Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

Posts

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#26

Jack Guzman from Maine

got it


Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#27

Re: 60_ Bedrock prefix

William Duffield

:D

I intended it to be a puzzle, and you figured it out! BTW, I ordered the #7 preproduction, at a nice discount, and had to wait quite a while for it. I guess that makes this a drive-by gloat.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#28

Those videos are textbook hypnosis...

Jim Matthews

I'm mesmerized by the delivery and slow repetitive movements.

It's only in application that incongruities arose.

Some of the methods illustrate a degree of compulsion I lack.

I'm about counting shavings, or measuring their thickness to determine how many to take off. Mark, prep and check. A proper plane reduces the fiddle factor down.

Heavy tools (much more than 2 pounds) get retired into storage. I'm like many enthusiasts: lots of my stash *seemed* like a good idea at the time. A #5 1/2 was so heavy that I would reach for anything else.

I want to get on with it, finish projects and still be able to raise my arms afterwards.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#29

pretty much sums it up..

David Weaver

..my first infill was a little test plane (it's heavy), the second was sort of a copy of the brese design (with parts that I bought from Ron B).

It's a sunday cruiser plane at this point. it's nice to use on an already flat board, but it's 5 1/2 pounds and needs sharpening far more often (halved durability) and its practical limit with working shavings is half or a third of a stanley....halved or thirded again.

So, the standard #4 is usable at just over half the weight and will do at least 4 times as much work between sharpenings with a similar iron.

I still can get more work done between sharpenings in cherry with a wooden try plane than I can with a metal jointer and XHP. The woody types in heavy work don't get stuck on wood when the shaving gets heavy (and puts downforce on the plane). Thick stuff out of them is just so much easier.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#30

Re: Those videos are textbook hypnosis...

North of the Border

His videos are missing one important warning on the cover: You must not watch it when you are not at your best shape of the day.

If you're tired from a day's work, and think you can absorb something by watching any of his videos, you'd find yourself dead asleep within 5 minutes.

His monotonous tone and slow pace of delivery would put you to sleep as fast as anesthetics.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#31

I love his stuff.

Jim Matthews

Soothing, I would say.

There's a great similarity to Norm Abrams' delivery.

It *seems* easy enough. I always feel overconfident, as I climb "Mt. Stupid".

I still get quite a lot out of the source texts.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#32

Re: Patrick’s memes

TomD

"Maybe there are many colleagues here who have heavily cambered irons in their 5’s; my guess is that those among us who are actually using jack planes, are using woodies. Of course, I may be completely wrong :) ."

That would be me, though I am at some loss as to how one characterizes a low angle bevel up metal plane that I occasionally use.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#33

Re: I started on charlesworth....

TomD

"His planing video more or less shows how to true wood that's already near true, and in small parts"

It is like his ruler trick, or Cosman's latest cornering of every element of workmanship of risk when doing dovetails: Clever, and it gives people who feel they need absolute certainty a reason to try out hand woodworking. But you can easily use the cambering tricks for rough wood also. I just imagine people who pay a fortune for a process video want to see it used in a situation where an axe does not seem like a ready alternative. Small parts are also relevant as they come up with things like guitars, as you know.

I remember the fights here when people worshiping at the alter of camber were adamant that there was only that one way to adjust angle on the edge of a board. Not much contrary opinion either. I trotted out something like 8 ways it could be done. Not that that put a stake through the vampire.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#34

On teaching of any method

Jim Matthews

If instruction required demonstrating ALL methods, it would take too long.

The inestimable DC and others must choose what they show, and importantly, what they don't illustrate, for clarity and brevity.

I have never heard one of the Big Dogs dismiss any given approach, or claim their way is the superior choice. "You could do X that way, but this works for me."

We each of us must navigate the varied offerings to find what is practical.

For me, Jim Tolpin hits on all cylinders.

The dulcet tones of DC's patrician delivery make it seem as if even I might accomplish the near impossible.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#35

one exception....

David Weaver

..for some reason, some of the gurus seem to want to take pot shots at each other about sharpening.

When I watched the original charlesworth video, he mentioned something about one of his competitors refusing to allow students to use a guide.

Then 10 years later, I heard paul sellers (or read in a blog) talk negative about teaching sharpening using a guide. There are many more instructors than that, so that's probably not who he was referring to. I'm sure as instructors of beginners, they see a lot of incomplete edges, but DC and RC (cosman) were commenting on SMC years ago when I was still on there that each had only ever seen two properly sharpened edges in their classes.

I thought this was odd, but I get a lot of tools in use that are incompletely sharpened. People are working with them, though. I couldn't suss out of the two of them what really means an edge that wasn't sharpened (is it only properly sharpened if it's done with your method?).

