Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Making Linseed Oil Stain?

Posts

Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#1

Making Linseed Oil Stain?

David Weaver

I haven't done this yet, but I"m not satisfied with commercial stain on cherry. I'm guessing it's formulated more for heavily sanded softwoods, and even if I sand to 220 on cherry, the absorption is poor and the depth of the color isn't what I want.

I have the ability to dye the piece that i'm making, but I'd rather have an oil based stain (my dyes are alcohol based and will find use on guitars eventually).

http://antiquerestorers.com/Articles/SAL/homstain.htm

I located this as well as some other things, and it encouraged me to try an oxide that I have on hand for razors (but don't use), which is very submicron iron oxide. Doing something as simple as wiping on regular stain and then rubbing the oxide onto the surface and wiping off the excess made a wonderful uniform result.

I have time that some other people don't (as in, if it takes a couple of applications and there's a wait between the applications, I don't care. I prefer a good result two weeks later to a crappy one two weeks sooner).

Any thoughts from folks who have made their own pigment stains? Thoughts on the recipe in the link? I've purchased some earth pigments and a couple of small cans of japan color to try either way (the second is a hedge more in the case that the pigments are too coarse). I'm looking for dark on cherry, like the sample on the right (burnt umber, raw umber and burnt sienna are the colors I've gotten, and if I need a little bit of reddish, I have a lot of sub 0.1 micron iron oxide on hand that'll never be used for anything else). The sample on the right is alcohol-based keda dye, though. I'm looking for oil-based because of the finish I'm probably going to apply over the colors.


Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#2

Making oil stain

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I answered this question last week, and many times before, on the main Forum. Maybe someone will get it in the Articles and then I can just reference it.

Mineral pigments don't fade which is the primary reason to use them. The finer the pigment is ground the better it will perform- deeper color, more bright, etc. Ideally the particles should be ground so small as to be translucent.

I learned from the chief chemist at General Finishes that their stains are formulated from mineral pigments in the material they sell as "conditioner". The conditioner contains solvent, binder and curing catalyst.

Nothing is a better pigment than a quality artist pigment nano-finely ground in a drying oil and packaged in a handy tube.

Simply add 10-20 weight % to the conditioner, stir and done. Apply with a rubber, like shellac, to build to desired depth. Cure overnight and carry on. Used this way 100 mL will do a large piece of furniture. A tube of pigment will last a lifetime.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#3

Re: Making oil stain

David Weaver

Thanks, Bill. I noticed that the japan colors aren't really that expensive (and they are supposedly just very fine ground pigment in a linseed oil type base with japan drier).

Kremer was referenced years ago on the razor forum as a place to get .09 micron iron oxide. Many of the other pigments don't specify anything, so I have some reservation about how fine they'll be (we'll see).

.09 micron iron oxide does make for a nice edge on a razor, but it's a very transient level of sharpness, so it's not particularly useful for me.

My motivation is what you're saying about lightfast properties of the color. I don't want the cabinet I'm making to change color of fade like guitars do (transtint and other dyes may be very lightfast for dyes, but they're not lightfast in an absolute sense. Guitars are an easier medium because if they fade some, nobody cares if they age, and they probably don't do that quickly, anyway, as they're usually in a case).

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#4

The problem with Japan Colors

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Unless you have high shear mixing, or the patience of Job with a mortar and pestle, effectively mixing dry pigment into oil will never be fully successful. I have bags of useless dry pigment from this step in the journey.

Japan Colors have the same problem as varnish. Open the can, expose to oxygen, get free radical oxidation initiated and the next time you need some the material is thicker and eventually unusable. I have several useless cans as a reminder of this step along the way.

I suppose because of the reduced exposure area and impermeability of the metal tubes, artist oils seem to last forever. When the other approaches run into problems try the artist oils.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#5

Same problem with shellac...

David Weaver

..i tried this a couple of weeks ago to tone shellac. Most of the oxides aren't soluble in oil or alcohol, I gather, so you end up getting some color, and then other times, you get a huge amount of pigment.

What i noticed last night (and what I think I may try) is that with really fine pigments, it's easier to avoid making the "stain" if the situation will allow and sprinkle a little bit of powder onto the surface of the rubber or the surface of the test piece (case later on) and rub the oxide like that with oil.

we'll see if that works out in practice.

