Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

Posts

Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

#1

Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

Joe shelton

I have some Blue Spruce butt chisels that I've been saving for nice dovetails. They have a distinct secondary bevel unlike any edge I've used.

Since the new chisels are 'on deck' for something special, I just sharpened a couple of lesser bench chisels, and was playing around with newsprint.

The butt chisels couldn't slice or sustain a cut in it.

Now I have a whole new realm to explore. Sure hope I don't die anytime soon. Heaven knows what else I might need to learn...

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

#2

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

David Weaver

the butt chisels didn't, but your regular chisels did?

I'd imagine some of those chisels have a very steep secondary bevel to prevent getting an immediate email from beginners who put the chisel out of the box right into wood.

LN's cap irons used to be (still are?) a low angle. A friend of mine polished the blunt bit off of them and had a nice polish. They're soft, maybe 30 degrees.

The first cut he took with his plane dented the cap iron deeply.

he called LN and they said "you're not supposed to prepare them that way" or something to that effect, but at the time, there were no instructions with the planes. As LN does, they sent him another cap iron free of charge. It would've been better to include instructions, but they know more about their business than I do. You can still set him off (he's bought about 10 LN products) if you ask him about a $350 plane with no instructions. In his view, he believes they don't want to include information because they'll sell the DVDs separately (he's bought many of theirs) and would cut into sales if they included a mini DVD with just a few damage preventing instructions.

(my last plane from them, the only one I still have, came with some kind of instructions - things may have changed - this friend caused said problem about 14 years ago - I don't need the instructions, of course)

At any rate, without knowing how big the microbevel is and how steep, I'd guess it's easy manufacturing to avoid comebacks.

new razors sometimes come like that, too (yuck) and so do commercial blades (not so yuck, if they work, it's not like it needs to be sharpened off).

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

#3

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

Joe shelton

Yes, the pedestrian chisels and an old drawknife did, the butt chisels would not. And I'm not complaining about it. I need to use them as intended, and not draw conclusions based on what they'll do with paper.

Funny you mention instructions. I think those chisels came with, at least, explanations about the bevel.

If that secondary bevel is a good idea, I'm in trouble. I'll end up buying a honing guide.

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

#4

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

David Weaver

They're A2 if I recall correctly. They may need a little bit of additional stropping on leather, depending on what you like to use to sharpen.

If you like to use something like an arkansas stone, sometimes funny things happen, but the sharpness level after a little bit of stropping on bare leather if you use synthetic stones - that should be similar once the geometry is matching.

There is a razor sharpener and maker (i'm long detached from the razor community now, there's too few people there interested in looking at factual stuff) who sort of skips the whole regular razor sharpening thing with finish stones (not exactly tools, but similar principle) by using a super fine media and putting tap on the back of a straight razor. This creates a tiny microbevel. From what I hear, it works pretty well. If it gets too blunt because someone chases it steeper, then it won't work well.

If the bevel on those chisels (primary) is long and then, they need a little bit of help, but a better experience using them would be had if you just lift off the bevel a little bit and roll the edge some as you're sharpening. When it gets to be too big (the rolled bevel), then decide how you want to proceed (refresh the primary or move over to what you like to do).

A2 behaves mostly normally, but i found years ago that a washita will pull bits and pieces off of an edge leaving little voids and the resulting edge will never feel that sharp (leaves a dull surface with a plane, too - never knew what it was until I looked at it under a microscope).

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

#5

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

Wiley Horne

Hi Joe,

Were you expecting these chisels to arrive with final hone? I almost never see that. I just checked an LV PMV11 plane blade that arrived today—nice bevel on it, and terrifically flat face, but not sharp. And LV is very particular about tool finish.

Even high-end Japanese chisels require final hone. They arrive with a perfect bevel, and sorta kinda edge, but not a final hone on them.

Is there some instruction with them? The only thing I can think of is that, since they’re A2, maybe Dave has already put on a 33 or 35 secondary bevel. LN suggests the user do this, but they ship them at 30 IIRC. Even if this speculation is correct, that doesn’t mean they would have final hone. You might contact Dave and find out directly from him what he suggests.

If they were mine, I’d prepare them with a hollow grind and use the most acute final bevel the steel will take, _in your application_ (emphasis added).

