Re: Thanks, Richard...
Sgian Dubh
"Ideals are best chased in hobbies, which is what a lot of us (not you) are doing, but even my ideal isn't that rigid."
I largely agree. Referring to your own activities, from what I've seen you expend a great deal of energy into researching subjects that I simply let pass by. The work you've done looking at the hardness of steel and sharpening techniques and resultant performance of plane irons and chisels exceeds anything I could ever get motivated to bother my head about. I just use the tools after I've sharpened them, and never worried about any of those topics. Essentially that's because I've primarily just had to get work out of the door and move on to the next job using the tools and equipment available. There's room there for someone like yourself with no real need to produce stuff for a deadline to let your critical faculties ponder such subjects, investigate and experiment, and even make public your results.
I rather enjoy reading about such things as in, for example, recent threads here and elsewhere that you've either instigated or in which you've participated. It doesn't take too much time for me to monitor the thread and I can absorb and use as little or as much information as I want from the to-ing and fro-ing that goes on. Amateurs can frequently make valuable contributions to knowledge, something I think that has significant historical precedent.
In a sense, I suppose my book on timber technology was the result of something close to being a hobby, but one that was strongly linked to my main lines of work in furniture design and making along with teaching those subjects to learners. Of course, my primary hobby has always been rugby, in which I was a rubbish player in my playing days, and an avid watcher of now, but it was a great way to let my hair down and get away from all the furniture making stuff I did all week, ha, ha. Slainte.