Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

Posts

Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#1

Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

David Gli

I recently received a new LV butt chisel. The back is now nicely flattened and polished and I knocked a bit off the sides on a diamond stone. I went to convert the bevel to a hollow grind and ran into a snafu. Because of the short blade, there is no way to get the proper grind angle using any jig or free handing on a platform. The Tormek jig and a platform jig both use up almost all the length of the blade so barely anything protrudes. The system would work if I wanted to put a 60 degree bevel on this chisel. :-(

Does anyone have an easy way to do this or should I just use a flat bevel on this one chisel ?

Thanks!

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#2

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, you need to use the flat platform and not the blade holder. Make a shallow spacer/table to fit on the platform, to lift the back of the blade up and off the platform. Then simply dial in the grind angle, and grind.

Platform on the right ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#3

Which way does the wheel turn...

Jim Matthews

...in the Tropic of Capricorn?

I know it induces otherwise sensible people to put centerlines to the right.

What other foibles ensue under this insidious influence?

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#4

As the world turns ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Jim, I do know that, in the Southern hemisphere, water will create a counter-clock vortex and it runs down the drain - the opposite to the North. What this has to do with sharpening only twisted minds can say! :D

The flat plate on the right side is to create a hollow grind on a thick scraper, one I made from the rear of an O1 plane blade.

Here it is magically on the left side ...



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#5

Re: Which way does the wheel turn...

Joe shelton

Jim, I'd follow you through a Coriolus Effect. But only for comic relief...

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#6

what I did for a short chisel

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I made the chisels I use. In an after thought I converted a piece of steel from another purpose to what turned out to be a short chisel. The length of the chisel is shorter than the distance across my Wolverine grinder rest/platform. I was not pleased by this discovery.

To sharpen it I fasten with double sided tape a more narrow piece of wood on the rest and use it to guide the chisel. Not ideal but it works. The annoyance is that the angle of the rest needs to be changed for the raised platform.

As a curiosity, what is the advantage/purpose of the short butt chisel over the "standard" length?

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#7

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

William Duffield

Do you have a 1-2-3 block? If so, and you have some bolts to fit it, you can bolt the butt chisel to one of the faces of the block and set it on your flat grinder platform. If this technique is not clear, here is an example, at about 3:00, which happens to be a bit more complicated than grinding a butt chisel.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MFGdSAiQGBc&frags=pl%2Cwn

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#8

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

David Gli

Thanks Derek! That seems reasonably straight forward. I shall try that tomorrow and report back.

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#9

Re: what I did for a short chisel

David Gli

I bought a 1 3/4 inch butt chisel for its intended purpose after being less than thrilled using using my 1 3/4 inch very long paring chisel for mortising the hinges on a tool cabinet. I probably would have purchased a 1/ 3/4 inch bench chisel instead had I been able to find a modern one of equivalent quality to the PMV11 Lee Valley butt chisel.

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#10

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

David Gli

I do have one and will try this if the little wooden platform doesn't work for me.

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#11

Revelation and a wood block story

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have some big bench chisels and rarely use them because they are too unwieldy. I see, the solution is a butt chisel.

Before I bought the Wolverine grinder rest I fashioned an equivalent from a piece of 3/8 plywood. The large surface area was a vast improvement from the dinky rests the grinder came with. One day I was aggressively grinding a mower blade. The sparks were flying. They were also accumulating on the underside of the plywood, soon to be followed by a cloud of wood smoke. The large area plywood was replaced by the nonflammable steel rest.

Grinding a chisel should not generate enough sparks to result in a similar ending.

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#12

Freehand grinding on a flat wheel

David Gli

So a 1/4 inch thick piece of wood on the platform did the trick. Unfortunately, at least in my hands, freehand grinding on a flat wheel is less than ideal. I can make a very straight grind freehand on a crowned wheel, but not so much on the flat wheel. Because the grind wasn't straight, it took too long on the stones to get a nice edge due to the large flats. Not terribly long but not just a few strokes on 1000 and 8000 grit Shaptons. Since I do not have a crowned wheel set up right now , next time I need to resharpen this chisel, I think I will go back to a flat grind with a secondary bevel. Pics attached.

I would show a pic of the chisel cutting end grain radiata pine, bit I didn't have any. :)



Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#13

Another grinder debris story

David Gli

When I switched over to CBN wheels, the debris coming off the grinder was just tool steel. I thought why not just put a magnet close to the wheel to catch the debris. This would however eventually mean I would need to clean the magnet. So why not just put the magnet in a ziplock bag? You all know now where this is going.

The magnet worked brilliantly until it didn't. When reshaping the grind on an old, but new to me plane iron, I smelled something funny. There, behind my grinder was my ziplock bag and a good sized pile of swarf, not flaming but smoldering and melting the bag. I am now back to vacuuming when I am done working.

