Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

Posts

Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#1

Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

Jim Matthews

I replaced my Partcle board nightstand with a larger piece.

24x24x37" it fits neatly where the landfill candidate served.

It's made of what I have, and the stuff is challenging.

Quartersawn Sycamore which saws beautifully, but is so heavily figured that tear out was unavoidable. *LOTS* of sanding was required.

The the legs came from the same billet, faced with with shop veneer from the same stock to present more interesting grain on the show faces.

I experimented with a side frame to connect the front and rear leg pairs (they were traditional tenon and dovetail assrmblies).

The side frame is half laps in Yellowheart (because I had it).

The side frame is attached with glue and screws.

Each side accepts a press fit panel of QS Sycamore.

Drawers are front rabbet, rear dado. Front rabbets held with glue and screws.

Rear dado is plywood, drawer bottoms are plywood with rub joint supports.

Drawer bodies are Poplar.

Drawers ride on dovetailed "rails" of White Oak.

Finished in Shellac and clear wax.

http://imgur.com/gallery/y9NLMCk


img

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#2

questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I experimented with a side frame to connect the front and rear leg pairs (they were traditional tenon and dovetail assemblies).

The side frame is half laps in Yellowheart (because I had it).

The side frame is attached with glue and screws.

Each side accepts a press fit panel of QS Sycamore."

I am doing a desk and I want an appearance like you have on the side- "frame and panel". I do not understand your description of how you did this part. I have blued the the parts I didn't understand.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#3

Details and more pictures 

Jim Matthews

It's a glorified picture frame, each corner joined by a half lap.

Detail pic in the linked gallery.

The catch is to make each side square and precisely the same front to back length.

Since the drawers are supported on runners, height isn't critical.

Side frame detail https://imgur.com/gallery/p5VoVvN


img

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#4

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

David Weaver

Looks good!

The wood is so bright and clear!

Sycamore is common here (anywhere there's a ditch or creek close by), but I've never seen anyone do anything with it and I don't have access to take a log of it anywhere. Some of the trees are gigantic (6ft or more across at chest height) and would yield nice quartered boards.

Quartered stuff has been used on some limited run guitars in place of mahogany for backs and sides (acoustics).

What's the hardness like? like cherry or so? I've never worked it and have a board of "london plane" that I got at hearne years ago - it planes more like something between soft and hard maple and is entirely different even though the tree outsides look similar.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#5

Thanks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Thank you for the additional detail. I am not confident what you did would be robust enough for the desk I am making. The larger desk structure will put more stress on the leg to side joints.



For the desk in the picture I used sturdy joinery but it was hard to execute. Too many joints had to come together all at once and mate tightly. The top rail is dovetailed into the leg, the bottom rail is M&T into the leg and the panel is set in a dado in the leg and rails.

For the desk under construction, I am considering mortising the panel into the leg to provide a sturdy connection of the legs to sides, then simply fastening the top and bottom rail to the panel, with a tight fit between the legs. (the rails will not be structural components, merely decorative framing for the panel)

I am smitten by the appearance of a framed panel for the side of something with legs sticking beneath. This effect appears in student work from College of Redwoods. Would be nice to know how they do it.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#6

Impressions of Sycamore

Jim Matthews

It's softer than Poplar, harder than Butternut.

It saws straight and true, even resawing.

Planing a QS panel was best across the width, at an angle approaching 90°.

I still had lotsa tearout, even at a very fine shaving.

It produces a powdery sanding dust which fills in tear out, that is difficult to detect until shellac is applied.

I've had my fun, if you want some to make a Mandolin top from.

If should make good looking coasters, too.


img

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#7

The frame can be very stout.

Jim Matthews

"For the desk in the picture I used sturdy joinery but it was hard to execute. Too many joints had to come together all at once and mate tightly. The top rail is dovetailed into the leg, the bottom rail is M&T into the leg and the panel is set in a dado in the leg and rails."

Exactly why I explored this kludge.

I can keep two legs planar, but cutting additional (perpendicular and planar) mortices in the legs gave me pause. I considered cutting them after the front and rear pairs were assembled - but that approaches my 40" limit for handling in my shop.

The cross section of the frame gives it resistance to torsion - it's as strong as the weakest joint. The idea was to make two as similar as I'm able and plane them to match.

Fitting the panel afterwards makes the glue up a breeze - lotsa room for clamps!

I watched a video testing simple rub joints to destruction (MDF displays for retail) and was impressed that glue alone should be strong enough - the screws just help with alignment.

