Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Flattening my Washita

Posts

Flattening my Washita

#1

Flattening my Washita

Chuck Bjorgen

I posted a couple weeks back about the six-inch long Washita I picked up for a decent price on eBay. This weekend I got around to flattening the one side that seemed dished and cleaning up the other side that seemed flat, but pretty dirty. I had viewed some YouTube videos in which the authors had used Silicon Carbide (SiC) grits for the flattening and because I had some of this stuff along with the recommended laminate sheets from a long-ago purchase, I decided to go that route. I used 90 grit SiC on my 5/16" glass plate, protected by a laminate sheet because that's what I had. It was somewhat effective but very, very slow.

I became impatient and decided to try a full sheet of 80 grit sandpaper, of which I had only two sheets. The result was much better, although still somewhat slow. I kept cleaning the sandpaper with a bench brush until I felt I was done. The dished side of the stone still showed discoloring but a straight edge led me to believe the dishing was mostly resolved. I'll be using the stone as is from this point.

I recall from another Washita purchase that the seller had cleaned the stone in boiling water. And another YouTuber had cleaned Arks in hot water and dish soap. Any thoughts on those treatments?


The top photo shows the side that had been dished. I stopped with the sandpaper because with freehand sharpening I can try to use the full surface of the stone. I'm not sure I'll try the SiC grit for anything again but am open to suggestions.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#2

Re: Flattening my Washita

Jim Matthews

Yours looks pretty clean, already.

Test for flatness with a ruler longer than the stone and a flashlight in a darkened room.

I would not subject this lovely example to extremes in temperature, when mechanical "scrubbing" should suffice. If you don't have a plate for use with lapping compound, float glass is good or an I used cast iron plane body.

Once you save up some funds, the Trend diamond plate (300/1000) is well received.

That's a good way to keep Arkies flat.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#3

Re: Flattening my Washita

David Weaver

i have a video on youtube about using the hard idler on a cheap belt sander as a line. you pretty much move the stone around on the idler (where the paper can cut aggressively) until you can get it no flatter and then move on to paper or diamond hone or grit. It turns out that you can do a pretty good job, fast, and a $2 belt from harbor freight would do several of the most dished stones you could find.

a good mask is a must, or a serious outdoor breeze at least. Smells like fire, but silica is a known baddie, of course. Not sure if novaculite does the same, but no reason to test luck.

As far as cleaning the stones - the razor community (for reasons beyond me) was militant about not wanting to use oilstones, so they would soak washita stones and other old stones in simple green. If you're willing to wait a day or two and use simple green in pretty good concentration, it will cease beading of water on an oilstone with very little physical work.

Boiling is also relatively common. The oil that's in these stones when they're caked is almost certainly something that shouldn't have been on stones in the first place. It works just as well to use a diamond hone once or twice then the stone is flat and use a non-drying oil and then the surface will be smart again.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#4

Re: Flattening my Washita

John Aniano in central NJ

Hi Jim,

I've cleaned oilstones first with a stainless steel metal pot scrubbie pad and dish detergent and warm/hot water in the sink. Then I put the stones on the top shelf/rack and run them though a medium wash cycle in our dishwasher. I try to open the door before it goes to the dry cycle. I run them through sometimes twice to get them clean. Then allow to cool slowly and let the water fully evaporate- maybe a week - before I try to assess flatness and true it up. I've used diamond stones to flatten oilstones if the dishing isn't too great.

John

Re: Flattening my Washita

#5

Re: Flattening my Washita

Chuck Bjorgen

I did initially try my 250 grit EZY-Lap stone and it worked a bit but again, too slow and I was concerned about what was happening to the diamonds. I might try the Simple Green which I already have. Thanks.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#6

curious to know...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

what does one use a 6" stone for that it matters if it is flat? When would it matter if any stone was dead flat along its long axis? I'm trying to work out in my head the geometry. I can't come up with a reason why even an 8" stone used for a plane blade would need to be flat along it long axis.

Nothing I use for knives is close to flat. I think the result will be a convex edge which I think is a good profile.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#7

the geometry...

