Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

what profile is this molding plane?

Posts

what profile is this molding plane?

#1

what profile is this molding plane?

ken ca

Pulled this one out of my dusty old collection of wooden planes, cleaned off the dust sharpened the blade and this is what it cut. What is this profile called? It makes a quarter round with a fillet but I am hoping there's a better name for this profile?


img

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#2

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

Wiley Horne

Nice plane! Maybe Warren can put a date range on it—looks old to these eyes. How is the heel marked?

John Whelan, in The Wooden Plane, p. 194, says it was called a Casing Molding plane, because it was a frequent mold found on door and window casings in tHe 1800s. He goes on to say the profile is definitely older than that, though.

Years ago, I bought from Patrick Leach a 7/8” (marked ‘7’ on the heel) plane like this, made by John Lindenberger, who served in the American Revolution. Like yours, it is sprung. I’m pretty sure I recall Patrick saying a typical use for this size would be profiling the top of a blanket chest.

Patrick also may have called it a ‘thumbnail’ mold, but I could be misremembering this. Perhaps Warren can cast some light on casing molding versus thumbnail versus......

Wiley

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#3

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

ken ca

Wow, thanks for the info Wiley. I have that book, so will check it out.

Other than three users names - a fact alone that's kind of unusual, I rarely see more than one, occasionally two - at least on my selection - there are no other marks on the plane. A few woodworm holes, and plenty of hammer marks on the heel but nothing useful.

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#4

Thumbnail

Wiley Horne

Ken,

Jim Bode also calls it a ’thumbnail’.

https://www.jimbodetools.com/products/crisp-and-fine-10-inch-yellow-birch-6-8-inch-thumbnail-molding-plane-by-jo-fuller-providence-59168

Wiley

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#5

Re: Lindenberger

Steve Voigt

Hey Wiley, Lindenberger is quite early; that plane must be fairly collectible. I'd love to see some pics if you've got any.

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#6

John Lindenberger

Wiley Horne

Hi Steve and all,

Here are some photos:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157712278341536

The plane is 10” long. Doesn’t look like beech to me. It’s got marks collected over the years, but is perfectly sound and works well. You could read his stamped name in a dark closet.

American Wooden Planes, Pollack, has a long write-up on John Lindenberger. Planemaking years were after the War, 1786-1817, advertising for an apprentice in 1803. Present at battles of Brandywine, Germantown, Trenton, and Princeton.

Interesting item: His estate at his death included 962 molding plane irons, 1500 feet of beech and birch, 1/2 gross sandpaper, 14 float files, 391 molding planes @ $0.20, 59 bench planes @ $0.50, 2moving fillisters @ $1.00, 3 plow planes @ $2.33. Besides planemaking, he was a blacksmith, toolmaker, taught architecture, traded goods and accepted country produce as payment.

Died insolvent in 1817. I might add that the ill-conceived War of 1812 caused great devastation in the economy of the New England states (and they seriously considered leaving the Union in consequence).

Wiley

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#7

Re: Thumbnail

ken ca

Cough! Cough! Bode's pricing is err......pretty high. LOL.

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#8

Re: Thumbnail

Wiley Horne

True, but he has worked hard to build a reputation, and Jo. Fuller is very collectible.

Wiley

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#9

I used to be...

David Weaver

one of bode's biggest critics when he first started because he listed everything as "rare, exc., mint" and tried to sell a lot at double the current market (and in the case of some things, like infills, he would buy all that were available wherever he went - squeezing out other dealers who were more reasonable).

BUT, in time, he appears to have learned that the market won't pay exorbitant prices for normal things, and I've actually bought a few things from him, and unintentionally recently sold an infill plane to him on ebay. He paid more than anyone else on a fixed listing - as in, the plane was listed for quite a while (a reconditioned spiers coffin smoother) and he is the only one who had any interest in it.

I've been perusing his site hoping to see what he's going to ask for it, as he's got other infill planes that are *less* than I've sold some of mine for, which makes me a little bit embarrassed!! I haven't seen the plane he bought from me cross his page, and it may never as it could've been a request from one of his favorite customers to find spiers planes or whatever.

And in perusing, and in previously looking for some common less than perfect tools, I have become a customer of his. Yesterday, I bought 10 NOS simonds taper saw files from him for $28 shipped (of interest only for people who would be filing rip saws, they're not little files) - that's a steal.

W.R.T. any good condition plane that may have come from the 1700s, as a non-collector (as in, maybe there's an exception I don't know about), nearly anything made prior to 1800 seems to have significant value.

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#10

Re: Thumbnail

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Both these planes appear to make a quarter round moulding with a fillet. There are several terms for this type of moulding over the centuries.

Thumbnail moulding is a term we use for a quarter round with fillet that is used on furniture. Examples are the inside edge of a door frame or the outside edge of a lipped drawer. I think this is a twentieth century term, but we use it a lot, mostly for the more delicate mouldings. Here in Pennsylvania when this same moulding occurs on a 6X6 white oak door frame, we usually call it a bead.

