Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

Posts

Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#1

Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

Philip F Duffy

I have a #7 Stanley sweetheart plane, a gift years back, that has a broken "wing" on the part of the frog that rotates and moves the blade forward/back. It seems the part might be replaceable, if one was available. Does anyone know where such a part might be found? Thanks! P.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#2

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

David Weaver

Are you talking about the y shaped piece that straddles the adjuster wheel?

https://www.fine-tools.com/juumaplaneparts.html

Not suggesting that part, just showing as a picture. Anything that's not genuine isn't worth the trouble. If so, check Ebay and if you find someone selling a lot of parts, but not what you need, send them a message with a request.

It may just be easier to buy an entire replacement frog.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#3

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

Philip F Duffy

Thanks, David. I will try your approach. I do not need the #7 as my #6 is excellent but I hate to see an historic piece just sit there unusable. P.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#4

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

William Duffield

Names and numbered parts list for Stanley Bailey bench planes can be found here:

http://supertool.com/StanleyBG/stan1.htm#num3

I don't understand your preference for a #6. :D

http://supertool.com/StanleyBG/stan1.htm#num6

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#5

Ebay search string

Wiley Horne

Philip,

Go to Ebay and search the following string: ‘ Stanley Y adjusting lever’

Unbelievably, there’s a few of them on offer. Means your problem is shared by many others :)

Wiley

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#6

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

Philip F Duffy

William, I do not pretend to be a fine cabinet maker/chair man, like most folks on this site. Hense, the #6 serves me well. Besides, my nr 6 is in great condition and never fails to do what I need have done. Your links are great and I will study them more closely later today. Tks! P.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#7

Re: Ebay search string

Philip F Duffy

Thanks, Wiley. As you said, lots of choices. Will see what happens next. P.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#8

The hate for 6s

David Weaver

I never really understood the disdain for 6s. I'd bet more than one person has described a 6 as a useless plane and lusted over a 16 or 17 inch infill panel plane.

:b

Plus, sometimes you can find parts that fit 4 1/2s and 7s!

I never use a 5 1/2 or 6, but must admit a giant preference for the 6 over the 5 1/2 or the 5 1/4 of we're looking for planes that seem forgettable ( I do have a 5 1/2, too, though, but it was cast off by a friend who was going to throw it in the trash )

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#9

Patrick’s memes

Wiley Horne

Hi David and all,

One does wonder how much influence Patrick Leach’s whimsical memes have—against the 6 and even moreso against transitional planes. It gets to be a ‘thing’ through repetition, as happened here.

But hasn’t the original Stanley logic of smooth, jack, fore, try, and jointer been lost in the modern era? I really like my 605 ‘jack’ plane, but it is not a jack; it is straight-bladed, a short try plane. How many No. 5’s in modern hands have strongly cambered blades? Similarly, the foreplane—prominently described by Moxon—is in the wilderness, I suppose because of the prevalence of S2S and S4S lumber, and machine planing among those starting from rough lumber.

Maybe there are many colleagues here who have heavily cambered irons in their 5’s; my guess is that those among us who are actually using jack planes, are using woodies. Of course, I may be completely wrong :) .

Wiley

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#10

Re: Patrick’s memes

bridger berdel

The #4 and the #5 share iron and chipbreaker, as do the 4_1/2, 5_1/2, 6 and 7. I keep an eye out for spares of those sizes and prepare sets of iron and chipbreaker at various cambers to swap amongst their respective planes. Gives lots of options.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#11

Re: Patrick’s memes

Wiley Horne

Bridger,

Great idea! When regrinding to put new bevels on the irons (and chipbreakers). do you use jigs, or handhold and grind to your line by eye? I find that putting a new hollow grind on a cambered iron takes a Good eye and steady hand.

Wiley

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#12

Re: Patrick’s memes

William Duffield

Sorry. My comment on the #6 was meant to be tongue-in-cheek. I think Patrick's comments were too, but I could be wrong.

The only strongly cambered iron I use is on my #40 scrub plane, but my forked-tailed apprentices do all the heavy work.

Looking back, the first bench plane I was introduced to was a Stanley #5-1/4, for my first woodworking project in high school shop class, of course. I haven't used one since. :( That's too bad, because the iron and chip breaker pairs from my #3 (favorite smoother) and #603 would drop right in. I have acquired several #4s and #5s--I don't know where--they just seem to crawl out of the woodwork--and a 4-1/2.

Of course, a #6 can be configured either as a try plane or a jointer. I think the only reason I don't have two of them is I am spoiled by my #7 (which should have been called a #607). Whether you decide to pick up a #6, a #7 or a #8 should depend first on the length of your board and not on which shoulder muse you are listening to at the time.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#13

Jack Guzman from Maine

The Part?

Jack Guzman from Maine

Is this the part you need. This frog is off a #7 sized stanley plane. It is an orphan,the plane is long gone. If it is the part you need I could send it to you. No cost. Just spare parts in my junk drawer.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#14

Re:5.5 and 6

Steve Voigt

I never understood the hate for 6's either. My 6 was the last metal bench plane that I phased out of my rotation.

