I used to be...
David Weaver
one of bode's biggest critics when he first started because he listed everything as "rare, exc., mint" and tried to sell a lot at double the current market (and in the case of some things, like infills, he would buy all that were available wherever he went - squeezing out other dealers who were more reasonable).
BUT, in time, he appears to have learned that the market won't pay exorbitant prices for normal things, and I've actually bought a few things from him, and unintentionally recently sold an infill plane to him on ebay. He paid more than anyone else on a fixed listing - as in, the plane was listed for quite a while (a reconditioned spiers coffin smoother) and he is the only one who had any interest in it.
I've been perusing his site hoping to see what he's going to ask for it, as he's got other infill planes that are *less* than I've sold some of mine for, which makes me a little bit embarrassed!! I haven't seen the plane he bought from me cross his page, and it may never as it could've been a request from one of his favorite customers to find spiers planes or whatever.
And in perusing, and in previously looking for some common less than perfect tools, I have become a customer of his. Yesterday, I bought 10 NOS simonds taper saw files from him for $28 shipped (of interest only for people who would be filing rip saws, they're not little files) - that's a steal.
W.R.T. any good condition plane that may have come from the 1700s, as a non-collector (as in, maybe there's an exception I don't know about), nearly anything made prior to 1800 seems to have significant value.