I made the not so smart assumption that because japan color pastes are often described as being in a linseed oil base that mine would be, too. Then looking up the MSDS found that it appears that they're naptha and something else that's not similar to oil.

The other thing I was hoping to try was finding a combination of pigments that worked well, mixing them dry, and then using only some of the mix at a time, to make a heavy paste that could to stuck onto a rubber or placed on the workpiece and then smoothed out with some of the same oil that's used in the paste.

I think some of these might work, but they're not commercially viable for sure, or that user friendly for someone who wants wax on/wax off, or they would be in wider use.

Aniline dyes are super popular in the world of guitars because they're easy, I guess - apply some dye, it dries quickly, if it's not strong enough, do it again, or three or four times if needed.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#6

Re: Same problem with shellac...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Pigments are not soluble....by definition. Definition: pigment insoluble dye, soluble.

They are to be dispersed into something. They are formulated to be dispersed into whatever they are preferred to be dispersed in and shellac is not one of the possibilities. After exhausting all the other possibilities try what I have found works best.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#7

Re: Same problem with shellac...

David Weaver

re-reading your post, I think we're on the same page (except I don't have any tubes to put pigment in, but I could improvise something with plastic). I've given up on the "one pass and it's perfect" kind of thing and really favored how sprinkled on pigment worked (then spread around with additional oil to make it easy to even out).

The honing paste marketed for razors is more or less the same thing, too - an oxide mixed with some kind of oil (but thick) and intended to be spread out on a surface. When it's diluted a little bit, it's more or less just a stain.

The definition of japan colors in tubes is the same thing you're saying, too - concentrated color, but as with most things, without doing a lot more shopping, I can't find exactly what I'm looking for (micronized powders either dry or already mixed in linseed oil).

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#8

Re: Same problem with shellac...

Oskar

I can´t add much to the pigment discussion, but maybe adding raw linseed oil to the first coat (or just raw linseed) might be a way to get more depth. Raw linseed oil has smaller molecules than boiled, and penetrates deeper and faster. Maybe something for your cherry?

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#9

General Finishes conditioner+artist pigment

Wiley Horne

at 10-20% pigment by weight. Don’t want this gem to get lost in the thread.

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#10

More conditioner....

David Weaver

being unfamiliar with staining (generally, aside from floors or other things that aren't very demanding), when I bought the pigment stains to try, I got a few minwax types.

I also bought a small can of their pre-stain conditioner to see if it made any difference.

From a not-researched point of view, it seems like it's nothing more than "clear stain", just a way to get the carrier for the stain in wood before the stain itself so that the stain can't "overabsorb" into softer spots. It did OK, but in something like curly cherry, it didn't really do much. That's neither here nor there - I have it now and could mix pigment in it.

(a one-minute check of the SDS shows that's either accurate or almost exactly correct - that the non-pigment materials are the same as those that are in the "pre-stain conditioner").

I like BLO for reasons that I can't really defend. I may be imagining that I'll have better luck with a thick paste that's diluted on the piece with additional oil and applied a couple of times to even things out.

We'll see.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#11

Re: More conditioner....

Wiley Horne

Hi David,

As always, your experiences, fully detailed, are valuable to all of us.

Bill gave this reason for using conditioner as the pigment-carrier, rather than putting the pigment directly into the oil:

“ Unless you have high shear mixing, or the patience of Job with a mortar and pestle, effectively mixing dry pigment into oil will never be fully successful. I have bags of useless dry pigment from this step in the journey.’”

Please let us know whether you have the same experience, or different.

Wiley

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#12

Artist's oils lasting forever...

John in NM

I have a tube of perfectly good crimson that I use in duplicating a horrible red stain from a German G3 rifle - they were birch with this red stuff on them, everyone thinks they were walnut.

Point is, that tube belonged to an aunt who dabbled in painting as a girl in the 1950's.

