Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Wooden Plane question

Posts

Wooden Plane question

#1

Wooden Plane question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have some planes from a relative that was a carpenter? in the late 1800's. They are all long and longer planes. The ones you all show are long and longer.

Now days many find a block plane, as well as 3's and 4's essential to their woodworking. Was something equivalent to a block plane, and short planes, made/used back then? Are they made now, by you all? If not, why not? Anything else of interest on the topic.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#2

Re: Wooden Plane question

David Weaver

you can buy a small smoother (coffin planes in the 1 3/8" and up size) if choosing to use an older small smoother to do that kind of work.

The typical double iron coffin smoothers that I've found are generally 2 to 2 1/4" planes. I've seen smaller planes (and I've seen some marples coffin smoothers up to 2 1/2" wide).

Not being a furniture builder, I'm not sure what folks would do. I generally do everything you'd consider block plane work with a stanley 4 and rarely use a block plane.

Jim Matthews sent me a small single iron smoother (I can't remember the maker name, it was more recent, perhaps english) to reharden the iron on last year that would probably make a handy one-hand plane for someone less sure about a stanley for certain things.

Little bits that need chamfers, I generally file or chisel instead of planing.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#3

clarifying the question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Now days a block plane is considered essential for even a modestly equipped shop.

Was there no equivalent in the old days of wood planes. If not, and it sounds like not, any speculation why? Would they be hard or impossible to make?

To word another way, if not then, why did Stanley invent them? Did they develop a market or fill a need. Personally I rarely use one but I am the exception.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#4

Re: clarifying the question

Wiley Horne

Is it possible we’re talking about the difference between a carpenter or joiner, versus a furniture/cabinetmaker? Bill, did you inherit his whole toolbox?

Wiley

Re: Wooden Plane question

#5

Re: clarifying the question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

inherit his whole toolbox?........no

Re: Wooden Plane question

#6

Re: clarifying the question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I stopped using a block plane decades ago. I think the block plane was originally designed for carpenters, something they could carry on a belt or apron. I do use a #3 plane.

Before iron planes were common, smoothing planes were made of beech about 7 inches long with no tote. They were widest at the mouth and tapered front and back (coffin shaped) so you could get good handholds cradling the plane with both hands. They were extremely light. As mentioned in period literature, these planes were used chiefly for cleaning off finished work. I would say in a hand tool shop the trying plane and the jack plane are used more heavily.

In the 18th century smoothing planes were not nearly as tapered and rounded at the back as later 19th century planes, so many of us think them a bit uncomfortable. Steve Voigt makes a 19th century style plane which is pretty comfortable and well rounded. Old Street Tool claims they make "early 18th century" style planes, but except for having just a single iron, their smoothing planes are 19th century in style and similar to Steve's.

Voigt plane


Old Street


Re: Wooden Plane question

#7

Phil Lowe dismissed block planes in a seminar

Jim Matthews

His take on them was that they were suitable for trimming crown moldings and sharpening pencils. While it was just a workshop, I never saw him handle anything smaller than a #4 - all ancient cast iron.

Lately I've grown fond of a tiny (palm sized) Japanese plane that squares small stock beautifully. I suspect block planes make sense for Violin bow makers, traditional fishing g rod builders and Shoji Shokunin.

The size allows the user to wrap their fingers around the plane and "index" the workpiece by touch. That doesn't seem like the sort of thing to do shaping rough stock.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#8

Re: Wooden Plane question

TomD

The main characteristic I use my block planes for is the low angle. Though many of them are just regular 45s, but I don't use those.

In the past there were plenty of very small planes around, at the tiny end there are planes for violin plate tuning, though unlike some folks figuring stuff out for themselves in the 70s, I doubt they used those for the whole plate back in the day, they probably started with an hollowing adze. The Japanese have whole set of planes about the size of 2 cubes of sugar +.

You can make a low angle block plane in all wood, it was actually one of the first successful planes I made, it was bedded at about 35 degrees with the bevel down. I still use it today. I was japanese style. That works out to the same as a block plane with a 12 degree bed, or even lower.

There were infill planes that were low angle, both large and small. It is a little difficult to make them in all wood if you want a 12 degree bed, as it is not very sturdy, but bevel down you can cut to probably 30 degrees. I doubt Stanley invented them other than a form.