My first edge was a good one. It took about 50 minutes to follow the steps that charlesworth went through preparing a LN iron, and then use a guide to sharpen the iron the way he said to. I had no idea if the edge was any good, other than that it worked. I realize how that it was a good edge, as good as a king 6000 would do.

Ditto on the delivery, though. We will be precise with everything from the start!! (and my wife will say, or would back then "oh...you're watching Jesus again!! we're going to fall asleep!!!)

Branching out after learning standards does lead to wanting those standards when they're needed, but figuring out how to get them faster.

One thing I noticed about George very early. He doesn't talk much about methods. He talks about good design and working to a standard. He's hesitant to say much about methods unless he's got something novel (like that broaching head cutting planes quickly), but he will talk about design and standards, and once in a while he'll mention time.

I asked him how he made the infill scraper that Larry is using in the harpsichord video thinking I might like to have something like that for guitar tops, and he said "I made it in an hour or so at one point when we needed a scraper" (WHAT!?. Infill scraper, hour what?)

He said "you have to have a mill to do it that quickly", but it's "just" a piece of brass tube (squashed into an oval) soldered to a sole with the infill cut to match the squashed brass tube and then an iron made for it.

Hour. :|

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#36

you know I'm not much of a power tool user, but

David Weaver

...the spindle sander and trim router were missing from the lie nielsen series.

They're long ago obsoleted now in commercial guitar production - even the pin router is, but the plane is still useful - sometimes needing accommodation on electric guitars (binding the tops and bottoms and slab siding them if you're going to smooth plane them).

Richard, Bill and I had a conversation about that kind of stuff offline. A hobbyist can do those things, but paying shops will probably never see any of it. last I recall, the total non-buffing time for an american made stratocaster is about 5 1/2 hours and I think that includes stuff like moving things around in the factory and floor sweeping.

online is a bad place to get advice about guitars, though. on the telecaster forum, I was advised that planing mahogany and spruce would've be possible, that spruce would be too splintery to make a body (so....cut it close to the line and scrape and spindle sand it to final size in an extra half hour?...jeez). and that fitting a neck pocket without shims, jigs and a router wasn't possible (plane making tools make it *really* easy. )

(hand planed spruce https://i.imgur.com/kkKJuiw.jpg short of having some kind of industrial sanding setup, I just don't know a faster way to get the surface ready for finish than the 5 minutes or so that it takes to plane any handling damage out of the spruce and make a couple of finish passes. Even if you're going to round over the edge and sand everything to get uniformity with finish absorption. Change this around to an industrial setting with an oscillating triple drum sander or something like that, then it's way back in favor of the power tools).

Never looked to see if there are guitar gurus who sell their methods to make something that you'll lose money making, but there's probably a market for selling that stuff to beginners.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#37

Re: On teaching of any method

Charlie

"I have never heard one of the Big Dogs dismiss any given approach, or claim their way is the superior choice. "

You must not have read this forum much over the years then.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#38

Re: one exception....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Charlesworth is constantly ridiculing anyone who has skill. His whole attitude is to concoct techniques which are "repeatable", id est those which require no skill. They are not historic techniques.

Here is an example: He makes fun of people who come to his classes and extend their arms while planing. Since he would lose control, he assumes everyone likewise would lose control. So he planes with his entire upper body rigid at the speed of about three inches per second. But skillful people, whether French or Japanese, two hundred years ago or this year, plane by extending their arms. I have seen teenagers who had more control of a plane than Charlesworth.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#39

Out of context.....

David Weaver

I had a baseball coach in little league who didn't want us to have out of control swings. His solution for it was to demand that every swing should end with the bat pointed at the pitcher (and not recoiled to there, but stop there).

If someone was a master of bunting, maybe that would sound good. It's awfully hard to do much with planes without using your arms.

I made the comment at one point on a UK forum that if you're going to use hand tools for everything, you should probably get past needing to do stop shavings to plane a slightly sprung edge. I'll admit, I didn't "study this up" but it has a lot to do with using a cap iron and getting an even planing stroke. I noticed when I dimension, if I don't pay attention, boards have a tendency to be hollow in the middle. On edges, they tend to be too sprung. Planing ends low is not an asset and learning to plane slightly hollow without extra steps is pretty useful.

David (was not alone, but I did get reminded of how much longer he's used planes than I have) asserted that this could not be. I don't know if he used the word not possible, but that was the assertion - the reward you get for providing a helpful answer.

One other person who started to use the cap iron had the same experience.

Still not possible.