David Weaver

..may not be out of flat in a way that's favorable to you. For example, I've gotten a lot of older razor stones that were hollow in their length, but the barber who had them would've had razors that matched the gradual hollow on the stone. If another person put their razor on it, the result may not be great.

Whatever you do with your knives, it's going to go in the shape of the wear.

Typical for me to see with older stones is a little bit of hollow in the center, never more, but often a lot of hollow in the length. I'm sure that whoever is using the stones is moving their plane irons on the diagonal and then working the back of the irons over the edges of the stones. It can be done indefinitely without much degradation in the quality of the edge.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#8

Re: curious to know...

Chuck Bjorgen

In my case, Bill, this old, well used stone is new to me and I simply wanted to give it a new start. I do not routinely flatten my stones, even my water stones. I have been spending a lot of my COVID-19 downtime (not sick) trying to perfect my kitchen knife sharpening techniques. The internet guy I’ve been following, his web site is Burrfection.com., does not do much stone flattening and he uses nearly 100% water stones.

I know you and Bruce Haugen are devotees of diamond paste on cast iron and had those cast iron plates precision ground to flatness. I’m sure you had your reasons.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#9

Correction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

had those cast iron plates precision ground to flatness.

The motivation was grinding them to smoothness. The surface of cast iron is not smooth from the casting process or in one case the sawing apart of a casting to yield two plates.

If someone used a stone to where it was worn concave it is a good bet they knew what they were doing with the tool being sharpened. And, apparently the hollow of the stone did not affect their use of this tool.

The problem with silicon carbide for flatening is the toughness of this abrasive. It is plenty hard enough to cut silica. But the particles fracture easily when used on something hard like silica. The coarse grit soon becomes a much finer grit from fracture. Go easy on pressure when using this abrasive.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#10

Re: curious to know...

Steve Elliott

Some of my work with chisels requires a very flat back, more than just 1/2" or so because the chisel back is the guiding surface. For these chisels I carefully flatten the back when I first prep them and then only touch the back to a very flat finishing stone.

For any blade with a secondary bevel on the back (plane blades, for instance) and for many chisels the concavity of the long axis of a stone would hardly matter.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#11

Flatness

Warren in Lancaster, PA

For a plane iron it is nice to have a small amount of curvature to the stone to correspond with the amount of camber on a smoothing plane or a jointer. However, since we sharpen other irons with more curvature and chisels as well, the stone is often more hollow across the width than optimum, so we wear the center of the iron on the edge of the stone to manage both the edge and the stone.

Sharpening small chisels and carving tools is rough on a stone's flatness, so it is nice to use a separate stone or at least the other side of the stone for these tools.

Having a stone hollow in length is not so critical as in width, but we usually sharpen with the edge not quite normal to the long axis of the stone, maybe 20 or 30 degrees skewed to the side. We do this because it is more stable (effectively has a larger base in the direction of travel). So if the stone is quite hollow in length, it shows up as giving more camber to the iron.

For a chisel especially it works best to have a flat bevel; a concave bevel is harder to sharpen with precision and does not perform as well.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#12

Silicon carbide

Warren in Lancaster, PA

For lapping, I have used silicon carbide occasionally over the last 40 years. I use it with water on any old piece of glass; I am not making telescope mirrors.

I have to say I don't know what a "laminate sheet" is. I would say try lapping with the SiC on old glass without "laminate".

Re: Flattening my Washita

#13

glass not ideal, or desirable

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Just like diamond on some substrate, you want the abrasive fixed and that to be ground moving. SiC will not embed in glass. Hence, the glass will be abrading along with the stone or whatever as the two surfaces are slid past one another. Works, but not ideal.

A further disadvantage of glass is its hardness. SiC is easily fractured. Capturing it between two hard surfaces will crush large SiC particles like what is used for flatening (not a significant issue with fine particles).

I don't know what an ideal substrate would be for SiC. A laminate like Formica could be good. Corian might be a good substrate to try.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#15

Weird

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It is weird reading that some guy sat in a chair and decided that something I have done for 40 years does not work.

