weaver

This method actually works well for planes, but it takes a different nuance.

This is the modification you'll need to make - switch out the very saturated (thus harder) buffing wheels that you have and find one that's got some loose cotton after the last stitch. This is important. A buff won't generally raise a wire edge, but felt will. I suspect your wheels are behaving (due to the loading and solid look) more like a felt wheel and less like a cotton buff.

Any wheel (including felt) that raises a wire edge will damage the ultimate edge slightly. Paper, cardstock, leather, felt - all will do this at high speed. The wheel needs to have give. Here's what you do for plane irons:

* same primary (20 degrees)

* secondary as shallow as you can freehand hone on a fast medium stone

* hone the flat face on a fine or medium fine stone to remove any prior wear and weaken the wire edge a little bit (don't remove it)

* buff the edge on a softer wheel more similar to the one shown in my videos, less firmly, but completely, and at a slightly shallower angle, and chase anything remaining with the soft corner of the wheel (you'll need a new wheel for this - try to avoid loading the wheel as yours are shown, the stitched wheels like that are intended to be used with their weave still open).

This is the result. These are end grain shavings - notice the waxy look.


Examine the surface left behind on some cherry offcuts (end grain).


This is a picture of a cherry shaving that I made previously when bill and winston mentioned that perhaps people would have just as much to gain from sharpening planes if I would be willing to experiment. It turned out to be less difficult than I thought it would be, but there's less wiggle room. These long grain shavings are thinner and more uniform than any that I've ever gotten with any stone.


Stringiness in thin shavings occurs due to some tooth at the edge. I suspect your wheels are just too aggressive for planes.

I will write a separate article at some point about doing this with plane irons. It's about an even-time trade for freehand honing (somewhere around a minute total) plane irons, but it's definitely sharper than a stoned plane iron.

This is with a 5 micron calcined buffing compound applied to a wheel without any caking - the caking at speed may batter an edge.

I don't know how far and wide you'll post this (if it'll be here and the UK forum), but I'd hesitate for now telling a very wide group of people who may take the advice on plane irons as a permanent thought. As in, they'll conclude what you mention and never try it on planes where they may gain quite a bit of improvement.

Winston and bill were right and their viewpoint is valid - that not everyone is good at freehand sharpening and this can be done in a minute by anyone whereas freehand honing may not be doable. While it's slightly more difficult to get the touch than it is with chisels, it's still easier than doing the edge completely on stones, and it may prove to be valuable for beginners.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#18

Re: marples and more

Steve Voigt

The biggest gains with this method are made with marginal chisels.

This is an interesting question to me, as much for historical reasons as practical ones. I've got no interest in big box store chisels, but I've got a number of old chisels with lovely ergonomics (and aesthetics) but middling steel.

An enduring mystery (to me) is why so many vintage chisels are just not that hard. It's true of the round shank Marples, the early 20th C Buck Bros, and many others. A really hard (60+RC) chisel from before WWII is the exception, not the norm. I've spent years seeking out and hording the good ones.

Maybe with this method, you've figured out why makers just weren't that concerned with super hardness. But that in turn suggests that something like this unicorn thing was widely practiced--not with a buffing wheel, but in some other form.

No proof of that, of course. I haven't seen any historical sources that support it. But I seriously doubt that it wasn't discovered before 2020, and I have long thought that many hand tool techniques that were standard in the past have been lost. Maybe this is one of them. Pure speculation at this point, but worth looking into.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#19

Re: marples and more

Warren in Lancaster, PA

An enduring mystery (to me) is why so many vintage chisels are just not that hard

I think we can stand a pretty good range of hardness.

I am getting very fine results with English chisels from the first half of the 19th century. They sharpen very easily.

A few years ago I made end grain cuts half an inch deep in jarrah using one of these chisels. I made 200 cuts (so 100 inches of endgrain) without damage to the edge. The chisel still shaved hair; I stopped only because it is so boring.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#20

English chisels.

David Weaver

I suspect the English chisels (as I've had about a hundred of them) are generally harder than most of what we think of as "good american chisels".

They are closer to the sweet spot (Which is around 60 or only slightly above) than american types like swan, witherby, stanley, or the early bucks (I can't remember - but I think the buck brothers may have made chisels on both sides of the ocean). The softness of some of those chisels has led to the old wives tale that the steel quality is low. The hardness within brands is very consistent. Wards are generally low 60s based on their behavior (despite the fact that ward could make some overhard plane irons from time to time), I have a full tyzack set that's close to that, several older marples (before the use of chrome vanadium varieties) and.......from going to the shop to look at the rest...

