Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

Posts

follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#1

follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

David Weaver

Last year, I reported that I was going to buy one of the generic CBN wheels off of ebay. They're not aluminum as far as I can tell, they're straight across (no special edge profiles or abrasive on the sides) and about $45 shipped, sometimes more sometimes less - I only see them for about $60 on ebay right now.

The design is very much like the spartan from WTW, but the arbor hole is 25mm on mine, which means I needed to make a bushing (so will anyone else). The inexpensive wheels in the US (about $100-$110) seem to be mostly or only for 8" grinders, and I have a 6".

Being that this was a "temporary" experience, I turned a wooden bushing that's close to perfect, but isn't perfect. the idea of buying a bushing and having it shipped seems like it cancels out some of the economy, but to some extent, I'm splitting hairs.

So far in fairly heavy use (including primary bevel work on new irons) the cheap wheel is fine. I miss the radius edge that was on my "good" wheel that came from WTW several years ago (their radius edge wheel) and my bushing of wood is slightly less accurate. The radius edge is nice to have as it allows for tidier grinding of kamisori, and it does make some things in spot grinding a wider bevel a little easier.

All in all, I'd buy the WTW wheel again for $125 (I think the regular price is $149, though, and not sure about shipping and tax).

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#2

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

Wiley Horne

Thanks for the report.

Question: Is your 6” grinder half-speed or 3600rpm? And do the irons heat up on the CBN wheel so that you have to grind intermittently to give them a chance to cool?

Question: What do you prefer about the CBN wheel over the alternatives?

Just my opinion: For any Tormek users, I think the CBN wheel from Woodturners Wonders is the best thing that ever happened to Tormek. No water, no wheel dressing, and will cut any steel from vintage high carbon to M4. My only problem was getting the old wheel off, which was ‘frozen’ onto the arbor. There’s a youtube video on how to do it, which I should have gone and found before I used my prehistoric method involving a hammer.

Wiley

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#3

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

Steve Elliott

Hi Wiley,

I'm in the process of retiring (one last project to complete when virus lockdown is over) and will be going back to sharpening using my Tormek instead of the 8" grinder with a CBN wheel I've used at work.

The wheel at work is pretty coarse and if I had it to do over, I'd get a finer grit. I think it's 80x but I'm not sure. It cuts very fast with almost no heating.

Can I ask which grit CBN wheel you got from Woodturners Wonders? I just looked at their site and was thinking about maybe getting the 600x wheel. I still would be polishing using 1 micron diamond to finish.

Hope you're doing well.

Steve

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#4

My take and need Derek’s opinion

Wiley Horne

Hi Steve,

Congratulations! Although I suspect you may have calls from your company to come back to do special jobs!

I think I got the 200g, because I see the Tormek as a pure grinder. I grind all the way to the edge—to a primary burr—and then go to Sigma 1000 or 2000 as the next step. However, I am sure I could go to a much finer stone. Almost any stone that can cut the steel will establish a new edge, after you grind all the way to a primary burr.

On your question, I think you could go straight from 200g CBN to 1u diamond, and am quite sure you could go from 400g CBN to 1u diamond. I hope Derek will

give an opinion on this, and David may have experience as well since he’s done about everything :) .

Wiley

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#5

Thanks, Wiley

Steve Elliott

I'm not ready to order the wheel yet but I appreciate hearing your experience.

Steve

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#6

Baldor full speed...

David Weaver

..my grinder is the 3600 rpm baldor cast grinder (cast rest and cast guards - unfortunately, the guards can't be used with wide wheels, so the outside part of the guards is off. Better than nothing...anyway).

Once the CBN settles in on a grinder, it's still fast, but it will create heat when you lean on it. I remember seeing a thermal transfer figure for CBN - it transfers heat to the wheel far better than al-ox or silicon carbide, but it's not 100% so you can still make an iron hot.

As a matter of policy with grinding, I don't keep water at the grinder. When I used brown al-ox wheels, I dressed them relatively often, used the coarsest possible and when I thought an iron might be warm, I pulled it across my palm to check. An iron has to be awfully hot before it will burn you that way - hotter than you want it to be.