I always try to have the workpiece held and a plane large enough to get a good two handed purchase on. I don't really see the point to block planes most of the time. Back in the 60s, everyone had a usually dull one in the box, I never knew a relative who could sharpen, or had good tools for it, though I assume my GF having been properly trained in an apprenticeship in the UK had it all squared away. But it seemed as though block planes were just something woodworkers thought they should have. Not too expensive. Even a bit dull they could be used to knock a corned off. They were used one handed, which was a plus for people who hadn't a bench with well worked out holding, as they needed a free hand for the work.

Often the first plane purchased, but they would also be the first I might give away if I had to loose something. I have an ECE with a Hock blade; That small LE, mine badly machined; another rebate LN; A really nice infil though they went out of business, they did not charge much; Several I have made; A kit I have not finished for an infill; A terribly badly made Record; And LV that I did not like but have come to value. And a few more. Amazing, I had no idea. The stuff one picks up over 40+ years.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#9

conclusion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This question about block planes is merely a curiosity with no personal application of the information in mind. I have a regular sized one, Stanley something or another, and a low angle bought, I suppose, because everyone else had one. I can't recall the last time I used either. I think I "shot" the miter on a tiny molding with the low angle.

Yet in the club what I hear is statements like "this is the plane I use the most". I never thought to ask, doing what?

So, the answer to my question seems to be that the wood block plane equivalent in 1840 was something not recognized as useful so it never got made. I don't know why questions like this one stick in my head and bother me till I get an answer.

If I could learn to quickly adjust it I would find use for the coffin plane you describe. A short sole does have application and wood on wood is recognized as a nice feel even by me.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#10

guessing on uses...

David Weaver

..a friend of mine is a mechanical engineer. He got me into woodworking and has half a dozen planes that he likes to use....

....but not much on projects.

The only plane I've seen him use often is a LN 60 1/2 block plane which is pretty much his do-all flush trim and edge breaking plane.

I get the sense that a lot of people who don't necessarily use planes that much (this is a risky thing to say, because everyone who uses planes thinks that they use planes a lot) like the simplicity of a block plane for doing those things.

I don't know how warren uses his smoother, but I have no issue one handing a 4 to do all of these things instead and probably would have when I started.

There were early casted planes (chariot type) that caught on in some number in England, and then they persisted parallel with the stanley type block planes, but the number wasn't anything close to block planes.

I think they're just not necessary and while they seem simple when you start, they seem limited after that. And when you already have a smoother that will do what you're going to do, why get something else out?

Re: Wooden Plane question

#11

Re: guessing on uses...

Sgian Dubh

This thread has got me thinking about the uses to which I put my two block planes, and the truth is that although I value them and wouldn't want to be without them, I can't really say they are vital. In other words, I could probably live without my Record 09-1/2, and the Lie-Nielsen 60-1/2.

The use of both is limited I suppose, although I must have used the Record one quite a bit at one time over the forty or more years I've owned it because I know I'm on its third replacement blade. I've never replaced the blade in the Lie-Nielsen version, but it's only about fifteen years old, and been lightly used.

Years (decades) ago the Record block plane was used a great deal for trimming high pressure plastic laminates applied to flat panels, and that stuff wears irons quickly. Routers later took over that task for the most part, so that sped up the job and saved the block plane irons. I suppose trimming p-lam doesn't really fall into the realm of fine furniture, but probably one of the bigger uses I have for both of my block planes now consists of trimming lipping applied to veneered panels, stuff that is usually anywhere between about 3 and 5 mm thick. Sometimes the lipping goes on first followed by veneering the show faces, and sometimes it's the other way around, with lipping going on last.

Apart from that, use of block planes tends to be for knocking off arrises, bits and bobs of light trimming, supplementing the use of smoothing planes here and there in surface polish preparation and, perhaps counter-intuitively, the Record block plane is handy for knocking off rough sawn surfaces at the timber yard to help reveal grain and colour during wood buying trips.

As to the original question about wooden block planes, I can't recall ever coming across anything that could be counted as a wooden block plane equivalent; that's not a surprise really because metal planes or infill planes have been the mainstay for hand plane use in my furniture making career, although I do have one rather neglected wooden jack plane that's very efficient at removing a lot of wood, something that has come in handy occasionally, ha ha. Slainte.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#12

chariot?

David Weaver

Richard - did you do much using of chariot planes? they're stylish over here for collectors (i would guess due to their size making them unique next to a bunch of more common planes).

I've noticed some chariot-ish planes of more modern make (like preston) are quite valuable.

Years ago, I bought a spiers panel plane kit (not from the original company - shepherd - they had gone out of business). The owner of the kit never put the plane together and convinced me to buy the shepherd chariot plane with it. Which was a mistake as I have no machine tools and the mouth isn't actually opened on the kit. I need to poo or get off of the pot and just toss it on ebay for someone with the metalworking skills to finish the mouth.

