Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

Posts

studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#1

studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

David Weaver

(long message below - the gist of it is that I think I can manipulate the edge of a tool a little bit - like the last half thousandth - to work better than just sharpening a final bevel off to a point - in regard to knives and chisels - plane blades, I haven't experimented with this - using a buffer to finish the very edge and mute the thinnest part)

one of the things that I'm interested in from a toolmaking standpoint is figuring out where an edge fails, and then seeing if I can come up with a way to stop it without compromising something else.

I get that most people don't really think of something like this beyond just changing edge angles or sharpening equipment or tools, but I'm looking at this a level deeper and have been off and on for years.

Back story here - years ago, I was looking for that kind of one-media setup that works like the washita does, but across some harder steels, so I ordered some cheap wax bars from mcmaster carr that are 5 micron particle size alumina. These turned out to be too much when used on MDF or anything else - the edge just isn't very good - 5 micron is too harsh and a wire edge is created that's pretty toothy once removed. It's not damage, just deep scratches, so I set that bar aside other than to use it to remove deburring wheel scratches. It works well for that on a hard buff.

But over time with the little thin knives that I make, I've learned that the failure when it occurs is right at the edge. In knife sharpening, there's a lot of static from people who don't really know what they're talking about and then there are a few people who actually experiment with purpose. One of them is cliff stamp. Some of what he does has nothing to do with woodworking, but I appreciate that he's always curious to see something, work with it, and be able to describe what's going on - whether it's making the point that uniform wear is a desirable thing, especially combined with sharpening things, or that really inexpensive knives with better geometry outperform chunky very expensive boutique knives in actual cutting tests.....

..at any rate, he put a video up at one point where he briefly discussed moving the failure point in an edge (and without changing the cutting characteristics of a knife much, because he was using a fairly thin bevel knife). This equates to having a knife fail only due to wear, and not due to deflection or chipping.

This is a nice thing to have in chisels and shop knives, too. In planes, I always chase something steeper than others seem to (measured my plane iron finished edges around 33, and I've never shipped something to someone and had them complain about short edge life - rather the opposite happens sometimes, where I'll get a follow-up email about an edge not holding up as well once it's resharpened. It's not the steel, but the geometry of what's going on at the edge).

This morning, I was sharpening my cheap pocket knife with the usual regimen (deburring wheel, then buff) and I thought about it - what I've come to over the years is shifting the failure point of knife steels away from the very edge, because deflection and chipping end things quickly, but they also create a lot of extra follow up work. The strange part of this is that as long as I make the knife itself thin, the buffed over edge and its performance in cardboard is always *sharper* and easier through the cut than edges I sharpen by hand. This is with that 5 micron wax buff stick - it's fantastic in a buff even though it's too harsh on a hard surface.

So, I figured I'd try this on a paring chisel vs. 1 micron diamonds on steel. What the edge looks like under the microscope with the buff (judicious use is key - to only change geometry where it's desirable) is more refined than the diamond edge, and ease through wood is better. The failure point of the very edge has been modified to slight rounding, just like a strop does to a razor, but at steeper angles, and the pairing resistance through end grain cherry isn't any higher, but the surface left behind is even better than off of the fine abrasive. The crux is this - while the chisel is no worse paring in a relatively hard (for cherry) piece of cherry, it never sheds anything and leaves visible lines whereas this will eventually happen with a hand sharpened edge.

Under the scope, this tiny rounding is less than a thousandth of an inch long, and only on the bevel side, but it's eliminated the thing that I really hate - edge failure that's due to anything other than wear, seemingly without compromising anything like a full steeper bevel would. And with the buffer, it's easier to apply and with better refinement than I can do by hand.

I think my chisel sharpening regimen is about to change from washita to finish stone to washita to buff.

I've long done this when mortising plane bodies - round over the last bit of an edge on a chisel so that the corners and the edge are protected a little bit. It improves the ability to mortise quickly by a factor of ten without driving the wedging resistance of the chisel through the roof.

With the little knives, in the event that the geometry ever gets a little wonky, I just walk the knife over to the tri hone and reset everything in a minute or two, but I cannot deny that in that case (and probably with chisels now) this may be functionally better as a finishing routine as long as one can manage to use it properly (a beginner would just blunt a whole chisel).