I hazard a SWAG that tightly press fit panels have a skin effect, on the assembly.

The real question is what happens to these panels over the Summer.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#8

Re: Impressions of Sycamore

David Weaver

It really looks fantastic with flecking on the surface. I'm inclined to find some sold here - I probably just haven't looked hard enough. I've seen it marketed as flooring before.

I thought martin's desire to buy some (i talked to a guy at one point who sold wood to martin, and they'd bought sycamore and locust from him - former should sound more like mahogany, and latter like rosewood) was a little odd - he was offended when I told him I'd find a $4k guitar with locust on the backs and side a little bit undesirable, but then he tried to sell me some low quality norway spruce for electric guitars at a really offensive price, too ($40 a board foot), so I felt less sorry about it!!

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#9

Sycamore as a commercial species

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It never shows up in hardwood market reports so there is no national market for it. My limited experience with it was warpage when air drying. A local factory bought it in 6/4 lumber and turned stair balusters. There are plenty of trees available and they tend to be tall, straight and free of lower branches. I saw 6/4 boards at this factory that were more than 36" wide (took two lumber rules end to end to scale them). It could be a good timber tree, but it must have some disadvantage that limits its appeal in the commercial market.

I turned some replacement balusters for the Barter Theater (drunken actor kicked them out). I found it turned nicely. I did not finish them.....probably painted.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#10

Re:  warpage

David Weaver

I've heard before that it has warpage issues commercially. in keeping with the discussion on the other side, the market for true dead on quartersawn wood that's sawn dead down the center of a tree is too small for most sawyers to ever cater to it.

The only instance I can think of is horizon making plane blanks of beech at 13.50 a board foot (Which I'd gladly pay as I've bought quartered 8/4 beech elsewhere with less care and a fair amount of it always twists because it's quartered, but the pith isn't centered relative to the saw path).

That may also explain why it's suitable for flooring. Nailed in place, it probably can't do much, and the flooring is already narrow to begin with.

Martin was buying thin resawn wood from the fellow I mentioned - I'm sure they buy a lot of wood and probably discard a lot of defective wood. The guy who told me about his sale of locust and sycamore was really full of himself, so he'd never admit that some of it will twist over time, but I'm sure it will. In the (really) old days a dealer, would've kept, dried and stored the wood and sold only the fraction that stayed straight seasonally to high end customers.

The trees here are as you say - giant clear sections. Some of them are straight and some are leaners (Since they grow near water and go toward the open area above the water if they're near enough to it). It may not be possible to get stable wood out of the leaners. The quartered look of it is dazzling, though.

These things occur to me as something that I might be able to do in retirement - sourcing my own wood. It's not practical now.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#11

Re: QS sycamore would make a stunning saw handle


Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#12

Re: QS sycamore would make a stunning saw handle

William Duffield

Aren't you confusing saw n. with saw v.t. :D ?

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#13

Sir William, I don't think John is ...

Raymond in Trenton

... confused :o) He's just always looking for that elusive saw handle.

More on topic:

Sycamore and London Plain Tree both turn well, so would assume it also planes easily. Fairly hard and not brittle. I nabbed some curbside LPT, but none of those pieces were applicable for furniture, maybe boxes. I cut it up for turning blanks. The quartered figure of LPT is very similar to sycamore, just not as spectacular. All my blanks moved, but none cracked.

Raymond

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#14

Re: Sir William, I don't think John is ...

johnv

London plane tree is a cross between native American Sycamore and an Oriental Sycamore so it stands to reason that it should behave similarly.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#15

Re: I'm Just Plane Confused

William Duffield

Could someone explain to me the difference between Acer pseudoplatanus and Platanus x acerifolia and maybe even Ficus sycomorus. :D

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#16

Re: I'm Just Plane Confused

Warren in Lancaster, PA

One of my Pennsylvania Dutch neighbors once said to me, "The German Bible says that Zacchaeus climbed a mulberry tree and the English bible says he climbed a sycamore tree. Now which is it?"

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#17

Re: Sir William, I don't think John is ...

John Aniano in central NJ

Hi Ray,

I'm always confused...

Yes, I have two of those London Planetree wood slabs you gave me a few years ago. Nicely QS and fully dry I think. Will someday make nice panel saw handles. Just barely big enough for a London pattern handle of London Planetree.

John

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#18

Re: Sir William, I don't think John is ...

Wiley Horne

Hi Raymond!

Whatcha been doing for the last 20 years? Great to see you back in the Woodcentral saddle.

