Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Making Linseed Oil Stain?

Posts

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#26

Using pigment may be possible

David Weaver

I have one of the darker mini cans of minwax, but the name escapes me. It's not java, but something similar (burnt umber).

I put 4 coats of it on this test board, but the result was still only half as dark as this. I sprinkled the pigment on and used a bit of stain to spread it out and the darkness and uniformity just about doubled. Next check is to make a paste with the stain that's thick as sprinkling it everywhere won't be possible, but a thick paste that can be spread out should be fine.

It's a little darker than the picture suggests.

https://i.imgur.com/2Juy3MC.jpg

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#27

Thanks, John...

David Weaver

I don't have transtint dyes, but I have dyes from a company called Keda. It may not have been a great time for thrift, but I have them yet to try if the pigment doesn't work, and would rather use oil so this tip may come in handy.

The reason that I'd rather use oil is because you can tune what you're doing with the oil and leave a heavier or lighter coat. Hard to explain, I guess, but I noticed I can do the same thing with pigment and oil or stain conditioner - you have some touch with it when using it unlike thinner mediums. Especially vs. thinner fast drying mediums.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#29

Re: Thanks, John... *LINK*

John Aniano in central NJ

All true David,

For my joint stool I did just that - tinted the BLO for the different oak species I used. The chestnut oak had a greenish tinge to it and the red oak didn't. So I had to darken them differently to make them match. I was aiming to make the piece look old. I also found a tinted wax that worked wonders in the antiquing process. It's Lakeone Buffing Wax and it comes in different colors.

John


Lakeone Buffing Wax

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#30

Paint

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

At some concentration of pigment in oil you are making paint and not stain. If your research project winds up rediscovering paint on lookers are not going to be dazzled by the discovery ;)

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#31

Actually

David Weaver

Given that linseed oil paint (which looks quite nice) seems to be oil, drying agent and pigment) I was wondering when this would be considered paint.

The definition that I saw is that it becomes paint when the job is to obscure grain, but we won't be going that far.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#32

vs. carnauba?

David Weaver

Hi, John - can you give me your assessment (brief is OK) of that wax vs. carnauba and beeswax (in terms of hardness, sheen, etc)?

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#33

I think you missed the point

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The kind of wax referred to is used for coloring. Hardness and luster are not the attributes important to its use. Rub it on mahogany, for example and then rub it off preferentially to provide shading on moldings and to put color in pores.

An alternative is to use glaze before the top coats.

Commercially, the look you are striving for would be achieved with dye stain and glaze. The dye stain provides the depth of color and uniformity. Glaze adds more color and provides shading and grain enhancement. Might be finished up with a tinted wax.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#34

didn't miss the point...

David Weaver

...i already have tinted briwax.

If there is something a little harder, i'm interested in that. I don't recognize the type of wax that's in this variety, thus the question. When you finish by hand often, you start to appreciate having some control over the hardness of the wax.

I'm not really interested in what's done commercially, though. Commercial is often the cheapest way to a mediocre visually uninteresting result (the same is often true on guitars - very uniform from one to the next, but very uninteresting and sometimes awkward where that's OK but not desirable).

As an aside, I don't want to spray anything toned. I can get away with spraying clear in my space, but do not want to come up with an area where I can spray lacquers that aren't clear.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#35

Re: didn't miss the point...

William Duffield

Don Williams (donsbarn.com) offers shellac wax and a mixture of shellac wax and beeswax, that are both harder than pure beeswax, but not as hard as carnauba wax.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#36

Re: Same problem with shellac...

William Duffield

First, you mix your dry pigment with your carrier (e.g., mineral spirits, turpentine, etc.). That wets the powdered pigment. Then, you add the binder (e.g., linseed oil, tung oil, walnut oil, BLO, etc.). Of course, you choose a carrier that is miscible with the binder. Choose the carrier based on how quickly you want to wipe off the excess stain: Naphtha evaporates much more quickly than mineral spirits but gives you much less time to manipulate the pigment. If you need a carrier that evaporates much more slowly than mineral spirits, you could try a specialty product from Gamblin called Gamsol. Note that it is quite a bit more expensive than paint thinner at your home center.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#37

Re: vs. carnauba?