All that said, CBN isn't any faster once settled in than the brown wheel was, but there is some less heat - it's like the amount from the freshly dressed wheel, but all the time. I still keep the brown wheel on the opposite side of the grinder for heavy annealed work or mild steel where CBN isn't really suitable.

Life changing? No, but really easy to refresh a hollow with and the dust is just metal, not wheel and metal. It would be my first choice again - the ability to grind kamisori is a really nice plus, as they're sensitive to heat and a really coarse finish wouldn't look as good - the amount of grinding is slight and a big wide surface and slow work is just the ticket.

I had the same experience with a tormek. I had trouble getting one wheel off and put another one on (the black one). When I wanted to get the black wheel off to sell the tormek and the wheels, I ended up breaking it getting it off. Just after I'd bought the upgrade kit for a stainless arbor. :( I gave the whole thing away instead (before there were ever CBN wheels for it).

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#7

I'd value wiley's opinion more than mine..

David Weaver

...but I can say this - a bit of how these wheels break in reminds me of diamond hones. I'd probably go for 200 grit to refresh tools as the wheel will slow down some over time and you'll appreciate the speed.

I had a pink wheel on my grinder (Friable, 46 grit I think). I remember being somewhat started about how deep the grind from the 80 grit CBN wheel was when I first got it, it really hacked up the bevel. But it leaves a finer finish by far now after several years of use (And the 80 grit wheel is even OK to freshen a hollow in a kamisori). It doesn't have that aggressive tooth feel of a new wheel but it's fast enough and I'd bet that with some use, the tormek wheel will do the same thing over time.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#8

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Can I ask which grit CBN wheel you got from Woodturners Wonders? I just looked at their site and was thinking about maybe getting the 600x wheel. I still would be polishing using 1 micron diamond to finish.

Steve, as Wiley noted, my view of the Tormek is that it is primarily a grinder. Some see it as a sharpening system, which is how Tormek position themselves, however I suspect that that appeals to the power tool worker who has little interest in sharpening hand plane blades and chisels.

Further to this, the only reason I imagine a turner would have any interest in a Tormek is the tool rest, which takes accessories for making specialist grinds, such as finger nails. The slow cutting and friability of the watercooled wheel makes no sense to me for the turner, since the lathe chisels are likely to be M2. The tool rest is available as the BGM-100, and makes a great accessory for a bench grinder.

My grinder set up is a half-speed 8” bench grinder with 80 grit and 180 grit wheels. This is set up principally for hand planes and bench chisels. If I did more lathe work, I would add something in the region of 300 and 600 grit. If I could only have two CBN wheels and worked equally with the two domains, it would be 180 and 350 or 600.

There is a reason why I have a 180 grit CBN for my main wheel. When I discovered CBN wheels, they were known to turners but unknown to flat woodworkers. I wanted to replicate the Tormek, which essentially is a 220 grit grinder. The 180 grit came closest. It was a happy conclusion, since that is what I went on to recommend since it just works so well for everything. I keep the 80 grit for when there is much shaping to do.

My grinding set up: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/UltimateGrindingSharpeningSetUp.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#9

Thanks, Derek

Steve Elliott

After using the Tormek as a grinder for about 15 years I set up a CBN wheel on a half speed 8" grinder for the shop I work at. It was so much quicker I put the Tormek away.

Now I'm considering what kind of set-up I want for my home shop when I'm retired. Over the years I've followed your website and really appreciate that you've shared your experience with different set-ups and methods.

Since both you and Wiley are recommending something in the neighborhood of 180 to 320 grit I know what I want to buy. With the 80 grit wheel at the shop I never wanted to grind all the way to the edge because of subsurface damage to the steel from that coarse an abrasive.

I will probably have both a Tormek style bar set up and a Stuart Batty tool rest that can be adjusted to different angles.

Thanks again for sharing your knowledge.

Steve

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#10

Re: Thanks, Derek

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Steve, one of the advantages of the Tormek (echoed by CBN), owing to the cool grind, is its ability to grind to the edge of the blade, leaving the minimum amount of steel to hone. Some may argue that this creates a weak edge, since the steel backing the edge is small. However, in practice - especially testing shooting hardwoods - I have not found this to be so, that is, the blade edge is not any weaker.

