Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Leap of faith.......

Posts

Leap of faith.......

#1

Leap of faith.......

roger lance

I come to woodworking from the power tool side.....my dad was a carpenter and I worked with him growing up......Norm Abram became my role model.

I've followed the advice of people here like Derek Cohen and others in choosing hand tools. Now, my nice new western style back saws are giving me pause as they are "sticking" when I try to start a cut and I remember watching a Paul Sellers video where he took a flat metal file and trimmed the first 5 -6 teeth on a dovetail saw which allowed it to begin cutting with no problem.

That calls for a leap of faith.....filing like that on a new saw.....but, I did.....and it works. Thanks Paul.....you've got a new fan.

Re: Leap of faith.......

#2

Re: Leap of faith.......

Jim Matthews

I consider Derek an invaluable resource. Most of what I plan to build, he has documented his approach and warned us of the pitfalls.

I've taken to cutting a "V" where I want the saw to start cutting. I think DC mentioned that, too. That's the thing about his suggestions, they seem obvious - after I botch everything else.

Re: Leap of faith.......

#3

Re: Leap of faith.......

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Jim, thanks for the vote of confidence. I would like to clarify that, while I have mentioned the “V” notch when starting a saw cut, that was a long while ago. Bill is the one who has been using and writing about it recently.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Leap of faith.......

#4

dovetail saw starting

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Starting a saw to saw a dovetail kerf is a complex operation. The saw needs to be oriented with high angular accuracy in two directions and positioned on the scribe line to +/- a very few thousandths of an inch. And then the teeth need to be engaged with a stroke of the saw while keeping all that positioned properly. It didn't go well for me when I had to keep all these variables in mind at the start of the cut. Some crutches are helpful to lessen the number of things to be concentrated on, at least until some of them become subconsciously controlled.

Starting the saw is smooth if either/or the saw is lifted some at the start or it is oriented at a steep angle to the end of the board. I saw unusual so the lift works for me once it became something I didn't need to think about. The LV saw starts easier I think. I have come to prefer it over the LN saw unless the dovetail stock is thick.



I think it Roger who brought my attention to making a notch to start the saw in, as shown in the picture. I could saw dovetails now without this crutch but keep it as a time saver. I timed 30 seconds to make these notches on a 7" drawer- 4 pins and 2 half pins. I am trying to wring time out of drawer making and this crutch is a winner for me in several ways.

I just finished 6 drawers and two dovetailed cases- dozens of dovetails in total. All these joints came together without further adjustment. I drop the saw in the notch and saw away, confident that one positioning variable is fixed by the notch. That in itself is a major time saver. Added over the sum of dozens of saw cuts the notch saves time sawing too. There is no fiddling with saw position, only the saw angle. The notch may even aid saw starting for the saw is started on a small flat rather than an edge.

Someone will probably ask, why the double scribe line? Granddaughters were helping build these case pieces and the younger one grabbed the wrong marking gage, scoring the incorrect line, to be corrected by the second scoring.

Re: Leap of faith.......

#5

More currently ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Most here are likely aware that I promote the use of blue tape in marking out tails, and a kerfing chisel for deepening the socket kerfs.

Blue tape makes it much easier to see the lines, as well as accuracy in sawing. Place the saw against the edge of the tape, and go for it. No need for "V" cuts :)

I have also written about blue tape to aid in registering the tail board against the pin board, which came out of compound dovetails at the time.

Deepened kerfs makes waste removal much easier.

Kerfing chisel: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/KerfChisel.html

These three "tricks" add about 1-2 minutes to set up, but save several times this in accuracy, transfer effort, and waste removal.

I have just uploaded a short (8 minute) video I made in 2018 when dovetailing the compound drawer fronts for the Apothecary Chest.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gsBTfs7tVSs

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Leap of faith.......

#6

Re: Leap of faith.......

Hank Knight

Roger, my view is that filing a perfectly good saw is a non-starter. There are techniques that solve your problem. I'd practice one or two of them until I got proficient before I considered filing my saw. I had the same problem starting a cut that you describe. I kept at it until I could start accurately with one or two light strokes against my thumbnail registered on the line at the beginning. It works for me. Derek's and Bill's solutions I'm sure work too. Pick one and keep at it. Don't file your saw.

My $.02

Hank

Re: Leap of faith.......

#7

Re: Leap of faith.......

roger lance

Hank.....I know it sounds absurd......but, it works very well.

Please go to YouTube and find a Paul Sellers video on "10 Quick Woodworking Tips" from October 2019......the saw tip is towards the end. He uses a flat file which is pitched at a slight downward angle from tooth #6 to #1......just a couple of strokes with tooth #1 more filed that #2.....etc.....etc.

Just a lite filing and its done.....and the saw is able to freely start on the first downstroke.

Re: Leap of faith.......

#8

Placeboes and crutches

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Anything that encourages someone to use dovetails is good by me. The placeboes and crutches that get one started will be soon shed as experience is acquired so no harm is done.

Question (I don't do Utubes), are you filing the end of the saw? I don't start a cut with the end of the saw, but then I saw strangely.

I have to ask....what are you building with these dovetails? We are suffering a shortage of building examples on this site.

Re: Leap of faith.......

#9

Re: Placeboes and crutches

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I don't start a cut with the end of the saw, but then I saw strangely.

Strange you may be ... :) ... but I similarly do not start a saw from the toe. Looking at the video, I start about 2/3 back.

I also note that, depending on the grain, I can start the cut with the plate resting against a thumb, and push forward lightly. On a different angle, the saw may be dragged back and create a slight kerf .. and this is because the teeth want to dig in at that direction.

There is also demonstration here that the saw cut is started at the heel of the line, and intersecting with the vertical line (although I chose not to bother pencilling in a vertical line here), and then sawing across the board. Sawing both lines simultaneously aids accuracy.

Lastly, that blue tape acts like a fence to guide the saw. Place the teeth against it and just do it.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Leap of faith.......

#10

An alternative approach

Denny

The one thing that made the biggest difference for me was completely eliminating any vibration when starting the saw. I use a quick and dirty moxon vise and grip the piece that I'm sawing as low in the vise as possible, so only the minimal amount of wood is protruding above the vise. The vise is firmly clamped to the bench. I find that as little as 1/4 inch extra sticking up above the vise makes it significantly harder to start the saw. I've found this to be the case when working with cherry and using either a Lie Nielsen or Lee Valley saw.

Maybe this is obvious to everyone else, but it was a miracle cure for me. No filing, no notching needed. I still use blue tape to make it easier to see where to saw.

Denny

Re: Leap of faith.......

#11

good point- It wasn't obvious to me until.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....I made the Moxom vise which held more securely than the less secure arrangement I had been using. I thought I had been holding drawer sides tightly. So, my experience matches yours. I find I can use a coarser saw with the board truly vibration-free.

Re: Leap of faith.......

#12

Location

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Is the notch made on the waste side of the cut?