Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

First successful (sort of) Pencil

Posts

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#26

Re: one more - shellac french polish

Oskar

looks good Dave! Nice project you have found.

Still can´t let go of the knife sharpening practice. There been a lot of mention of good type of sharpeners, but the pictures still show a rough surface, typical of cross grain cutting.

A knife sharpened pencil looks a lot better in my opinion, and it is not a big skill to learn sharpening a pencil without wasting lead.

Looking forward to hear about your lead-making endeavours!

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#27

Re: one more - shellac french polish

David Weaver

Yes, on both of these pencils looking rough - but there's a reason in this case.

1) my ranger 55 sharpener (I think those were branded boston at the time) does a poor job for some reason with these. It doesn't center them. I fight it, to, the results look bad

2) the kum sharpener does a great job, however, the one at my bench is dull and worn. I shouldn't be so cheap. Here's what a shaving looks like from a tombow pencil (their wood is somehow better than mine). It's a great thrill to stuff one of these pencils in a cordless drill and sharpen them when they're new - if you look closely, you can see the thin shaving starting at the start of the pencil going to full width. With a dollar store sharpener, you don't get this result. I don't have a picture of the pencil, but needless to say, it was smooth and perfect looking (else the shavings would have voids in them).


It's possible for me to make a much harder blade for these sharpeners that will cut a glassy surface - I think I'm going to break down and do it.

And I will take your advice, too, and knife sharpen a few of these. I'm not sure how long this jones will go with pencils, but I've only made 6 or 8. They're tremendously fun to make when you've only got 15 minutes to do something, and probably useful for people as a skill builder hand sawing, hand planing, and sizing small parts by pulling them over a plane instead of the plane over them.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#28

Shellac

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Shellac is an extremely durable finish. It is especially durable for tool handles; I have some that were finished with shellac nearly forty years ago. And i am not talking about tools on some display rack.

Cashew, poison ivy and lacquer tree, and sumac are all members of the cashew family, and many have the urushiol compounds that are allergenic.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#29

Water or Alcohol

David Weaver

I was thinking less about hand durability and more about water or alcohol, but you're right, it's pretty much irrelevant in the context of a pencil. If it lasts long enough for either of those to be an issue in anything other than drawing tickmarks in a liquor drinking contest (I don't drink), I should be ashamed.

Putting the shellac on is pleasant, too. Cashew is more of a fight.

Trying french polishing has yielded a very useful offshoot for me - the benefits of mineral or paraffin oil with shellac - even without the other parts of the process. One can apply shellac to something like this pencil without the stickiness of the finish being an issue either as far as halting the application process or making the pencil itself susceptible to light handling during the process.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#30

A few more...

David Weaver

both chess pieces and pencils. I need the practice turning, so making sample pieces hasn't been a waste of time. I've settled on the pawn design on the far right and will start making 16 of them next weekend after Thanksgiving.

https://i.imgur.com/FXYyqN5.jpg


Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#31

knife sharpening, to chisel sharpening

David Weaver

I'm going to make a video of the pencil making process, and you can tell from my recent pictures that the first rough sharpening is done with a chisel.

You were right, I kind of like it. I was considering that I might make a lot of pencils and thought I would just give in and buy 50 kum sharpeners, but I think now I'll not do that.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#32

Great recommendation on the book..

David Weaver

Got a used copy from amazon over the weekend and started reading it. Not far enough to know if I'll find much for making, but it's interesting reading to someone who doesn't really get much out of reading fiction/classics.

Thanks!

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#33

Re: knife sharpening, to chisel sharpening

Oskar

looks a lot better!

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#34

Re: knife sharpening, to chisel sharpening

David Weaver

Easy to do them much more neatly than those pictures - they're just the result of ripping the end of the pencil off with a chisel to get to the (the groove is always a little wonky at the very end, so I insert the led back from the end a little bit).

Nonetheless, works better and faster than I expected with a good sharp chisel.

I still like putting them in a cordless drill and zipping the ends off with a rotary sharpener, but that will go through sharpeners, and with a fresh pencil, unless you wrap the barrel with something, the chuck marks up the pencil. Easier with a pencil with a metal ferrule. No need to fetch the drill.

I'm guessing the typical chisel bevel is shallower than a knife bevel, thus the preference so far for the chisel.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#35

Clint Searl

Re: A few more...