I suspect the lack of smaller older planes is all of the above, and the explosion in number of block planes has a lot to do with being able to make one that can be closed down (The adjustable types) and made easy to use for a new apprentice on a construction site.

The point about carrying one around to look at wood sans saw or rough planing marks is a good one.

I talked to a union carpenter here about hand tools once at a wedding - he and I both did not thrive when the entire wedding became an 8 hour dance party with 90% floor participation, so we were left talking about tools. He said they are still required to buy a plane and chisels, but he couldn't remember the last time he's sharpened his chisels. perhaps a decade, and his work on site was dwindling as he moved up through the ranks.

I think their work is commercial, and a whole lot of the bits that doors are installed in are metal. REsidential customers can't afford the union hourly rates and it's sort of a political thing here about larger public jobs requiring certain rules to accommodate. Things like football stadiums and office towers, I suppose, won't have a whole lot of miters to trim. short carpet, metal, drywall and paint (and a lot of glass) is what we see. Even the furniture is generally veneered to get a uniform look , and probably to stay flat and avoid movement issues.

It lends much to what you say the work looks like these days - that is the high paying work and there's not a whole lot of "plain old wood" in any of it.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#13

Re: Essential?

Steve Voigt

Now days a block plane is considered essential for even a modestly equipped shop.

Bill, it's funny that you said this, but basically no one on this thread (including you and me) seems to find it essential! :D

Most of the important points have already been covered. I basically agree with Warren and others that it is a good job site tool, and also good if you want to work one handed, but not essential. I haven't pulled mine off the shelf in several years.

I do use coffin smoothers though, all the time. I much prefer the plane Warren kindly showed, which is 7-1/2" long, to a no.4-sized plane, but I tend to work on a smaller scale than people doing a lot of tables or case pieces, so that's a factor.

I also like using a smaller smoother, about 5-1/4" long. Similar, I guess, to a block plane's dimensions. It's not really a traditional plane--the short blade would not have been tolerated--but I like it a lot anyway. The one below is made from Virginia-grown boxwood that Glen Mackey pulled out of the town dump somewhere near Richmond.


Re: Wooden Plane question

#14

Re: Essential?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This has been an interesting discussion. If you posed the question "what is the first plane you should buy" to our WW club I'll wager the answer would be a block plane. It certainly is the most discussed plane and often someone in the club is looking to buy one. A professional Period Furniture maker with a good pedigree gave a program before we shut down and he extolled the virtues of his block plane that he had sharpened to a steeper angle to mitigate tear-out.

I was of the impression that I was the only person in the club that did not find this plane essential. If we ever meet again I must ask what they are being used for.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#15

Re: chariot?

Sgian Dubh

David, I must admit I'm pretty sure I've never used a chariot plane, and to be honest, I don't think I've ever seen one close up. Apart from standard bench planes, i.e., block plane to try plane, plus routers, shoulder planes and the like, I've also never really used moulding planes in anger. I'm a bit limited I suppose on many of those planes that fall into the category of old style specialist planes still in use by purist hand tool woodworkers.

The nature of the living I've made in this furniture game has always pushed me more towards machine woodworking than to hand tools. Having said that, I am fond of, and enjoy, the hand tools I do use, and they have more often than not formed an essential element of what I've made over the years. For instance, something I think I've mentioned before elsewhere, I enjoy prepping (when the job and/or time allows) wood surfaces polish ready with my little squad of smoothing planes, i.e., a Spiers infill set fairly coarse because it holds a good edge for a long time, followed by a Recod No 4, not quite so coarse that needs sharpening quite often, and a Clifton smoother set fine to finish off that seems to hold a good edge for a long time, and almost always a bit of scraping and/or sanding to finish off.

I'm not a hand tool purist, don't wish to be either, and the greater my involvement in the commercial furniture/woodworking sector has been at various times in my career, the lesser has been my use of hand tools, basically because in that sector, the production schedules and the volume of production required just won't allow for it.

Still, I've a fair amount of experience teaching woodworking learners too, and for those learners there's real value in developing a decent understanding and facility in the use of hand tools, which rather chimes with your mention of the union carpenter and the requirement in his past to buy planes, chisels, saws and the like. I think it's a truism that the lessons learnt about how wood reacts to working relatively slowly with hand tools transfers readily to working wood with machines, but the lessons don't work so well the other way around, i.e., beginning with machines and then trying to transfer what's been learned to hand woodworking. Slainte.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#16

Thanks, Richard...