There is some version of this that applies to cap irons in a heavy cut, too - maybe something on that at some point another time, but the short version of that is that the very low angle cap irons that ward and matheison made always work better in a brisk cut than a more modern emmerich type that's highly sprung and more blunt.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#2

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

bridger berdel

What are you using as a buff?

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#3

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

Wiley Horne

David,

Very interesting post. I wonder what is the difference between your buffed edge versus an edge with, say, a 2-degree microbevel? In other words, is the essential effect of the buffer to create a steeper bevel, or is it to create a more compact edge by tearing away tags and unsupported ‘tooth’.

I look forward to extending this discussion to cap irons.

Wiley

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#4

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

Steve Voigt

I'll echo Wiley in asking: is it the geometry, or is it the medium? If it's the geometry, it should be replicable on a stone.

the very low angle cap irons that ward and matheison made always work better in a brisk cut than a more modern emmerich type that's highly sprung and more blunt.

I don't understand what you mean here. Spring (which I define--and measure when I'm making cap irons--as the gap between the cap iron and blade before the screw closes the gap up) and angle (not sure what angle you're referring to; do you mean the overall shape of the business end?) are two separate issues.

That last paragraph of mine is painful to read. Reminds me of Adorno, and not in a good way. Sorry folks.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#5

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

David Weaver

A relatively dense stitched wheel. Years ago I used hard felt and didn't like the outcome as much. I didn't get the stitched wheel to sharpen, rather to polish metal, like when cleaning razors.

I can't recall exactly how I got to trying this, other than to realize that gray scotchbrite raises a wire edge and the buff is good at taking it off.

When I used the 5 micron stick to hone and found it to be terrible on a harder surface, I set it aside because of the theory of spontaneous junk, and later noticed how bright of a polish it left off of the buff. I expected it to leave a matte finish, but it's ultra fine.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#6

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

David Weaver

Separate side comment about cap irons. The one on top is a ward cap iron. Long flat primary and smaller final bevel. The one on the bottom is a more round and blunt butcher. Both irons are similar.

https://i.imgur.com/Rcz1HtF.jpg

The butcher is in one of my own planes and the ward in a nearly unused greenslade plane. Same width and about the same weight, but the ward cap is much easier through a heavy cut. Tearout prevention is similar. Mathieson caps are similar. These are some of the early all steel caps after they switched from wrought. As time went on, caps got more sprung. Same thing happened with Norris planes, they started like this and then became much more blunt.

This only really matters in making tighter plane fitting and especially in taking heavy shavings trying jacked wood.

The greenslade plane is a couple of degrees steeper than mine, too...bed angle, that is.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#7

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

David Weaver

Hi Wiley- I believe it's more than 2 degrees more but have no easy way to measure accurately. It could probably be imitated with a small flat bevel with some experimentation, though.

I like the buff because it doesn't concentrate on a point or small area, and because I'm used to it.

Too much of it, though, and the edge just becomes blunt.

As far as cap irons, since they have a pain in the rear soft composition that makes for a persistent wire edge, I've used this buffer to finish the top edge on each new cap iron. It leaves the leading edge buffed with no wire edge at all.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#8

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

Wiley Horne

When you look at the buffed edge under a scope, does it look qualitatively the same as a stoned edge, or does it have a different look?

Wiley

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#9

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

David Weaver

It's rolled over, you can see by the shadow (as you're aware, i'm sure, the toplit metallurgical scopes are very sensitive to just what surface is reflecting right back, so edges that roll off can be hard to get a good image of), but very smooth and very fine.

The buffed edge rolls off into a little bit of darkness, but the very edge is still visible. Coincidentally, scuzz on the edge (jagged or wire edge bits) manages to show up easily because some part of it is reflective back to the lens.

All that said, instead of looking like a stoned edge, it looks more burnished like an oxide edge. I don't think this is burnishing, rather it's the inability of particles to cut very deeply just because their backing medium has no conviction.

The PC hooked to my metallurgical scope is near death, but I may be able to convince it to work this week to get a picture of this edge on a knife. my setup is a flat setup, so it's hard for me to get the picture of the bevel side on anything - the toplight comes down onto the bevel and is reflected into lateral space, never for whatever it's carrying to be seen again through any eyepiece of camera, so little knives and razors are easier to photograph - I just have to prop something under them so that the bevel is co planar to the lens.

At any rate, the oxides on a soft surface also leave a smudged looking edge because nothing is cutting deeply, or perhaps if it is, it's below the visible wavelength in size. We don't see edges like that in woodworking much because they disappear quickly in use. They've become popular in razor sharpening because you can be new and kind of a hack and use them easily, and when I sell a kamisori (because they're hard and will hold an edge like that for a little bit), I will sometimes leave the edges like that with minimal stropping to give people the shocking experience they want.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#10

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

Steve Voigt

Ah, ok. That actually looks like as much spring as I would normally have, a bit more even. I don't think I've ever seen an Emmerich cap iron; if it's got a lot more spring than these, I'm not sure I want to!

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#11

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

David Weaver

https://www.fine-tools.com/hobele.html

That picture understates the spring a little bit due to the angle.

Mujingfang appears to have copied these in their chinese planes, all the way down to the tall windowpane front on the cap iron, but they solved feed issues by making the wear really really short - like 1/4 inch or so.

Some are sprung more than this.

I remove some metal from these when I find them, but the modern planes are usually open enough that it doesn't matter, and they work fine. There's just so much spring that it makes fine adjustment below a certain amount kind of difficult.

Then, there's LN cap irons on the opposite end where there's just almost no give. Ward's design is between that but with the long gradual primary bevel (more so than just the thickness difference between those two in the picture) gives you the ability to stop tearout without having a big wall of a cap iron further up from just the point of contact that's needed to hold the chip in place.

The two that I have in the picture aren't doubly different in force, but it's noticeable. I was cleaning up rough cut sticking this weekend with this try plane and with a fat little smoother I made when we first started figuring out how to make double iron planes.

https://i.imgur.com/ybiuuLT.jpg

https://imgur.com/gallery/KgTW24k

https://i.imgur.com/jr9O8ZI.jpg

(the kids love these shavings)

The cap iron in the smooth plane is (not sure) on top of an IH sorby iron. IH sorby irons are usually pretty good, but this one is a tad soft, so I let it do fat shaving work only, and it sails through wood - same shape of cap iron. 5-7 thosuandth for smoother shavings to get things cleaned up, then anything left is almost nothing in terms of tearout. The shavings out of the try plane were double that - 2 1/8th wide. Heavenly to work - everything is so stable and as soon as the shaving is continuous, you know you have a pretty good surface - not much to check.

I did one stick with the try plane in this picture (ward cap iron and ward iron) and one with my first try plane after making a jointer (which is actually a decent plane, and uses the other iron in the picture above). I learned based on that fatter cap iron that I can't just pick a wear iron and size when dealing with different irons, but rather have to guess at setting the wear up to work with the cap iron - as in steeper by 5 degrees or so. It pushes a chip right into the wear, so opening the mouth doesn't really solve it, the wear has to be steeper. I'm stuck on that whole thing - keeping the wear as tight as possible because it looks pretty on the older planes like this greenslade.

The aesthetics on that cocobolo smoother are suspicious, to say the least, but it's great at taking fat shavings off of cherry. 8 smoother shavings on one side of the board to go from sawn from the mill to finished (it's wide enough to do the narrow side of the sticking without using the try plane) and 9 on the other. The fat side was hand sawn (by me). I'd like to say it took fewer shavings than the mill edge, but I don't think it did!!

https://i.imgur.com/xqmm1m4.jpg

It looks pretty good off of the saw (that's the fat side, 2 1/8th), but it relieved itself a little away from straightness when sawn, bowing toward the sawn side.

TMI.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#12

sneaking these rolled edges on people..

David Weaver

I think i said this already, but generally when I ship something to someone, I roll the edge a little bit so that their first experience with whatever I send isn't an iron or chisel that chips.

I passed that file steel chisel to steve and rolled the edge on it some (just with a stone) in case he put it to hard work. He'd mentioned in a follow up email that he thought it was a bit hard tempered because once he'd resharpened it, it didn't stay chip free as well, but he didn't say it felt dull to use the way I'd sent it to him.

The irons that I sent back to jim (the xhp), I rolled the edge some on them so that they'd not get chipped in rough cut wood or something and be a problem right away. It would be a real buzz kill.

I'm always curious about passing things around because I've learned in isolation by experimentation, and my ears are open if I come up short somewhere. This whole rolling the edge thing is probably a huge no-no in the eyes of most gurus, but I haven't noticed the shortcoming and I've come to it slowly (which is always easier - no rush to try something, do it a way that it doesn't work, and then conclude it's no good -the first time I ever used a loaded wheel to sharpen a chisel as a beginner, I made it too blunt and considered it unworkable).

Last thought on this that I remember from randall rosenthal (a superb carver who carves pine into extremely intricate still-life type carvings), I asked him what he does to sharpen his gouges because all of the cuts were very bright and clean in his roughing work, and he just said "oh, i'm so lazy. I do all of my sharpening on a buffing wheel" or something to that effect. It takes a lot of experience to find exactly where chisels/gouges will work well (no chipping, but not too steep to make bright clean easy cuts) using a buffing wheel. It wouldn't work if an edge took on damage as the buffing wheel will buff the damaged profile as well as the clean (i've noticed this using the buffing wheel on hard knives - I just used it and the gray scotchbrite yesterday to sharpen a VG10 japanese knife. Blindingly sharp, but some of the tiny pinprick sized defects remained - i think they get chased deeper.

(i have to tape the handles of my knives after sharpening here so that my wife won't touch them until I take the tape off of the end of the handle when they've dulled a little).

If I had more interest in making things, I guess I wouldn't ponder this dumb stuff.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#13

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

Steve Voigt

Hi Dave,

Thanks for the pics and all. One followup request: approximately what angle is the "long primary" on that Ward?

My two cents is that the issue is not really curved vs long primary/small secondary, but rather how steep the bevel (or tangent line to the bevel) is in the range from 1/64-1/16 above the bottom of the cap iron. I can't really tell, but I'm going to assume that on the Ward you have a very small bevel--curved or not--that is 50-ish. But right above that, the angle is quite shallow, certainly sub-30. The Butcher, on the other hand, looks to be steeper, above 30. That is the crux of the matter, I think.

I'm surprised that you would vary the geometry of the plane based on the cap iron. As you surely must know, it is much easier to reshape the cap iron. If the Butcher doesn't work as well as it should, a little time with grinder and file would fix it.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#14

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

David Weaver

It's probably a 50/50 thing - when I looked at that picture, I knew this was coming unless you decided not to bring it up :)

I'll go do some measuring and estimate the leading edge -but some of the difference in geometry is intentional (where I can make it so) and some is not (where the cap iron won't allow it as it's designed).

50/50 meaning that yes, there's a whole lot less "there" for the ward cap iron above the initial contact point, but the other 50% is that the butcher cap iron is pretty much just honed and polished and that puts it way above where I'd want it to be.

For some types, like the more modern ulmia descendants, the amount of spring is so high that you can't make a cap look like the ward cap - the cap irons are so drastically made and are thinner and then also apply tension due to the spring rather than thickness.

brb

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#15

not what i expected

David Weaver

the high pitched part of of the ward cap iron is only about .015 to .02" long and it tapers to shallow really quickly. It's rounded, and near as I can tell with good lighting, it's about 50 degrees where it terminates into an iron. I have a preference on the try plane of something like that, though - none of my planes terminate as steeply as warren's.

The butcher cap iron (the fatter one) is about 60 degrees at its terminus and the steep part works itself out over about .045". It seems relatively insignificant, but I guess the next step is to marker the cap iron and see where the marker rubs off. That's a hit or miss strategy as it just shows where the wood is rubbing, not where it's rubbing hard (marker comes off easily).

As far as filing them back, I do that fairly regularly - the butcher (even as you look at it) is far less drastic than a lot of the modern euro types so it needed about 5 degrees or so steeper wear, which seemed like a lot at the time.

I put that iron in my second long plane, so I didn't know as much at the time - it's literally the one where I learned that. The iron itself is so wonderful that I didn't ever revisit it until now (someone gave me the iron as a gift, I can't sell the plane with it and it's fitted, so I'll keep it).

Not that most other people will be too familiar, but butcher irons are often supple and easy sharpening but soft. For some reason,that iron is really close to my sharpening sweet spot - just at the range where the washita is slowing down a little cutting it, leading to a really good edge without being too hard to have inadequate toughness.

(after I get the marker experiment done, if the wear off of the marker shows that the shavings are rubbing well past the height of the ward cap, then I'm going to file some of that back and see if doing so evens things out).

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#16

Re: not what i expected

Wiley Horne

As a practical matter, would you get the same effect if the Butcher cap iron were placed a couple or three thousandths farther from the edge than the Ward?

Wiley

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#17

maybe!

David Weaver

I don't really know. I set them both about the same - absolute tearout elimination isn't the goal with the try plane, but reduction to an amount that doesn't cause the shaving to separate or vary in thickness is (which correlates to about the amount that will be removed smoothing, anyway).

I could play with it a little longer, but that said, it always seems easier and more forgiving to me to keep less metal in the way of the shaving (there's a wider range of seemingly similar function).

I measured the cherry shavings that came off of the better performing of the two planes in this case (it never bulled me to a standstill with too heavy of a cut, but I wouldn't want to go heavier) and they were .01 to .014 in thickness with the thickest showing a little bit of chatter (i haven't fitted the old plane).

I have long thought that there's a productive amount of chatter for heavy work (where a plane is easier to use with that kind of shaving than an absolutely tight locked down plane ), but that's a road I'll go down a different day. Planes set like that can be really loud. Unintentionally.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#18

Re: Dave and Wiley

Steve Voigt

Dave--the numbers you report seem consistent to me with the difference between the performance of the two cap irons.

Wiley--I would say the answer is no, because Dave is probably already accounting for the slightly steeper business end on the Butcher by setting it a bit looser. The issue is (I think) not the final angle, but what lies above it.

The instructions for sharpening super surfacers blades have made the rounds here a couple times. I don't have them in hand, but IIRC they are pretty specific about the size of the secondary bevel on the chipbreaker--0.3 mm. This is also the size (length is probably a better term) in the KK video. My experience is that it's worth taking this seriously. That's not to say that a length of .4 mm is going to cause a problem, but exceeding it by a factor of 3 or 4 is going to yield different results.

Dave's numbers for the Ward are right in this ballpark, but for the Butcher they aren't. So that's the first thing I'd look at.

The second thing is that on a good British double iron plane, the difference between the bed angle and the wear is about 30°. So if the cap iron doesn't get to sub-30 pretty fast, there are going to be problems. It may not actually choke, but if it takes effort to force the shavings out of the escapement, that is added force that the user will have to supply. I suspect that is the issue here, though it's obviously hard to say without being there.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#19

Re: Dave and Wiley

Wiley Horne

Got it! Thanks, I didn’t understand the problem until you explained it!

Wiley

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#20

Steve arrives with his wrench...

David Weaver

..throws it in the spokes as I'm riding by on this experiment :)

I think steve may have told me this order of events, but I didn't remember it properly because there was a complicating factor...but he *did* find my chisel edge chippy.

I tempered the chisel (that nobody probably remembers now, but it was made of a file and had a pretty gross bolster) as hard as I could stand (the first attempt or two left the edge very chippy, and the last one before I sent it was at the upper end of what anyone would tolerate - chasing a chisel that wouldn't hold a wire edge).

So count one against my sharpening method (but it may really be a count against me as a crappy tool maker) - if steve is leaving a chisel finish on planes where facets are cut,any lines at all will be easily noticed and not tolerated.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#21

How is a rolled edge different...

Jim Matthews

...different than a convex bevel?

Certainly more steel is lost to the media, but for a plane iron or bench chisel - it's one less step. Knives and razors would seem to me built to a very different purpose.

Even Yari Kanna have a subtle convex bevel on the bottom. Not only does this give a measure of control (where the approach angle limits engagement of the blade) but also supports what might be a fragile edge.

I find the convex bevel appealing because there are no settings to remember.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#22

Re: less work

David Weaver

convex bevels all on one work well for an edge that never gets damaged.

Once there's damage, then you're into working the entire bevel and what the microscope shows me with full bevel methods is little damage that's never completely removed.

I'm going back and forth between just hollow grinding and then performing a small "lift" on the final bevel to make sure it's been worked by a fine stone, and going toward how I've seen some vintage professionally used tools set up - which is a relatively long shallower primary bevel and the convex part is just a bit.