Clint Searl

I think it would be more fun to make and play all the related pieces in different proportions/sizes/woods. You already have 3/4 of the white pawns done.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#36

Re: A few more...

David Weaver

that's actually an interesting idea, and might be worthy of a second set. Just to make the game visually a little harder.

Kind of a take off on Fischer 960 chess - do something to make the game a little bit more visually difficult for those who have memorized absolutely everything by looks.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#37

6 facets on a pencil instead of 8

David Weaver

I didn't know at first why there are 6 facets on a pencil. It's easy to theorize that doing 6 instead of 8 makes them easier to manufacture (maybe it does).

But there is definitely a case where holding a pencil with a fingertip grip is more comfortable with a 6 sided pencil than 8.

Not that it's that important, but interesting that when you try things, you often can feel why the widely accepted standard is the standard.

that leaves me looking to make a change in cutting the facets on the barrel as cutting 8 sided is easy. Cutting 6 is a little less easy.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#38

Re: Great recommendation on the book..

AlanWS

Petroski's books are worth reading in general, I think.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#39

Re: A few more...

William Duffield

Not a good idea, unless the chess set is just for show in your den or library (or man-cave :D in the current vernacular). I used to play competitively. In a tournament, if you sat down at a table for a match, and produced non-standard Staunton chessmen or a non-standard board, your opponent could, and almost always did, demand that you remove it and replace it with a standard set. This concept is fair, like a "level playing field."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Staunton_chess_set

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#40

Re: A few more...

David Weaver

Yes, that's the case for the second one. Almost as a gag.

I never played competitively and never will, but I operate mostly visually. The use of differing pieces would create a substantial challenge for me.

I intend to build the matching set first. Realistically, once I do that, I probably wouldn't get a second set made for another decade.

I've seen some of the ebony and boxwood sets made in the third world for about $450 and they are far beyond anything I could ever produce (due to the quality of the carving above and beyond the turning), so it's kind of a waste of time to make a set at all. But wasting time is what i'm doing woodworking!

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#41

Re: 6 facets on a pencil instead of 8

AlanWS

When I've cut hexagonal stock (as a driveshaft for a grain auger to use in moving sawdust to allow a shorter cyclone with a large bin -- unfortunately it didn't work well: planer shavings are not like grain,) the easiest way I found was to cut a rectangular cross section with a 1:1.732 ratio (sqrt 3). The short side measures the face to face distance across the final hexagon, and the long side is the point to point distance.

I cut it by tilting the tablesaw sawblade 30 degrees from square away from the fence, allowing 4 rip cuts without changing settings to establish the hexagon. Tweaking was needed only to make sure the cut met the short face halfway up.

A planing jig to hold stock at the correct angle, and a line ruled down the centers of the short faces, might make planing fairly easy. It's harder to describe than the tablesaw approach, which is why I let that leak into the hand tools section.

It's interesting that you need to plane four surfaces, whether you convert to a hexagon or an octagon.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#42

Re: 6 facets on a pencil instead of 8

David Weaver

Yes, a jig *should* make it fairly easy, though the jig will have to be small and be able to hold the pencil firmly and support the back side of the cut properly (or the facets don't get cut to the same depth).

what I'm looking to do at this point is avoid making any jigs that have any complication on the stock (e.g., gripping the barrels at both ends would require a normalized stock length, or a fixture that can slide). I think what I'm going to do next is make a plane that cuts two facets at a 120 degree angle in one pass. I have a stock board that has a 120 degree groove in it.

The attraction of the octagonal barrel is it's easy. It stays in place in a 90 degree groove no matter what and you can just sort of freewheel them out. The pencil isn't uncomfortable, it's just apparent to me that the feel of 6 is better. I attempted it with the first board, but the pencil becomes unstable to hold once you've planed the facets on the first side and you try to plane at an angle on the second side.

I'd made the barrel blanks on the first attempts (which were 6 sided) square to the longest measured point across the center by turning the pencil in calipers to get the largest measurement.

It's an interesting problem. One that may also be solved by making a wooden bottom plane a little longer than the pencil length and pulling the pencil across it like someone would use a cooper's jointer. That would be pretty satisfying, a little fiddly, but once the cut starts, not that fiddly. I like the less than perfect but good result.

