Thanks to David Weaver I'm a believer in this powdered stainless steel formulation.
Anyone on the fence about commercial versions of this stuff should consider at least trying it if there's a favorite plane in need of fresh iron.
It's undeniably tough, surprisingly keen and stays sharp far longer than my favorite mid-1970s oil quenched blades.
I'm in the midst of building a matched pair of subwoofers the size of dorm refrigerators: *lots* of trying and fitting panels that must be square to seal.
I have a lovely little smoother with a replacement XHP blade (single iron bedded around 45 degrees) that has sorted the entire first build (1.5 sheets 4x8 half inch 7 ply) and is still sharp enough to slice paper.
The confirmation case just arrived as a replacement iron in my ECE jack plane.
This is a double iron setup. Oak, Cherry, even Tupelo (interlocking and soft) are a breeze.
Carpenter and Veritas have a winner for our application in this stuff.
It would seem to be the same or similar steel, but not necessarily both coming from the same place (i.e., I remember Patrick Chase mentioning that the patent is expired on V11, so it can be made elsewhere, and I think he had someone xray fluoresce a sample or at least said he did - I wasn't smart enough to figure out exactly what he was saying at the time, and my experience with most other exotic steels was that they offered trades I didn't really want as a user of natural stones).
I get my stock from a place called SB metals (who has some kind of affiliation with carpenter), but their internet stock is only available in one thickness (ground 3/32, or pre-ground of the same at .1 or so - which would be a bad idea for a shade tree garage toolmaker working metal almost without power tools).
It's nice of Wiley and Jim to make nice comments, but they're equally generous (plus some), and the fact that the irons that I make even work has to do with how good the steel itself is, as I don't follow most parts of the heat treatment instructions (I can't - just heating fast and hot in open atmosphere and quenching in oil).
Someone’s instrumental chemistry test has given a strong hunch that it is. But we have been tip-toeing around your question out of respect for Lee Valley and Rob, and also because it is not known for a fact, nor do we know LV’s heat treat regime.
Some months back, David Weaver undertook testing of PMV 11 against a number of other steels. He wanted to test PMV 11 in an actual wood-planing exercise, as opposed to LV’s planing of an engineered material. David began his testing skeptical of PMV 11, but by the time he was done he had high praise because the LV steel had handily beaten the others, including a CPM 3V iron that I sent him.
He was sufficiently jazzed about the PMV 11 that he went and bought some Carpenter XHP plate steel and made a half-dozen or so home-brew irons out of 0.10” thick stock. Those turn out to be great irons also.
The interesting thing about both David’s home-made irons and the PMV 11 irons, is that they sharpen more readily than they should, given their edge longevity when planing wood. Derek did some chisel testing that found the same thing.
As a result of David’s work, I ordered one of LV’s Stanley/Record replacement irons for a vintage 605, and am awaiting a 1/8” thick PMV 11 iron for an LN5.5. LV makes the 1/8” thick irons for its own Veritas planes, but based on the slot width (0.44” or so), they should fit LN planes.
Robert Frost has a line, roughly remembered, "...if you'll have as your guide one who has at heart only your getting lost...". I must choose my guides with intent.
But I congratulate you. You obviously are an adept.
David, I seem to recall that there was going to be a writeup of your plane blade tests. Did that ever happen? If not, consider this a vote for doing it. I know it's a huge amount of work (which I don't have to do), but many of us would really appreciate being able to learn from all the work you already did conducting the tests.
No, I never formally wrote it up. I considered publishing the results in summary and discussion on YouTube as it would be easier to do and take less effort than reading for folks just wanting to know the results.
Dave, I was telling Darryl Gent about the very nice XHP iron you made for me, and he was wondering if the stuff can be forged without losing its characteristics. Any thoughts? I would think it would be fine, but haven't played with it myself.
I don't know the answer to that, but the best way to find out is to try. There are two potential problems that I could see:
* chromium aggregates in steel (leaving behind a non-uniform structure) when the steel is left between something like 900F and 1400F. My objective to heat really quickly and quench is a matter of avoiding spending much time in that range.
* It hardens with changes of temperature of 50 degrees F per *minute*. It may be a huge challenge to do anything with it after forging as it'll probably harden when it cools, and if not, it would spend a bunch of time in the trouble temperature range on the way down.
I didn't read the schedule for annealing (it would have to be done in a vacuum, I think) because there's no way I could begin to do it, so I avoid letting it get any serious heat anywhere (even little local hardening drilling, etc, is punishing) and work it with hacksaw/file, and a drip of water while drilling (slowly).
There's a lack of ground bar stock available in terms of sizes, but knife supply places do seem to have thicker blanks (but they're usually narrow and thick) that might be suitable for a try forging without spending huge amounts of money on a larger bar or sheet.
My guess would be that machining thicker stock to shape under coolant will probably yield a better result for planing (not sure about chisels - it appears to be a pretty good chisel steel, but I would be surprised if it outperformed ideally made plain steel or O1 chisels - the bar for most manufactured chisels in terms of toughness isn't very high).
never hurts to try is still my view on it. If you asked anyone if you can just heat XHP and dip it and put it in the oven and come up with a good iron, most folks answer no (that was advice I got quietly by email "there are places that will do that for you, just send it to them and don't ruin it").
The fact that it hardens so easily is really the biggest threat, i think - forging quickly with limited heats can probably mitigate much of the chromium migration issue.
I did do one iron where I left the iron in the heat some longer chasing a slightly hotter color to see if the iron would turn out better, and some of the chromium move somehow. On the back of the iron where the hottest heat was, a pool of what felt like chromium formed (it polished differently than the rest of the iron) and the iron isn't as good as the ones that just got a quick heat. I could see the pooling when the iron was hot and hoped it would go away, but it was very prominent once the iron cooled, almost looking like a spot of plated metal on top of the iron.