The second advantage of the Tormek is the tool rest. The captured blade sides along the bar, and this method produces a very straight bevel edge. The beauty of this is that there is little to straighten up, as one would with a coarser stone, such as a 1000 waterstone. One could actually (and I do) begin the honing process with a 6000 waterstone, and then move on to a polishing stone. A few stokes on each, and call it done!

A polished edge on a 1" Veritas PM -V11chisel ...


The photo above is a chisel ground on a 180 grit CBN 8" wheel. While the wheel is slightly coarser than the 220 grit of the 10" Tormek, the higher speed enables it to leave a smoother edge (1450 rpm on my grinder vs 120 rpm of the Tormek).

Using the same Tormek blade guides, it is a win-win (or should that be win-win-win :) ) for the CBN/bench grinder set up: speed, coolness, and smoothness.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#11

Hollow grind information...weakness...OWTs

David Weaver

When I was first starting, the assertion by many (without proof, but you don't know what proof is when you're starting - OWT type arguments with simple diagrams look attractive as proof) that the hollow grind creates a weak edge was very misleading.

The advice by supposition (presented as fact) on this kind of thing still remains an irk - especially when it would be pretty easy to prove.

It caused me to hesitate to move to a grinder and buy a tormek (which I didn't need, and now don't have) to have a larger hollow, but once I moved to a grinder and polled forums several times half a decade ago, nobody could ever present an instance (or even remember one) where they'd had an edge fail into the hollow in regular use.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#12

Hollow Grind v. Subsurface Damage

Steve Elliott

With the Tormek I found the hollow was so shallow it went away faster than I wanted when I refreshed an edge. Even with the 8" diameter CBN wheel the hollow is shallow enough that I never worry about a weakened edge. I'm thinking of a 7" diameter wheel being about optimum for me.

The edge weakening I'm concerned about has to do with very coarse scratches (80 grit CBN in my case) that may cause damage below the surface of the steel that remains even after the surface has been polished. I've read about this in reference works on metal polishing and have had some bad experiences with blades I've ground all the way to the edge which may or may not be due to subsurface damage.

My preferred sharpening routine involves grinding up close to the dull edge but leaving just a sliver of the edge so that the shape of the blade edge (crowned a little or whatever) is preserved. That leaves a little bit of steel to be removed on honing stones but speeds the process up considerably. It also keeps the deep scratches from grinding away from the cutting edge a little.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#13

Grinding to edge with Tormek

Wiley Horne

One of the things I like about Tormek is that with the slow speed I’m not afraid to grind through the previous edge, to get to new steel. That way, I’m pretty sure the wear bevel on the backside is gone. Talking about dry grinding with CBN.

Grinding to a new edge has led to edge damage exactly one time: a very hard Japanese blue steel chisel which I believe must have been a true RC64-65.

Wiley

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#14

Re: Hollow grind information...weakness...OWTs

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would say that there are a lot of subtle phenomena that you might not have enough experience to notice. Here is one that I was thinking about when you were testing plane irons.

When I tried the cherry end grain test it was very painful. It was painful because I knew that it would take a good number of sharpening cycles to restore the iron to perform as it had before the test. We don't abuse an iron like that because we know from experience how long it takes for recovery.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#15

Re: Hollow grind information...weakness...OWTs

David Weaver

I'm surprised you'd be as careless making assumptions, warren.

When I tested the plane irons in end grain, I did expect less footage. I also expected that in the test (as well as the long grain tests), I would have to do more honing to remove the wear than I would generally in day to day use (I don't plane those footages with an iron before resharpening). With a hollow grind, removing that much wear in a cycle is no big deal. If you're using a medium stone and working an entire bevel, it's not going to serve well in a situation like that (though a crystolon stone would eliminate the wear easily).

It took one sharpening cycle for me to remove the wear presented by that. It would take one freehand, too, but precisely why is because I hollow grind the irons and work a fairly small amount of metal - especially with finish stones.

I have used chisels both with flat bevels and hollow - quite a bit of each. The types of failures one gets will be the same either way. In typical actual work, I would generally work through a project (like a case held together by dovetails) using only a finish stone.

