Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Flattening my Washita

Posts

Re: Flattening my Washita

#26

Re: Flattening my Washita

Chuck Bjorgen

I remember watching your video using the power sander to flatten a stone. I’ll probably not have need for that but it’s good to know about. Your thought about using Simple Green to clean the stone was good. Just 30 minutes and it brightened up the light colors of the stone which I’ll now put to use.

The plastic laminate sheets seemed to be recommended by Lee Valley. I checked the used sheet more carefully today and found no sign that the grits were embedded in the plastic. There were serious scratches in the plastic for sure so I suspect their use is to protect the glass from being abraded. My 5/16” chunk of glass was bought for this purpose many years ago so I was happy to protect it. A simple project is done.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#27

Re: Flattening my Washita

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don’t think corian would work for flattening but it makes a dandy strop, used with green compound or even rouge. I haven’t tried it with diamond paste. I’ll bring you some next time we do lunch.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#28

Re: Get-together

Chuck Bjorgen

To do that, Bruce, we may have to get take out and sit in our respective cars, drivers side to drivers side, six feet away. I hope yesterday’s suggestion we may have a vaccine in 2021 is a reality.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#29

Re: Flattening my Washita

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I can guarantee that the abrasive particles are immobilize in the plastic while rubbing the hard stone across it. If not the plastic would be shredded. What you have observed is that the particles may not be permanently stuck into the plastic. But they are largely immobilized in the plastic under the pressure of the stone.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#30

Corian

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I'll wager it will be a dandy substrate for large particle sized abrasive. I tried 220 grit diamond on cast iron. Utter failure. This large particle did not embed, rather it rolled , not ideal.

I did not try Corian, available as scraps at any cabinet shop working it. I did try various things and what worked was acrylic (Plexiglas). Particles embedded under the pressure of the steel and immobilized, resulting in effective cutting.

Corian is hard enough to not deform under pressure, yet soft enough to be dented by an abrasive particle. Denting will more or less immobilize the abrasive, just what you want to happen.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#31

They go in deep...

David Weaver

not necessarily limited to plastic laminate, but they go in deep in a softer substrate and some do roll around and shred and dent the substrate. The key for diamond use on steel or cast or laminate or whatever it may be is to give up a little bit of wanting the cutting media to feel like fresh sandpaper - when it embeds, it won't. when it's loose on the surface as it's settling in, it's definitely fast, but it's destroying everything and there's a temptation to keep loading it on to get that feel and speed.

I tried 100 grit diamonds on a kanaban (mild steel flattening plate from japan) and they are too big - they still work because they're rolling and they beat up everything, but the kanaban became hollow quickly. reflattening mild steel by hand then is something most of us would like to avoid (it's very rubbery compared to hardened steel and cast iron).

I wouldn't want to use any of these hand methods to flatten 1/8th or 1/4 off of a natural stone with a lot of sway, though.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#32

Re: They go in deep...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

David, you have mentioned using diamond paste on hardwood as a strop. I don’t want to sound argumentative, but how is that different from a hard plastic or composite? I haven’t tried diamond on corian but the green crayon works pretty well. OTOH, that stays completely on the surface.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#33

I don't know that it is any different

David Weaver

the level of polish from wood is like mentioned here - the diamonds bury very deep, and they don't have the same aggressiveness. They're slower and the level of polish is super high (for example, to get a completely perfect cosmetic polish on something with them in wood is far easier than it is on a harder surface, and almost no wire edge is ever retained on anything).

I used wood out of laziness and because diamonds aren't expensive. but long term, I'd use cast, because it cuts faster (that's in regard to sharpening).

I've got a lot of corian. I'll try it sometime today or tomorrow, but that's separate from something like flattening a stone. Not sure if I can find the 100 grit diamond bag that I had previously, but I can try silicon carbide in it.

For fine diamonds, I'm sure it would work very well - the virtue of cast is that the edge may be slightly less polished (it's still a superior edge to an arkansas stone for keenness and longevity - even though the feel is lacking compared to a natural stone), but the cast is very stingy with diamonds. You charge it seldom and with very little. The drawback to cast is that if there's any contaminant on the surface, even tiny, it dents the edge (wood doesn't).

At any rate, I'll try the corian and see what I can find. There's often corian scrap on ebay for barely more than the cost of shipping and for anyone curious, you can cut it with a hand saw and trim the edges with a plane without issue.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#34

Re: I don't know that it is any different

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks for that. My interest in corian is strictly as a strop. I have a couple cast iron plates that I use with diamond paste for sharpening, 15 μ, 3 μ and 1 μ.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#35

Re: I don't know that it is any different

David Weaver

Just subjectively, I think it should be good as a strop. Better than cast - it should have just a little give and let the material reach above its grit level and not raise a wire edge by pushing an edge over like even brass can.

I like the idea - I wish I'd have thought of it as I've got an unbelievable amount of livingstone (same as corian but different brand with "Big particles" in the material) from the dealer sending me an extra sheet by accident when I fabricated my countertops.

That's on top of a full flat rate box of corian that I thought I'd turn to make bushings.

Anyway, seems ideal -a little but still control of edge geometry. I should've used it for my iron test.