Wiley

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

#6

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

Joe shelton

Thanks, Wiley. Let me reiterate - I'm not upset about or concerned with my Blue Spruce chisels. The only thing I've done to them so far is to remove the gummy protective glob at the working end. The only thing I've tried to cut was a piece of newspaper, and I didn't push them hard at that.

I'm excited about them, and I'm going to learn why they are prepared as they are, and whether I like that approach.

But, truth told, I kinda like a hollow grind that goes close to an edge and sets up a great way to hone.

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

#7

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

Joe shelton

Well, dammit. I thought the only new wrinkle was going to be a honing guide, and now you're telling me my Arkansas stones are problems, too.

Does the fine India I started with today qualify as a synthetic?

I am learning, not extolling, but most of the sharpening I do starts with the fine India and goes through three grits of Arkansas stones. And I've come to like finishing on a strop. Even the drawknife today, which I had struggled with previously, was very good after the strop.

And I acknowledge that none of the blades I tuned up today was A2, so if you're talking only about A2 on those stones, I have no rejoinder.

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

#8

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

David Weaver

I don't know about every oilstone, but I can tell you that washitas will not agree with A2 and will tear little bits out of the edge. somewhere on a dead computer, I have pictures of an edge after a black arkansas and a washita. The same thing didn't happen on black or trans ark stones. Would it happen on a soft ark? I don't know.

I don't think it'll be an issue on a fine india - I don't remember it being a problem.

If you sharpen and sharpen and sharpen the A2 and it's not leaving a polished surface on whatever you chisel, that'll probably be the problem.

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

#9

A short review of Blue Spruce Dovetail Chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have some Blue Spruce butt chisels that I've been saving for nice dovetails. They have a distinct secondary bevel unlike any edge I've used.

Since the new chisels are 'on deck' for something special, I just sharpened a couple of lesser bench chisels, and was playing around with newsprint.

The butt chisels couldn't slice or sustain a cut in it.

Now I have a whole new realm to explore. Sure hope I don't die anytime soon. Heaven knows what else I might need to learn...

Joe, I've been using the Blue Spruce dovetail chisels since Dave Jeske first began making them 15 years ago. In fact, the 3/4" (which is the largest size I have) was made to my specifications, and then this went into production. What is unique to Blue Spruce are the 1/8" thick blades which, together with the hollow ground, minimal lands, produces a light and nimble chisel.

The fishtail chisels here are the nicest I have used (and I have a few).


All the blades on mine are hollow ground at 30 degrees, and then freehand honed at this angle. Generally I take them to Sigma 13000 grit and then remove any wire vestiges on Veritas green compound (on hardwood).


While these chisels do not hold an edge as long as Veritas PM-V11 or Koyamaichi white steel, they get very sharp - as sharp as any other blade I have - and hold this long enough. They are also tough enough to hold an edge long enough when chopping. They do not chip. I have never felt a need to grind to a higher angle, or that 30 degrees was too high to pare.

Well balanced chisels with some of the nicest handles. These are African Blackwood, and have stood up to being used with a UHMW-faced mallet (in other words, respectfully!)

Use them like there is no tomorrow.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

#10

Re: what derek says about abrasive..

David Weaver

..is the other side of the coin. I didn't want to go on at length with what I found under the microscope, but the pictures of all steels looked similar if the finishing is done with a fine synthetic combination like derek is talking about.

I didn't want to go on at length because i don't want to suggest buying something to fix a maybe problem that may not occur.

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

#11

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

Joe shelton

This exposed some of my misunderstanding (I've got lots of that) about natural stones.

Previously, I'd thought 'washita' and 'Arkansas stone' meant the same thing. Glad you prompted me to look it up.

I don't have any washita. For the moment, I use fine India, soft Arkansas and hard Arkansas in an IM313, then black Arkansas in a small size. I plan to get a translucent stone, if only from curiosity.

Sounds to me as if the A2 on washita is sort of a 'catch'. My A2 stuff does well with my stones. Especially when I do my part.

Re: Maybe I need to learn more than I'd thought

#12

I like this philosophy

Jim Matthews

Buy things you enjoy using.

Spend it ALL.