Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Quilt display Red Birch and Tupelo

Posts

Re: Quilt display Red Birch and Tupelo

#26

Re: A couple more

Sgian Dubh

"Speaking of arrises, I also did not understand the comment "what else but abrasive paper would be used to remove arrises." If you are talking about breaking an edge, I would normally use a plane, often complemented by a chisel."

I think I understand what you're getting at in the earlier part of your post - a difference in appearance where, if I understand it correctly, essentially where a rounded or softened surface meets a flat surface. Whether planed or sanded aren't you essentially describing a situation where the intersection between the rounded surface and the flat surface is at an obtuse angle, anywhere between roughly 100º+ and perhaps 160-170º?

In that situation there's unlikely to be a sharp corner (arris) such as that which occurs when two planes meet at 90º or less. What you described regarding breaking such an edge with a plane or a chisel suggests you're creating a chamfer rather than a round over. Each approach, chamfer or round over, has its place, depending upon requirements, preferences, client specs, and so on. Slainte.

Re: Quilt display Red Birch and Tupelo

#27

Re: Quilt display Red Birch and Tupelo

Steve Voigt

Richard, I think we inhabit different woodworking planets. I wouldn't continue to plane a tabletop with a nick in the blade (I thought earlier you were talking about nicks in the surface, not the cutter). If I had a nick in the iron, I would sharpen it. I wouldn't try to finish plane a panel that was twisted or bowed; I would flatten it with a large plane before smoothing it. If I had to sand with 180 grit after planing, I would conclude that something was wrong with my planing technique, or setup, or sharpening.

As I suggested before, I'm not a purist or an anti-sandpaper zealot. But there is great value and efficiency in being able to produce finished surfaces from edge tools--including but not limited to bench planes. If someone is unable to do that, a reevaluation of one's technique seems in order.

Re: Quilt display Red Birch and Tupelo

#28

Re: Quilt display Red Birch and Tupelo

Sgian Dubh

That we inhabit different woodworking worlds may be true, Steve, but that's what makes participation in forums such as this interesting: on my part there are all sorts of characters and their experiences to assimilate. I don't know how you make a living, but my background is primarily in the furniture industry as a maker and designer, workshop manager and business owner in the past, but also now in a small way as, in what I suppose is a mostly semi-retired self-employed freelance woodworker. But I also have experience leading and teaching in higher education furniture design and make programmes. I've been knocking wood around seriously for money since late 1973, and was doing similar as a hobby for about five or six years before that.

So, a wee nick in a plane blade during the last few passes over a panel is nothing to break a sweat over - a quick sand fixes it.

Smallish panels that develop a certain amount of warp after glue up and bringing down to thickness on machines followed by storage aren't going to be machined further to get them flat again, because they're already at their required thickness. Nor will I do additional flattening for a solid wood table top that's perhaps 8' long by 40" or so wide with a bit of pretty inconsequential warp. I just find a way to get the show surface(s) prepped ready for polishing, and if that means a bit creative clamping on to a flat surface over some judiciously placed spacers (shavings, for instance) on the underside of the panel, it gets done.

It's all in a day's work, and in the end very few solid wood panels just float about unrestrained so that they have the chance to warp significantly. Most panels are largely restricted from warping willy-nilly by the structure they're part of, e.g., rails and bearers restrict the warping tendencies of table tops, panels in cabinets are held in place by a restraining structure of some sort, such as frame and panel, internal parts such as runners/kickers, rails, corner joinery, pilasters, back panels, etc.

Like you, I'm no purist at working wood. When I'm engaged in the money making side, which has been the case most of my working life, it's pretty much do whatever needs doing to get the thing out of the door at the right quality to make a profit (or at least pay my wages without getting it in the neck from my employer), followed by dispatching the invoice, and getting the client to pay on time, occasionally a little bit tricky that last bit.

I truly enjoy setting up and using hand planes that work really well to work wood, right up to completing the prepping stage, if there's time. But when I'm faced with getting something like forty or fifty solid wood table tops machined, glued up, prepped and polished in time for a new restaurant to open, I tend to go with whatever does the job most efficiently to match whatever quality is deemed acceptable by whoever sets those standards.

Over the decades I've had to knock out quite a bit of horrible stuff in too little time. I made whatever it was, moved the piece(s) of crapola on to whoever wanted/needed it, happily forgot about it within minutes or hours, and never thought about it since, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Quilt display Red Birch and Tupelo

#29

Smooth planing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I don't know how you make a living

Steve and I are professional woodworkers. We do not teach woodworking for a living. We do not write books, or sell videos, or give workshops.

If you cannot plane a board well enough that sanding would be a serious waste of time and produce a serious degrading of the surface, it is nothing to be ashamed of. Many woodworkers are in the same boat. On the other hand, a lack of this skill is not something to brag about as you have done.

Re: Quilt display Red Birch and Tupelo

#30

Re: Smooth planing

Sgian Dubh

"Steve and I are professional woodworkers."

Well, that makes three of us then. I'll not bother responding to the rest of what you said. Slainte.