I have worn through three Silicon carbide bench stones (one inch thick) and four 800 grit water stones (1 3/8 thick) and put a lot of wear on my Washita stones, which I use every sharpening.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#16

Re: glass not ideal, or desirable

Chuck Bjorgen

I wonder, Bill, if the laminate sheets are the same items used in offices to protect valuable documents. They come as pouches and are heat sealed to protect their contents. Probably 20 years ago when I decided to try water stones I bought from Lee Valley an item called the “Stone Pond” which included the 90 grit SiC and a few of these laminate sheets. The laminate sheets were to be used on an included piece of glass. They were self adhesive and seemed to protect the glass although I did not get the sense that the grits embedded into the sheets like diamond paste might do in cast iron.

Truthfully, this flattening of the Washita was probably a one time thing for me and I may never use the SiC grits again.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#17

Re: Weird

David Weaver

Bill's not the only person who advised that, but I think it's an illustration of what we see much of in woodworking. What works. 20 things. What works on the internet 2.

I used loose silicon carbide on glass for a while and it does hollow the glass a little bit, but glass is cheap and you can work the surface of the glass at the same time if you don't work the center. Silicon carbide bought loose is really only price-affected by shipping. So 1 pound may be $15 and 5 pounds may be only a little bit more.

The first plane flattening video I found was one with ernie conover and he advised silicon carbide on plastic laminate. Plastic laminate isn't cheap and once you embed silicon carbide in it, that's pretty much what you're using it for.

It was cheaper for me to get a cabinet shelf (3/8" glass, 8x42 inches) at a glass shop here in the city than it was to do anything else, and so I've remained using that and PSA roll for things that I lap flat - just not novaculite or india stones.

Maybe for ernie conover (my understanding is that he was making money on classes at the time more than anything else, but that could be wrong), the difference in speed was important. I couldn't show a picture of an oilstone that I flattened a second time because I don't have one.

George mentioned that at CW, he had a large sandstone wheel that as fairly useless for bevel grinding as someone had ordered one (as in, a new one - it may have been after they decided they wouldn't use antique items - that still seems goofy to me) that was very fine and hard, but that it worked well for flattening oilstones, so he used the side of it for that.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#18

If I understand....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....The plastic sheet got stuck to the glass and the abrasive sprinkled on the plastic? If so this is exactly what is optimum. The hard particles will stick/embed in the plastic and become immobile. The stone will move and the abrasive will largely not move.

People unfamiliar with how the abrasive works are surprised that the case iron substrate for diamonds never wears significantly. The diamond sticks to the cast iron and does not move relative to it as the chisel or whatever is slid across the surface. Hence, little wear of the cast iron.

Obviously with glass as the substrate the abrasive rolls around between the two hard surfaces and abrades both of them. Not the optimum situation. Because both surfaces are hard, large particles of abrasive are subject to crushing.

To be clear, I absolutely understand trying something just for the curiosity of trying it, for example flattening a 6" stone if for no other reason than to try it. This kind of activity brings joy to life(for many). The risk is that someone will read about flattening a 6" stone and think they must flatten it for their pocket knife. My original comment was to initiate a discussion about when flattening might be necessary.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#19

let's get specific

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In you enthusiasm to discredit what I posted you seem to have lost sight of what it was I wrote about.

What exactly in my post do you disagree with?

Where in my post did I say what you do/did, "didn't work"? With your command of English you surely understand the meaning of "ideal". Do you believe glass is ideal? Do you discount the possibility that someone knowing it is not idea might come up with something better? Would you applaud this discovery?

Which takes us to another issue. You seem to believe that what ever you do is best and you seem driven to convince the rest of the woodworking world that they should do what you advocate or they are fools. There is no other way nor any opportunity for improvement in the last 40 years, or 140.

If someone suggests another way or investigates an improvement they are a threat to your position as the font of woodworking knowledge. You respond by attacking their credibility and hide behind a veil of generalities about the source of your 40 years of woodworking experience. If you want to keep up with your snarky comments about me I am going to respond with specific questions about this 40 years of vague experience you claim so that your claims can be put in context of how you got it.