As a kid I had my paternal grandmother's paints, tubes were so old that the lead tube had lead caps! Paint was dried into the threads but I would get to it by poking a little hole with an Xacto and squirting out the still good paint. The hole would scab over eventually and I could just pull the scab off and get more paint. I think I still have those around somewhere, I ought to see if they are still good 35 years later.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#13

Oil in the recipe

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When I originally published this procedure it included 10% linseed oil. I was challenged as to whether the oil did anything if a varnish finish was used. I didn't know. In fact, I add the 10% oil, but it may not do anything to improve anything. With a shellac finish I suspect, without confirmation, the oil would deepen the effect.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#14

I was not clear........

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

“ Unless you have high shear mixing, or the patience of Job with a mortar and pestle, effectively mixing dry pigment into oil will never be fully successful. I have bags of useless dry pigment from this step in the journey.’”

This reason is the reason I use artist oil. For the binder and solvent I use the conditioner because that is what General uses, and by association, probably every other pigment stain manufacturer.

What would be the difference diluting the artist pigment, or any pigment, with linseed oil as David seems inclined to do. I don't know. I have had excellent success with what I have been doing so I am not going to change unless data causes reconsideration.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#15

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There are some weird notions in this thread.

Here are some other options: You could use a water stain and use linseed oil on top. You could use an alcohol stain plus linseed. You could tint the linseed oil with an oil soluble dye.

You could use a long oil varnish like "danish oil" that has been tinted with dye or you could add your own dyes to Danish oil. Or you could do a combination of water stain and tinted oil coat.

Keep in mind that cherry darkens considerably with age and looks awfully nice on its own after a term, so you might want to go a little easy on darkening. A pigment stain will compromise clarity, depth, chatoyance.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#16

Historical....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In the Schiffler book, stones for grinding pigment into oil are listed in several cabinet shop inventories (as well as frequent mention of Turkey stones). Greene's book lists both dye and pigment stains used in 18th century Period Furniture-the Siennas, Van dyke brown, the umbers, for example.

Indeed if the surface, and the stain, is not properly prepared a pigment stain will compromise clarity, depth, chatoyance. Staining is a lot like all the other facets of woodworking. It takes some experience to get it right.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#17

Color considerations

David Weaver

In this case, the mrs has chosen " very dark " to match other furniture that was purchased. My choice is to never use stain, but I'll try to get this one uniform.

I used "nothing special " wood that I have for this one, too, so it'll benefit from the dark color.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#18

Re: Historical....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think most microanalysis of early finishes suggests water stains on the wood (or chemical stains) and pigments in a topcoat, not really 20th century style oil stains.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#19

Follow up - terminology...

David Weaver

So, there's trouble with terminology for me here because I haven't been exposed to the art world and hadn't thought much about stain other than noticing that the conditioner seemed to be the stain made without pigment.

What you're referring to as artist oil is what I thought japan color was, as one article explained japan colors to be concentrated pigments in oil. It also mentioned that they were in linseed oil with dryers.

But further examination suggests that a lot of the japan colors are now in naptha, and hydrocarbons similar in name to the stain SDS.

It appears your terminology for artist colors and my japan colors are similar. I like linseed oil better than the "conditioners", but if they mix better with the japan colors I got (which are just artist oils in a can instead of a tube), then I'll likely be doing almost the same thing as you've come up with.

I'd still like to try the pigment pastes (making them with linseed oil), but we'll see how fine the pigments are. If they're coarse, then it'll be a no go because they won't settle in on open areas of cherry without drastic sanding.

What I noticed about the submicron iron oxide is that it seemed to settle in on areas of differing density much better (evenly across all surfaces) than stain in a can. Many test pieces to do before subjecting the cabinet itself to destruction.

At any rate, terminology with something new always causes me a problem. My problem solving and experimenting sniffer is strong. Reading and properly discerning verbal things and using proper terminology...not so much.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#20

to get dark.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You are going to have to use a dye stain and maybe a glaze on top of that to get dark. Spraying will be easiest if you have the capability.

I have never successfully stained with pigment over a hand planed surface. I can't control the depth of color. But, I am striving for a lighter more transparent coloring.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#21

I'm OK with that....

David Weaver

..if it turns out to be the only thing that works. In the sample picture I showed, dye goes dark fast, pretty much on any surface, and the reason guitar coloring often uses it (as far as I can tell) is that you can go little or lots of color depth and evenly more easily than you can with stain.

I have concentrated alcohol based dyes now (in anticipation of failure of staining, so be it).