John Aniano in central NJ

Hi David,

Haven't tried mixing my own waxes for this purpose, so I can't really comment.

The Lakeone product was hard to rub out to a nice shine. VERY hard. Especially if you wait too long - longer than the recommended time between application and rubbing out. DAMHIKT. It was a workout, but the final effect was excellent imo.

I have mixed various waxs and pigments to make a pore filler for ebony used in making violin bows. I used shellac wax, asphaltum powder, gray carnauba wax and a bit of beeswax. All from Kremer. I mixed them while melted and cast them onto sort of a crayon which when rubbed on ebony with more open pored grain then I would have liked, it filled the pores with a moderately hard and colored black wax.

John

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#38

Thanks, John....I was...

David Weaver

..I was actually asking outside the scope of the staining. I'm always interested in a tinted wax (or any wax) that works well with shellac and has nice hardness.

My guitars are waxed with mothers carnauba. Not supposed to use car waxes on finishes, I guess, but it was french polished - i like the way it feels. Plus, it's mine, so I don't have to worry about what anyone else does with it.

When you tell me it's hard to rub out but works up to a nice hard sheen, that's exactly what I'm looking for. :)

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#39

Re: Don's wax

Steve Voigt

Slightly off topic, but this weekend I started experimenting with making my own paste wax, using Don's shellac/beeswax blend. I melted a bar in a double boiler and added mineral spirits and a pinch of rosin, to make it less slippery (this is for planes, and i don't want my plane flying across the room). No firm conclusion yet, but indications so far are positive. If there's any interest I'll update y'all later.

The biggest thing I noticed so far is the smell. Commercial wax like Johnson's smells like ass, but the homebrew stuff smells divine. If coronavirus is stressing you out, melt some beeswax--it's great aromatherapy.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#40

Ditto on the wax, varnish, too...

David Weaver

I've long made mineral oil beeswax mix for just about anything I can use it on, but if there's a trick to make it a little harder and longer lasting (with shellac), I'm all for it.

I like the smell of briwax, but it's not healthy, that's for sure.

Varnish made in house was an epiphany, too - it smells wonderful, like a less sharp pine sol type scent, and handling it is far nicer than commercial alkyd varnishes (it's sticky, but you can wash it off more easily). Drying without any drying agents in it is a bit of a challenge, though, if you don't have sunny days or a bird-free outdoor area.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#41

Re: Ditto on the wax, varnish, too...

Steve Voigt

Definitely try the shellac/beeswax blend if you want a little extra hardness. It's 3 parts beeswax/1 part shellac wax, which seems plenty hard as far as I can tell. One bar was enough to make enough mix to last me a long time.

Any thoughts on the proper ratio of mineral spirits to wax? I did a little less than 1:1 v/v, and it's a bit too stiff--I'm going to reheat it today and add some more mineral spirits.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#42

Re: Ditto on the wax, varnish, too...

David Weaver

When I use oil, 1 to 1 is nice. It's too stiff to just easily smear on wood, and the oil stays in that case (but on countertops, no problem).

As i recall, it can go from too stiff to too soft pretty quickly.

With the beeswax, if I'm trying to apply it to a countertop quickly, i put some mineral oil on the countertop and then blend the beeswax into it, and it all mixes pretty quickly. I can't say if that works with mineral spirits.

The shellac stick that you're talking about, is this a pre-made shellac wax? (as in, is this the wax that is removed from shellac?)

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#43

Re: Ditto on the wax, varnish, too...