I will be the first to acknowledge you have a lot of valid experience to offer. But woodworking a broad deep field with opportunity for a lot of valid means to the end, and new technology. There are others that have acquired as much or more experience on a topic than you have. Accept the reality that you don't know it all or what is best for every occasion.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#20

Re: curious to know...

Brad Chenoweth

I agree, Bill. I can still remember the stone my grandfather sharpened their butcher/kitchen knives on. I don't know about across the width, but it was severely dished from end to end. He used it for all of his old carbon steel knives. They butchered all their own pigs and chickens, along with wild game, along with general kitchen use. And I can tell you, those knives CUT!

Re: Flattening my Washita

#21

Re: If I understand....

AlanWS

I'd agree with this assessment, and say it's consistent with the experience I've had with grinding telescope mirrors: loose grit on glass abrades both surfaces, and requires frequent renewal of grit, but fine grit on softer pitch abrades only the harder glass, and requires less frequent renewal.

When I flattened a severely dished oilstone I found loose grit to be much more efficient than other abrasives I had. To grind quickly I found that sprinkling the grit on sandpaper affixed to glass worked well. The sandpaper can be worn out and any grit because its role is simply to keep the loose grit from easily slipping sideways in use. This cut many times faster than the other methods I tried, but of course I didn't try everything.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#22

The lesson about embedding...

David Weaver

..is quickly learned using a wrought iron backed japanese tool on a cast plate for loose diamonds.

It's certainly reasonable to say "why? ....would anyone do that?", but sometimes something is at hand and you use it rather than faffing with anything else.

The wrought jigane will instantly get in a war with cast, and you just can't get away with it no matter how tempting.

But other than wearing the glass, I got along fine with what warren's mentioning, too - just not for any heavy flattening as i often like to do with a new to me stone. plastic laminate would come up short for that, too - I'm looking to remove 1/4" of dish in 10 minutes and not hours, so the belt sander for the rough work on the ends is the way to go, but even then - the edge of the idler and not working on the platen.

If precision is necessary (like you're talking about, grinding lenses), then rolling abrasive is no good. It works OK for truing oilstones, though, and is intentionally what we're doing using a slurry on natural japanese stones.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#23

Re: let's get specific

Warren in Lancaster, PA

What is lacking here is judgement. The idea that a piece of glass with 150 square inches is going to show significant wear when being lapped with a stone that has 12 square inches at most (and starts out with less than 4 square inches). The idea that we cannot distribute the wear with some degree of evenness. The idea that a Washita stone might need to be abraded often enough to worry about efficiency in using cheap grit. And on and on. I am having trouble imagining that you have used a Washita stone often enough to have experience here.

Chuck had grit, he had glass, what could be simpler?

Re: Flattening my Washita

#24

You continue to not understand the word ideal

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The only reason I replied to your suggestion of using glass is the fact that glass does not have the properties to make it an ideal substrate for abrading with large particle sized silicon carbide. It might be that if someone understood what properties an ideal substrate should have they would come up with something better than glass. Maybe Corian, Lexan, or Plexiglas which is good for large particle sized diamonds, or ???

You continue to attempt to discredit my knowledge of abrasion with a loose abrasive on a substrate by questioning my experience with an ARK stone. It matters not what one is abrading the fundamentals are the same. The original poster spoke of the slow abrasion he was observing. If he could find a more ideal substrate the abrasion would be faster. Worth the effort to look? That is up to whoever needs to do it. I don't care. I have pointed out the properties in a substrate to look for if someone whats to experiment.

For example, when I became interested in the topic, abrasives were being embedded in MDF, maple etc to sharpen tools I studied what was known about the topic, not by people with vast experience in planing wood, but people that had expertise in abrading stuff with diamonds. Turns out the people that know the most are not woodworkers but diamond faceters. I found that for centuries diamonds were embedded in cast iron as the ideal substrate and remain so today. If someone, as a result of convenience, stubbornness, frugality or what not continues to use diamond on MDF I could care less. If they advocate using MDF I will point out it is not ideal. The audience can choose what to do as suits their situation. My well being does not depend on whether my advice is taken or not.

Re: Flattening my Washita

#25

clever application.. thanks for suggestion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I never would have thought to charge sand paper with abrasive.