I originally had the foolish thought that I'd buy a canned stain and put polyurethane over it (something i never do) and it would work well. Dye is my backstop if nothing else works. It isn't just about this project at this point, though, or I'd just go to it and be done with it - it's the desire to experiment and see if I can manage to achieve the same or similar results with lightfast pigments. I'm OK with failure, as success without experimentation doesn't really get me anywhere (it's not like i'm doing this for money - the mrs. is lining me up to replace all of the doors in the house and fix/paint all of the trim - I'm in no rush) and it's often not interesting.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#22

It is all about particle size

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The highest quality artist pigments are pigments that have been ground in some sort of drying oil base, probably linseed oil, to a particle size that becomes transparent. There will be enough verbiage from the manufacturer to ensure the particle size is as good as it can get. I don't know if the formulation has "drying" catalyst but I suspect not. Invariably they come in a tube and the stuff in the tube lasts forever, which is why I suspect lack of catalyst.

As I understand it Japan Colors are similarly ground into oil and with catalyst. I have never seen any information about particle size on a Japan color can. They are cheap so I would guess they are not ground as fine as high quality artist oil paint pigments.

While I don't understand it, high energy mixing either from a high shear mixing device or elbow grease with a mortar and pestle seems to be necessary to incorporate the pigment into the oil. I don't understand the physics of what is going on. (When I was trying to prepare pigment stains from powder I got a lesson from someone in a paint research lab on this topic. )

But it doesn't matter. To get dark and uniform you are going to have to dye.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#23

choosing a dye stain

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The stains based on "premetallized" dyes are extremely light fast. I tested some against historical chemical coloring of mahogany and they greatly out performed ammonia, caustic and chromate.

You can tell if they are premetallized if you can get a MSDS sheet on them. Duh, the information will have some clue they contain a metal. Often it is cloaked. For example, this dye is know to the state of CA....CA "knows" that every metal used for dyes causes cancer.

As I understand it the Transtint dyes are premetallzied. So are a lot or all the Moser dyes from Woodworkers Supply.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#24

Re: choosing a dye stain

David Weaver

My dyes may be too friendly to be "good".

Reading a little bit further about the pigments, and your mention that you cannot get them to become uniform in oil without a lot of work, I think I see where we're differing (and as a side note, I quite like the look of linseed oil paint, but the expensive linseed oil paint also mentions that it needs to be mixed thoroughly when used because the pigment will settle at the bottom of the can).

At any rate, whereas you've gone to artist oils because they blend into the conditioner readily, i'm thinking more of an end-around with micronized pigments - but micronized not for mixing capability, rather the ability of the super fine pigments that I have to settle uniformly on the surface of wood, whereas the relatively inexpensive can stains seem to be extremely sensitive to surface prep. the iron oxide sprinkled on and then moved around acted differently - it seemed to get a grip on and stay on everything unless worked more briskly.

So the honing paste type consistency that I'm thinking of just makes the paste that the pigment is mixed in too thick for the pigment to settle easily. Rather than mixing the paste into the conditioner (this is, i gather what you're saying), i'm adding the conditioner (could end up being linseed oil) into the pad to rub the pigment on and using that as the medium to disperse it.

that worked really well on a small test piece, except i used powder. I have enough experience with honing to know that I don't want to handle the powder all the time because it's too easy to spill it. The thick paste will hopefully work the same way, but you can't accidentally sprinkle it all over the place or have it blowing around.

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

#25

Re: Making Linseed Oil Stain?

John Aniano in central NJ

Hi David,

Another approach might be to use Transtint dyes to color your linseed oil. Although I don't think they don't mention it any longer, the alcohol based Transtint dyes can be mixed with some acetone first and then this is added to your oil. Their old instructions described this process. The acetone is miscible in alcohol and somewhat in oil. The method has worked for me several times using long oil varnishes such as Sutherland Wells tung oil varnish, Epifanes boat varnish as well as plain BLO. I tinted the former two to match fading due to decades of carpet on my home's pine stair treads and living room flooring. The BLO was used to darken and "pop" the color on an oak joint stool I made a few years ago. I used chestnut oak for the turned legs and had to match the color of the rest of the stool made from red oak.

My $0.02...

John