Lots of shellac
David Weaver
someone gave me a gift certificate to ace a couple of years ago. What I ended up with was not finding much to buy, and got two cans of amber/orange shellac (they didn't have sanding sealer in stock at the time or it was some nutty price online compared to local...can't remember).
That boils down to being able to do this test many times without worrying about wasting anything other than time. I keep mahogany, rosewood and khaya offcuts for reasons I can't explain - rosewood is great, you can turn it, sand it, mix it with BLO and make gaps in infills disappear, etc. But the others, the kids usually marker or do something with - pointless to go on about that other than that I hate to throw such nice ribboned offcuts away.
Anyway, the short point about having all of this shellac is that I can explore another sanded surface today and we can see how it turns out. When you posted your comment, my train of thought before that was that the biggest difference is:
1) the planed surface has no residual on it, so the now common method of clogging the pores at the start isn't what I did (it would sand the wood). It takes a while before it stops taking in shellac. I could experiment further with thin coats to start and then starting the french polish process further after that
2) sanding, i can actually use the sandpaper to develop the cake and the initial process is very fast (the cake is there just from sanding - one could really get it out of the wood vacuuming a bunch and such, but I didn't do that because I wanted to speed the pore filling process and knew I could rub the cake into the pores and voids and get moving fast
For practical purposes finishing a guitar with khaya (which has gigantic pores), it's much easier to make this paste and use it.
I'll scrape the shellac off and do one more round, but removing the dust and not making a cake. For purposes of consistency, I may still use 220 grit with dust absolutely cleared so we can see just that difference and not two differences. I'm sure higher grit sanding looks better.
But in my head before your comment was how similar these two samples look in person when you can't compare them side by side. Once you have the pictures, you can see difference and the finish absorption by the planed piece made it look nicer. So I'm surprised that the comments so far emphasize the differences rather than to state how similar they look.
This test piece is vivid, too, which may mask some of the differences between planing and sanding.
The most useful thing to me so far is two fold:
* if rounding over a guitar (Back side or back and front detail) the guitar will still look great sanded if the wood is nice
* The planing of this wood is very fast. silica is the only challenge, but you can overcome it for the very final planing by sharpening one time and not taking any more thick shavings after the initial work is done. This only takes a couple of minutes. For a home shop person, to do coarse to fine sanding on this takes longer
Industrially, these come off of CNC, anything that's chipped heavily is tossed aside, probably for paint instead of a clear finish (it can be bodyfilled) and the good bodies are either very quickly linear sanded at high speed or go through a progressive disk or drum sander. So the fact that this doesn't scrape well because of the softness and sanding it a full progression over a large surface would be agonizing has zero commercial implication.
Most small hobby guitar makers buy a performax type drum sander because they don't have the skill to do much (they come to the hobby to make guitars, they don't come to hand tools, get good with them, and then make guitars later). I hate having those kinds of tools sitting around as they're expensive, they resell like crap, something never works quite as well as you want and the more floor space you lose, the more organized you have to be.
So, anyway, I'm surprised that the responses weren't more like "they look the same to me" and will do one with dust vacuumed out, even though I think most folks french polishing would like to push that dust into the pores and use it. It's actually far faster to do that than it is to use pumice and you don't wear a hole in a linen rubber like pumice does (I hate that).