David Weaver

..not looking to find little holes in the armor to poke through. Woodworking for hobby (as I do) and finding what pays well enough to woodwork comfortably professionally are probably two drastically different things.

I'm not aware of anyone who has worked a lifetime entirely by hand without having some other source of income at least in parts. The same goes for other hobbies (not uncommon for engineers to leave their profession in principle and make high quality electronic guitar gear, but the ones who design, manufacture, sell and support their on pedals entirely as one man operations usually go back to being engineers or whatever else got them to the point of running a business.....

...

or they realize that their talent is being a pedal designer and the value proposition works if they can navigate through what is vs. what they wish would be (e.g, the $200 point to point pedal that someone can make two of in a day and clear $200 profit is killed by some non-payers or intellectual property thieves, but designing a PCB with the same circuit and getting a manufacturing partner and hiring a few employees.....not the same purist sense, but leaves enough money to hire legal when someone steals your design).

...

at any rate, having said that, I picked you to explain because I've seen folks mention chariot planes before and figure that only someone in the UK could tell us what was actually done with them. I literally have seen the statement "once you've used a chariot plane, you'll never go back to using a block plane", but in buying a shepherd kit, I wasn't smart enough to think about the fact that I'm not using a block plane anywhere.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#17

If you only ever learn to use one plane...

David Weaver

my aforementioned friend who does clean (though somewhat plain) very tight work with machines doesn't really use other planes.

when LN sold their planes in the early/mid 2000s without sharpening instruction other than perhaps short explanation on their website (without reference to it in the boxes?) and the ability to buy some DVDs at a fairly high price (nobody needs to get excited about this, think about it from the perspective of someone who has never used a plane before and would expect a $375 hand plane to come with instructions that are at least as good as a $129 power router) showing their chosen method (Charlesworth at the time).......

Anyway, after that run-on sentence - my friend bought some planes. He declined at first to add on $25 for a sharpening DVD as he was sure that anything he'd need to know would be included with the planes. When he finally did buy the charlesworth DVD, he wasn't able to make it work on anything but his block plane (I found the DVD to be quite useful - that would've been before youtube, 2005 or so).

long story short - there's your person who doesn't have anyone else advising them, likes to woodwork enough to have power tools suitable for professional full time application, but can only find preference for the block plane.

I'd bet there's a lot of that, and as Rob has mentioned somewhere that only about 10% of the LV customers appear online, one would guess the purchasing and using habits of the rest may differ significantly.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#18

Re: Essential?

Frank House

About 1970, give or take 5 years, I read a book called "Planecraft", sponsored (I think) by Record. It had already gone through several editions at that time.

The origin of the block plane was said to be a specialist plane for use on butchers' blocks -- wooden chopping blocks, monolithic or laminated, with the working surface being end grain (of course, you know that).

Block planes were usually small, bevel up, low angle to suit the grain, and cheap enough for a butcher to own one to tidy up the working surface from time to time.

I have several block planes of various configurations (angle, size, weight, skew blade, flush one side ...) and I often find myself reaching for one without thought for tackling "quick-and-easy" small jobs which do not require the formality of "precise, flat, and square all sides" work. Also handy for softening arrises, revealing the figure below a rough surface, cleaning up spelch from drilling etc. (I think some people even use them for sharpening pencils ... I would not dare in case I was deafened by the noise of my early woodwork teacher spinning in his grave).

Even for conventional furniture work they are capable of shooting end grain on small items held in the bench vise when the shooting board has crept away and hidden behind a stack of timber.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#19

Re: Thanks, Richard... *LINK*

Sgian Dubh

Like you David, I can't think of anyone I've met and know making a living as a furniture maker/woodworker entirely with hand tools. I suppose the nearest I can think of of people likely to get get close to make a living in such a way are those involved in historical reenactment or restoration projects, such as, for example, The Weald and Downland Living Museum, linked to below.

As to chariot planes, I don't think I've heard much discussion of them outside venues such as this and maybe magazine articles, and I don't recall anyone suggesting using one would put you off ever again using a block plane.

I was, however, prompted through reading this thread to do a little basic research and the first source I opened, George Ellis's Modern Practical Joinery briefly describes a wooden mitre block plane, with its main use being 'for planing mitres in a screw mitre shoot', and available from Messrs Nurse & Co, so apparently not a particularly common plane if there was, as it seems, perhaps only one supplier. He also describes a metal chariot plane as a 'small metal smoothing plane for hard wood'. The book was first published in 1902. Slainte.