Wiley

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#19

Re: I'm Just Plane Confused

William Duffield

Neither one. It is a species of fig, Ficus Sycomorus

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ficus_sycomorus

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xy86ak2fQJM&frags=pl%2Cwn

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#20

Re: I'm Just Plane Confused

Wiley Horne

Outstanding example, Warren. Both Bibles are right, says Wikipedia:

“Sycamore is a name which has been applied to several types of trees, but with somewhat similar leaf forms. The name derives from the ancient Greek συκόμορος (sūkomoros) meaning "fig-mulberry"......

Ficus sycomorus, the sycamore (or sycomore) of the Bible; a species of fig, also called the sycamore fig or fig-mulberry, native to the Middle East and eastern Africa......”

Wiley

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#21

Re: Sir William, I don't think John is ...

David Weaver

>>would plane easily<<

The stuff I got from hearne is a lot like hard maple - some bits of the billet are nice and others are contrary. It can be planed, though.

It has the kind of obnoxious resistance to heavier planing that hard maple does. Interesting that you say yours moved. I'd bought mine to make planes and never used it (Fortunately), as even though it was kiln dried and is quartered, it twisted pretty significantly over the next year or two.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#22

Re: Sir William, I don't think John is ...

William Duffield

Some wisdom I heard (probably at least third hand) from an old geezer who sawed the stuff, "If you tie it down it'll do fine; otherwise, it'll get up and walk away on you". I think I mentioned this a few weeks ago in another sycamore discussion thread. That coincides with another observation someone here made on problems with drying it, specifically that the bottom half of a stickered stack had dried straight, but the top half had contorted. I think the lesson here might be to weight it down with two or three times your usual weight (or tie it down) while you are air drying it.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#23

I have less of this than I thought I did...

David Weaver

...but I went and pulled out what remains of my plane billet - somehow it's now less than two moulding planes long (I may have cut trash off of it if some part of it was no good, and burned it).

But the dismaying part is the quartered billet that is now at least a decade old has twisted more in the last several years. This is unusual in my experience. It's not unusual for this kind of movement in the first few years, but after that - to see a significant subsequent amount is unusual. I guess I'll set it aside 5 more years.

So...badly behaved. Yes.

I planed a bit of my piece - it's quartered -really quartered. I'm determined to use it because I paid hearne something like $14 a board foot this and a bunch of other stuff (i know that's absurd, but when you're making moulding planes, it's not so bad).

The end grain - that shaving is end grain. If only the quartered face planed so nicely.


The face of the same billet. Lovely white color, but looks like hard maple and is contrary like quartered hard maple.


Not finish planed, just planed quickly.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#24

Re: I have less of this than I thought I did...

Sgian Dubh

"Lovely white color, but looks like hard maple and is contrary like quartered hard maple."

On a sort of slightly divergent note, it's remarkable sometimes how similar in appearance, and behaviour during working, is what we Europeans simply call sycamore (Acer pseudoplatanus) to hard or rock maple (Acer saccharum), native to North America. Once or twice, maybe more times, I've used both species in the same piece of furniture, although probably never directly next to each other as in a panel glue-up, and their appearance after polishing was pretty much identical. For instance, I recall from many years ago a legset made of hard maple, and the table top made of sycamore, or it may have been the other way around - can't recall for sure.

I suppose the physical similarities often to be seen in the two species aren't entirely surprising, both being Acers, but I suppose they could have evolved to be markedly different in their characteristics, being native to different continents and all the other differences in growing conditions, weather, climate, and so on. Slainte.

Re: Nightstand in QS Sycamore (handtools only)

#25

Since you asked about 'my movement'  :o)

Raymond in Trenton

Hi David,

I believe my pieces are too short to twist, or have notable twist. The longest is only 12"-12" long (with the grain). The movement made all the squares morph into trapezoids. It's still no issue for turning. The incentive was free wood for: 1 - practice/learn drying wood and 2 - teach myself turning. Don't have a moisture meter and I didn't think to weigh them. It's been just over 4 years. William is right, it moves, more so being kiln dried. All were anchorsealed.

Back in early 2016, construction in the neighborhood took down some big LPTs. Most were 4+ foot at breast height and all the sections were 18+ inches. I couldn't even roll some. I did find a small tree and the only section I was able to 'harvest' was a triangular "slice" 3/4 through the tree. At 3 ' wide and 12" (and down to 2") it was all I could do to get it into my 'pickup'. (a '94 Subaru plain Legacy station wagon!) All under cover of darkness.

Regards,

Raymond