Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Small Router Plane

Posts

Small Router Plane

#1

Small Router Plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I've been wanting to build this router plane from St James Bay for many years. I purchased the brass rough casting about 18 months ago, and finally got to it this past weekend ...


With the aid of a file and Dremel, and Jarrah (what else!) handles turned on a lathe, this is the result ...



The blade is 1/4". The one used here is from Lee Valley.

Alongside the Veritas Large Router Plane ....


This one is going to be used.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Small Router Plane

#2

Re: Small Router Plane

Howard Pollack

Very handsome Derek. -Howard

Re: Small Router Plane

#3

thoughts vs. stanley 271?

David Weaver

What are your thoughts about its proportions and the feel in use vs. a stanley 271?

I like the SJB kits, though there's always a bit of skill in making a good tool out of them and sometimes there are some odd issues (there's no real lateral room in some of the infill kits and the mouth is out all the way in line with the pin line on the sides. This is unusual, but the iron can be tapered in its with a little bit and used.

Re: Small Router Plane

#4

Re: thoughts vs. stanley 271?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

What are your thoughts about its proportions and the feel in use vs. a stanley 271?

David, as you know, these SJB kits are really rough. One has to be dead keen to machine them, especially without machine tools :)

I do not have a Stanley #271. I had one years ago and replaced it with the Veritas Small Router. They are dinky things. I find it a little small, preferring something with more registration area.

I have the Large Veritas, which is the best router plane on the market in my opinion, and it gets quite a bit of use. I could have just purchased their Medium version for smaller work, but I just fancied the looks of the SJB. I plan to make a few extra blades in different (smaller) sizes.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Small Router Plane

#5

Re: Small Router Plane

roger lance

Derek....

I've added a couple of planes to my large router plane.....the medium router.....and the hinge mortise plane (which I've had occasion to use as a router plane).

The medium router is a nice, serviceable size.....very functional.....and all three planes use the same blades.


Re: Small Router Plane

#6

Re: Small Router Plane

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Nice! I’ve not made one of those but I did make an infill smoother from a SJB kit. If you’re ever in the area you should stop and talk with Bob. Be prepared to spend some time. I stopped in to get some advice, 30 minutes I told my wife. We left two hours later. He’s a great guy.

Re: Small Router Plane

#7

Re: Small Router Plane

John Jardin

Very nice addition to your tool arsenal...thanks for showing it.

Re: Small Router Plane

#8

Thanks, derek..

David Weaver

..except for very small work or softer wood, the 271 can become a bit painful for me to use.

I'd imagine not many of them are used regularly, but I"ve got use for a small router to work material out of guitar fingerboards for block and trapezoidal inlay (finally have a use for a tool that looked so useful!!).

I've got the original stanley and veritas big routers and am too accomodated to using the stanley so far to make the veritas work better for me. As dumb as it sounds, it's made to "too close" of tolerances and sometimes when you're doing mostly bulk removal, a clattery coarse adjusting tool is a little easier.

But there's the hours bias there, too (i'm used to the stanley - how it feels, what it does, how not to ruin the sides of dadoes with it, etc).

Re: Small Router Plane

#9

Re: ANDY Router Plane 

William Duffield

That brings back memories. I built mine maybe 18 to 20 years ago. I made a blade from a cement nail, and later replaced it with one from Lee Valley. My first handles were borrowed from my L-N #98 and #99. I turned the handles in the pics from cocobolo. The lost wax casting was done well enough that the holes for the handle screws don't need to be tapped. The bottom needed a whole lot of flattening. I drilled out and countersunk the holes for mounting a larger bottom plate. Where did you get your blade clamp? It doesn't look like the cast one that came with mine.





Re: Small Router Plane

#10

Re: ANDY Router Plane

John Aniano in central NJ

William,

Those are beautiful turned handles! Very delicate yet stylish. A wonderful tool - you should be proud...

John

Re: Small Router Plane

#11

Re: ANDY Router Plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

William, you know I remember your version. I went searching for it on the Internet and could not find it. I thought that it might have been Brian Buckner.

Your casting is different from mine. It is not only the blade clamp, but you have a V-groove for the bed of the blade (mine is round, the shape of the round shaft). I did not have to flatten the sole of this plane, and the bed for the shaft is perfectly vertical. No work needed there.

It dawned on me when posting the pictures, seeing the router alongside the Veritas, that I need to remake the handles and capture the screws inside (so they do not show at the top). I really like the shape of your handles, but the size on mine feels right to me. So I will redo these (turning small parts, especially in this highly interlocked Jarrah, is a challenge).