It went as far as having to make a video starting with a dead flat edge to a starrett straight edge (and proof of that by video) to planing the edge hollow - twice - to prove it wasn't by chance - without taking a shaving less than the full length of the edge.

I have no idea if this was ever a common thing people do, but when you dimension wood, it seems awfully useful.

I often join rough panels without match planing (if they're too wide) or using a square or straight edge, either. Again, no clue if this is common, but it seems sensible and quicker. rote routines are fine to work to a standard, but at some point, you feel the desire to make things a little less difficult.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#40

Re: I started on charlesworth....

Charlie

I've never been his biggest fan, but he can make furniture.

https://www.davidcharlesworth.co.uk/contacts/dc-sofa/

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#41

I should've explained out of context...

David Weaver

I should've explained what I meant better than that.

My little league coach had never played baseball. I don't think David has dimensioned much wood. If planes are never used for much heavy work where you have to understand efficiency and functional laziness, but worked with a lot of students who didn't have neural development (and the turnover is brisk, I'm sure) planing, it may be sensible to think that it's great to take the coordination right out of it.

I know David has said several times on other forums that the idea that one would do rough work with planes instead of machines is bonkers. For certain things, it may be, but for a hobbyist or even a guitar maker, it wouldn't make much difference in output (at least not in terms of quality work).

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#42

Re: one exception....

Charlie

The 'offending' video one presumes:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nka94EiVkmM

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#43

Re: I started on charlesworth....

David Weaver

Charlie - that's sort of like asking if this is "the" segment where ron white tells the joke about having a lot of quit.

The method is David's recommendation any time anyone asks about planing (open forum, demonstration in video, etc).

I commend him for having such rigid adherence to technique, as one would expect from someone who has specialized in teaching for 43 years (I gather Robert Wearing must've been nearby or a mentor as purchasing a Wearing text tips you off that a lot of what David teaches is out of Wearing's library).

You could tell better than I can if that's what it looks like working in a paying shop. Not trying to get you to step into a trap, just making a statement that it looks like a way to plane when you either plane board that come off of a machine jointer (to true a joint) or you're just starting.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#44

Re: Out of context.....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I responded to the comment about needing to stop plane on this forum. Charlesworth "guaranteed" that if a flat edge were then planed five or ten times it would develop a "bump" as he called it, and no longer be flat. As it happened, I was joining two boards, and I got them so there was no light between them when stacked up. I planed one board ten times: nothing. I planed the edge a hundred times, put the two edges together: no light not .001 inches anywhere. So much for the guarantee.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#45

Re: I started on charlesworth....

Charlie

As the world turns...

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#46

Re: I started on charlesworth....

David Weaver

No soap opera is complete without your participation, Charlie. Show us your worst. We know you won't show your work.

Strange to see you heckle charlesworth years ago and run him out of another forum, now you're angling to make him a darling so you can use him to stir the pot.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#47

Re: Out of context.....

David Weaver

Strange that you had the exact same experience. Not that strange, but I wonder who got it first.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#48

Show us your finest work.

Jim Matthews

Still waiting on that demonstration of your skill.


img

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#49

Re: I started on charlesworth....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

David, you ought to be ashamed. A few years ago you said on this forum that Charlie was being supported by his wife. No evidence, just meanness. Charlie wrote back that his poor wife had died of cancer the previous year.

We have had people post their work on this forum as an attempt to gain status, sometimes the same piece over and over. I had guys who in the middle of an argument, will post a picture of something they made as if to say to me "you couldn't make something like this." How are you supposed to respond to that? Are you supposed to say "Yes, that looks very amateurish." or "Do you not remember that I was the one who helped you out when you got stuck making that piece?"

Do you not remember, David, how some ungrateful people badgered you to show work? Your posts speak for themselves. We did not need pictures of your work to know you were offering valuable comments.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#50

Re: I started on charlesworth....

David Weaver

Hi, Warren - perhaps you're right -there's obviously a little bit of back story. Long ago, David Charlesworth showed up on woodnet. I was thrilled. Charlie single-handedly heckled him and he said something like "that's enough of that" (David did) and David left as fast as he came. At the time, Charlie asserted that David didn't make anything, I retaliated by calling him out and got a temporary time out.

Charlie has constantly harassed people to show their work in an attempt to get leverage in a discussion, but rarely shows his own. The vagueness of position is intentional, and seeing "David knows how to make furniture" here touches a nerve. I was merely using his own line on him - I'm more or less an advocate of not posting your own work on here unless you want to for more than one reason, but among those are the fact that someone will probably heckle it, and second, you will spend a fair amount of time organizing just communicating it and the bigger likelihood is that nobody will respond at all.

Talk about a technique or a guru, though, and the switchboard lights up.