almost certainly
David Weaver
...something happens to the metal when planing other than just abrasion, but the question is how deep does it go? Or is it just transient and does it disappear with wear all the time.
I believe (but can't prove) that something different happens with a razor because the rate of wear is so slow, but razors are a funny case because the sharpest you can get them is often a mistake. Linen and leather to round the edge some is a better idea because it pushes an edge failure point further up the bevel (where it won't occur) and it also keeps a razor from cutting skin at the back of a pore propped up by a hair without really changing its ability to cut hair. But then what's on the razor mostly stays there.
I expected to find something different with my tests - but it's only sort of circling around this. Alloy irons have a bad reputation among most craftsmen for coming apart a little bit and leaving lines. Kato and kawai found this in their planing machine tests - that the only blades that kept good uniformity at that time were the yellow steel blades (for practical purposes, the same thing as white 2).
I believe this has changed, but the machine was different than my test, and the least tough iron that I had (the chinese HSS iron, probably) still did OK and didn't show much defect.
What I believe is actually occurring with most folks when they use alloy irons is they're planing with them longer (Because they can) and incurring more damage just because they're passing more opportunities. Then, the situation is exacerbated when sharpening because the damage isn't completely removed and it continues (I have seen situations where there's a deep groove or a small edge defect and the steel erodes around it - LV actually showed the same thing somewhere on one of their testing sites - carbon steel is better at not failing that much around one of these scratches because of its toughness - what's left around a defect that's fresh is really like the corner of a chisel, and someone who uses japanese chisels that are true full hardness will likely find that their corners erode first as that's where the metal has the least support - that's where I find the limits of japanese chisels when mortising plane bodies. They can shed corners even without mistreatment).
At any rate, what my microscope showed is that you can perceive that you're doing a lot more sharpening on something like 3V or 65 hardness M2, but when you get the iron under the scope, if you know what you're looking at, you can see unfinished defects and guess what they were. 3V, for example, takes about twice as many swipes on a controlled surface to get the wear removed vs. 01. Small defects left are trouble.
However, here's the rub - when I was forced to go back and finish the job and remove all defects until they were completely gone visually, the planing defects that I expected to see early in (threatening surface quality) didn't occur. The surface brightness from the alloyed irons was higher than carbon steel, but this is probably an exacerbation of the perception of them - tiny defects show up, just as a person who takes on japanese planing will find it to be very difficult once a surface is so bright that it looks wet - absolutely everything will show up on it unless everything is perfection.
I don't think this is a shortcoming of carbon steel, I think it's a benefit - the surface is still bright, it's brighter than scraping and far brighter than sanding and some of the tiniest defects are hidden.
The only two confusing results that were documented was the fast dulling of the surface brightness with Tsunesaburo blue steel (which the microscope showed as small pocks coming out of the iron itself - it remained reasonably sharp and the defects were uniform, but they ruined the brightness), and one that's not confusing to me - that at the end of sharpening cycle, A2 seems to sort of come apart and uniform small defects appear all over the surface.
*i suspect that most people using V11 will conclude that it leaves more lines on work not because the steel itself is the issue, but because it abrades half as fast and people will not fully sharpen out prior defects*. Some of the A2 reputation for chipping is probably also due to that.
If we normally sharpen for two minutes and we sharpen for 3 with one of these high wear steels, we think we've really added a lot of time (it'll seem arduous by routine), but we're likely still coming up short.
V11 sharpens really well in the sense that it relieves itself of the wire edge, but it grinds and hones about half as fast as O1 steel at the same hardness - worse than that if an abrasive is marginal for chromium carbides. I doubt most people sharpening a dull iron spend twice as much time on it - when i got down to counting strokes for the test (sharpening) I found actually doubling them to be far more than I would've perceived if I was doing "extra work".
The fact that the fresh metal blades lost no relative durability in footage planed, and didn't really accumulate any defects (aside from the silica in maple destroying the edges of all of the irons - deflecting them into a perceived bent wire edge) makes me wonder if I was imagining the coddled benefits of my carbon steel edges.