Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

Posts

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#26

English Sycamore is not American Sycamore

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think I recall from a class on inlay with Latta that what the English call sycamore is in fact a maple and close to our "soft maple". It looked to me like soft maple. We used it for "white" inlay as a substitute for more expensive holly. It took bends easily but was not snow white like holly. I never used it again as a substitute for holly.

If my memory is correct and English Sycamore is maple and like out soft maple, it bears no resemblance to the wood from American Sycamore, other than it is soft.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#27

Well hello Wiley!  -  OT.

Raymond in Trenton

Wiley Horne! Hello my friend.

I don't think it's been 20 years .... but it has been a long time. Maybe 15 ... Wow! Feels good to be remembered :o)

I'm still alive and kicking, work changed (actually a good change) and interfered with my WC time. Still without internet at home so that sort of cut me off. Oh well. It also interfered with bench time, so much so it wasn't worth starting anything involved. Needless to say, the "I want to do this" list has grown.

To preserve mental stability I started teaching myself turning. Mostly small stuff; mallets, bowls, eggs, lidded boxes and a couple Christmas ornaments. I can work for as little as 30-45 minutes, get my fix and walk away. The good thing about turning is when I go back, just pick it up and continue. I'm spending my time between the turning form and here. And if I can remember/figure out the picture thing again, I'll put up some photos of my stuff.

Hope you've been well and are and continue to do so in this current situation.

Regards,

Raymond

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#28

fork in the road...

David Weaver

What I recall visiting hearne was the word "english sycamore" and then "london plane tree".

It appears those are two different things. Acer pseudoplatanus (English sycamore) and a hybrid - acrerifolia platanus.

I couldn't tell you exactly what I planed except that I go to hearne, or used to, on Christmas Even when Rick was pretty much the only guy there. Not by design, that's just when I was on that side of the state -I've never seen the business in full swing. If I tried to say he told me that london plane tree and english sycamore are the same thing, there's a 99.99% chance that I just didn't understand what he was telling me.

Whatever it is that I have, it's similar planing to hard maple. Hearne has lots of stuff. For a guy walking in the door maybe thinking of spending about $400 on a few different species to try out in 8/4, you're often below the cost many of the wide shorts in a single board.

Once I found beech and rosewood supplies, I stopped going there (but no slighting of hearne - I found the owner and the dogs friendly and helpful - you know you're not looking for home depot cull wood when you go in there).

Long story short, I'd guess what I have isn't acer pseudoplatanus, but at the same time, I've not seen any hard maple that's any brighter than this board. It's almost like smooth wax across the endgrain, but it's at least as hard to plane across the end grain as american beech (fagus grandifolia). Had I not bought it, I would tell someone it was hard maple.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#29

Re: Since you asked about 'my movement'  :o)

David Weaver

Thanks for the response, raymond. I'm looking for that kind of luck in a neighborhood tree. Here in the burbs, if the owner says so, the tree services leave large trees behind bucked.

If not, I often see the lower level workmen quartering rounds and then sawing them again just to throw them in a grinder. They must have a customer for the chips. Wiki says LPT is a town hybrid that doesn't suffer some of the same ills of the american sycamore - I need to start paying attention more around here so I can have stories of getting something useful!

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#30

Re: Well hello Wiley!  -  OT.

John Aniano in central NJ

Wiley, et al...

Ray is much too modest! His turning efforts are excellent IMO. He's not using a pole lathe though...

John

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#31

But I am a Pole using a lathe - close, right?


Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#32

Re: English Sycamore is not American Sycamore

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The tree the English call sycamore is Acer pseudoplatanus. When this tree is planted in the United States we call it sycamore maple. It is in the maple genus, not the plane tree genus. Some English know to be careful when talking to an American audience and some do not.

The hardness of sycamore maple is slightly more than most of our soft maples (Acer rubra and others).

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#33

Re: English Sycamore is not American Sycamore

Sgian Dubh

"I think I recall from a class on inlay with Latta that what the English call sycamore is in fact a maple and close to our "soft maple".

He's right in that they are both Acers, i.e., A. Pseudoplatanus ([European] sycamore) and A. rubrum (soft maple). In terms of working properties and appearance either as unworked wood or as a finished item, I can't recall ever working soft maple: so I can't make comparison or judgement outside my experience of hard maple and (European) sycamore. Slainte.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#34

What my pieces & Aniano's handle blank look like

Raymond in Trenton NJ

Two photos:


Combined two images of the LPT harvest.


Posting a photo of John Aniano's LPT saw handle blank from the above. He said this was easy to plane. This was a quartered piece I gave him and shows great (IMHO) sap/heart color.

Regards,

Raymond

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#35

The saw handle piece

David Weaver

looks spectacular!

It's interesting that my piece of wood doesn't look at all like that in the sap - and it's dead quartered. That's a very sycamore-looking property to the flecking. It's really appealing.

Mine is very plain. Maybe it's hard maple :) Or maybe it is English Sycamore and not LPT and it's just unusually hard.

EDIT: the smart thing to do is just go to google and do an image search. Mine is Acer pseudoplatanus

I have no idea why it's as hard as it is as the wood database describes its hardness in a range more like acer rubrum (just slightly harder). My piece is half way hateful.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#36

Ever use "curly maple

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Our "red" or "soft"maple is more commonly curly than hard maple. People that buy "curly" maple may be getting red maple.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#37

Re: Ever use "curly maple

William Duffield

Sometimes, if you are lucky (or go to Hearne's with a roll of Franklins) you can find curly hard maple, mostly Acer saccarum, also called sugar maple or rock maple. Birdseye maple is almost always hard maple.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#38

Re: fork in the road...