I can guess why this was for two reasons:

1) someone using a plane on site wouldn't have to work through much if they damaged an edge a little bit, but a some point, they would have to put in considerable effort to reset the long bevel (presumably not while doing paid work)

2) it's fast for sharpening in general, you can use a single stone and still have a fine edge whereas something like the washita is pretty marginal sharpening a full bevel on harder chisels by itself.

Some of this started about 6 or 8 years ago when I was buying planes to use to see what I'd want to copy to try to make a good plane. One of the planes that I received was barely used and it had a huge long thin primary bevel on it, and the last bit of the edge was maybe (guessing) a millimeter long - steeper and more like what we're used to. I thought for sure it would break off, but in use, it didn't. It was very deliberately done (and unusually not ham handed off by a later less skilled user) and crisp.

Always a chance that i'm going down the wrong road.

As far as knives go, it depends on what knives are being used for. If they're for slicing, the whole action is a lot like paring and planing. What tests well for knives seems to work well for planing and paring. Mortising, maybe not so much.

People who like to scrape pipes or cut barrel lips - same thing - not so applicable. The razor as a whole, too - not that great for woodworking - we wear off in five minutes what is used in a razor edge in 2 years, but close up pictures across the bevel that show the rounding after stropping with linen and leather (something you can't see even with a flat metallurgical strop) make some sense in this.

It's common now (good leather and linen aren't as common) to use oxides and leave a gleaming flatter finished bevel, and the sharpness/keenness isn't really necessary. I always noticed that a linen and leather edge seemed to last all year if you really want it, too, but didn't figure as much rounding was going on as there is in pictures. Without it, the razor edge is more transient. Too much of it, the razor edge is blunt.

https://scienceofsharp.files.wordpress.com/2014/04/stropped_100linen.jpg

this is an extremely highly magnified image, this is at half as much magnification:

https://scienceofsharp.files.wordpress.com/2014/08/fusion_10kx.jpg

The top edge is a straight razor. I think the bottom one may be a coated DE blade.

While not directly applicable to woodworking, the issue is the same - the failure point in an oxide edge is deformation of the very edge. Spectacularly sharp for a shave or two (and I've noticed over the years that an oxide edge on a hard razor isn't preserved on linen - I think it gets rubbed off, so when I sell something like a kamisori, I don't use it on linen).

The razor done in the first picture on linen here has 100 strokes or so. I generally will do 50 a week. The edge is seemingly better for shaving a few weeks in than it was new (I think because it's probably more rounded, but not too blunt to easily cut hair).

Keeping the primary flatter in chisels and trying this stuff out has another side issue i'm wondering about - will it slip through material more easily without causing edge failure if the main part of a convex or flat bevel isn't there.

I have a steeper version of this from mortising cocobolo planes - but in that case, the regular bevel isn't steep - it's just "regular". the edge fails due to the hardness of the wood. If the whole chisel bevel is made too steep, it creates more physical work, but if just a little bit of the end is rounded over, it's generally easier overall to mortise than it was with a "normal" bevel because there's less edge failure.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#23

before this gets too long (already did)..

David Weaver

..in the other post, more comments about mortising hard plane bodies because i have a lot of actual experience with it and plenty of failure to bring up.

It was popular when i first started woodworking to set a bunch of chisels up all the same, use them in a single task, and then declare the ones that held up less well as failures. I did the same thing and moved toward harder chisels.

When I started mortising plane bodies with a heavier chisel, then everything set up normally just didn't tolerate, and what i'd gravitated toward (japanese chisels - an imai timber framing chisel that I bought for planes in this case) set up at a fairly blunt bevel failed spectacularly. so I made it steeper until it tolerated the mortising and then eventually sold it. I tried it against an old american framing chisel (underhill or something) and that one held up as well as the japanese chisel but was less work to keep in shape (and less valuable) - they both did OK once the edge was rolled a little. A fatter bevel and the mortising became a lot more work, but a little bit of the edge rolled was good enough and it was easily reversed when done.

So I followed up mortising a plane with a cheap stanley 720, which didn't do well with a flat bevel, and rolled the edge a little on it, just a small one (perhaps another 5 degrees) and it also held up fine whereas using it with a flat bevel at 30 degrees or so was an absolute failure. Make the whole bevel steeper, then the mortising gets harder (probably due to friction or wedging).

I figured by the time I'd experimented with all of this stuff, the difference in where the good chisels tolerated mortising vs. the not so good was just a couple of degrees difference in the small roll of the edge.

I have a set of chisels (modern sorby) that don't hold up that well in hardwood, so I'm going to continue this experiment with them. They're soft. If you do pine drawers, they work fine, but even in cherry, they deflect easily and the edge gets bent up. If you increase the flat bevel angle enough to get them to hold up in hardwood, then you get the typical crushed fibers between the tails from breaking wood out instead of shearing it off. They'll be a good canary for this. Chisels that are too hard do the same thing, except they chip vs. deflecting.

I'm not really chasing anything here other than fiddling for my own benefit - it's not like the cap iron where I would tell someone else to do it.

I've learned over the years when someone says they're doing heavy work and their chisels aren't holding up to tell them to roll the edge over just a little bit and move on, though (rather than heading out to the internet to hunt down the the next chisel that costs 3 times more to do 20 minutes worth of work). Advice like that is usually ignored, though, just as newbies often do when they are asking which plane they can buy to work figured wood when they already have a bunch of common double iron planes.

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#24

Re: Plastic feeler gauge is more like it...

Steve Voigt

Dave, the chisel was a bit chippy, but I raised the bevel a bit and I *think* it was fine. I'm hedging because I haven't put it through any heavy paces--perhaps I've been treating it a bit too gingerly. I'll resolve to give it a thorough workout later this week and get back to you.

So, I don't think it's a strike against your method…but rather just a slight mismatch of hardness to final angle.

Something the Internet gurus never talk about (when they are recommending some very specific angle that you should sharpen all your tools to) is the relationship between sharpening angle and control of the tool, especially when making freehand finish cuts. I remember that when I first tried your chisel, I was paring the cross grain chamfers on a couple planes, and the tool sailed through the material more easily than the pre-war Marples I normally use. I was pretty excited, but as mentioned, it didn't hold up to continued use, so I had to sacrifice some of that ease of use by raising the bevel a bit. I think that's entirely a positive thing, finding the failure point and then adjusting the freehand sharpening technique accordingly.

I don't really have anything useful to say about the rolled edge technique…I am still wondering though, if you think the important thing is the geometry, or the medium of your buffing wheel/rouge. In other words, is it replicable on stones alone. I look forward to further investigations, as I get the sense you're just getting started… ;)

Re: studying edge failure...somewhat obscure

#25

stones are fine....

David Weaver

..it can be replicated on stones. it's the same simple roll a lot of people do but don't say when you're just finishing an edge and you want to be sure that the finish stone got all the way around it.

At one point years ago, I was chasing really low bevel angles and really fine edges and paring, etc. That probably works OK for pine. I remember having several different paring chisels set up like that and more "normal" when I was cutting the facets on planes and I thought the really slightly set up chisels lacked control because I often over cut with them. There's always one or two facets on a plane where the paring is into the grain and a sharper edge yields better results, but I liked the feel of the washita stone edge on the other ones - it wasn't slick enough to overcut easily, but sharp enough to leave a good finish.

as far as the rolled edge on the file chisel, if it is a good chisel, I would guess it should've tolerated that, but it's probably too hard. I also faffed with it mortising so I may not have noticed the same issues that would show up in a finishing facet. I'm really curious as to whether or not some part of it will break easily, so I wouldn't be offended if you figured out how to break it - the files that it comes from will break easily if they're pried with or bent, but I'm sure they're also harder.

I would guess that it's 2 or 3 rockwell C points harder than something like an iles chisel and is probably still a little bit too hard - I can recall being on a big bender at the time trying to get something that would sharpen really finely on the washita and not hold on to much of a wire edge at all. It may not be a practical thing to do (japanese chisels in white steel drop their wire edge off like that, but they're usually not very tough without geometric assistance).

as far as the buffer, though - it's a combination of laziness, being used to using it already, as well as some wonder at how fine the edge is with a fairly coarse cheap buffing bar. This fascination may pass quickly if I find something else to waste time on.