Re: Quilt display Red Birch and Tupelo
Sgian Dubh
"I know this is a constant thorn in the side of people who don't plane to finish, ... I lot of us finish with planes because we like it- the way it feels, the way it looks, the way the finish absorption is a little different."
But there's the thing, David. In the 60s and early 70s pretty much all my work was hand planed, from initial wood preparation, including sawing to length, width and thickness, dimensioning with things like wooden and metal jack and try planes through to prepping with smoothing planes and sometimes block planes prior to polishing. Typically there was scraping and sanding involved too using, back then, antediluvian and now long gone glass paper. I was young, from pre-teen to early adulthood, and didn't have access to, or wasn't allowed to use any big machines.
Then I began my training and work in the furniture industry, and much of the grunt work was taken over primarily by heavy duty three phase machinery, plus all sorts of other equipment and power tools such as routers, nail guns, dovetailors, dowelling machines, morticers, tenoners, screw guns, inline sanders, etc.
But, to this day, the bulk of my prepping prior to applying a finish is undertaken at least in part with hand planes. For that I generally have three smoothing planes set up for this task - an old Spiers set a bit coarse to knock off remaining planer ripple and to get below any planer tear out, a Stanley set somewhat finer, and a Clifton set finer again for the last bit of cleaning up. There's the usual thing of sharpening each plane as needed, of course. But there still quite commonly comes a point where a bit of scraping is required, and some sanding to remove the arrises and for a bit of general final surface preparation.
It's rare indeed when I'll say a surface is prepped straight off a plane, perhaps only on a narrow edge of a piece, or maybe the wide face of a rail, something like that. But I can't think of any large surface I've worked on over the last forty five or so years, such as a top for a dining table, desk, etc, that I've polished straight off a plane, simply because that surface always needed at least a little final prepping with abrasive paper to take out at minimum the odd plane knick, or a bit of ripple, or something, plus what else but abrasive paper would be used to remove arrises?
So, in a piece of furniture I've made where there has actually been a few narrow edges, or fairly narrow faces of wood that had nothing more than planing to prep, and other parts of the piece that were planed, perhaps scraped as well, and sanded, I've never been able to spot any difference through an applied finish in the quality or characteristics of the prepared surface underneath that polish.
And, of course, I've prepped many a surface where a hand plane got nowhere near the job - all prep work would have been undertaken with such kit as wide platen oscillating sanders, drum sanders, hand held belt sanders, in-line pneumatic sanders, finish sanders, random orbital sanders, hand sanding, and so on.
So, that takes me back to my earlier question. Some say there's an obvious difference in the characteristics of the prepped wood, whether planed only, or perhaps planed and sanded, or surfaces prepped where a plane has never been near the surface.
What is different? Can the differences be described and quantified? Slainte.