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#14

What is the issue?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, that looks fine to me. Only the hollow is not even - but the bevel/cutting edge looks fine. That is the important part.

If you want a perfectly straight hollow, either practice and get better at it. Or make a guide for the chisel. Here is a design: angle iron with a wooden clamp ...



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#15

use an oven bag

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

they are Nylon and will stand much higher temperature

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#16

Rafael from PA

Re: Another grinder debris story

Rafael from PA

What are your thoughts regarding preventing the dust generated by the wheel going airborne and you breathing it?

On another forum, it was brought up that sucking the grind debris into a dust extraction system was a fire hazard.

Wouldn't a water cooled grinding stone be preferable to all the complication associated to these CBN wheels?

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#17

Brief note on CBN wheels

Wiley Horne

There are CBN wheels for Tormek. You use without water—one of the advantages—and they don’t heat up. I recommend for Tormek owners.

Buy at Woodturners wonders, or maybe Ebay. No financial interest in either.

Wiley

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#18

Re: Another grinder debris story

John in NM

Any dust seems good to avoid to me, but then considering a couple years I worked in a welding shop while in school, the amount of dust inhaled while grinding even my entire collection of blades is trivial compared to one day in that place. I survived, but I was in my 20's. Dust mask always a great idea (and the ones with exhalation vents are not preferred for the current plague, so they may still be on the shelves - they are vastly preferable for shop use IMHO).

I agree, don't pick up hot debris in a collection system. I think he's talking about vacuuming after he finishes though, that will be fine. True of AlOx, SiC, or any wheel, same as CBN.

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#19

Nothing wrong with that at all...

John in NM

As Derek said, the edge is the important part. Speed isn't even important in the world of hobbyists, results are what matter most and that chisel will cut just fine.

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#20

The issue is time

David Gli

Thanks Derek! It is awfully nice to be able get a very straight edge off the grinder to minimize honing time, as you have pointed out on your website. With a very straight grind , there is less time honing and in use, more hones before needing to regrind. My edge was indeed as sharp as I care to make it. I do like your angle iron jig and will likely try that next time I need to grind this chisel.

Using a crowned wheel, if I saw I was getting such a big central flat, I would have gone back to the wheel and just hit the center of the blade and then gone back to my first stone. With the flat wheel, it is super hard( for me) to hit just the middle of the blade. I recognize that this may be skill related and the ability to visualize perfect squareness. With the crowned wheel though, this is fairly easy. Now only if someone made a nicely crowned CBN wheel, I would happily swap out my coarse CBN wheel for a crowned 180 grit one, using the flat wheel for jigged grinding and the crowned one for freehand. I guess I could go back to a friable wheel, but I am spoiled by the lack of airborne abrasive using the CBN one.

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#21

Re: The issue is time

Jonathan Elliott

David,

Joel at Tools for Working Wood sells a crowned CBN wheel. He has them specially manufactured, it's the only one I'm aware of.

Jonathan

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#22

Something wrong with that

David Gli

I agree with half of what you say John. :)

The chisel indeed cuts well, but I would disagree that an amateur's time is less valuable than someone in production. I am much happier working wood than steel. I am willing to put in whatever time is mandatory to get the edge I need, but a quick sharpening lets me get back to what I am doing sooner and doesn't really disrupt my "flow." Plus if honing is quick, I am much more likely to do it as soon as necessary rather than later than ideal.

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#23

Re: The issue is time

David Gli

Cool. Unfortunately, the finest grit he has is 80. I have never gone straight from my 80 grit wheel to a stone, but rather go from my 180 grit to a stone. I shall have to try doing the former, next time I grind and see how that works out. If it does, I will have a barely used 80 grit Woodturners Wonders Flat CBN wheel on the classifieds.

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#24

80x Crowned Wheel

Steve Elliott

My only CBN wheel is Joel's 80 grit one. It removes steel more quickly than I expected and with very little heat, which is what I wanted from CBN.

I'd prefer a crowned 180 grit wheel and hope Joel will eventually offer one, but for now I'm very happy there's a crowned CBN wheel on the market at all.

Re: Hollow grind on a butt chisel?

#25

80 grit, too..

David Weaver

i also use an 80 grit wheel, but a flat one with rounded edges from wood turner's wonder.

A lot of the aggression will go away with some use - mine has settled in and is no issue grinding anything (fine or not).

I'd prefer (in cbn) a flat wheel with a radius edge over a completely rounded wheel (for grinding narrow tools - you can just place them against the flat part of the wheel and grind their hollow without doing anything else, not even moving them), but it's not really a big deal either way. The radius edges allow you to work a small area (like you would with a crowned wheel) of a wider tool if you choose to.