Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

epoxy

Posts

epoxy

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

epoxy

Jack Guzman from Maine

I have never been comfortable using epoxy. There are too many options on the shelf where they sell it. I don't know what the benefits of 2 hour or 6 hour epoxy. Two part applicators ,sticks of solid stuff that you mix two colors together. All that stuff makes me not know what to buy.

I want to use epoxy to hold a ferrule on a handle and hold the shaft in the hole drilled in the handle of an awl. So what do I buy?

Re: epoxy

#2

justin ball

Re: epoxy

justin ball

The longer to harden, the stronger it is. Also, it will deal with heat better. Personal note: use 24 hour epoxy with motorcycle hot grips. One hour melts when the grips get hot. All mix in some ration. Stir well so each of the little molecules bond up. Comes in different thickness. Some mixes thin for casting and takes a long time to set so all the little bubbles come out. Even the ones you can't see. You can thicken epoxy with sawdust, wood flour. I use sand, bread flour, whatever. Just to get an idea what you're doing, go to the dollar store and buy a bunch of those syringe kits and popcicle sticks and go home and experiment. Use a dollar store ice cube tray to make castings of trapped pennies, pills, dead fly WHY. You'll catch on. Have fun.

Re: epoxy

#3

Re: epoxy

Joe shelton

Jack, for that kind of application, I've had good luck with JB Weld.

Re: epoxy

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

J B weld

Jack Guzman from Maine

I have some of that. Years ago riding long distance in a 54 chevy truck. The engine drive pulley broke. JB weld held it together long enough to get to a junk yard and get a new one.

Re: epoxy

#5

justin ball

Re: J B weld

justin ball

JB weld is fantastic stuff. And in the UK evo-stik metal. But it's black (or grey), and that stuff can go everywhere. They are all epoxies. I've used West System in boat building, but you don't need that volume. Only mix what you need. On no account should you ever dip a toothpick in mixed epoxy and then jam it in a lock and break off flush.

Re: epoxy

#6

Re: epoxy

John in NM

For general use, tightish fit use any 5 minute epoxy. I used to buy this stuff at Home Depot that was made by Pacer Technologies (a big super glue outfit) but they stopped carrying it.

I don't like all 5 minute products, the most recent I bought was a JB Weld brand and one component is so stiff that the two halves don't push out at the same rate, guaranteeing you an uneven mix and a tacky cure.

For filling large voids (like threads in a plumbing nut used as a ferrule) use a paste epoxy like either JB weld or PC11 marine epoxy paste (that is the one I like since it's whitish and transtint blends in making a good filler putty). For PC11 you can use denatured or isopropyl alcohol to clean up uncured epoxy (and it cures overnight).

Re: epoxy

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Voice of experience?


Re: epoxy

#8

justin ball

Re: epoxy

justin ball

Cheaper and quicker is using flour. West System sells bags of wood flour (really fine saw dust) but anything organic with fillaments works. So does micro beads (tiny glass balls) when weight is a premium. By this fineness, anything that bulks it up is good. I've used flour to bulk up dollar store epoxy syringes when doing a fillet joint for just about everything....skiffs to gramophone wood horns. Buy the hype when it's critical, the rest of the time...

Re: epoxy

#9

justin ball

Re: Voice of experience?

justin ball

Oh yeah. I love epoxy.

Re: epoxy

#10

Re: epoxy

William Duffield

I like West System. What I like besst about it is the documentation and the research it's developers have done on the applications I use it for. Justin is right, the pumps dispense it is much larger quantities than you would ever need to gluing tools to handles, whether you are making awls, turning tools or knives and machetes. I use two techniques to overcome the expensive waste. (1) I keep an epoxy list of everything that needs epoxy but I have set aside for later because I am too cheap to throw any away; (2) I mix small quantities in small graduated mixing cups that I get from Lee-Valley.

https://www.leevalley.com/en-us/shop/tools/supplies/applicators-and-cups/20009-mixing-cups

But even these seem to be a big waste if I'm only attaching one handle with a 5:1 ratio of resin to hardener.

Another good quality epoxy is T-88. It is made by System 3, and sold by Woodcraft. But, as John notes, for your application, as long as the joints are clean and fit together without wobble, and you haven't stripped the threads off the handle when installing the compression nut, most 5-minute epoxies from the home center will work fine.

Re: epoxy

#11

Re: epoxy

Wiley Horne

“...most 5-minute epoxies from the home center will work fine.”

Sir Wm.,

Do the 5-minute epoxies you refer to care whether the bond is wood:wood, wood:brass, brass:brass?

I’m like Jack when I look at all the different offerings.

Wiley

Re: epoxy

#12

Re: epoxy ***Links***

John Aniano in central NJ

Hi Jack,

I use three different types of epoxies. The classic "5-Minute" type, G-2 and G-Flex.

For doing the ferrules as you described, the 5 minute stuff is fine. Mix equal amounts by volume and I mix it on a "PostIt note" sheet using a clean wooden stirring stick. Just don't wait too long. Mix it fast, and get it where it needs to be quickly, especially if it's warm in the shop. I like the System Three 5 Minute product, but that's just my preference.

https://www.systemthree.com/products/quick-cure-5-minute-epoxy

For the strongest bonds, and on oily woods, I tend to use System Three G-2 epoxy. I mix it by weight, which I measure in grams with a small 650gram digital scale. Again, unless I need a lot, I measure and mix on a PostIt note pad sheet. For G-2 measure by weight, it's 1:0.44 ratio A: B. So, for example, for 3 grams of resin, you add 0.44 x 3 of hardener, or in this case, 1.3 grams. With G-2 you have maybe 1-1/2 hour maximum working time in normal shop temperatures.

https://www.systemthree.com/products/g-2-epoxy-glue

For some tough jobs where I want a bit of flexibility, I use West Systems G/Flex epoxy. Again, I measure by weight, but G/Flex is a 1:0.83 ratio. So, for 3 grams of resin, you measure 0.83 x 3 or ~2.5grams hardener. G/Flex sets up faster and is a darker tan color than G-2 epoxy's light clear/gray. Same PostIt note mixing regimen. Maybe 40 minutes working time with this epoxy in normal shop temperatures.

https://www.westsystem.com/specialty-epoxies/gflex-650-toughened-epoxy/

In all cases with epoxy, don't think "if I put additional hardener in, it will be a stronger bond" - WRONG! Extra hardener fails to fully combine with the resin and winds up acting like a plasticizer. Maybe someone more versed with chemistry can chime in, but I was instructed by the tech folks at both System Three and West Systems not to add extra hardener as it weakens the bond and makes the cured product less rigid. Best to measure by weight and you get reproducible results.

John

Re: epoxy

#13

Cheaper?

John in NM

At the small quantity, retail level, you get a couple oz. of a product like PC11 for about the same price as those 5 min syringe deals - those are usually less than an oz. Maybe you pay a buck more for twice as much.

Now if you use a lot of 5 min (or the even better liquid slow cure like 20 min or 2 hr), and have 8 oz bottles around, I would agree that mixing your own paste makes sense.

For a occasional user like me however, it makes sense to have both around when I need one or the other (Transtint also doesn't go into liquid epoxy easily in my experience - only if you use enough acetone and end up with an unpleasantly rubbery cure).

Re: epoxy

#14

General Schooling - Bill? *LINK*

David Weaver

is it necessarily true that the slower epoxies are stronger than the fast?

I'm not a regular user of epoxy, but do use it a couple of times a year. When I was putting in my kitchen, I used the glue-on gadgets that hold the sink to the countertop (undermount - you glue threaded rods and then lever against them - they work well, but most people would probably wish for something threaded into the counter -which is less strong than the glue type from what I've read).

I used a 5-minute loc tite epoxy which i later found has a 3500 psi rating. Not knowing any of that, I said to my dad (who was helping), I don't know if 5 minute epoxy will hold the sink up, but I'm also not looking to make a separate trip to go find some late at night.

Shopping later to add "slower and stronger" epoxy back to my shelf, I couldn't easily find anything slow that was significantly higher rated in terms of strength.

I put bill's name above because he often has looked at these things on a chemistry basis and would be more likely to say yay or nay based on something other than what I have (speculation).

And I realize that epoxy can mean a million different things (filled, not filled, industrial, marine, finishes, dental products, auto products) - i'm just referring to the two part unfilled epoxies like this:

https://www.ebay.com/c/14012036947

(note the drastic difference in psi rating vs. this)


Devcon fast epoxy

Re: epoxy

#15

Sounds a lot like soap...

David Weaver

..as you describe when the mix isn't right, what happens may not be what's expected.

I left a batch of shave soap about 5-10% short on oils once - not on purpose. I figured that it wouldn't have the margin oil in it (having a little bit extra to make sure all of the lye is converted - better to have a little extra oil than a little extra lye), but I was wrong. It was brisk, shall we say - with some unconverted lye in the soap.

I ended up using it as bath soap to avoid just throwing it away, but it had some extra sting vs. any other soap I've ever used.

Re: epoxy

#16

Re: epoxy

Philip F Duffy

HI Jack, A buddy who builds fishing rods for a living put me onto an epoxy that comes in two little tubs; mix the 2 into a smooth paste and apply. Simple safe and solid-- -but not so fast. It takes time but it also is very inexpensive because the amount you waste is Zero. The fishing rod web page is where I make my purchase. P.

Re: epoxy

#17

Universal adhesive considerations

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Adhesives fundamentals are quite simple:

1.The adhesive must wet the surface being bonded. Wet means spread like water on a perfectly clean piece of glass and not like water on a waxed car. In this regard water is an excellent adhesive for fastening glass together except.....

2. If the adhesive wets the surface this adhesive property can't get any better. Wetting reveals how strong the adhesive sticks to the surface being bonded. . However, if the mated surfaces are not molecularly close together, or the mated surfaces are subject to a force that will slide them apart, then the mechanical strength of the cured adhesive comes into play. Water fails as an adhesive for glass because the water itself is weak and the glass surfaces are easily slid apart. if the are separated by a thick water layer they are easily pulled apart. In each case the strength of the water is determines how well the glass surfaces are stuck together. But, if the glass surfaces have only a few molecules of water between then they can't be pulled apart ("stiction" when sharpening on a smooth stone). In this case wetting alone results in the force holding the surfaces together.

So, what makes an adhesive strong? Adhesive molecules don't stick to one another very strongly. However, the bonds holding these molecules together are boggling strong.

Picture a very long red rope and green rope. Rope doesn't stick to itself strongly so if the ropes are laying side by side they are easily separated. (molecule sticking to adjacent molecule analogy). Now take these 100' long ropes and tangle them together. Grab a red rope in one hand and green in the other. Pull. At first there is a bit of give and then the separation stops. To separate the ropes by force any further the tangled rope loops will need to be broken (analogy is breaking the strong bonds holding the adhesive molecules together.)

A strong adhesive will be one where the adhesive molecules are long and tangled like rope, and the longer the better. Epoxy curing is turning small molecules into big ones by chemical reaction of the curing resin. As cure proceeds it gets ever harder for the molecules to wiggle into the right position to hook together ideally.

Slower curing epoxy, all else being equal, allows more time for the molecules to wiggle into optimum position to make big, and hence, more tangled, stronger cured resin.

"Urethane" and "epoxy" describes the chemistry for hooking together (bonding together with chemical bonds) the small molecules into bigger more tangled, hence stronger molecules. These names provide no clue what chemicals are being hooked together. The names are near useless for predicting properties of the hooked together polymer.

Longer setting epoxy is probably stronger.

Re: epoxy

#19

Thanks, Bill..

David Weaver

..I was also wondering if there was something about the rating. I didn't know what the PSI rating stood for (how it's tested, does it imply something about hardness where a higher test number may still not fare better, etc).

I saw an item description for another epoxy that said the test strength is shear failure. I don't know how useful that is for me, but whatever the case, the sink has held up and I've gotten over my unsettled idea that gluing some pieces of non-threaded metal to the bottom of a counter top (then levering them) may result in trouble if the sinks are full of water and cast iron pots. I'm probably off in their actual strength by a large factor.

Interestingly, one of the issues that I had with the epoxy (so I thought) was that the instructions for the parts suggested putting them onto a blob of epoxy and making sure that they were within good coverage (which I'd envison as encased in epoxy). The 5 minute epoxy leveled very easily and I was unhappy with that. I may have had it backwards as the flowout may have created a better bond.

Whatever the case, I attribute this curiosity to overanalysis and not that important and wouldn't expect that any decent epoxy would fail how I'm using it. In woodworking, I've never even considered it (but have had joints fail when they get wet repeatedly - like gluing stones to a wooden base).

At any rate, thanks for the quick response.

Re: epoxy

#20

how it cures

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Curing" is a chemical reaction A+B to yield cured epoxy. The most useful thing learned in a chem class is that a whole A molecule reacts with a whole B molecule. It doesn't happen that 2/3 of a molecule can do anything. If you have 3 A molecules and 2 B molecules and they are allowed to react there will be

2 A-B epoxy molecules formed and one A molecule left unreacted.

The curing chemistry is like building a long train (polymer) from individual cars with one exception. Coal cars will only couple to tanker cars. Coal cars can not couple to themselves. So, as long as you have an equal number of coal cars and tanker cars you can build a train as long as you want if you have the time. But, if there are more coal cars than tanker cars when all the tanker cars are hooked up tanker- to- coal, there will be coal cars left over.

Long molecules (the train/polymer) get tangled and become strong. Small molecules can't tangle and they are not strong.

Left over hardener molecules weaken the cured structure and can make it rubbery.

The polymer we call cellulose acetate is hard and brittle. Dissolve 25% of a small molecule into it and it becomes flexible. This mixture is what we know as the flexible backing of Scotch tape.

In the case of epoxy somebody knows how many coal cars and tanker cars respectively are in a squirt each of resin and hardener. Following directions results in them being equal in number.

Re: epoxy

#21

crosslinker...

David Weaver

...is this the same concept (generally) as the cross linker additive in water based finishes? To extend the length of molecules so that they can tangle more completely resulting in higher hardness?

(I've sprayed target with and without crosslinker, and then sanded or buffed them to a gloss. The difference is incredible with the crosslinker).

There must be some cross/commonality with this and the high build finishes with isocyanates in them - well, there is or isn't, not must - but a wild guess of mine. I haven't used those again since painting a car hood with them and having no clue how toxic they are. The result was a finish that created overspray that was very difficult to even scrape off of glass.

Re: epoxy

#22

cross linking

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Cross linking chemically links together what ever molecules are present, in the typical case a low molecular weight (smaller length) polymer. The result is an insoluble material (might soften it with solvent but never dissolve it), and typically a harder material, and maybe a tougher material........ for reasons of more entanglement, and other reasons that are too complicated to readily explain with my pedestrian typing skills. Cross linking makes the resultant structure more rigid.

Often this linking chemistry uses the formation of urethane bonds, or in the case of epoxy, bonds generated by the epoxy molecules in the clear component. The naming is Byzantine. In the case of "urethane" the name says what kind of chemical bond forms. In the case of "epoxy" the name says what kind of chemical is used to make the bond. The bottom line is that names in finishes and adhesives are near useless for any predictive purpose.

Re: epoxy

#23

Re: epoxy

William Duffield

I'm not sure how to answer your question, since I haven't done any in vitro testing of these joints. Also, I can't remember any instance I actually epoxied brass to brass. I've epoxied brass to M2 stainless steel and C4 carbide, wood to brass and, it goes without saying, wood to wood. None of my tool joints have been particularly high stress, because I try to use the largest brass ferrule that will work with the size of the handle, to retain as much wood inside the ferrule as possible. In one of these awl threads, I provided a link to Doc Green's website on how to choose a ferrule and tool mortise depth to minimize splitting the wood handle. It is a good reference source for anyone using a ferrule for strengthening the attachment of a handle to the shaft of a hand held tool, be it chisel, awl, screwdriver, turning tool or carving gouge.

Also, I make sure my fit is not so tight that the epoxy is completely scraped off one surface or the other. I am also careful to not apply so much clamping pressure that the epoxy is squeezed from the joint. To the contrary, if I know that both surfaces are wetted by the epoxy and all the air pockets are eliminated, I avoid using clamps whenever possible. Sometimes, the joinery or gravity or a small weight or even the weight of the tool in the handle will be enough to hold the joint in place until the epoxy kicks. Unlike the water-borne glues that we use for joining wood to wood, epoxy doesn't shrink appreciably as it cure, so very high clamping pressures are not needed.

There are other techniques to increase the odds of a sufficiently strong epoxy joint. The most important is to thoroughly clean all surfaces. For metals and oily tropical hardwoods, I use acetone to remove the oils and other contaminants. Compressed air or a vacuum and brush remove sawdust. For additional joint strength (belt and suspenders :D ) I will sometimes add some "tooth" to the metal surfaces with coarse sand paper or diamond file.

When building a prototype tool, i have sometimes left the tenon a little too large or chosen an inappropriately brittle wood. That has resulted (double crud! :( ) in stripping its threads when installing the brass nut. For expediency, I have resorted to a quick application of cyanoacrylate instead of epoxy, and even this has not failed when i tested the tool. That is only for testing "proof of concept"--I don't trust superglue for long term applications.