Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

I need Japanese saw advice

Posts

I need Japanese saw advice

#1

I need Japanese saw advice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Is this Woodcraft saw suitable for the need described below

https://www.woodcraft.com/products/razorsaw-kataba-saw-255mm-no-105-with-replaceable-blade-gyokucho?via=573621f869702d06760016df%2C58051ef669702d7fa6002153

I don't regularly use a pull saw except for cutting the sockets for dovetailed drawer dividers. It was once asked why I was using a rip saw for this operation and the answer was ignorance and that is what I owned. Woodcraft has given me an opportunity to buy a cross cut at a price in line with the amount I will use it.


Re: I need Japanese saw advice

#2

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

Philip F Duffy

my 2 cents; they are precise saws and work beautifully at every PULL. P.

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

#3

cut length?

David Weaver

Is the cut length going to be something along the lines of 10-18"? If so, there's not enough structure to a kataba like that - that's essentially a parts saw.

The saw used for sockets and dado work is called an azebiki. It looks kind of like a veneer saw, but works well for long cuts.

If the cut is just going to be the front end as shown in your picture and there's never going to be much length or depth, I think you would still enjoy a saw with a spine like the one shown in your picture. A kataba like you're showing is better for cutting ends off of smaller boards (where a spine may get in the way) unless it's a bigger saw.

I gave most of my japanese saws away a few years ago to a friend, or I'd just give you one of mine.

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

#4

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

Wiley Horne

Hi Bill,

The specs on the saw indicate a very fine smooth cut, at 22 tpi, which you want for this use. It’s got the tpi of a fine dovetail saw on a longer blade. The lack of full-length spine may be a benefit for the intended use, because you’re always going to be using a finger to keep the blade against the fence (as shown in photo), and you have an unobstructed sightline from all angles.

It’s a steal for $20, and I would predict will find other special jobs around the shop.

Wiley

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

#5

ordered....thanks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have two bed side dressers and a desk that will involved these joints. Will let all know how the saw works out.

I have no doubt there are better saws for the task but the relevant question was whether there are better saws I would spend the money for, for the task.

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

#6

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, the saw you link to is not the same as the saw in the photo. The saw in the link is a kataba, and does not have a back.

I would prefer to use a dozuki, as in the photo, which has a back. Just like a Western backsaw, the back offers a stiffer and therefore more stable cut. With dividers, you are not sawing deeper than about an inch, so depth is not an issue here.

Secondly, the teeth of most dozukis are very fine, somewhere in the range of 18 - 26 teeth. More importantly, the plate is very fine and the set is minimal. I have used rip- and crosscut saws interchangeably. I do not think this makes much difference.

If you plan to get another saw, look for the one in the photo, or a Z-saw. They are both cheap and very reliable. Rip and about 20 teeth. I use one for crosscutting the dovetail ends of drawer sides, or for precision cuts in thin stock, where the finish is important.

Regards from Munich (visited an amazing museum of design today - more later)

Derek

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

#7

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

Jim in Burlington

Hi Wiley,

I have had similar experiences with the same saw,

Take care, Jim

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

#8

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

Jack

Bill,

If you do not mind, which saw did you order. I am confused as to the picture of the saw and the link. they seem to be different saws. Jack

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

#9

I'll try

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I accompanied my son in law to Woodcraft. I saw this saw on sale and it looked like it would be perfect for my need. I don't know anything about Japanese saws. It is cross cut.

It says Razorsaw-Japan 0.5-255 no. s-105

on the spline there are some characters and "05"

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

#10

I see the problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the picture shows what I need the saw for as illustrated with an old picture showing sawing the dovetail socket with a rip saw- Doseki? (or some such).

The new saw is different. cross cut and short spline

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

#11

Re: I need Japanese saw advice

roger lance

Gyokucho and Z-Saw are saw brands. Dozuki and Kataba are saw types.

If you are patient, Woodcraft does offer some very attractive deals on Japanese saws.....maybe one saw every other month.