The 5-1/2 is a different story. It seems to be a thing these days, particularly amongst non-practitioners of the cap iron, to combine a 5-1/2 (heavy plane, wide iron) with a high angle frog and a 10° back bevel. To me, this is the woodworking equivalent of a hair shirt, and contributes greatly to my aversion to this plane.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#15

Planes

Wiley Horne

Sir Wm,

You were being tongue in cheek for sure. I just happen to be a Friend of the Foreplane—we go around being over serious on the subject. I said we, but there may be only one of us, so far.

Were the early Bedrock’s missing their 60- prefix?

Wiley

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#16

bridger

Re: Patrick’s memes

bridger

all by eye

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#17

Re: Planes

William Duffield

I don't think so, but I'm far from a historian. i just reread Patrick Leach's discourse on the Bedrocks, http://www.supertool.com/StanleyBG/stan15.htm but don't see that mentioned.

However, Lie-Nielsen didn't and still doesn't cal theirs #60x. I don't understand why. Note that L-N's #1 is not a Bedrock. The only place you can get a #601 (or could 20 years ago) is from Patrick Leach. http://www.supertool.com/601.htm

All that said and referenced, I also question to some extent the need for a rapidly adjusted frog (and mouth opening), knowing that opening and closing the mouth is not nearly as effective as adjusting the chip breaker.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#18

Re: Patrick’s memes

John Aniano in central NJ

Hi William,

I LOVE my Stanley #5-1/4!! It is very versatile and just fits my hand well. I got it about three years ago and restored it lightly. It's a real charmer.

I also love my Stanley #2, but that's another story....

John

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#19

Re:5.5 and 6

David Weaver

I think, but can't prove, that David Charlesworth's LN videos demonstrating a late model stanley 5 1/2 and referring to it as a "super smoother" (sounds cool even though I'd never have any interest in using one as a smoother).....i think that those demonstrations may have something to do with the popularity.

Just as wiley says about the wooden jack planes - as soon as someone breaks a sweat with one of those compared to a stanley, it's over for the stanley. I think the same is true for a smoother in a dimensioning regimen - the idea of a super smoother on something that just needs "regular smoothing" sounds like a bunch of extra work.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#20

just when you think nobody...

David Weaver

....could love a given plane, then you find someone who really loves it!!

I kind of felt that way about ten years ago when mujingfang made an ebony copy of the ulmia continental smoothers. I loved it, and bought a second one. Talked all about it.

About half a dozen other people on sawmillcreek bought the same plane and hated it.

I still have one of the two. Still haven't found someone else who likes them like I do.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#21

Re: 60_ Bedrock prefix

Ron in Sterling, CT

Hi Wiley

I have never seen a Bedrock without the 60_ prefix, nor have I ever read anything about the early ones without the 60_ prefix. That doesn't mean it didn't happen. I am curious as to why the question.

Ron

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#22

Re: 60_ Bedrock prefix

Wiley Horne

Hi Ron,

When Wm. said his No. 7 should have been a 607, I made the guess that Stanley may have switched to the 60x convention after the initial production. But no—Wm.owns an LN 7!

Shows what guessing does—bad habit of mine.

Wiley

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#23

Re:5.5 and 6

Wiley Horne

I wonder if David C. meant ‘large smoother’. Some, like Patrick Leach, hypothesize that the 4-1/2 was Stanley’s competitor to the British infill and if there’s anything to that, then the 5-1/2 might be compared to the British infill panel plane. Some think of the panel plane as a big smoother, in the sense that you never see one cambered like a jack.

Seems to me the 5.5 is more of a short try plane, since big smoother is sort of a contradiction in terme—smoother has to get into the swales rather than cut them down.

Wiley

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#24

I started on charlesworth....

David Weaver

..a friend who doesn't like hand tools much showed me the charlesworth videos back in about 2005 or 2006 (the sharpen a plane and then plane a board video).

They were a good starting point, but I can't remember what he said about the plane that he used back then (his "super smoother") and no longer have any of those videos. The plane was already done in the planing video, and maybe some magazine articles preceded it. I vaguely recall some comment about restoring a stanley instead of using an LN to show his students that less expensive planes could be made to work well, but I don't think David has worked with many planes that were older as his opinions seem to be formed on the stuff stanley was selling new in the 70s (his view is that stanley irons and hock's irons are drastically different in edge life - which is true vs. the rounded top irons, but not so much vs. a lot of the earlier irons).

His planing video more or less shows how to true wood that's already near true, and in small parts - I get the sense that what he teaches in furniture making classes (where most of the truing and preparation has been done by machines) makes it so that he can use that plane for all of his furniture work.

He and I don't agree at this point about what's an improvement and what's not in everything modern/boutique, and he's not a fan of my insistence, so I probably won't go to the UK forum and ask him for explanation of his plane and the reasons he's using it. :)

It reminds me a lot of the panel plane concept, though - his planing video and the way he uses is plane - much the way someone would use a single plane if the plane were just a final prep or joint truing tool, but never to see significant stock removal.

Re: Replacement frog part for Sweetheart plane

#25

Re: The Part?

Philip F Duffy

YES!! That's the one, Jack. Your kindness is very appreciated. Address follows.

3220 Fowlers Lake Rd Williamsburg, VA 23185

p.