Weald and Downland Museum

Re: Wooden Plane question

#20

Where is the camera?

Jim Matthews

"...when the shooting board has crept away and hidden behind a stack of timber."

How did you know?

You've explained my aversion to tool wells on workbenches.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#21

Thanks, Richard...

David Weaver

..being a crank by saying this, too...

When we talk about someone making things with hand tools for a living (as a means of life. I can work in a mathematics related career without museum assistance, teaching other people etc. I'm paid precisely for my ability to use applied mathematics and it pays better than teaching people, etc)...

..at any rate, when we talk about "making things with hand tools for a living", then one would think the things being made are the revenue generator.

What you can find here is people who are teaching the use of hand tools to make things (the customer is buying the teaching, and not the product), museum workers demonstrating the use of hand tools (the customer is generally buying the demonstration - the items made would never pay the bills on their own).

The actual making is a very high bar.

Ideals are best chased in hobbies, which is what a lot of us (not you) are doing, but even my ideal isn't that rigid. I still have some power tools, and even on my least power-toolie thing (planes) I still usually open the mouth with a cordless drill, even if that's it - i'm not re-enacting and like to do it that way.

Re: Wooden Plane question

#22

Re: chariot?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We usually call these violin planes. You can buy them on Amazon.

In Diderot these planes show up in the Lutherie plate XII. (1774). There is nothing like this in the sections on furniture making etc.

There are a lot of woodworking tools that show up other trades. There is some back and forth, but it would be a surprise to see something like this in a furniture shop.


Re: Wooden Plane question

#23

loosely defined...

David Weaver

I went to check the size of chariots as the infill kit I have is flat and around 5" long (but the iron intentionally protrudes another inch or two out of the back).

A quick look shows some norris planes with 3 1/2 soles (about 5" long total, or perhaps a little more) and then some larger types (not sure if they're a copy of a norris type) casted with 5"+ soles.

I believe they were for cabinetmaking, and some much larger than violin planes (not sure what that type was called historically, I have a few of those in anticipation of making carved top guitars next year - they're still used by the few makers who hand carve tops instead of machine carving or pressing, and I think the very small ones (ibex comes to mind) are still common for violin making).

Re: Wooden Plane question

#24

Re: clarifying the question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Now days a block plane is considered essential for even a modestly equipped shop.

Was there no equivalent in the old days of wood planes. If not, and it sounds like not, any speculation why? Would they be hard or impossible to make?

To word another way, if not then, why did Stanley invent them? Did they develop a market or fill a need. Personally I rarely use one but I am the exception.

Bill, perhaps it is better to look at these planes for what they might offer you in the 21st century workshop, rather than compare them to classic woodies and woodworking of the 18th century. Both are valid, in that they offer a school of method that works for their user. Both have a bias towards the planes of that era.

You are I are 21st century furniture makers. We value both machines and hand tools. The question is not whether the 18th century had equivalent to the modern day block plane. The question is not even why Stanley designed and built them. And certainly, there is no tool that is indispensable - there are just too many ways to perform tasks, so many work-arounds.

The question is whether you find a block plane useful? And which ones - there are several types. These are the types I use most ...

While low angle block planes are balanced one-handed planes often used for arrises, bevels, and chamfers, a low cutting angle is not really suited for these purposes. Other than when bevelling across the grain ...


... use a common angle (or higher) block plane with the grain. Being bevel up, it is a simple task to create a higher angle on these planes.

One of my favourite planes is the small block plane-sized palm smoother from HNT Gordon. With a 60 degree bed, bevel down, this little woodie smooths small areas of interlocked grain. It can go where larger smoothing planes cannot go.


A rabbet block plane is valuable for planing against a wall, such as smoothing bumps inside drawer cases.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wooden Plane question

#25

Re: chariot?

John Aniano in central NJ

Hello All,

From what I've seen, most violin makers planes have bevel down blades. They are used to shape the maple and spruce tops and backs of violins. They are sometimes also called thumb planes. I've never heard them referred to as "Chariot planes". The single chariot plane I own, a cast iron body with rosewood infills, has the single blade bevel up. I use it as I would my Stanley 9-1/2 plane for fine trimming and of course bow work. It has a very short sole region in front of the mouth, maybe 3/4" max. Almost a bullnose plane.

That said, I have converted violin making planes to be better suited to making bows (hard, dense wood) by flipping the blades to be bevel up. With a ~35 degree blade bevel, this gives a nearly 80 degree scraping angle. Well suited for the sometimes squirrelly grain in bow wood.

John