My problems in life are generally not with noticing too few subtleties, they're getting bogged down in too many.

As to whether or not anyone understands sharpening and what's going on better than I do, I haven't seen it - especially when it comes to context of work and the entire array of sharpening media available. Laziness guides me to efficient and complete sharpness, and fiscal foolishness guides me to experience with what's out there in steel types, hardnesses and stones.

As a ruse, I usually send tools back to people (when I repair or set them up) with a washita edge to see if they'll notice that they're not that sharp. I sent steve voigt one that was done with one of the lower grade dan's stones (the one between the true hards and the softs). I haven't gotten any criticism yet about the condition of the edges.

Your assumptions in this case are probably wrong, just as my assumptions were when I thought I could come up with a carbon steel iron that would outperform V11 planing clean wood. There's no combination of subtleties that will make it happen. A few of the folks who love the finest white #1 steel had a problem with my results, too, but kato and kawai (thanks to bill pulling up his papers) found the same thing. Sometimes reality is disappointing, but it's usually a good reason to consider why it may be - in my case, my preferences turned into wants instead of observing what is - fortunately, the latter prevailed.

Of course, no conclusion is final. If someone presents something that shows I'm wrong, I'm always game for it. I'm also not above someone like Jim or Steve calling me out and saying "nah, that thing that you sent me, it wasn't that great". I'd take it to heart quick and try to find out where I was wrong.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#16

Re: Hollow grind information...weakness...OWTs

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am not suggesting that you did not sharpen to fresh metal or that you did not remove wear from one session to the next.

What I am saying is that for me, going back to fresh metal (or new steel as Wiley called it) and removing all evidence of previous wear does not result in a tool that performs as well as what I experience in my usual routine.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#18

Re: Please explain. You've lost me there.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

My point was that one could not label something an Old Wives Tale based on rather limited experience. So I mentioned a phenomenon that I thought some might not have noticed. If you haven't noticed this phenomenon it would be pointless to try to defend it. Let's just say that real world sharpening and tool use is much more complicated than many current models suggest.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#19

This would be easy to quantify...

David Weaver

...in terms of whether or not leaving a conditioned bit of metal, so to speak, would improve performance vs. fresh metal. If the conditioned metal performs better, it shouldn't be much of an issue to create an iron that matches the characteristics of the conditioned metal, but I think our wear vs. toughness ideals are pretty well established already.

I'm not able to show that it occurs with O1. I'm on the fence with razors about some of the things asserted while sharpening, but I sharpen so seldom with razors, I couldn't keep track (linen and leather definitely do some honing, too - not sure how someone scientific - not me - would be able to sample the actual very edge of a razor).

A razor is far different than a plane iron, though, in that only a dirty faced miner would present appreciable wear to the edge of a razor.

With plane irons, perceptions of things that may be are very strong vs. tested items of what are. For example, I got so used to getting the absolute most (in work volume) with the least effort out of O1, that I really was far off the mark regarding how it would perform - relatively.

For its first test, it was used and freshly honed (but not harshly honed) and it planed the same footage as every subsequent case did (as in, in work condition where I don't hone more than I need to, it performed the same) - either in footage or relative to XHP (XHP planes 1.8-2 times as long in long grain, whether it planes 4100 feet or 1650), to a surprisingly consistent level.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#20

Testing...

David Weaver

...lots of things could exist. My point with the hollow grind was that the very folks who asserted weakness of the hollow bevel failed to show up in describing what actually happens and where they've seen it, whereas, I haven't.

I have out of laziness caused various edge defects over the years that I could have easily attributed to the wrong thing if I'd wished to. Something as simple as getting a different chisel that one isn't familiar with could cause that - I know what the limits of some of my tools are - heavy mortising with japanese chisels and a heavy hammer - bulk work - will usually end with corners of chisels being missing - very small corners, but they will be eroding over time. That's annoying. A set of japanese chisels that was supposedly less good because they were tempered a little softer suffered no ills.