IH sorby

I sorby

A couple of different Robt. Sorby chisels

Older Marples

Ibbotson

Nurse-Invicta works

Stormont

I haven't used the stormonts, so I can't say anything about them, but the rest are just at the level where an oilstone will cut them and not at the soft level that a lot of american chisels were. I do have a bunch of older butcher chisels and some of those are soft - I suspect they're a lot earlier, but I'm not a fanatic of tool history, so I don't know.

All of the above chisels are the older "dry steel" feel on the stones and strop. They release their wire edge much more easily and probably took more skill to harden and temper and finish.

All that said, this method will make stanley, witherby, swan, and softer buck brothers behave far better, both in paring and malleting.

The better english chisels gain a little, but less than the subpar chisels.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#21

More on the planes...

David Weaver

..this is something to shoot for. Not because it's "big dave, the expert is showing you stuff so he can be expert", but more because there's something left in the tank here that I think you'll enjoy with planes.

I've been a bit surprised that the very shallow secondary bevel and the roundover seems to actually be a bit protective of damage at the very edge, whereas I thought it would be weak.

I have no idea what this wood is, but it's something that a neighbor cut down at the beginning of the summer. It looks like cherry, but splits terribly and it didn't have cherry bark. It's something we didn't cut for firewood as a kid.

I split and resawed this to make a cheap single use plane out of and the top was rough. I used the same iron that planed the endgrain (not resharpened). Through the interrupted surface and then to this point, no resharpening (no big deal, a single iron should do this several times).

But of interest is the surface brightness (I wish I could get the camera to show just how much of a mirror finish this is. IT feels sublime and the edge exhibits no behavior of lacking clerance).




The last picture is of a shaving. It is just the neatest smoothest matrix.

This is still the inexpensive 5 micron calcined alumina stick. I've never had an edge that betters this by hand, and must admit that it's now easier for me to get it with the buffer. This is my method now at the very least for finish smoothing.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#22

Re: an article is coming.. One issue that I see...

John Aniano in central NJ

David, et. al.,

Since this is a handtool forum, there needs to be a non-motorized way to drive the buffing wheel. I don't have a motorized grinder in my primary workshop space. So, other than a geared hand driven grinding wheel setup, I'm coming up with few ideas. Suggestions?

And going along with this, is there an optimum RPM buffing speed? 1750 or 3500 rpm? Might lower speeds be used? I have a Tormek, but at 90 rpm, it's pretty slow as compared to a higher speed unit.

John

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#23

I have explained how I did it w/o electrons

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

So, other than a geared hand driven grinding wheel setup, I'm coming up with few ideas. Suggestions?

You want a small convex profile. Picture the profile and then imagine how to get it on a flat "stone"

Once again

1 micron diamond on cast iron. About 5 pull strokes rocking the blade up as it was pulled, maybe 5-10 degrees. Followed by green stuff on strop, again About 5 pull strokes rocking the blade up as it pulled, maybe 5-10 degrees. Proceeded to dovetail 5 ash drawers with no readily observable damage to a Narex chisel.

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#24

A case for buying a buffer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

They are cheap. They don't take up much room, or make a mess. Mine weighs little so it is easy to shove out of the way or move. They are multitaskers. Since my new buffer has taken up residence on the bench it has done chisels, several kinds of knives, and I am about to try it for polishing the sides of a scraper. Had I know how handy it is to put tomato slicing sharpness on a knife I would have bough it years ago just for this task.

Winston uses a drill. Is there anyone on the planet that does not own a cordless drill?

Re: Unicorn summary requested

#25

Low speed vs. high

David Weaver

There are so many variables that can be changed -the hardness of the buff, the pressure into it, the strength of the buffing abrasive.

I think if someone is interested in doing this with a moving wheel but without power, a treadle is in order and something like felt (which can damage an edge at high speed) is perhaps in order because of its stronger cutting power (it's stiffer).

Felt's big issues at high speed are its influence battering or tearing at an edge, and the friction associated with that. But at lower speeds, neither of those will be a problem and I'd bet it would work well.

There's another issue with high speed man powered. My buffer is 4 amps - I'd bet half of that is used buffing an edge - to deform the buff at high speed takes a lot of power. It's too much power and speed for felt, but less power and less speed may work well whereas less power and speed to the extreme for a cotton buff may make the buff nothing more than a lightweight clean stropping mechanism.