Severe overanalysis! but I'd make bookshelves if I didn't want to do that.

One other thing that's interesting with the 8 facet pencil. You can freely pull the pencil along an upside down bench plane with the cap iron set and not worry about tearout, but at the same time, also not worry about your fingers. When the cap is set close to the edge, the iron just won't be able to get a deep enough cut to cut skin. You can slice across the blade if you're a dope, but that's easy to avoid. I don't think a single iron specialty plane will be as forgiving on the finger tips. We'll see.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#43

(I can almost guarantee)

David Weaver

That nobody who would ever qualify as an FIDE master or greater will ever seen my chess pieces, by the way.

I don't have the discipline to memorize openings, end games and middle games at the same time, but I do like to calculate.

A strong player who came to my house and who thought that I was playing a psychological game with non-standard pieces would figure out pretty quickly that they could relax!

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#44

By page 62 in petroski's text..

David Weaver

We are exactly where I am in my pencil making endeavor. Octagonal pencils with lead only in the business end.

No double iron planes at the time so an old European account specifies scraping the facets of the pencil with glass. No lead recipes yet as the text is still in the era of using cut graphite out of the mine.

I ordered a nice plain piping set to experiment with the lead soon, but I will be avoiding most of the refining process due to starting with micron sized graphite and clay already. The older recipes that I found online specify tumbling with rocks.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#45

6 facets is better, but harder

David Weaver

I did get a chance after traveling a little bit last week to make one pencil in 6 facets. It's definitely better suited to a fingertip grip. It's also harder to make by hand, because at some point, your bearing surface will be one small facet on the pencil, the pencil is flexible, and you need to cut even facets both relative to each other and end to end (pulling the pencil across the bottom of a plane is the easiest way to cut the facets).

The other choice is to make a special plane that cuts two facets at once top and bottom, but it'll be potential trouble if there is grain misdirection between the two glued halves.

The edges left by 6 facets are much sharper, and now it's apparent why all commercial pencils have the edges broken pretty significantly.

So, after all of the screwing around, we're almost where we would've been if we just copied a commercial pencil from the start!!

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#46

if anyone is secretly making pencils...

David Weaver

the height of the blank and width need to be square for an 8 sided pencil to prevent odd sized facets.

For a 6 facet pencil, the height of the blank needs to be 1.155 times greater than the width 1/(cosine 30).

You can just about see squareness. All in all, the 8 facet pencil takes about half as much time to make because you don't really need to measure anything. I'm sure someone making pencils all day every day could see the proportions that a 6 facet pencil would need to have just by eye, but I have to check them with a caliper while cleaning up the blank after sawing it out and prior to faceting.

graphite experiments next. On the fence about making a double iron V-shaped specialty plane to easily cut 6-sided blanks.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#47

My Port Orford cedar has arrived

Chuck Nickerson

and once the leads arrive I'll be on the journey.

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#48

Re: Ducking and Running *LINK*

William Duffield

:D


Bridge City Pencil Precision

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#49

$594!!!!

David Weaver

Wow!

Re: First successful (sort of) Pencil

#50

Convincing advertising

David Weaver

"...Imagine using Pencil Precision as a tool to boost the self-esteem for those young folks who are finding a hard way life. We know first-hand of such stories from users of our Chopstick Master."

8)

"...Imagine making a special pencil for your teenager who is about to take his/her SAT test.

...Imagine making pencils on your kitchen counter while your young grandchild watches in amazement and helps you pick the correct color ferrules.

...Imagine writing a poem to your loved one which includes the very pencil used to create the poem."

(imagine making them for the cost of materials without spending any money. When I got on this pencil kick, I did look around and there's some guy making a jig with kickstarter funding. It's not the kind of thing I want to do - part of the joy of making the pencils is controlling what's going on, but the guy did a good job and he's made leads available pretty cheap compared to anything else

https://www.in-kleind.com/store/Pencil-Making-Tool-c35225011

His jig requires the use of a block plane and a specialty router bit to cut the groove, and not surprisingly, most of the sample pencils have tearout, which we don't want. It makes the making accessible to someone who doesn't use a lot of hand tools, though. )

Making the six sided pencils is difficult. I could make a video at this point, but I'd like to wait until I've figured out how to make the 6-sided making a little bit easier for someone who hasn't done as much hand tool woodworking.