Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

Posts

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#26

Re: Assertions and "special knowledge"

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Kato did not prove me right about the double iron; experience proved me right. Bob Strawn and David Weaver learned to use the double iron before the Kato video became available. They learned when they actually tried it. And experience proved Carruthers was right in 1767 and Nicholson was right in 1811 and many more. On this forum Todd Hughes was also a constant critic of those who argued the cap iron did not work.

Here is what an American plane maker wrote to me in 2008:



Use of chipbreakers and their effectiveness sure can bring out a lot of

passion in people! I sure don't mind if some argue about their effectiveness

for them for today's uses, but to put forth that they were not an

improvement when they were developed and adopted almost universally

worldwide strikes me as being revisonist with history and frankly a little

bit arrogant. Oh well, I guess that's what forums are for.


Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#27

I wonder what happened to Bob..

David Weaver

...I remember at the time that he was working with various things. Experimenting with the cap iron, but comments about it were intermittent.

He was also, as I recall, using strips of copper loaded with abrasive, and I didn't know what to make of that (I tried that stuff to - always went back to stones).

Before your discussions with larry (where larry typed 4 times as much and had arguments that are just old wives tales - OWTs always appeal to beginners because false arguments with a kernel of half truths look just as good as true arguments) and todd, I could find (other than bob's posts) only two instances on the internet of someone saying that they use the cap iron regularly - both on the UK woodworking forum. One of the guys said "I'm just going to say i do it, and I don't want anyone to start a fight over it".

As much as everyone (it's a disease over there especially) says they already knew about it, apparently everyone forgot and it was toxic enough to say that you use the cap iron that a poster would fear an argument about it being a ridiculous claim.

Once we all stop posting (we'll run out of fuel at some point and collapse into neutron woodworkers), I have a feeling it won't take long for it to revert back to the old mean.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#28

Copper plates

John in NM

That is a lapidary technique, I've thought of doing the same except all my copper is round :D

Diamond, or any grit really, is mixed with oil and slathered over the copper and embedded by pressure, usually a roller. You could use carbide, but there is not a lot of point in carbide for stone cutting.

If one were buying the usual nickel bonded honing plates I could see wanting to switch to something that could be re-charged when it got dull.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#29

Content and composition *LINK*

Jim Matthews

How any given post is received is as much about the composition as the content.

It's entirely possible to be correct, without ever gaining adherents to a cause.

Reverting to historical texts as sacrosanct, or insisting the only way to know anything meaningful requires mastery is the sort of rigid thinking that terminates reasoning.

Too many posts devolve into shouting matches over how many angels may dance on the head of a pin. It's like watching full-contact cosplay - where the rules change constantly.

In the end, who cares?

One of the key reasons Wearing is revered today is his support of more mortals and the welcoming style to both casual and passionate makers. He has a modern equivalent in Brian Boggs who is unfailingly gracious and always encouraging.

By contrast those that prop up their arguments on fallacies will *always* forgotten.


https://dailystoic.com/meditations-marcus-aurelius/

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#30

similar to the cast idea...

David Weaver

..i recall that being similar to the cast idea, and that the strip method with copper was used by someone else...faceters? Or maybe bob was using thin strips.

Back then, I was probably afraid of the idea that something wasn't flat and rigid, but I've grown out of that.

Phil Smith sent me a truly primo flat piece of cast when I was testing plane irons, and I can't thank him enough for that. It's fantastic. I have trouble keeping anything clean and nice, and it's no exception (keeping the contamination from it), but when I'm not lazy, it's super useful for the fine roll over that I mentioned elsewhere on here.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#31

A little different

John in NM

With copper you push the grit into the substrate. That is not done with cast iron.

Copper is used by faceters, mostly for coarser grit diamond. I believe it was used for polishing grits historically, but these days there are vastly better substrates for polishing with diamond. Copper is too sticky really, so you need larger grit that holds the work piece up away from the substrate.

In faceting you use round laps that are run by a motor and a flow of water to wash away the abundant swarf.

I could see it being useful for someone who wanted to flatten soles quickly, but not much use for the finer diamond used in honing.

When I was in college I visited a friend of my dad's who made petrographic thin section slides - you glue a chunk of rock to a glass slide with balsam and then cut it down 30 micron thickness so that it will pass light from a microscope. He had a couple 24" cast iron laps, one coarse, one fine and used abundant water to rinse away old diamond grit. I don't recall him having much contamination trouble, so I don't think diamond sticks or embeds much with cast iron - if it did he would have had trouble with that fine lap, the two were right next to one another.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#32

Surface contamination...

David Weaver

..The issue of contamination with cast is less that of something bad embedding (though larger diamonds will contaminate a cast plate and embed if you want to use it only for fine things).

Rather, the bits and pieces that end up on my cast plate are settled dust and sometimes filings that I didn't intend. They notch an edge in an instant.

In the case of tooling (vs the lapping process you're explaining) some of the diamonds do embed in the cast, so it retains part of its cutting power for a while (the cast itself if it's cleanly ground will have some grooving that also does some burnishing, I'd imagine).

One of the things that is a no go for cast work is laminated tools with large diamonds. In normal use, pressure from sharpening sticks some of the diamonds into the cast (this is just a stiffer process vs. copper, for lack of a better way to put it). If one approaches one of these laps with something like a wrought japanese chisel, it pulls the diamonds (or embeds any loose diamonds) and then scratches the cast with them. This is very annoying!!

On hardened steel, the diamonds go into the softer surface (the cast) and scratch the slipperier and harder to penetrate steel.

I know bill has mentioned issues with diamond contamination if using medium loose diamonds and then going to a fine lap. This isn't a practical problem until it gets really bad, but it's certainly a cosmetic problem!! It's really hard to make sure something like 15 micron diamonds don't exist anywhere on a tool, and the super bright polish that a 1 micron diamond imparts on hardened steel makes it really easy to see spider webbing from the equivalent of 1000 grit particles.

I remember back then someone else was testing copper and said it was sticky for tools and sharpening. I've tried brass, too, and it works OK, but it's soft and sticky and abraded brass can be gray so it's hard to tell whats actually getting rubbed. I didn't like it vs. cast.

Wood works wonderfully for an aesthetic polish, though, as each particle doesn't have that much conviction. I didn't notice any subjective difference in sharpness (or wood surface) when using phil's plate during my testing vs. a piece of hardwood, but the plate is definitely faster, and the wood is much better at making a pretty polish with nothing for foreign scratch marks. Plus you can just scrape it off if you find any.