The terms ovolo, quarter round,andbead are historic terms for these types of mouldings, but strict definitions vary over time and place.

Ken's plane appears to have been altered; the plane is much too wide for the size of the moulding it cuts. Prices for this type of plane increase as the width increases because of extra labor.

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#11

Re: John Lindenberger

David Weaver

Excellent write up about the history of the maker, Wiley.

Interesting how many otherwise successful lifetime workers/tradesmen/whatever have a record showing that they were indigent at death (one would presume that either business changed for them or they "lived too long" and had a period of existence without the ability to earn).

My grandparents would talk about what it was like to farm through the depression. If you had two bad crops in a row, you may spend years eating things other people wouldn't consider now and spending $0 of discretionary income on yourself...years. They don't talk about it fondly, but I think they resent later generations for not having to deal with that in their lifetimes.

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#12

Warren, I wonder?

ken ca

Warren,

I wonder if it ahs been modified? I found this example online and it appears to be similar in dimensions to mine. Now, I don't mind if it has been modified because it's just a user and to me the large fence and stop made for easy planing so I am happy with it.


img

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#13

Hard times

Wiley Horne

David and all,

There were events leading up to The War of 1812, and the war itself, which caused havoc with the economy of the New England states. President Jefferson’s embargo on British trade stopped shipping between GB and the US, beginning in 1807. This pleased the Southern states but badly hurt merchant shipping from New England ports. These merchants and associated bankers and so forth had less money to furnish and refurnish their homes in style—so the cabinetmakers suffered. For example, the famous Seymours in Massachusetts never recovered from the war. One can easily imagine that the toolmakers—like John Lindenberger—lost orders as a consequence.

And of course, old age is the enemy of piecework, not to mention getting paid in produce. Lindenberger was born 1754 (in Baltimore), so was 63 at his death in 1817.

Wiley

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#14

Re: Hard times

Brad Chenoweth

Wiley, also, in the spring of 1816, Mt. Tambora in Indonesia erupted, causing catastrophic weather changes across the world. Frosts during the spring and summer months devastated crops across New England. It was during this time period that many New England families moved to the "Connecticut Firelands" area in NE Ohio.

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#15

To misquote Rutger Bregman

Jim Matthews

"In the past, things were worse."

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#16

Re: To misquote Rutger Bregman

Joe shelton

But only for 15 hours, then all was well...

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#17

Re: John Lindenberger

Steve Voigt

Wiley, thanks for the photos, and sorry for the slow response (I've been doing the holiday travel thing and haven't checked the forum since my last post).

The plane is almost certainly yellow birch, btw. It looks to be in nice shape and has all the great characteristics of the 18th C New England makers--length, species, finial, blind side chamfers, etc.

AFAIK, Lindenberger's estate that you mentioned is the earliest reference to planemaking floats. I suspect they were in use at least a century earlier, but proof is elusive.

Anyway, thanks for the pics and Happy New Year!

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#18

Re: I used to be...

Steve Voigt

Agree, I have the same take on JB. I bought some stuff last year and found the prices to be on the high end of reasonable. Customer service is also excellent with Jim.

Nice score on the files, btw.

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#19

Re: I used to be...

David Weaver

Unfortunately, the files are Chinese origin. They may still be ok, but I haven't tried them yet.

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#20

History repeating?

Wiley Horne

One of my high school jobs back about 1958 was working in a plumbing supply warehouse—pick orders, load trucks, offload trucks, offload railcars, drive trucks, whatever needed doing. I won’t forget one bin of wastewater fittings. Sorta off to the side, down on the floor. Was never any call for tees or wyes or anything from that bin.

I asked about it—they said, oh that’s j_p sh__. Nobody says that anymore.

Not China’s lawyer, but things change. Buy Milwaukee now, and it’ll likely be Made in China.

Wiley

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#21

Re: History repeating?

David Weaver

Yep. I'll reserve judgement until I get a chance to use those files. If someone really wants to make quality files in China, there's no reason they can't do it. They can make good water hardening steel there. I looked at one of the files when I got them and saw the origin stamp. The neatness of the file edges and teeth wasn't overwhelming, but I'm sharpening saws these days and not cutting teeth in plates, so even mediocre is fine.

The 1300 foot iron in my test (where hock and my 01 irons got to 800 was made in china and can be had in any mailbox in the us for the princely sum of about $8).

Re: what profile is this molding plane?

#22

My bode plane

David Weaver

https://www.jimbodetools.com/collections/whats-new/products/superfine-spiers-no-6-smooth-plane-90143

This is the spiers plane that bode bought from me on Ebay. However, that ward iron is a replacement that is full length, but someone like bode would have many at his disposal.

I know that one is mine because I draw filed the rust and pitting from the sides(and removed the file marks with abrasive paper) but left some on the bottom...plus some incomplete sanding on the sides of the infill.

FWIW, he paid about $240 for mine on Ebay, then added what is in my opinion about a $60 iron. Not going to get rich as a dealer on that one as he covers card fees and then ships for free.