William Duffield

Your source for shellac wax, beeswax and mixed beeswax and shellac wax, in a 3:1 ratio:

http://donsbarn.com/finishing-supplies/

Mineral oil and mineral spirits do not work at all the same way. Mineral spirits is a solvent and carrier. Another name for it is Stoddard Solvent. It does a pretty good job of dissolving waxes, to make them easier to spread and work into pores, but it soon evaporates and thereafter whatever it dissolved goes back to acting like it did before you added the mineral spirits. It is toxic. You do not want to drink it or inhale it. Mineral oil is a liquid lubricant. Once you mix it with other hydrocarbons and apply it to a surface, it basically stays mixed, leaving your finish softer and shinier that it otherwise would be. You can get it in a nontoxic (USP) form, that is intended to be a laxative. It is (unlike linseed) a non-hardening oil, and is thus remains suceptable to attack by solvents like mineral spirits, soaps and detergents.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#44

Re: Ditto on the wax, varnish, too... *LINK*

Steve Voigt

Yes, it's pure wax. William's link is where to buy it; I've put a link below that describes a little about the process. He wrote a longer post somewhere but I can't find it.

Also, a comment for William: Mineral spirits has a pretty low toxicity, though it's not zero. I have been on a jihad the last year trying to reduce the use of toxic crap in my shop, but mineral spirits I feel comfortable keeping.


http://donsbarn.com/shellac-wax-now-available-in-the-store/

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#45

Re: Ditto on the wax, varnish, too...

David Weaver

I think we got our wires crossed somewhere. I use a non drying oil that probably ends up in the wood, but food safe. You're using something that evaporates, thus my comments leading to the situations being a little different. While the ms is there, I can't guarantee the same gimmick will work (dribbling out a little extra solvent and then dropping a wad of premix on it and working it around. Your situation may actually work better for that as I chance too much oil that will never evaporate, but too much ms maybe solves itself. And maybe my fascination with having one mix and adding solid or solvent on the piece is dopey)

No food actually gets made on my rolling cabinet, but we do now use the ancient mix for chapped skin. Ms probably wouldn't be a problem

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#46

Re: Ditto on the wax, varnish, too...

William Duffield

It depends a lot on how cheap you are. :D MS comes in several levels of refinement, depending on how much of the nasty stuff they take out of it (or cheap, nasty stuff they don't pour into it): Paint thinner is most toxic, mineral spirits is less, low odor mineral spirits better yet, and odorless mineral spirits the least toxic, but also the most expensive. I think they remove all the benzene from the odorless, which is all I use in my shop any more. But, I think there are some very old partial cans of the smellier varieties sitting on the back of a shelf somewhere.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#47

Re: sources: shellac & candellila wax *LINKS*

John Aniano in central NJ

Two other sources:

Kremer Pigments in New York City for shellac wax:

https://shop.kremerpigments.com/en/mediums-binders-und-glues/solvent-soluble-binders/natural-resins/5694/shellac-wax

And because nobody else mentioned this wax for a mixture. I've used it to fill ebony pores by rubbing it in with a piece of cork. A very hard wax that comes from Mexico. It is used to make the emulsified wax mixture that George Frank wrote about in his books. For those who have never tried the emulsified wax, it works really well. Some violin makers use it as a top protective layer that is easily reversible. I've used it on antique furniture.

Woodfinishing Enterprises sells refined and unrefined candelilla wax:

https://woodfinishingenterprises.com/shop/waxes-and-polishes/refined-candelilla-wax/

https://woodfinishingenterprises.com/shop/new/un-refined-candelilla-wax/

John (a satisfied customer of both vendors)...

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#48

Re: sources: shellac & candellila wax *LINKS*

David Weaver

Thanks, John!!

I'm a satisfied customer of kremer pigments, also, but because a few of the nutballs who introduced me to it like it for graded oxides (sharpening). But the pigments I ordered this last week also came from there for no other reason than that I like them and they're reasonable.

I appreciate both links, and though it's not identical, the process that you describe with the wax fits another want that I have - which I guess would be similar to the description that I've seen for beaumontage. But I always like to have the supply to make stuff like that rather than juggling orders for small things.