William Duffield

I guess I'm being a bit picky here, but you got the London Planetree's name a little mixed up. It is Platanus x acerifolia. Platanus is the genus name, the "x" means it is a hybrid, and acerifolia, the hybrid name, means the leaves look like maple leaves. Its parent species are P. orientalis and P. occidentalis. East meets West. :) Even more confusing, it is in a totally different family, the soapberries, Platanacea, than the maples.

I have two huge American Planetrees, Platanus occidentalis, one of the parent species, in my front yard. The larger tree's circumference at chest height is almost 14 feet. The vernacular name around here is buttonwood, I guess because the wood is hard enough to use for buttons.

I have a few other maples around the property, including a huge silver maple, several Japanese red maples and at least one sugar maple, so I know what maple samaras look like, and they are nothing like the fuzzy balls the sycamores drop.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#39

Re: Ever use "curly maple

Sgian Dubh

If you're talking about curly soft maple, Bill, I think not. As I said in an earlier post, I can't recall ever knowingly working with soft maple (Acer rubrum), although I suppose I might have done so without realising.

I have worked with relatively small amounts of both hard maple (Acer saccharum) and European sycamore (Acer pseudoplatanus) that had interesting figuring, such as fiddleback or quilted. I've never really sought out highly figured examples of the various maples under discussion to work with, either because that wasn't the appearance or a characteristic I was looking for in my own work, and similarly, in the case of working for other people as a maker and employee, those characteristics weren't usually sought for their products.

Having said that, there have been a few occasions where I've worked on pieces where there were elements veneered with either hard maple or European sycamore with significant figuring: but I don't think my experience working with veneers really fits into this thread because the main thrust of the discussion seems to be focused on larger lumps of wood, e.g., boards, billets, and the like. Slainte.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#40

Re: Ever use "curly maple

David Weaver

often seen on high end solid top guitars - primo stuff is hard with a tight and even curl (classic looking)

Gaudy larger curl is a little more common on electrics (soft maple or bigleaf from the west if quilt).

I have a guitar from china with wood that's probably from the US. I'm guessing soft. the top and back are hand carved, the pickup is a lollar and the whole thing used cost less than I might be able to get the materials (that's not true when new, but they don't hold value that well).

https://i.imgur.com/Gp9PYza.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/WcKqivm.jpg?1

This kind of wood is gaudy on most electric guitars (it's used, anyway, but the rarer hard maple you're talking about is more common on those), but is common on an arch top. The top is perfectly plain (even and high quality) spruce - completely hides the surprise around and behind the guitar.

https://i.imgur.com/lcICkUY.jpg

I aspire to be building guitars like this within a couple of years instead of electrics.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#41

The market for this wood...

David Weaver

...the really highly figured stuff over here seems to go to instruments and veneer. I've always thought that the veneer people were my enemy in trying to find good solid lumber (they probably are).

Yesterday, I read an account of trouble on the page of a figured sycamore dealer's age that the veneer people were complaining that luthiers were buying veneer logs to cut musical lumber from and "ruining" the ability to get some of the logs for veneer.

:)

This is a picture I just posted in separate comment here of a guitar that I bought last year - used. It would be difficult to get this kind of wood into a furniture project tastefully except maybe in spindles or turned elements.

(the whole thing is like this except the top is dead straight spruce, dead quartered)

I've noticed that many of the sellers of quartered wood here show really spectacular lumber, and the projects made with it are really plain - sometimes thrown together looking. Giant slab looking furniture or window sills where the lumber is forced to stand on its own as far as style goes.

I've got materials to build a guitar like this (a couple, I guess), but I"m afraid to start yet as they're beyond my pay grade - not structurally, but getting a result that nobody would spot any part that looks like it was done by an amateur.

The virtue of living now is that there are books published to make guitars like this so that a dummy can be told what's essential (so that you don't make a very pretty looking dead sounding paperweight).

One made by the george that I always talk about. He's self taught as far as guitars go (formally trained in classical design, though) and said he'd followed a book (more or less) - no need to lubricate the secrets out of someone who may not be as good as they think they are.

http://www.cybozone.com/fg/wilson3.html

At any rate, if the movement of stuffing woods like this in plain furniture is kind of over, I think that's to the benefit of most.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#42

Re: Well hello Wiley!  -  OT.

Wiley Horne

Raymond,

We’d like to see the turnings that John spoke about. An alternative to figuring out Woodcentral’s native photo posting, is to use a photo host like Google Photo, Flickr, Imgur...there are many of them. What you are doing is giving each photo a URL—the URL can then be copied and posted here in your text.

Maybe Derek or Bill T. could describe what they do to get photos to render ‘live’ in the text, so there is no URL click required for viewing.

Wiley

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#43

Re: Well hello Wiley!  -  OT.

Raymond in Trenton NJ

Wiley,

I'll see what I can do. Keep in mind that John is overly generous.

I really don't have a web presence or spot to load to. However, since posting of my photo woes, Sir William has provided me a very complete primer on attaching photos, along with the WC size limitation. So I think I'm OK. (Thanks William!!)

Over, out and see you later,

Raymond