The round bed for the shaft is an issue for me. I want this router to be a user, and adjustment is done by a hammer tap. The round shaft is vulnerable to twisting, unlike the angled shaft on yours. That was a fix I came up with for the Small Veritas router plane many years ago, and I need to find a solution here. Any ideas?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Small Router Plane

#12

Re: ANDY Router Plane

William Duffield

There was discussion and I posted pictures on Badger Pond. That's probably why you can't find it. My old notes from Y2K indicate that Brian Buckner was involved in the discussions and had also built one.

The blade mounting post on mine was not perpendicular to the base (my notes say it was off by about 8°), so I straightened it to some extent and also gave it a better grip on the blades with a square cross section Swiss pattern file. The thumb screw on the blade holding ring was not the one supplied with the kit. I found it in my assortment of spare hardware. sites.

Curiously, I can't find the #98 and #99 Side Rabbet Planes on Lie-Nielsen's website.

Re: Small Router Plane

#13

Re: ANDY Router Plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

William, thanks for that. I wish my CD of Badger Pond worked. It refuses to play on the computers I have (now Mac, but it stopped on my last Windows laptop 10 years ago). I wonder if there is a way of getting a copy or making mine work?

Anyway, I was not so far off in guessing Brian was involved. What has happened to him? Any info?

And what does ANDY mean? I have forgotten this piece of crucial information!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Small Router Plane

#14

Re: ANDY Router Plane

William Duffield

I don't know what happened to Brian. All I have is a few saved pics of his work.

As I have always used Macs (except under duress or in exchange for a salary), I was never able to get the Badger Pond archives to work.

I think the originals of the ANDY routers came to SJBTC in a patternmaker's tool chest. The patternmaker's name was Andy, and he inscribed the initials "A.J.P'K." somewhere. [There is likely to be a typo in that.] My notes also say it is a 1/3 scale model of a Stanley #71-1/2.

Re: Small Router Plane

#15

Re: ANDY Router Plane

William Duffield

OH DEAR! I didn't clock the screws. >(

Re: Small Router Plane

#16

Re: Small Router Plane

ken ca

Sweet! Great job. That looks very handy - not too keen on the "Andy" but a small point. I have one of the Record mini router planes, I wonder how they compare size wise?

Re: Small Router Plane

#17

Re: Small Router Plane

William Duffield

It's a kit. All tools are kits. :D If you don't like the brand name, grind it off.

Rhetorical question: would you grind the raised lettering off of a Lie-Nielsen casting? ;)

Andy is not much bigger than a Stanley #271. It is 3-3/4” wide, 1-3/4" deep, and 1” high (without the knobs, which only you have any control over). The screw holes for mounting an extension base are 1-5/8” on center. The mouth opening is about 7/8” wide by about 1” deep.

Re: Small Router Plane

#18

New Handles

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

After William commented that he initially used the knobs from the Lie Nielsen side rebate planes on his version of the router plane, I had a look at mine, and decided to replicate these.

So .. new knobs ..



Here is the model ...


Compared with the Large Veritas router plane ...


Compared with the Small Veritas router plane ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Small Router Plane

#19

Re: New Handles

David Weaver

lovely improvement in aesthetics, too - the lines and proportions are really nice on those. Looks great.

Re: Small Router Plane

#20

Re: New Handles - MUCH NICER!  Beautiful!


Re: Small Router Plane

#21

Re: New Handles

William Duffield

Very nice. I'm pleased to have been an inspiration. I'm especially impressed that your screws do not show on the tops of the knobs.

Curiously, I checked Lie-Nielsens website yesterday, and I could not find the #98 and #99 offered. You can still buy the irons for the side rabbet planes.

Re: Small Router Plane

#22

Re: New Handles

John Jardin

I hope LN is still offering the 98 and 99 side rabbit planes because those tools are the absolute go to planes for trueing up dado grooves and more.

Re: Small Router Plane

#23

Re: New Handles

John Jardin

Very nice as usual Derek

Re: Small Router Plane

#24

Re: New Handles

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

William, I am surprised to hear that the side rabbets are no longer on the LN site. They are excellent, and I use my set frequently, along with the Veritas version.

Ironically, I have never thought of the knobs on the LN as more than decoration as they are not ergonomic in the least. At least, not for the side rabbet. Great for ghe small router plane! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek