Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Stirring the smoothing vs. sanding pot..

Posts

Stirring the smoothing vs. sanding pot..

#1

Stirring the smoothing vs. sanding pot..

David Weaver

...OK, i'm not really stirring it. Bill and Richard and I have had an offline (online, different online?) discussion via email about this because once again, I can be goaded into testing almost anything. IF there's some fruit, then I can be goaded into testing it and really wasting my time.

But in this case, there are two reasons that I like finish planing:

1) I can do it quickly. If i ever have to sand something, I can generally plane well enough on flat surfaces to sand with 220 grit and have zero defects

2) I like the way it looks while I'm doing it, and it doesn't excite asthma, burn through consumables or get a layer of dust everywhere

But I have to admit, that I can only get relatively minor differences in surfaces on test pieces that I've done.

So, I'm laying down the challenge to everyone - if you're good at finish planing, as I consider myself to be - I'm not good at furniture making, but good at finish planing - do some A/Bs with pieces to see if you can get a solid significant difference in a really well finished piece with 220 grit sanding vs planing (Scrape a third if you want) and then apply something like a french polish (a preference of mine for this kind of testing as you can get a dry-ish gloss finish on a test board in 20 minutes - no BS faffing around with bits that re-absorbed and sanding)

I may remember to start building a small library of different pieces, but this isn't a test I'm going to undertake now.

My initial conclusion - if I'm looking for something out of wood (like the nuance in this spruce, which is immensely pleasing to me and an actual guitar buyer might not care about), it seems like the result is about 90% wood selection and about 10% planing.

https://i.imgur.com/7ujtx3j.jpg

The big challenge to me then is getting some contrast with a gloss finish like a french polish on a guitar like this - this has the lightest possible padded coats of polyurethane so that I could prove that it doesn't have small tearout in it, but it'll get planed off when this guitar is built as something will get dented or scratched, and I'd prefer a little bit of warmth to the finish - polyurethane is seriously lacking in that compared to shellac.

So, anyway, I've failed in really coming up with a big difference under finish that I think most other than me would care about -at least thus far.

If anyone wants to join this "open kernel" effort, the A/B comparison has to be the same board and the same finish (the wood type doesn't matter) and more than something like oil and wax (if you prefer something simple like a couple of coats of poly, that would be a good test since it's common and practical). It's not a matter of proving that you can make a board look the same sanding and planing, but a matter of finding situations where there *is* a difference.

I don't wax much to a finish, but I guess if you can show a significant difference there, have at it.

The first few pencils that I made had some tearout from glue pulling wood out at the seam (got that figured out pretty quickly). I sanded the side of one of them and it turned out that the depth of the sanding ridges telegraphed and built french polishing them for longer than I would've worked through. On furniture, you wouldn't be trying to get a french polish type finish in 5 minutes, and I don't suspect anyone else here is trying to make pencils, though I'm sure someone who has turned more than a half a dozen pens will tell me how stupid it is.

Re: Stirring the smoothing vs. sanding pot..

#2

Reason Three.

Joe shelton

It's pleasant and rewarding to do.

Re: Stirring the smoothing vs. sanding pot..

#3

Re: Reason Three.

David Weaver

Certainly a good one.

Re: Stirring the smoothing vs. sanding pot..

#4

Re: Stirring the smoothing vs. sanding pot..

Steve Voigt

I'll try to get something posted in a couple days, though I think the only finishes I have on hand right now are Tru-Oil and Polymerized Tung Oil. I'll have to see what I can find.

I will say though, that I'm not surprised that you found the difference subtle. In the back and forth of the previous thread, I never argued for finishing straight off the plane as being important to me. That's because (1) I think the difference is generally small and not worth getting too worked up over; (2) most pieces (whether furniture, instruments, tools, architectural work, or whatever) will have surfaces that can't be finished by a plane; and (3) sometimes it's more time efficient to clean up with some fine sandpaper.

Just to clarify, what I argued for was basically some level of competence in handplaning. I think you did the same, Dave. One ought to be able to plane well enough that a very quick cleanup with 220, 320, or higher is sufficient. And if no cleanup is necessary, that's even better, if only for the purposes of saving time, avoiding dust, and avoiding drudgery.

Re: Stirring the smoothing vs. sanding pot..

#5

Re: Stirring the smoothing vs. sanding pot..

David Weaver

100% agree with all of that. If I have to sand, it's preferable to be able to do it after planing as well as possible (and faster, and less dusty, and cheaper - I know the cheaper is insignificant, but it's one less than to run a sheet short on) - I keep PSA roll because it's handy for all kinds of things and seems to last a lot longer than paper backed paper, and cost less.

Scraping - same. This is something I"ll french polish to see if it makes a difference after planing vs. sanding.

https://i.imgur.com/gZ9fWv1.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/g1yUQt5.jpg

The dents left in that in the center are sort of a spoof between Bill and I - I didn't send this picture and say anything about them, but why it's easy to do a quick french polish on this (quartered khaya - lighter weight and softer variety) and know I'll do it again - I roughed this body out and set it aside with some others. No clue where it got those dents or if they were in the larger blank before cutting it out.

In a commercial shop, these get roughed out by a CNC and someone unskilled runs a linear sander over them. Done. Nobody cares as long as the pore filling is done completely and the gloss is thick. The only remaining skilled worker is the guy on the buffing machine (Who gets something on the order of 20% of the total labor time just to buff after someone else has already done wet sanding.

Often what comes up is how irrelevant planing is because - well, look at the commercial process.

I don't own the commercial machines and if this is bound on both sides (Which it will be) it will allow for a plane to finish on both sides with the edge being scraped and burnished to match as close as possible with finish uptake. It takes very little time (less than 10 minutes for both faces, somewhat more for the edge). The french polish makes for a less dead guitar - even in electrics. As far as I know, the only paying use of french polish is on classical guitars (which are anemic in terms of sound output and still benefit at the higher price levels from as little finish as possible).

At any rate, I suspect not much difference planed vs. sanded on this because of the strong ribboning, but it'll add to the data pool. Planing it rather than scraping it and sanding it is a dream, even though it doesn't plane like a dream.