The same japanese chisels that don't tolerate mortising with abandon will also not tolerate any twisting at all to sever small amounts of fibers in half blinds. You can think you will get away with it but eventually a corner will come off - not a large one, but one that you can see - quarter of a mm? half? I don't know. The same chisels will show nothing if not abused and are indefinitely refreshed only with a finish stone whereas many modern western chisels will tolerate the abuse but their will not retain an edge in proper use the same way.

If there is something quantifiable to this subtlety, it could be tested twice in less than an hour. If it was repeatable, then it would be something folks would be interested in.

I thought also when I tested that I would find an edge to retain uniformity much better if sharpened with natural stones, but in reality, 1 micron diamonds outperformed all of the natural stones. No matter how careful I was stropping the edge from an oilstone, there were tiny defects that didn't exist with diamonds. I wouldn't have noticed them without a microscope - and I have no ability to tell anyone if they are the reason that the oilstone lasted less long - I just know that two different fine oilstones and two different irons that would supposedly benefit (a ward infill iron and an O1 iron) didn't end up showing what I thought I'd perceived in regular use.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#21

Re: warren - pushing the point

David Weaver

warren, I hope you don't take offense when I push points like this. If I wasn't genuinely curious, I wouldn't. If you lived closer, we could get some pretty good (microscope) pictures of what's going on to see if the wear rate is slower or more uniform in a controlled test.

If your comment came from someone who used a thickness planer and a tablesaw 98% of the time, I would write it off. Just as I write off the folks who talk about faults (on SMC at the time) of the hollow grind while having no real experience using it.

But since it comes from you, it is automatically indexed in my head as a credible possibility.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#22

Re: warren - pushing the point

Wiley Horne

Yes indeed. I have learned from experience to listen to Warren. On this particular matter, blade steel has a crystalline structure, tempered martensite, so it is easy to believe that applying heavy abrasive force right on the edge will have effects that are more than skin deep. Each of us, when we decide on a sharpening method, are picking a place on the spectrum of applied force.

Wiley

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#23

almost certainly

David Weaver

...something happens to the metal when planing other than just abrasion, but the question is how deep does it go? Or is it just transient and does it disappear with wear all the time.

I believe (but can't prove) that something different happens with a razor because the rate of wear is so slow, but razors are a funny case because the sharpest you can get them is often a mistake. Linen and leather to round the edge some is a better idea because it pushes an edge failure point further up the bevel (where it won't occur) and it also keeps a razor from cutting skin at the back of a pore propped up by a hair without really changing its ability to cut hair. But then what's on the razor mostly stays there.

I expected to find something different with my tests - but it's only sort of circling around this. Alloy irons have a bad reputation among most craftsmen for coming apart a little bit and leaving lines. Kato and kawai found this in their planing machine tests - that the only blades that kept good uniformity at that time were the yellow steel blades (for practical purposes, the same thing as white 2).

I believe this has changed, but the machine was different than my test, and the least tough iron that I had (the chinese HSS iron, probably) still did OK and didn't show much defect.

What I believe is actually occurring with most folks when they use alloy irons is they're planing with them longer (Because they can) and incurring more damage just because they're passing more opportunities. Then, the situation is exacerbated when sharpening because the damage isn't completely removed and it continues (I have seen situations where there's a deep groove or a small edge defect and the steel erodes around it - LV actually showed the same thing somewhere on one of their testing sites - carbon steel is better at not failing that much around one of these scratches because of its toughness - what's left around a defect that's fresh is really like the corner of a chisel, and someone who uses japanese chisels that are true full hardness will likely find that their corners erode first as that's where the metal has the least support - that's where I find the limits of japanese chisels when mortising plane bodies. They can shed corners even without mistreatment).

At any rate, what my microscope showed is that you can perceive that you're doing a lot more sharpening on something like 3V or 65 hardness M2, but when you get the iron under the scope, if you know what you're looking at, you can see unfinished defects and guess what they were. 3V, for example, takes about twice as many swipes on a controlled surface to get the wear removed vs. 01. Small defects left are trouble.

However, here's the rub - when I was forced to go back and finish the job and remove all defects until they were completely gone visually, the planing defects that I expected to see early in (threatening surface quality) didn't occur. The surface brightness from the alloyed irons was higher than carbon steel, but this is probably an exacerbation of the perception of them - tiny defects show up, just as a person who takes on japanese planing will find it to be very difficult once a surface is so bright that it looks wet - absolutely everything will show up on it unless everything is perfection.

I don't think this is a shortcoming of carbon steel, I think it's a benefit - the surface is still bright, it's brighter than scraping and far brighter than sanding and some of the tiniest defects are hidden.

The only two confusing results that were documented was the fast dulling of the surface brightness with Tsunesaburo blue steel (which the microscope showed as small pocks coming out of the iron itself - it remained reasonably sharp and the defects were uniform, but they ruined the brightness), and one that's not confusing to me - that at the end of sharpening cycle, A2 seems to sort of come apart and uniform small defects appear all over the surface.

*i suspect that most people using V11 will conclude that it leaves more lines on work not because the steel itself is the issue, but because it abrades half as fast and people will not fully sharpen out prior defects*. Some of the A2 reputation for chipping is probably also due to that.

If we normally sharpen for two minutes and we sharpen for 3 with one of these high wear steels, we think we've really added a lot of time (it'll seem arduous by routine), but we're likely still coming up short.

V11 sharpens really well in the sense that it relieves itself of the wire edge, but it grinds and hones about half as fast as O1 steel at the same hardness - worse than that if an abrasive is marginal for chromium carbides. I doubt most people sharpening a dull iron spend twice as much time on it - when i got down to counting strokes for the test (sharpening) I found actually doubling them to be far more than I would've perceived if I was doing "extra work".

The fact that the fresh metal blades lost no relative durability in footage planed, and didn't really accumulate any defects (aside from the silica in maple destroying the edges of all of the irons - deflecting them into a perceived bent wire edge) makes me wonder if I was imagining the coddled benefits of my carbon steel edges.

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#24

side comment about the kamisoris...

David Weaver

..as I go through my piles and slowly sell things off, when I hone a razor for someone, I know they could be a beginner, so I set the edge as i'd like it to be set. Not troublesome sharp, but hit with linen and leather so that they can easily shave hair and not bleed unless they make a mistake or are heavy handed.

But for whatever reason, people seem to prefer kamisori to be as sharp as I can possibly make them. That's very transient because it's an oxide-made edge with limited stropping, so the fineness of the edge is extreme and the linen hasn't been allowed to remove some of the very edge itself by abrasion - the loose bits are gone, the leather gets them, and there isn't much after an oxide finish.

I test shaved yasuki kamisori yesterday after leaving the edge like that. There are parts of your face in a flat expanse where the edge catches skin lifted by the hair so cleanly that you will get blood slowly coming out over a large area - uniformly without being able to identify where it's coming from (beyond the typical irritation of razorburn, which is also due to the skin pulled up by the hair at the back of a pore being caught and cut or scratched by the razor).

I have no idea why people like to get a razor that way, but based on the feedback that I receive from folks, they really think "you've done a great job, I've never had a razor this sharp. I cut myself far more than I normally do - how did you get the edge this sharp" whereas a proper edge that shaves hair easily and not skin prompts no congratulatory feedback (even though it is absolutely the ideal and is precisely why shaving with a straight razor is perfect for someone who has sensitive skin - you can set the edge as needed to prevent razorburn and have it exactly the same way every single day for months without rehoning).

(that's not a straw comment either, but getting cut or bleeding. I've gotten the same comment several times from different people - and, of course, I sterilize razors before listing them. razors are one of the few things where a large part of the buying public will be reassured if you say "I completed a full shave with this razor" (you used it?!!!?) vs. saying that you didn't test the edge at all. Kind of gross.).

Re: follow-up post on the cheap cbn wheel

#25

Assertions and "special knowledge"

Jim Matthews

"If you haven't noticed this phenomenon it would be pointless to try to defend it."

This implies special knowledge that only an expert can detect.

(Russell's teapot)

"Let's just say that real world sharpening and tool use is much more complicated than many current models suggest."

This implies that the current models are incorrect, without elaboration.

(Hitchens' razor)

Kato and Kawai proved you right about cap irons. Perhaps the reason no one listened to you about that was in the delivery. This is a very narrow field of interest.

Some of the contributors are generous, and gracious about it.