Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

Posts

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#26

I have to admit...

David Weaver

...that I haven't ever looked at the super surfacer recommendations, but if they are in line with what I've found, that's a good thing, i'm glad to see that's the case.

I'm often not as good at seeking information and using it as I am screwing around and figuring it out the hard way.

(there's always a chance I saw those recommendations and commented on them in the past without remembering them, too).

While the difference for trying work is pretty obvious using one plane right after another, I don't know if I would've noticed it in isolation.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#27

Re: before this gets too long (already did)..

bridger berdel

I've had a hundred or two of chisels to set up and use, ranging from new cheapies to a variety of vintage. A lot have come in pretty rough condition, so I've gotten comfortable grinding. I have found that a long shallow primary is a good way for me to discover where I want to end up, bevel-wise. I'm generally chasing past a bit of back bevel, whether from some past sharpening error or just wear, so the whole tip end gets a reshape. The long flat shallow bevel will fail soon, giving me some info about the steel and the rehone at the tip is quick and easy. Soon the angle of repose as it were reveals itself. I think i end up with something similar to your rolled edge just from my freehanding on stones. I haven't buffed an edge in years- I'll have to pull out that stuff and give it a bit of a play.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#28

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

David Weaver

No go for planes, though until I mentioned it here, I hadn't even considered it because of the clearance issues. It feels like a very sharp plane iron with not enough relief. Which it probably is. And it's chisels where I'm looking for a free lunch, but I figured I'd try it on a smoother, anyway.